Don't read history without knowing the true face of Liu Bang!

History & Culture of East
10 followers
17 Video Views·Sep 30, 2026
In terms of both military talent and character, Liu Bang was inferior to Xiang Yu in every respect. Throughout his military career, Xiang Yu was victorious in every battle, always slaying generals and capturing cities. Yet, in the end, it was Liu Bang who ascended to the throne, while Xiang Yu was the one who committed suicide by the Wu River.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedLiu Bang secured the throne not through military superiority, but through political acumen, pragmatism, and an exceptional ability to manage talent. While Xiang Yu relied on raw power and personal prestige, Liu Bang’s success stemmed from his decisiveness, his capacity for humility, and his strategic focus on winning the hearts of people over the mere acquisition of land.
Welcome back to Battlecry, a China history chronicle.
If you judge by military talent, Liu Bang was inferior to Xiang Yu in every way.
In his whole career as a commander, Xiang Yu won battle after battle, wherever he marched,
he slaughtered enemy generals and took cities. Yet in the end, it was Liu Bang who ended up on
the throne. And it was Xiang Yu who had to reckon with himself on the bank of the O River.
So why did this happen? What was Liu Bang's true talent?
Welcome to today's video.
Liu Bang's Talent
Liu Bang may not have been an especially grand figure by nature.
But in one way, he was the kind of man who dared to speak and dared to act.
When Liu Bang was still a village chief, he once transported hard labor prisoners to Lishan.
Along the way, quite a few escaped. Liu Bang then opened the gates to all the prisoners and said,
You all go ahead, I'm coming too. There's nothing to be feared.
Clearly, Liu Bang had a bit of a rebellious streak, he dared to think and do.
In modern terms, he had a bit of a bad boy in him.
This also shows Liu Bang was decisive. Once he saw something should be done,
he did it right away, no hesitation, no over-calculating.
In this respect, Liu Bang was far ahead of Xiang Yu and Han Exian,
though this is judging political acumen, not morality or character.
At the Hongmen Banquet, Xiang Yu had already decided to kill Liu Bang,
but he was persuaded not to, fearing bad reputation and left it for later,
so Liu Bang would die in Liu Bang's own hands.
And when Han Exian was urged before a major campaign to go independent and rebel,
he was also persuaded not to, he had the intention, but he could not bring himself to do it.
In fact, Han Exian's real mistake was his hesitation,
a regret he could not shake, which later turned into chaos.
Liu Bang's feelings toward Han Exian were also very complicated.
Han Exian's feelings toward Liu Bang were also very complicated.
There was both fondness and resentment, both contempt and fear.
So, until the last moment, Han Exian still hesitated, not knowing whether to rebel or not.
You can also see it in Liu Bang's talent policy and in how he promoted Han Exian step by step.
The same is true when compared with Han Exian's betrayal of a sworn brother bond.
Han Exian was not a trustworthy man.
Han Exian could betray a sworn brother bond.
So why, then, could he not betray Liu Bang?
Therefore, in terms of magnanimity, Han Exian was no match for Liu Bang.
Han Exian's flaw was exactly this, when he had the chance to rebel,
he still could not bring himself to betray.
Yet once he became a bird kept in another man's cage,
he always acted proud, reckless, fearing neither heaven nor earth.
Han Exian was a warrior hero, not a blustering one, a military man, not a politician.
No matter how cruel or petty Han Exian was, he could not compare with Liu Bang.
Han Exian always wanted a loyal, sincere heart and clung to his illusions.
He assumed that with such merits and such good feelings between them,
Liu Bang would do nothing to him.
As a result, he failed to be on guard in time and ended up a corpse under another man's blade.
In a ruthless political struggle, one thing is clear, it does not allow hesitation and doubt.
Liu Bang's greatest advantage was his ability to follow things through to the end,
to act fully and without hesitation.
Liu Bang may have lacked brilliance and elaborate strategy,
but his judgment was strong, he dared to decide and dared to risk everything.
