Innovation at the Speed of Space - #SpeedOfSpace - 9.10

TMRO Space News
221 followers
185 Video Views·Dec 4, 2022
This week we ask if the speed of space innovation is getting faster with new entrants on the scene. Will it ever reach the speed of technology innovation?
In Space News:
* Soyuz launches Resurs P3
* Proton launches ExoMars
* Soyuz launches Soyuz
* ULA VP resigns after controversial comments
* Space Fire
* Iran planning a space launch soon
* Space Clothes
TMRO Live is a crowd funded show. If you like this episode consider contributing to help us to continue to improve. Head over to http://www.patreon.com/tmro for information, goals and reward levels. Don't forget to check out our SpacePod campaign as well over at http://www.patreon.com/spacepod
Coming up, space launches, space controversy, and space fashion.
Plus, we're going to be talking about innovation
at the speed of space.
Stay tuned.
Tomorrow begins Space Now.
And welcome to tomorrow's season nine, episode 10,
for Saturday, March 19, 2016.
My name is Benjamin Higginbotham.
I'll be joined by Karian and Mike in just a moment.
But first, a huge shout out to all of the patrons of Tomorrow
who helped to make this specific segment of this episode happen.
These are the people who've contributed $10 or more to this episode.
We are a crowdfunded show.
If you'd like to find out how you can help crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow,
head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
Jared, you're looking awfully phony this week.
Welcome back.
Welcome back to the table.
Actually, Donna, do you have the image?
There you go.
That's where Jared, that literally is Jared right now, stuck in the mud.
That is why he can't be here.
You'll never see him again.
Let's be honest.
He might be gone.
Poor kid.
He's the one who wanted to visit Nietzsche for the weekend.
And so now he is.
He may need a rocket to help launch him out of that location.
And speaking of rocket launches, yes, that's how I'm going to segue.
Let's talk about a Soyuz launch of Rikers P-3.
And whoosh, it goes.
That happened March 13th at 1856 Coordinated Universal Time.
That was supposed to happen a day before, on March 12th.
But an abort triggered moments before ignition.
And we actually were able to show that on last week's show,
where for once in a very blue moon, a Soyuz rocket had a launch abort,
which was a little bit weird.
But 24 hours later, boom, successful launch.
The Rikers P-3 satellite hosts a boom.
It was more like boom, bigger boom, much bigger boom.
And you're like, just launch.
Just launch.
The Rikers P-3 satellite hosts a suite of digital cameras.
They're looking back to the Earth in 96 different spectral bands.
They're going to be looking at crop yields, vegetation health,
microbial activity in the water, easy for me to say,
and impacts of invasive insects on agriculture,
kind of what they're looking at.
They've got a telephoto camera with a focal length of 4,000 millimeters,
which will take the highest resolution images.
Their black and white imagery is going to have a resolution of approximately 1
meter, which is 3 and 1 half feet, or 3, I'm sorry,
3.3 feet for those of you in the US.
And then the color camera, it was going to have a resolution of about 10
to 13 feet, like I said, for colors.
It's going to join two similar satellites named Rikers P-1 and Rikers P-2,
which launched in June of 2013 and December of 2014 respectively.
All right, this is the one that Jared, and let's show a picture again
of where Jared is at.
This is what he was all excited about.
This is why you don't go to nature.
You bring nature to you.
This is why right here.
He was excited about ExoMars, and the first part of that mission
launched on March 14th at 9.31 Coordinated Universal Time.
Man, just the story of those images.
Wow, that was awesome.
That is the ExoMars mission to Mars.
It has the Trace Gas Orbiter and the Schiaparelli.
How do you do it, Mike?
Schiaparelli.
Schiaparelli lander aboard.
Now, the Trace Gas Orbiter is going to be,
as you kind of get from the name, orbiting Mars.
It's going to look for methane gas in the atmosphere of Mars.
It's going to look for, the reason it's looking for methane gas
is the breakdown of organic material itself creates methane.
