What I think About the Katana and Japanese Swords in General

"Echo Blade "
1 follower
47 Video Views·Dec 14, 2024
A detailed video to talk about my point of view on Japanese swords particularly if compared with Western swords.
Hello number ones, welcome back to my channel. This is the Metodron speaking. Today I would
like to talk about Japanese weapons, particularly Japanese swords, katana and whatnot. I've noticed
that quite a lot of us historical YouTubers have spoken about this topic, like what do I think
about the katana? Some people's, for example, I remember that Scalagrim did talk about this and
he said that he wasn't, he's not particularly, he doesn't find katana to be particularly
aesthetically beautiful. He doesn't find them to be particularly interesting and he doesn't like
them much. And I think that I remember watching a few videos from Matt Easton from Scholar Editoria
who also talked about, he has like a sort of a similar approach to katana. So he, of course he,
Matt Easton is similar to me in the sense that we aren't really weapons geeks, you know, we really
like any sort of weapons and, but he did say something like that and he's not particularly
interested in katana. So what is my opinion, what is my position, what are my feelings for
the Japanese katana? Now for this video I don't have a good quality katana to mess around with so
my Nodachi will have to do, although if you ask me, a Nodachi is actually really, really,
I even almost prefer a Nodachi over the katana because it's just, it's just badass, it's cool.
Anyways, this will have to suffice for this video. So what is my opinion on the Japanese katana
or Japanese swords in general? Well, first of all, I'd like to say that I really like Japanese
swords and I've always been fascinated by the katana so much so that I have, as you know,
practiced kendo. Now I know that kendo is not koryu and that therefore probably practicing
something like kenjutsu or iaido would have been, would give you a better grasp on understanding how
to use a katana. But at the time, in the place where I was living in Japan, it was a very,
small countryside town and therefore there was kendo because it's the most popular now,
to be honest, in Japan among all sword martial arts or sword focused martial arts. But
I could not find any koryu or iaido school nearby where I lived so this is why I chose kendo
basically. But I don't regret it, I mean I liked it, although in the future I hope that I'll be
able to study some koryu because I am interested in particularly katori shintoryu, kenjutsu and iaido.
So as I said, I like Japanese swords a lot but I must say that regardless of the fact that I like
them a lot, they are not my favourite kind of sword. As a matter of fact, my favourite kind
of sword is the typical 13th century European sword. So this is the kind of aesthetics that
I find particularly appealing and pleasing to the eye. I really like, this is an okesho type 12,
I've said a million, millions of times now on my channel but for those of you who are
new today here, new guests, this is an okesho type 12, 13th century, beautifully made sword by
Elgar Swordsmakery and it was hand forged, spring steel, solid build. So if you compare,
if we compare a Japanese sword to a European sword we can immediately see there is a huge
difference in the guard and I have to say that not only I prefer this sort of guard because it
because it does give better or offer better protection but I actually find it more pleasing,
I find it more beautiful to look at than the small disc guard. Although it's not that I don't
like it, I still like it but the reason why I like it is because it's typical. This one I like
it from an aesthetic point of view, this one I like because when I see it I think of the samurai
which I really really like. So it's a different kind of feeling I get but if I have to consider
its practicality then I have to say that I definitely prefer this over this. Now clearly
this is a one-handed sword, this is a two-handed sword so these are completely different swords
but it's just to give you an idea on the aesthetics. Even the way the fuller is normally
in the center of the blade with European swords in the majority of cases whereas for those katana
where there is a fuller as you can see it would be towards the top part of the weapon because of
the weapon's construction. So it makes perfect sense that they would do this but I still find
this more beautiful to see. So I started being interested in samurai combat and samurai swords
and all that and samurai armor when I was 14 because that's when I started when I was first
introduced to both martial arts as I started practicing karate but also because I started
playing video games that featured samurai wielding katana. So for example Bushido Blade
which is a fantastic series of games but it's still one of my favorite simulators of samurai
combat. But the knights is something that I have had in mind since I was a lot younger as a matter
of fact when I was 9 or 10 I started playing Dungeons and Dragons with my cousin and relatives
and of course the sort of weapon that you had in mind when you thought of the word sword would be
because this is the one that I've had in mind for longer. And this is why even if compared to a Roman
Gladius I would still prefer this one over this one a lot regardless of the fact that I'm a total
complete geek for Romans for the Romans and I love Roman history but I have to say that when I
if I look at the Gladius alone I'm like oh Gladius is so cool! Roma invicta! But then when I see it
next to this I'm like ah yeah but yeah I'm just going for this one it's cooler. Now if we compare
Gladius to a Japanese sword in this case the Nodachi again here is where it becomes a stall
for me because I like both. In this case I can't choose. I like the Gladius a lot but this one
really fascinates me because of samurai. So for me this is a perfect stall. I like both and I can't
Now one thing that I would like to say though is also I think one of the reasons why at the end of
the day a because there are many types of western swords okay a type of western sword namely the
