🍪 Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies Ingredients • 10 tablespoons (5 oz / 142 g) butter, diced • 1½ cups (7½ oz / 213 g) all-purpose flour • 1 teaspoon baking soda • 1 large egg, at room temperature • ⅔ cup (4 oz / 115 g) dark brown sugar • ⅓ cup (2½ oz / 71 g) granulated sugar • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract • ¼ teaspoon salt • ⅔ cup (4 oz / 115 g) chopped bittersweet chocolate
📌 ABOUT GEMMA & BIGGER BOLDER BAKING 📌 Hi Bold Bakers! I’m Gemma Stafford, a professional chef originally from Ireland, best-selling cookbook author, and the creator of Bigger Bolder Baking and the Bold Baking Network. I want to help you bake with confidence anytime, anywhere with my trusted and tested recipes and baking tips. You may have seen one of my 1,000+ videos on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, or TikTok, or as a guest judge on Nailed It! on Netflix or Best Baker in America on Food Network. No matter your skills, my Bold Baking Team & I want to be your #1 authority for everything baking.
One simple step can completely change how your baking tastes richer, deeper and so much better.
Hi, I'm Gemma Stafford, a professional chef with over 20 years experience.
And this is one of the easiest ways I upgrade flavor in my baking.
We're going to brown butter, use it in a recipe and show you exactly what it changes.
Browning the butter is not something that should be feared.
It is very simple.
You just need the right instructor like moi to tell you how to do it.
So here's tip number one.
Start out in like a frying pan is much easier and faster than doing a small pot.
I did a small pot before it took 15 minutes.
So we're going to start out in a shallow frying pan to give us that surface area to cook faster.
Number two is not a dark coated pan.
You want something that is not coated like maybe stainless steel,
because we need to be able to see what's going on in the bottom of the pan.
If you use nonstick and it's a black bottom, you won't be able to see.
Now we're going to add in our butter.
Use your favorite type of butter.
I use salted pan on another tip, medium low.
You are not helping yourself by cranking up that heat trying to make it go faster.
All you're going to do is burn your butter.
And this is not about burning.
It's about browning.
So medium low controlled heat.
Your next tip is patience.
You have to be patient.
Butter is expensive.
And if it gets burned, then unfortunately, there's not much we can do about it.
So while the butter is melting, I'm going to show you this different stages,
what we're going to look for so we can tell when it's not done,
when it's perfect, when it's overdone.
You also have to know when you've gone too far.
This is a fantastic skill.
Once you know how to brown butter, you can use it in any recipe you want.
It really makes the flavor so much better when you're baked goods.
Just this, if you just watch this part of the video,
you've already learned a lot because learning how to brown butter correctly is a skill.
And once you know how to do it, you can apply it to any of your recipes.
Sweet or savory.
Another tip, don't walk away.
And I'm talking about even for a minute because you really want to watch what's going on.
Now, here we go.
This is the first step in browning butter.
It's starting to foam.
It's bubbling up.
It's simmering.
Now, here's what we have to do.
I'm using a spatula.
You can use a wooden spoon.
Spatula I think is kind of handy because it gets the bottom of the pan.
Stir.
If you just let the brown butter simmer by itself without stirring,
what will happen is the milk solids in the butter will burn on the bottom of the pan.
And when that burns, it tastes very bitter.
And it's pretty much unusable.
So a little stir.
Nothing too aggressive.
Make sure you get all around the sides.
That simmering is kind of therapeutic.
So there you go.
We're around two minutes in.
Look at this.
You see it changing slightly.
Do you see the way the foam is getting a little bit darker?
You can see it getting a little bit more golden brown.
I'm going to turn that down a small bit.
I don't want it to get aggressive on me.
So now here's the tip.
This is not browned enough yet.
It is getting brown.
There's going to be some flavor there.
Look underneath here.
See that liquid?
See what happens in a heavy bottom saucepan is that the beauty of them is that they retain heat.
So when you remove this from the pan, it actually keeps on cooking,
keeps on browning if you're doing eggs, if you're you're cooking anything.
So look at this.
I just removed it from the heat there for a minute.
I kept on stirring.
When this foam dies down, it's kind of got almost like a peachy color.
Nutty.
I can smell it.
Smells toasted.
It smells nutty.
We can see underneath.
It has not burned.
It's almost like a golden brown.
The foam is disappearing.
Here I have a bowl.
Now this is a really important step.
Have a bowl beside you.
Pour it into the bowl.
Stop the cooking.
So remember, factor in if you're using a heavy bottom saucepan.
It's retaining extra heat.
So that's why you really have to be careful.
And here's the thing.
Maybe you are in somebody else's house making brown butter and you don't have your own pans.