It was because of that quality that Liu Bang repeatedly turned danger into peace
and weakness into strength, step by step, into victory.
Liu Bang was a rogue among heroes and also a hero among rogues.
For that reason he dared to stake his own life.
Han Tian was a rogue, yet he had the bearing of a nobleman.
In terms of presence, however, he still could not match Liu Bang.
In truth, Liu Bang is not a man of broad-minded elegance, not a true gentleman.
He is not vicious, not crafty, and not a secretive schemer.
When choosing people, Liu Bang could be generous and free-handed.
Once he trusted someone, he could lift that person in one bold move.
But when ruling men, he was equally fierce, with no leniency.
Liu Bang's retinue included every kind of person,
Zhang Liang was a noble, Qin Ping a wandering scholar,
Xiao He a county clerk, and Han Xi'an a commoner by birth but from noble stock.
Han Chao was a butcher, Quan An a cloth seller,
Lao Qin a cart driver, Ban Viet a thief, and Chu Bo a drummer.
Liu Bang was broad in spirit, treating them equally, using each by ability,
ignoring birth, and never favoring anyone by rank.
On the other hand, among the martial types,
arrogance could make some of them lose everything for no reason.
Yet when Liu Bang decided to execute, he did so regardless of closeness or loyalty.
Liu Bang heard a report that Fan Kui was not fully loyal,
and he had Qin Ping bring Fan Kui in to be executed, and Qin Ping beheaded him on the spot.
Liu Bang and Fan Kui were among the closest of friends.
Long ago and by county, the two were friends,
When rebellion broke out,
Fan Kui rode out to welcome Liu Bang back and gave him a grand welcome.
Later, Fan Kui followed Liu Bang through campaigns in east and north,
achieving brilliant victories.
When Liu Bang first entered Hanyang,
it was Fan Kui who told him not to be over proud and broaden the guards,
building hope for Liu Bang.
At the Hongmen banquet, Fan Kui rushed forward and was ready to kill Xiang Yu,
and that is what saved Liu Bang's life.
Fan Kui later married Empress Liu's younger sister,
so with Liu Bang they became sworn brothers, almost like blood brothers.
But Liu Bang needed only one order, when he said kill, it was done.
In the end, Qin Ping still had no chance to issue the death order,
and with Liu Bang then in severe danger, that matter was over.
As for Liu Bang, he was truly relentless.
Xiang Yu, though harsh to his enemies, was willing to slaughter 200,000 enemy soldiers.
Yet toward his own men, even his closest aides, he had never gone that far.
Of course Xiang Yu also killed people, and he even killed Long Teng.
And it was precisely the killing of Long Teng that was blind.
Yet when it was time to kill, he did not kill.
He had Liu Bang in his hands several times and still could not kill him.
So we can infer that if Xiang Yu had true supreme command,
he would never have executed his own meritorious ministers,
who in all heaven dares to anger him.
This came from personal will, he could kill even a loyal meritorious man.
From political necessity, killing by planning and plotting is not possible.
For Xiang Yu, there was no such thing as merit higher than the Lord.
Was there anyone with merit higher than Xiang Yu?
Could anyone stand against Xiang Yu, such a towering hero of his age?
Probably not, or at least Xiang Yu himself believed so.
So in Xiang Yu's grip, a meritorious man was fairly safe.
As long as you didn't provoke Xiang Yu, he wouldn't be viewed as someone to remove later.
Even so, Xiang Yu didn't even acknowledge anyone as a meritorious hero.
So, even with some injustice, he still kept his life.
Or, if someone was recognized as meritorious, there was nothing to worry about.
Because then Xiang Yu would already have admitted him as a hero.
A true hero always respects other heroes.
With that hero-to-hero instinct, Xiang Yu would harm no one.
At Hongmen, Xiang Yu firmly decided not to kill Liu Bang for that reason.