So that will actually prove that there is organic life on Mars breaking
something down and turning it into methane.
That's pretty neat.
It's going to start doing that in December of 2017.
And then we've also got the Schiaparelli, I hope I did that right, lander.
This is actually kind of a precursor mission to the ExoMars rover
that will be going in 2018.
So it's designed to test the technologies of the ExoMars rover
that will be landing in 2018.
So it's going to kind of go down there, land,
it's basically a crash land on the surface of Mars,
make sure that that works before they actually send the real lander in 2018.
The arrival target for the whole mission is October of 2016,
specifically October 19th of 2016.
And also aims to take high resolution pictures of Mars
and search for hydrogen embedded in the crust itself.
So pretty freaking awesome.
And I know Jared's going to be excited because proton launches
aren't the most stable launcher out there.
What did we determine last week?
What was it, Mike?
Like a 1 in 7, 1 in 8 failure rate, something like that?
I think it was something like that.
The value changes after each launch.
But yeah, in recent years, it's been something like 1 in 6, 1 in 7.
So scary, but it was successful.
So huzzah.
All right.
Good job, guys.
And last launch this last week, Soyuz launched Soyuz.
Oh, all right.
Well, we're going to have to wait for this really long ignition sequence again.
So, yes, the engines fire.
Yeah, we're still firing the engines.
Flight speed standing by.
Jeff Williams, the Lexio team, and Oleg Skripocha
launching to the International Space Station.
Oh, he did it for me.
I don't even have to do it.
March 19th at 2226 Coordinated Universal time.
That is the Soyuz TMA-20M or 46S spacecraft sitting on top
with the three crew members heading up to the International Space Station.
And it's going to be a busy time for those astronauts going up to ISS.
We just completed our year in space.
So huzzah, awesome for that.
But coming up shortly, we've got Cygnus cargo craft going up on March 22nd.
So they're going to have to take the cargo supply off of that.
Then shortly thereafter, there's a Progress resupply mission
scheduled for March 31st.
So just about a week later.
I love the little owl floating in there.
We're not going to reach it in this particular show.
So if you want, go hit YouTube, look up our launch library or whatnot,
and go back and search for TMA-20 or Soyuz launch.
And you'll actually see at engine cutoff,
the owl just bounce way up out of the frame.
It's kind of cool.
And then, so after the Progress supply ship on March 31st,
you've got a Dragon cargo capsule arriving at station on April 8th.
And the really cool thing about that is that's
going to be bringing with it the Bigelow Expandable Activity
Module, or BEAM module, which is a giant inflatable
section of the space station, which will essentially
be proving out what I'll call a space hotel.
That's not really what it's doing, but I'm going to do that.
I'm going to call it proving out a space hotel,
because I would love to fly to a Bigelow floating space hotel.
I think that'd be pretty awesome.
Stay there for like a week.
Get like the concierge level, the club level.
Right.
That's the thing.
All right, Mike, Space Mike.
A few things went down at United Launch Alliance this last week.
It all happened very rapidly and took us by surprise.
It was kind of amazing.
Talk to us about that.
Quite a bit, quite a bit.
So the vice president of engineering over at United Launch Alliance,
Toby Brett, he made some pretty controversial statements
regarding the GPS contract that United Launch Alliance bid for,
and their competitors, SpaceX, and also the engine development
on their future rocket, and whether or not
they're going to choose Blue Origin or Aerojet Rocketdyne.
And when it came to those two companies and the engines
that they're working on, he said that these two engines,
he pretty much compared them to fiances.
And one company was like the rich girl,
and the other company was like the poor girl and had no chance.
And his comparison was that Blue Origin was the rich girl,
and Aerojet was the poor girl.
So pretty controversial there.
You know, outside of the idea that it's controversial,
it's like mild, it's sexist.
I mean, it's just in bad taste, it's sexist.
And then he's basically saying,
we don't care about Aerojet Rocketdyne,
we're all about Blue Origin.
What the heck?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Pretty bold statements to be making,
especially since the company has been working with both companies.