When you follow all the steps that I just mentioned,
no matter what pan you use,
preferably not dark,
you'll get good results.
So look at this.
I'm going to swirl it around a little bit.
Let it cool down.
But it can't get any browner right now because it's cooling down and it's out of the pan.
So this is what correctly browned butter looks like.
It smells like I said,
nutty and toasty,
but then also kind of caramelly.
How would you not want to use this in all your recipes?
OK, but listen to me,
your brown butter lesson does not stop there.
You're getting good value for your money today because here's what we're going to do.
Look at that.
I'm going to put it back in the pan
and I'm going to show you how quickly it can go from perfect to burnt.
Now, a lot of what this comes down to is smell and sight.
And as a professional chef with over 20 years experience,
I've seen it all.
I've smelt it all.
I know exactly when I've gone too far.
So it is a little bit of practice.
And sometimes, you know what they say,
you have to crack a few eggs.
Sometimes you have to burn a little butter to be able to,
you know, to learn how to do it right.
So Joey, have a look in here.
It's getting browner.
It's getting darker.
It's still usable at this stage.
OK, I can smell it,
but I can smell it's also about to turn.
See this?
Watch this.
Seconds.
Do you see that?
From brown to almost black.
Burnt butter solids.
Brown butter.
That is unusable.
It tastes smoky.
It tastes gritty.
And it tastes burnt.
Unfortunately, I had to ruin some very lovely butter
to be able to show you what not to do.
There you go.
And of course, smoke is a telltale sign.
So that burnt one is unusable.
But lucky for me, I have a brand new one over here,
over on the counter.
So let's head over here and start to make our lovely cookies.
So here is our lovely butter.
No joke.
It actually smells like caramel.
And what you want to do is just make sure that it's not hot
when you go to use it.
So I'm going to put it in my bowl
and we're not going to want to waste a drop.
This is why spatulas come in so handy.
Liquid gold in there.
Next, we're going to add in our dark brown sugar.
The reason I use dark brown sugar for my cookies
is because it gives you that extra flavor.
It also gives you moisture.
So it has like a double effect.
And these are the kind of cookies that are like
gooey bakery style cookies.
And that needs brown sugar.
So we do a little bit of white for sweetness.
But then you also do brown for moisture
and for those caramel tones.
Now, here's a little trick that I do
that Ami kind of taught me this.
Rather than putting your salt into your dry ingredients,
put it in to your like your sugar and butter mix.
And it really just kind of gets to melt in there.
Mix it all around.
And it just combines all the way through the base of the cookie.
And I definitely notice like better flavor
when I do that better saltiness.
And you definitely need for an awesome chocolate chip cookie.
You need some saltiness.
Just combine those together into this.
We are going to add a room temperature egg
and some vanilla extract.
These are good stuff.
My chocolate chip cookies have to have vanilla extract.
Mix them until they're combined.
And you can kind of see that there's no more brown sugar lumps
and the sugar is kind of dissolving.
You just know your cookie is going to be good
if that is the base of it.
So my favorite type of chocolate chip cookie
is gooey in the middle
and like a little bit almost like undercooked
and then lightly crisp around the outside,
like just set in the middle.
And to get that, you do not want baking powder in your recipe.
Baking powder will give you cakey result.
If you like a cakey chocolate chip cookie, you do you.
It's not my favorite thing.
What I like to do is add in baking soda into my flour,
mix it around and then add it into the rest of the batter.
So baking soda, what it does,
is kind of the opposite effect of baking powder.
It will work as a leavening,
but it will kind of keep your center kind of gooey.
Also, the top of your cookie,
that lovely kind of deep crinkle that you see
in beautiful chocolate chip cookies that you see online,
that's what baking soda will do.
It will give you that crinkle.
And if you age your cookie dough,
and by that I mean once you've mixed it,
you put it in the fridge for a few days,
that crinkle on top will get even deeper
and the center, the gooeyness will be even more defined.
Mix in your dry ingredients.
And then I'm going to add in my bittersweet chocolate.
I love bittersweet chocolate.
I do recommend bittersweet chocolate for this recipe.
Semi-sweet's okay.
I wouldn't do dairy.
I will say that my six year old
has always eaten bittersweet chocolate his entire life.
And it's his jam.
And he's going to get one of these cookies
and then just mix that in.
For my chocolate, I buy a bar of good quality chocolate.
I chop it up and that's what I use.
I prefer not to use chips in certain types of cookies.
This is one of them.
The benefit of using a bar of chocolate
in a chocolate chip cookie is a few things.
Number one, if you buy a bar, you can control the quality.
If you want 85% cocoa solids,
if you want 90%, if you want 72, that's up to you.
And also what happens when you melt this chocolate,
it doesn't have any stabilizers in it
like the way chocolate chips do.