Of course, he may have spared him also from contempt,
Liu Bang was so insignificant that killing him would only soil his hands.
We all know Xiang Yu was a proud, arrogant lord.
He had looked down on Liu Bang from the beginning, and that was one reason Xiang Yu failed.
The Huai King said to the lords that whoever entered Guangzhou first would be king.
Then Xiang Yu ordered Liu Bang arrested at Nam Trinh, the intent was obvious.
Although Xiang Yu let him into Guangzhou with ceremony.
It was to settle a score with Xiang Liang, not because Xiang Yu feared Liu Bang getting there first.
The conference of lords did not agree, and Xiang Yu had to give in.
Xiang Yu fully believed that a rough brute like Liu Bang could not defeat the Qin army.
So when he heard that Liu Bang had entered Guangzhou first.
With gold, silver, and every kind of treasure on hand,
Xiang Yu's pent-up jealousy flared up like thunder.
Now Xiang Yu could not publicly accept Liu Bang,
yet deep down he still refused to recognize Liu Bang as a hero.
If Liu Bang were accepted as a hero, Xiang Yu would have to respect him truly,
and then he could not kill him.
If you want to kill Liu Bang, kill him properly on the battlefield.
But to summon him to a banquet in camp and kill him in secret is a disgrace you can never wash away.
If Liu Bang is no hero, why kill him?
Fan Xing had to hint several times, yet Xiang Yu sat there, confused, without saying a word.
Fan Xing pushed harder, and Xiang Yu still did not react.
Deep down, Xiang Yu kept wavering in his calculations.
A sterner counsel only showed where he was weaker than Liu Bang.
In the end, Liu Bang slipped past the tiger,
and Xiang Yu sent the tiger back into the wild, a grave mistake.
But it was not just that.
Xiang Yu also underestimated Liu Bang for sparing him.
True, Liu Bang was a rough man, a hero among rough men.
Calling Liu Bang a rough man refers to his birth and upbringing,
not necessarily his natural quality.
As for talent, Liu Bang was not short on leadership.
He had all the essentials of a leader, and they were natural in him.
Especially keen observation, judgment, and quickness were gifts heaven gave Liu Bang.
Han Exian said that Liu Bang's skill at leading troops came from heaven, not from human effort.
As a leader, Liu Bang's greatest strength was knowing people.
Knowing people is not simply knowing who is talented and using them.
More importantly, it means grasping each person's strengths and flaws in character.
Only then can all forces be united, only then can the enemy be isolated.
Then the enemy can be worn down one by one, and only in the end can one win the realm.
After all, what is the realm?
The realm is made of people, not of land.
So to have the realm is, in truth, to have the people's hearts.
Liu Bang understood this.
Since almost his birth, Liu Bang knew how to befriend others.
Liu Bang disliked reading, but he was naturally sharp-minded.
He had an open heart and could accept sound strategies.
Even a gatekeeper, even a lowly soldier, if they met Liu Bang,
could become a close friend of his.
So in addition to being generous, open, unpretentious, and easy-going,
Liu Bang also understood one important thing.
In this world, people are the greatest treasure.
So Liu Bang could treat everyone as his most valuable resource.
He feared only shortages, not abundance, and did anything to read people's hearts.
In other words, he understood what others wanted and helped them get it.
Han Exian could never forget Liu Bang's kindness
when Liu Bang gave him his coat and fed and drank him.
Clearly, Liu Bang had one Han Exian's heart.
Liu Bang gave himself wholeheartedly, matching heart to heart.
If Liu Bang was hungry and wanted to eat, he knew others were hungry, too, and shared his rice.
If Liu Bang was cold, knowing others were cold, he would simply give away his coat.
Liu Bang wanted to take the realm and become emperor,
and he knew others also wanted honor for their wives and children.
So he boldly and freely bestowed titles and rewards.
His way of thinking and acting was to provide rice for everyone to eat and clothes for everyone to wear.