And it is not only that, but there's
other contracts working for both companies
to develop their engines.
So it's pretty kind of a weird situation there.
But also with SpaceX, he praised their ability
to be able to land the first stage of the Falcon 9
back on December 21, 2015, but called the whole reusability
plan dumb, and pretty much said that the whole reason
that they didn't want to compete with SpaceX in the most
recent DoD contracts for the GPS III fleet of satellites
is that they didn't want to enter into a price war
with SpaceX, which is completely contradicting
their official reason for not competing in that competition.
So of course, John McCain is pissed,
and he is launching an investigation
into this Toby Brett guy, and into United Launch Alliance
as well.
And because of all this, the guy resigned immediately.
I mean, immediately, CEO Tory Bruno
disavowed all of those comments that this guy made.
And the guy has since resigned.
And we're just going to have to wait
and see if this is going to lead to any more
serious consequences for the company.
It may.
I mean, he went on to say some other really interesting
things.
In all fairness, I don't think he
thought he was being recorded, right?
He was back at his old school.
Yes.
No, no, don't get me wrong.
You shouldn't be saying these things.
Yeah, exactly.
Even if you think that this is a closed session talk,
you shouldn't be saying these things.
You shouldn't even be liking these things to other things.
Look, I don't want to make an excuse.
He was giving the talk.
It's one thing if he said these sort of things
in the hallway with someone.
It's another thing if he was a speaker
and was saying these things to an audience.
So I'll say two things.
One, you don't say these things even in the hallway
to someone when your official answer is
something else in your multi-billion dollar
company with an actual contract.
That's not super smart.
But two, I don't want to make excuses for him,
but he's giving a presentation, right?
And it's hard to do that.
And he's at a school, so he's trying to go with the flow,
and he may have just made a bet.
I mean, that's what every millennial wants
is two fiancés, isn't it?
It was a bet.
Let's be fair.
It was a bet.
I'm not making excuses for him.
It shouldn't have been said.
It was a bad judgment call, but it sucks.
I will say that when this story first broke,
people, there was a lot of misinformation
because a lot of people were very excited
about things that had been said.
And initially I heard, they were like,
yeah, the head of ULA was saying blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
And I was like, I'm sorry.
Tory Bruno, homie, what?
Like, cause he's-
He's up there.
Yeah, but I mean-
He's not Tory, but he's up there.
No, no, no.
But Tory has a tendency to be very
all ships rise to the tide.
You know, this, that, and the other.
And I was very surprised by that.
But then once I finally had an understanding
of what was going on, and I was like,
oh, Brett Tobey.
I'm like, that's a completely different person.
Nevermind.
Yeah.
I'll say Tory Bruno is doing a fantastic job
of making United Launch Alliance cool again,
which is important to bring in new engineering talent.
And they just didn't have that under the old regime.
And Tory Bruno, I think, is doing a fantastic job
of making ULA actually much cooler.
This was a bit of a setback.
I won't even say cool,
but definitely approachable and welcoming.
I would say cool.
And interesting.
He's on Twitter.
He's interacting.
I think he's engaging.
That's pretty cool, right?
I mean, I don't even know who the last CEO was.
Yeah, I don't remember either.
We've had, we've like mentioned him on the show,
and I don't remember his name,
but I will remember Tory Bruno.
I think he's doing a great job.
This sucks all the way around for everyone involved.
It should not have been said.
I'm not making excuses.
All I'm saying is the situation sucks.
That's all.
So there you go.
Speaking of fire.
Yeah, that's.
Well, speaking of being fired,
let's talk about fire in the International Space Station.
Wow.
Okay, it's not in the International Space Station.
Oh man.
Didn't we just talk about misinformation?
We're great at that.
Goodness.
So speaking of the Cygnus cargo vehicle,
so Glenn Research Center in Cleveland, Ohio,
part of the NASA Research Center groups,
is purposely going to set fire in space,
which is just awesome all the way around.
It's awesome and generally a very bad idea.
Exactly.
But designed as an experiment.
