Should All Humans Be Eliminated from the Earth? | PragerU

PragerU
799 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 23, 2025
Would the planet be better off if there were fewer people inhabiting it? Elon Musk, Zuby, and Marian Tupy explain why fewer humans does not make for a better world.
📲 Watch our content ad-free on our app: https://prageru.onelink.me/3bas/vgyxvm79
Follow PragerU on social media!
Instagram ➡️ (https://www.instagram.com/prageru/)
Twitter ➡️ (https://twitter.com/prageru)
Facebook ➡️ (https://www.facebook.com/prageru/)
I think the whole overpopulation thing is a massive sign up.
Why do so many otherwise smart people buy into that?
Well, I think to some degree, this is a side effect of the environmental movement.
Like in the limit of environmentalism, you sought to conclude that humanity is a plague on Earth.
That humanity is actually the problem.
That's a big one.
Yeah. And that's like obviously taking the environmental movement just too far.
But there are literally people who believe this.
They're like extinctionists.
New York Times some months ago had a front page article with some guy and his quote was
there are eight billion people on Earth and it would be better if there were none.
That's dark.
Yeah. I'm like, hey, buddy, you can solve it yourself.
You know, if you really want to make a difference, I would take your advice here.
That's like literally saying let's genocide humanity.
Like what?
There are now eight billion people living on the planet.
Is there enough room for all of us?
Aren't we going to run out of natural resources?
How are we going to feed everybody?
These are not new questions.
Doomsayers have been asking them for at least 200 years.
In 1798, an English economist named Thomas Malthus wrote his famous essay on the principle
of population.
In it, Malthus claimed that population grew exponentially, while resources needed to feed
that population grew at a linear rate.
The difference between the two growth rates, he argued, must lead to starvation.
Malthus was wrong and not by a little, by a lot.
As the population grew, food production improved, and so did almost everything else.
Consider the life of a typical American blue-collar worker over the span of a century.
Using a unit of measurement known as time prices, we can estimate the amount of time
someone would have to work to buy a given item.
Between 1900 and 2018, the length of time our blue-collar worker had to work to earn
enough money to buy a pound of pork fell by 98 percent, to buy a pound of rice by 97
percent, to buy a pound of coffee, 94 percent.
While people can't eat rubber, aluminum, or cotton, these commodities are valuable
inputs in the production processes that impact the prices of goods and services, and hence
the overall standard of living.
Their prices fell by 99 percent, 98 percent, and 96 percent respectively, while population
of the United States rose from 76 million to 328 million.
Famines, which were once common, have disappeared outside of war zones.
In much of the world today, it's obesity, not starvation, that is a problem.
This relationship between population growth and abundance may seem counterintuitive,
but it's true.
Remember this chart that so frightened Malthus?
The reality looks very different.
The more people we have, the more abundance we have.
Relative to previous generations, we now live in a world of superabundance, the term that
my colleague and co-author Gail Pooley and I have coined and use as the title of our
book.
What makes this superabundance possible?
The answer is knowledge.
Thomas Sowell, the brilliant Hoover Institution economist, explains it this way.
The difference in the standard of living between the caveman and us is not natural resources.
The difference is knowledge.
We have a lot more of it, and we use that knowledge to make things from the same natural
resources that existed during the time of the caveman, but which the caveman could never
have imagined.
Let's look at something as simple as a grain of sand.
It's been lying around for billions of years.
Then, some four and a half thousand years ago, someone figured out that by heating sand
to just over 3,000 degrees Fahrenheit, sand could be turned into glass beads, then glass
jars, and much later, window panes.
With every step of discovery, the value produced from a grain of sand increased.
Today, we use glass in fiber optic cables and computer microchips, turbocharging our
productivity.
That's making us much more prosperous than our ancestors.
Counting the quantity of known raw materials, like Malthus and many other people have done,
might seem logical, but it misses the ingredient that changes everything.
Knowledge.
And new knowledge emerges from the human mind.
A newborn comes into the world not only with an empty stomach, but also a brain capable
of intelligent, potentially world-changing thought.
So what really matters is not the finite number of atoms on the planet, be they of zinc or
copper or any other element, but the human ability to combine and recombine those atoms
in ever more valuable ways.
Therefore, we can confidently say that economic growth is less about resources, which are
limited, and more about knowledge, which is limitless.
As the Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Romer put it, new ideas do not add up, they
multiply.
Here is another useful analogy.
The world is a closed system in the way that a piano is a closed system.
The instrument has only 88 keys, but those keys can be played in an infinite number of
ways.
The same applies to our planet.
The Earth's atoms may be fixed, but the possible combinations of those atoms are infinite.
What matters, then, is not the physical limits of our planet, but the human beings and their
freedom to experiment and reimagine the use of resources that we have.
Can we continue to live in a superabundant world?
That depends on two components, people and freedom.
The more people the planet has, and the more freedom they enjoy, the greater the likelihood
that new, useful ideas will be generated to tackle our problems, whatever they happen
to be.
So, do you still think there are too many people?
Or maybe not enough?
I'm Marian Tupi, senior fellow at the Cato Institute and co-author of Superabundance,
for Prager University.