Xiang Yu had money to let everyone spend and to hand out rewards,
which made him very popular in China.
But Xiang Yu usually did not know how to share much with others.
Even when he did, he gave only a few small favors.
In his distributions, he depended entirely on his own likes and dislikes.
He liked to use authority as a threat against people.
Xiang Yu advanced as far as Liaodong and drove a king and his rank far out to die.
He expelled King Han Tanqing, creating the pretext for strategist Zhongliang to aid Liu Bang.
He first denied him permission to return home, then demoted him to marquis,
and finally plotted to assassinate him, petty and narrow-minded.
In the end he forced Zhongliang, who had belonged to Han Qing,
to come to Liu Bang's camp, Xiang Yu clashed with Han Qing to the very end.
In truth, Zhongliang had already urged Liu Bang to rebel,
and the allied troops of Jingbo and Bangde had also rebelled,
all through Zhongliang's coordination.
Liu Bang had top-tier merit in defeating Qing,
and since he could not be made king of Zhongyuan as promised,
Xiang Yu should have at least returned his old home or nearby lands to calm the army's homesickness.
By contrast, Xiang Yu was simply eager to go home in comfort.
In fact, Liu Bang's officers and soldiers long day and night to go back home.
But Xiang Yu never did that.
Perhaps it was jealousy, Xiang Yu entered Guangzhou first,
and he resented that Liu Bang had already taken his own glory and authority.
Naturally Liu Bang was pushed toward Hanzhong, then seen as a wild and remote land.
Liu Bang also did not want to stay there for even one day,
how could I live here forever?
And he finally led his army east.
Even though Liu Bang seemed stunned at first in Xiangyang and did not want to leave,
he did not suspect Xiang Yu had deeper schemes.
So from one angle, it was Xiang Yu who encouraged Liu Bang and Liu Bang's officers to revolt.
Of course, soldiers who have gone home will not return to the battlefield.
So that is why Zhongliang saw it.
The world had settled everyone in place, and nothing could be stirred up again.
But Xiang Yu would not let Liu Bang have any peace.
That left Liu Bang unable to absorb Xiang Yu and strike back.
A person who does not think of others also does not really think of himself.
One who can care for others can usually care for himself too.
Liu Bang knew himself to have no outstanding talent.
He could not stabilize people through scholarship,
secure a state through force, plan with enough strategy,
or hold the enemy back with enough strength.
So Liu Bang freely handed all affairs over to others.
He himself only kept two jobs, using people and making decisions.
That way he avoided his own weaknesses and gained the benefits of others at once.
More than that, Liu Bang could clearly tell right from wrong,
good from bad, and he listened hard to others.
He dared to correct his own mistakes, could tolerate others' mistakes,
and did not care about fussing over rank when using people.
So he drew many outstanding heroes, Fan Kui was brave, Zhongliang was sharp,
Han Exian knew how to command, and Xiao He knew how to govern, a perfect combination.
As a result, Liu Bang worked with ease and success.
Xiang Yu could not understand this, convinced he was the top hero under heaven,
doing everything himself, only to waste himself and become an isolated man.
Xiang Yu did not know how to use people and did not understand himself,
he did not know where his strengths ended and his limits began.
Xiang Yu never admitted fault either.
Even when his army broke at Kaixia and he killed himself by the banks of Oujiang,
he still said heaven wanted to kill him and he had done no wrong.
Liu Bang was different.
Liu Bang also made mistakes, indeed, many, bad judgments, bad strategy.
But Liu Bang dared to admit them and dared to change.
In 200 BCE, Liu Bang misjudged the overall situation and enemy force,
took the tiger-antservant tactic, ignored Lao Qing's blunt warning,
and led his troops into an enemy ambush himself.
As a result, he was trapped at Baideng, near Bingqing,
dating, a small town near there, in today's Shaanxi.
Later, he used Jinping's plan to escape the danger.