So when it melts in the oven, it'll pool
and it will kind of flow throughout the cookie
where a chocolate chip will not do that.
It will hold its shape and stay in the one spot.
And for me, a chocolate chip cookie,
you have to have like those little and big bits of chocolate
all the way throughout, just melting.
I do everything in one bowl, just like this.
And these are actually my Gemma made magic bowls.
Okay, lovely.
There we go.
That's our cookie dough.
Cookie doughs always benefit from chilling.
And also because this had melted butter in it,
we do want to chill it for a little bit.
So your chocolate chip cookies
don't end up spreading too much.
So I want to pop it into the fridge,
let it get nice and chilled, and then we can scoop it.
So for this dough, it's already kind of firm.
So I just chill it for like 30 minutes
to let that fat solidify
and make it easier for me to scoop.
You can, however, once you make your dough,
what I like to do is scoop it.
Then I will like leave it age in the refrigerator
for up to three days.
And then I also freeze the balls.
So it just makes life so much easier
when it comes to entertaining.
I've got a six year old.
Somebody always needs a chocolate chip cookie.
It just is really handy to have cookie dough in your freezer.
It's actually my mom's secret
because if you invite me somewhere
where there's going to be kids,
I will show up with cookies
and they will be the best cookies you ever had.
For this dough, I scoop it around two tablespoons,
which is kind of a tablespoon scoop
with the same measurement on bottom as it is on top.
Shape them into balls in your hands
just so they bake down nice and evenly.
Make sure you're getting
some good chocolate chip chunkage in there.
I always like to point them towards the top
so you really get a nice big chunk
in the middle of the cookie.
My gosh, I can smell this.
If you want to eat a cookie dough
and maybe like sans the egg, this is it.
So when we do food photography for my website,
we definitely, I would say,
embellish the look of some things.
And if you really want to make
that awesome bakery style cookie at home,
just like you see in cafes and in restaurants,
this is what you want to do.
You scoop your cookie
and then any of the little bits of chocolate
are floating around your bowl.
Just put it right there on the top.
That just makes sure that like every cookie
has a hero piece of chocolate.
That's how the pros do it.
Okay, lovely.
My oven is on.
It's really nice and hot.
So let's get these guys in there.
So this cookie dough makes enough cookies for two trays.
When I bake two trays of cookies,
I always do fan assist
so the fan can circulate around the cookies
and they bake evenly.
So that is 350 degrees Fahrenheit
for around eight to 10 minutes.
Be really careful,
err on the side of caution,
take them out a little bit early,
let them sit, relax,
and continue to cook.
If you're only doing one tray at a time,
do 375 and do it for the same amount of time.
Okay, now on that note,
while they are in the oven,
bowl baking hotline.
These are some good questions about brown butter.
People are very curious.
So the first question is,
can I make brown butter ahead of time?
The answer is yes.
It's actually a really smart move.
Chefs in kitchen would do that all the time.
Keep it in your fridge
and then let it get to room temperature
or whatever the texture is that you need it.
I'm guessing you could even freeze it
and it'd be even handier.
Our next one is,
can you save burnt brown butter?
It is a tricky one
because the flavor goes all the way throughout.
Your best solution,
if it's not too bad,
pass it through a coffee filter,
anything remaining in the bowl you can use
and then discard the burnt solids
because that's really where the nasty flavor is.
This next question is a fantastic one
and I love the way you think.
Can you make brown butter in the microwave?
And you know I am all about microwave recipes
and the answer is yes you can.
It's actually really easy
and there's less chance that you'll actually burn it.
Put it into a microwave safe bowl
and you're going to want to heat it up in increments.
Take it out, whisk it.
You'll see it starting to turn color.
Keep an eye on it.
Know that it continues cooking outside of the microwave
and wait until it gets that golden brown color
then remove it.
It will take a few minutes
but it's a really fantastic way to do it.
And you can do it in my metal Gemma made bowls
because they go straight in the microwave.
So I know these cookies are perfectly done
because I can see those centers are just set.
For those gooey cookie lovers,
here's a tip.
When they're out of the oven,
take them straight off the tray.
If they sit on the tray,
they'll continue to cook.
They look absolutely gorgeous.
They've got a lovely textured top
with loads of crinkles
and as you can see,
we have that very strategic big chocolate chip
on the top of each one
that has melted beautifully.
As you can see,
these are not your average cookie.
These are next level,
intense flavor,
perfect texture cookies
straight out of a professional kitchen.
The extra step we took making the brown butter
has really paid off.
It has definitely taken my chocolate chip cookie game
to the next level.
This might be one of the best
chocolate chip cookie recipes on the internet.
I'm just saying.
Thank you so much for watching.
I hope you enjoyed this recipe
and I'll see you back here again really soon.