orcish type 12 or even type 15 to be honest well I like most orcish anyways I think the reason why
this happened is also a matter of statistics because if you think about it there are loads
of different kinds of medieval swords in Europe okay loads of different kinds of swords from
falchions to all the different kinds of orcish swords to lots of different kinds of swords. In
Japan instead and this is really interesting it's a very curious thing if you think about it I mean
look at the Tanto, Wakizashi, Katana, Tachi, Nodachi. They all look like the same sword but in
different length if you think about it. There isn't much variation all the guards are the same
the handles only difference is basically the length and the blades only difference is basically
the length and the amount of curvature but the concept is still the same so the Japanese basically
reaching one point in history when they developed the Tachi they just sticked to it whereas in
Europe that didn't happen much we think of the difference between a again my orcish sword and
for example completely different concepts we had both double-edged single-edged and yes you can
find some very primitive forms of double-edged weapons in Japan as well but that's not the
majority and once they reached the concept of Tachi they just stick to it the only exception
being the Nagamaki which is a different concept still very similar but it's a different concept
because of the ratio between the handle and the blade and that is why I'm very fascinated by the
I'm considering acquiring one a Wakizashi looks like a Tanto in steroids a katana looks like a
Wakizashi in steroids a Tachi is a bigger katana Nodachi is a bigger Tachi so and that thing
continues only having basically one pattern to choose from it would make sense that this pattern
doesn't please me in its entirety if compared to much more variety and this variety comes from the
idea that if you think about it I mean what happened in Europe historically speaking in Europe
what happened is that we kept on having making war at each other and of course the Japanese did as
well but the difference is that while the Japanese made war against the other Japanese yes there is
the Mongolian invasion but as a matter of fact against the Mongols what they did is that they
they started using pole arms mostly it didn't much affect weapon development as far as swords
are concerned but basically the Japanese fought against themselves a warring clans against other
warring clans so they just found one thing that worked and kept on using they didn't have to come
up with completely different things because a completely different culture had come up with a
new way of making armor or a new warfare tactics at least until the development of Tanegashima Teppo
which again came from the west from the Portuguese so as you can see the one thing that literally
changed completely the concept of warfare in Japan is a western weapon a western invention
in Europe instead you've got all these completely different cultures I mean an English man a French
man an Italian and a Spanish and a German and a Greek we're all completely different we don't
speak the same language we don't eat the same food we are very very different our buildings
look different even today regardless of globalization our buildings look different
our houses look different the way we live is different the way we eat is different
we are completely different and of course we come up with completely different tactics and
concepts as far as war is concerned and therefore our weapons will be I mean if you look at Italian
and Northern Italian armor and you compare it to German Gothic armor and you compare it to native
English armor they are different they are very different each one making his own decision and
of course based on what they were going to face in on the battlefield etc this is why I think I
at the end of the day I do prefer western swords but again I think the difference in terms of
aesthetics between a western sword and a Japanese sword is not that much for me so it's like this
is for me an Okashot type 12 for example or quite a few other kinds of western swords and this is a
katana okay they're very similar if you take for example a European falchion then this is what
happens and if you take a viking sword although I really like them you know it's I still prefer
katana over viking swords but if you give me the Okashot types of swords then I do prefer those
so that's my situation I really like katana and I would like to expand my understanding
and my ability to use them but I do find European western swords to be more pleasing to the eye
okay one last point I'd like to bring up before closing this video is that there is one thing
though that I prefer Japanese swords over western swords and that is quickdraw now I'm not an expert
of quickdraw as a matter of fact not only I'm not an expert of quickdraw and iaido techniques but I
don't actually know any iaido within my lack of knowledge of this martial art still when I tried
to quick draw a katana and then I tried to quick draw a western sword or my Okashot for example
I still find it easier to quick draw or to draw the katana from the scabbard and I don't know why
to be honest um some people say because of the slight curvature I've seen people bringing up
lots of arguments against it saying but no the curvature is not going to change anything you can
give me all the theory in the planet but when I'm going to try when I test it and when I try it
it feels easier so I don't know the mathematics of it I don't know the physics of it um but it's
I do know the feeling and as far as the feeling is concerned whenever I try to quick draw a western
sword and when I try to quick draw a katana even if they're a very similar size it's easier to me
to perform such draws and such moves with a Japanese sword but let me know what you think
about this in the comments below
all right then I hope that you enjoyed this video if you did please remember thumbs up and subscribe
to my channel for more content from the Metatron I will see you tomorrow for my next video
and remember the Metatron has spread his wings goodbye samurai