Liu Bang moved his army to Guangwu, to Yangmingbao in today's Shaanxi,
and when he reached Lao Qing he removed his armor, bowed, admitted his mistake,
gave Lao Qing 2,000 households, and promoted him to Inner Marquis.
Xiang Yu could never have done this, so at least Liu Bang was better than Xiang Yu in this respect.
Liu Bang acknowledged his mistake, and that showed true heroism within him.
In Chinese history, few emperors or commanders can do this.
Once they do something, they immediately think they are geniuses who understand everything.
They have plenty of slogans, and every statement becomes absolute truth,
every action is presented as correct.
If any foolish criticism from subordinates appears,
it is either crushed at once or buried as resentment.
If someone criticizes a policy as a mistake and is later proven right,
that person is usually forced out in disgrace.
In 200 BCE, Yuan Shao ignored Dian Feng's advice in the Guangdu Campaign,
so he was defeated in the north, and to save his face he had Dian Feng killed.
They use new mistakes to cover up older ones,
never admitting fault, and never even acknowledging that they erred.
Liu Bang was trapped at Bidang in 200 BCE, that same year, Yuan Shao was defeated at Guangdu.
The two cases were 400 years apart, yet their outcomes were completely different,
so you cannot say it was only a matter of moral greatness.
Yuan Shao was an aristocrat with lofty status and a proud posture, respected everywhere.
Liu Bang was a rough rogue with not a coin in his pocket and no room for boasting.
Yet Liu Bang's momentum was of a kind that someone like Yuan Shao could never catch up with.
Liu Bang was not only generous, he was also meticulous.
On the surface, Liu Bang seemed rough and careless,
yet in practical matters he was extremely precise.
On the eve of the Hongmen Banquet,
Liu Bang heard Xiang Yu would assemble outside the city gates the next day,
and also heard that Xiang Bo could intervene, he immediately moved to draw Xiang Bo closer.
But Liu Bang did not rush to meet Xiang Bo first.
He first asked Zhang Liang whether Zhang Liang or Xiang Bo was older.
When Zhang Liang said Xiang Bo was older,
Liu Bang at once changed his address and spoke to him as an elder brother.
Thus, by claiming elder brother ties with Zhang Liang,
Liu Bang could become Xiang Bo's older brother too,
putting him on equal footing with Zhang Liang.
Zhang Liang grew even more open and sincere, and the two men quickly got along well.
Liu Bang was truly intelligent, Xiang Yu and Liu Bang were different in many ways.
Xiang Yu looks cruel on the surface, but in truth is soft,
he appears heroic, yet he is actually weak.
Liu Bang seems gentle on the surface, but he is ruthless underneath,
he seems easygoing, but he is truly resilient.
Xiang Yu is quick to snap and quick to anger, if anything displeases him,
he flares up like fire leaping up a man's height.
But after a few bowls of soup, he's back to seeming as if nothing happened.
Liu Bang is the opposite, he can endure a brief insult,
and later quietly settle the account.
Look at Liu Bang with Han Exian, he handles him like a cat toying with a mouse.
Clearly, Xiang Yu is straightforward-minded, while Liu Bang is a pragmatist.
Because he is pragmatic, Liu Bang does not mind using even petty men,
and he does not mind killing loyal ministers either.
Because he is pragmatic,
he is also unafraid to admit a mistake in public as long as he achieves his goal.
Liu Bang does not care about preserving his personal image.
Xiang Yu does the opposite, he makes everything about honor
and would rather die than admit he was wrong.
But Liu Bang does share one trait with Xiang Yu.
Both of them value heroes and praise people of merit.
Liu Bang does not divide the world foolishly into good enemies and bad allies.
He does not assume everyone on the other side is evil and everyone on his side is noble.
Whenever he sees a true hero, a genuine gentleman, Liu Bang shows sincere respect and praise.
It does not matter whether that man is a foe or friend, a supporter or an opponent.
