This video covers why democracy may be humanity's biggest obstacle in space — and what Frank White thinks we should do about it.
White doesn't mince words. Every two to four years, a new administration tears up what the last one built. For a civilization trying to expand into the cosmos, that's a structural problem no rocket can solve.
His answer: a transnational body — something like a Human Space Alliance — that can weather the political storms.
Not American. Not Chinese.
Human.
If you're in the suit, you're going up.
This isn't a new idea for White.
At the end of the first edition of his landmark book The Overview Effect, he was already calling for exactly this — a Human Space Program built on a transnational foundation, committed to expanding into the solar ecosystem with values he describes as ethical, inclusive and sustainable.
He also introduces a term he's adopted from fellow space thinker Jeff Greason: polycentric humanity — the idea of settling anywhere in the cosmos, from multiple perspectives, with multiple approaches.
Not one flag. Many.
And then there's the question of where all this thinking came from — because Frank White will be the first to tell you he was no philosophy student.
If you have questions for Frank, leave them in the comments and we will gather selected questions for a future interview.
There's lots of beautiful things for democracy.
I like what Edward Morgan Forster, E.M. Forster, said,
two cheers for democracy.
He thought two was enough.
Three means you don't have any critique.
He had plenty of critiques, but two, you know,
because it allowed some basic pushback and questioning.
But I think there is a downside to democracy
in the sense that exactly every two to four years,
we rip our policies apart and we start over,
and so we really get left behind.
It would be nice to have some sort of
extra-national, international body for space
that could be the human, you know,
you have the human space program.
We could have the Human Space Alliance or something
that could weather the storm of all those
crazy political moments.
You know, no matter where you come from,
if you're human, you are in the suit.
You're going up.
We're gonna build space for humanity.
But I mean, that's probably a big, it's a big lift.
It's a big request for sure.
Well, it's interesting you bring that up
because at the end of the first edition
of the overview, in fact, I started talking
about a human space program.
And the reason was I felt like we needed
that kind of transnational attitude
that a national space program would never be enough.
And so the human space program exists,
it's a 501c3 organization.
And we are committed to, you know,
exploring the universe,
but starting with the solar ecosystem
and, you know, making sure that it's ethical,
inclusive, and sustainable,
that the human expansion of the world
has positive values behind it, overview effect values.
And therefore, we are not,
although we were founded in the United States,
we don't want to limit ourselves
to being an American organization.
You know, I've started using this new term,
Jeff Greeson, who's a guest we had on recently.
I think you might know Jeff Greeson.
I do.
Really good guy, brilliant.
He uses polycentric humanity in the sense that,
you know, obviously I founded multi-planetary society.
I'm very partial to the term multi-planetary,
and I've always said it means asteroids
or starships or planets.
It's not just planets, but his idea was polycentric,
because it means settling anywhere out in the cosmos,
but also coming at it from different ways,
different perspectives, having different options.
So I love the idea of polycentric.
It's become part of my vocabulary now.
A lot of what you're talking about, Frank, is philosophy,
and you are a space philosopher.
That's not something that a lot of people
are familiar with, even in the industry.
I would love for you to go back and talk to me
about the origins of that for you.
When did you realize, or when did you really cook up
this idea of space philosophy?
When did that become part of your life?
That's an easy question.
I've often said to people,
I only took about two philosophy courses in college,
and I didn't really do all that well in one of them.
So I started out, my training is as a social scientist.
In 1986, after the Challenger disaster,
I was working on the Overview Effect book,
and there was a TV show called This Week with David Brinkley
and it was the weekend after the disaster.
So David Brinkley had Isaac Asimov,
and Tom Wolfe on, and they were talking about,
well, wait a minute.