After Han Exian was killed,
Liu Bang also killed Ban Viet and exterminated all three of his clans.
All of them were executed at the market outside Luoyang,
and a proclamation warned that anyone bold enough to take their bodies would be killed.
At that time, a grand envoy named Long Bo, a man from Liang,
had gone down to Qi and arrived in Luoyang.
Long Bo knelt before Ban Viet's corpse, reported the progress of the mission,
then kept bowing to the ground in full prostration.
Liu Bang saw that Long Bo had done it without Liu Bang's order,
was curious, and ordered him thrown into a vat of boiling oil.
Long Bo calmly walked there, turned back, and said,
let me say one sentence, and then I will die.
Liu Bang said, you may speak.
Long Bo said, that year, the emperor was besieged at Ban city.
He was at Huinyang, in danger at Qinggao,
that is why Xiang Yu could not push west and pursue us.
Because the king of Ban Viet was amassing troops at Daliang, allied with Han.
At that time, if the Ban king had only made one quick move, this day might never have come.
Even at Kai Xia, without the Ban king, Xiang Yu surely would not have been defeated.
Yet this is how fate worked, the Ban king was denied a thief and any peace.
It was astonishing, just because he fell ill and had to stay in bed,
and missed one levy of troops.
From there, the ruler began to suspect the Ban king of plotting rebellion.
There was no proof of treason, yet he searched for petty pretexts, condemned the Ban king to death,
and even annihilated three clans.
All the high ministers of the empire were deeply afraid.
By then the Ban king had just been killed, my body was still warm,
let this servant jump into the cauldron.
After hearing this and feeling deep respect,
Liu Bang immediately ordered Long Bo released and gave Feng an appointment.
Liu Bang released Long Bo out of shame, because Long Bo truly had been innocent.
He also did it out of respect for Long Bo's character and moral dignity.
There were many similar cases, like releasing Fan Kuai,
his mercy was sometimes too generous.
Guan Chao had once served as a top official of a state,
he was arrested for plotting to assassinate Liu Bang.
Even under savage torture, Guan Chao refused to betray King Zhang Gao.
Liu Bang respected the gallant Guan Gao, and after clearly seeing his true nature,
he not only rewarded Chuang Nao, but also spared Guan Gao.
Even when Han Exian's betrayal was exposed and Guan Gao's attempt on Liu Bang was clear,
they all admitted it themselves, yet Liu Bang still did not execute them.
Liu Bang was not a mindless killer, he killed meritorious men only when autocracy required it,
not from personal love or hatred, which is why autocracy later killed Han Exian,
Bai Viet, Tang Tra, Tran Hai, Liu Quan, An Bo, and eventually even Fan Kuai.
The many executions under Liu Bang were therefore the cost of an autocratic order.
Still, for men with no troops and no real authority, Liu Bang did not kill them.
Killing them would have meant nothing.
It was not to show generosity or improve his image.
At Hongmen Banquet, although Fan Xing gave orders several times, Xiang Yu stayed silent.
Yet when Xiang Shuang aimed his sword at Liu Bang, Xiang Yu still did not stop him.
It was still a moment of both possibilities, to kill Liu Bang or not, as if awaiting heaven's
command. But once Fan Kuai entered, the situation shifted immediately. Fan Kuai burst through the
entrance, stepped straight into the tent, and stared directly at Xiang Yu. Fan Kuai's hair
stood up, his eyes blazed, and Xiang Yu was shaken by that sight. When Zhang Liang said he
was a trusted guest, and with Xiang Yu's guards nearby, he was praised as a brave warrior.
Fan Kuai drank the full cup, ate the pig's leg, and Xiang Yu became interested and admiring of him.
So when Fan Kuai replied to Xiang Yu, even with death looming,
he could still raise and accept another deep drink.
Soon it was clearly criticized that Xiang Yu wanted to kill a worthy man,
showing his judgment had failed. Xiang Yu then forgot his mission to wrest control,
thinking only of face, and finally granted Liu Bang his life.
And that is also the mark of a hero, ready to give up everything for honor.
Liu Bang and Xiang Yu are both heroes, but different, Liu Bang is the hero of strategy,
Xiang Yu the heroic warrior. Xiang Yu was brave yet impatient,
bold yet ungenerous, candid yet narrow, and often ruled by feeling.
He could not look ahead, so he lost to Liu Bang, who used clever tactics and never lost patience.
Liu Bang was expansive in generosity, with deep thought, practical reason, and subtle,
hard-edged plans. He could be restrained, patient, and capable of waiting for the right moment.
So Xiang Yu's rise and fall, his merits and his faults, all came from the same root.
He was a highly distinctive hero, a hero with a unique, aesthetic style.
Because he was so distinctive, he lacked the ability to truly succeed.
Xiang Yu is both lovable and tragic.
Han Exian is both admirable and pitiable.
Han Exian is admirable because though he was born poor, his spirit was noble.
His body was in low station, but his mind was lofty, unlike Liu Bang's straightforward path.
Liu Bang's strength was in learning, which let him grow through warfare.
With a high, broad vision and a talent for adaptation, he eventually rose to become emperor.
Han Exian, by contrast, was prepared at every step of his life.
He ate beans in other people's homes, starved on riverbanks, and endured hardship.
At times he was a lowly attendant under Xiang Yu, at other times, he managed guests for Liu Bang.
Always, Han Exian prepared himself, always believing that heaven had made him for a place.
He never imagined he might live his whole life without one day to truly show himself.
Because of that trust, Han Exian endured with patient restraint.
That same pain is what let Han Exian survive.
Han Exian's regret was that he never carried it to the end.
But Liu Bang was the opposite, Liu Bang was far more practical.
Liu Bang was patient, but his patience was pragmatic, adapting flexibly to reality.
Han Exian relied on a half-measure, using feigned loyalty to buy political leverage.
But he faced someone who seized the moment, Liu Bang, who underestimated him.
Bai Yang said the tragedy began when Han Exian had no real wish to rebel,
if he had, it would have been better.
Han Exian's words before he died, saying he regretted not listening to Kuo Yitong,
were probably not scripted or set up.
Of course, that statement can explain that Han Exian lost his chance.
And it can also explain that if Han Exian had truly planned to rebel,
everything would have ended then.
But no matter how you read it, Han Exian still had some intent to conspire against.
Things turned for the worse because Han Exian had both loyalty and treachery in him,
and neither was complete.
He could not be fully loyal, and he could not rebel with full heart either.
If he had followed loyalty to the end,
Zhou Peng could still have later framed and harmed an innocent man.
There would surely have been upright men like Guan Bo to speak up,
to intervene in injustice, or later to restore him and erase the accusation.
But sadly, none of that came.
If he had gone all the way into rebellion, that would have been better.
If he had succeeded, success would have been clear,
in failure, there is no shame and regret.
At that moment, Han Exian could have spoken plainly to Lu Bang and said,
I want to kill this man, exposing this beast-hearted face would be better, wouldn't it?
Yet Lu Bang did not execute Han Exian as he had in Guan Chao's case.
Guan Chao had committed a grave crime, to kill a king called for execution by beheading.
But Guan Chao was consistent and straightforward from start to finish, utterly without intrigue,
one declaration making him seem loyal, another making him appear traitorous.
In the end, in the eyes of people, Guan Chao remained a hero.
Since he was treated as a loyal sacrifice, calling it injustice is not entirely false,
saying it was not injustice is also not wholly right.
He was neither a loyal minister nor a rebel,
neither could be embraced, nor could he be fully approved.
Try telling me, was it really easy to judge?
In short, Xiang Yu was a born hero, and also a thorough, uncompromising hero.
Han Exian became a hero only with great hardship, yet he was not a complete one.
That is why Xiang Yu died gloriously.