Right, because they want to study the behavior
of how fire spreads and acts
basically outside of Earth's atmosphere.
And this will be the biggest fire,
a man-made fire outside of Earth, I suppose,
or in space is what I'm trying to say.
And the whole idea is that they're motivated
to reduce risks on long duration flights.
So one of those risks could potentially be
something catching on fire.
That's a high, that's a big risk.
Right, so you have to understand what you're doing,
what's going on, and how it acts
and all that other fun stuff.
So the NASA Spacecraft Fire Experiment, or SAFIRE,
because...
Backronym.
Yes.
It's a team of researchers from 11 US
and international government agencies and universities.
And the first of three plans,
they have six plans experiments all together.
Three of them are already built.
And the first of those three, that make sense?
Okay, is scheduled to launch on the orbital ATK Cygnus
cargo vehicle on March 22nd that we talked about earlier
to the International Space Station.
The experiment takes place in a three by three
by five foot tall module,
and it'll be conducted on the return trip
because Cygnus, as you know,
just usually burns up in the atmosphere.
So this will happen between coming off
of the International Space Station
and before returning or getting burnt up in the atmosphere.
That's a pretty big experiment.
Yeah, three by three by five.
It's like a mid-sized lion.
It's like an adolescent lion, give or take.
The data and images.
That probably has something to do with the fact
that there's so many cargo flights coming up
in the coming weeks as well.
I mean, we have the orbital ATK Cygnus,
we have a Progress and we have a Dragon
all within a couple of weeks of each other.
Yeah, well, I thought three by three by five
was like fairly sizable.
Cygnus is a decent size,
but it's still taking up a good portion of that.
So I was impressed that they were able
to get something that large as just a,
hey, you have to take this up
and it's gonna take up room for a while
and you can't pack it, even though it's a cargo mission
and you have to just wait and just leave it in there
for its return home.
You know what I'm saying?
Anyway, the dated images will be transmitted
to Glenn before brought up on re-entry.
And like I said, there's three out of six,
three of them hopefully are gonna be flown this year
with the next three to be then built
and then flown in 2018, which is kind of cool.
All again on orbital ATK Cygnus cargo resupply missions
the International Space Station.
So that was really cool.
Awesome.
Very cool.
Space Mike, talk to us about of all places Iran.
Or as some people pronounce it, Iran.
I've gotten a lot of flack that before.
So Iran, anyway.
Which way is it?
Am I pronouncing it wrong?
I've been told that the correct way to say is Iran.
All right.
Tell us about Iran.
So the Iranian National Space Agency
is planning to launch a new class of rocket soon
that'll be their next satellite launcher.
And they've launched a couple of satellites in the past,
with their Safir rocket.
And with this new rocket that we see here in this image,
this is called the Simyorg rocket.
And with this, it's gonna be a larger diameter
first stage than the Safir rocket,
but its upper stage, which you can see a model of there,
is going to be the same as the Safir stage.
And this rocket is actually really comparable
to the same rockets that North Korea recently launched.
And the two countries have been working together
on rocket technology for several years.
But with these kind of new images coming out,
we're seeing that there actually are quite a few differences
to the Simyorg rocket.
But in any case, the space program hasn't launched anything
in over a year and a half because of budget limits.
That's the only factor that has been slowing them down.
And they're preparing to launch this new rocket
from a new field.
There's actually US officials who tell Fox News
that they could be launching as soon as this weekend.
They could be launching right now, for all we know.
And they'd said that that was from an undisclosed location,
but here is a picture of their new launch center,
the, excuse me, I have to make sure I pronounce this right,
the Imam Khomeini Space Launch Center.
I think that's how it's pronounced, Imam Khomeini.
And you can see there,
from the larger diameter of the first stage,
that is the Simyorg rocket.
It has a pretty nice gantry there
compared to just the kind of ICBM truck
that they used on their previous rockets.
And according to some sources,
they missed an opportunity to launch
on the anniversary of the Islamic Revolution,
which is kind of a pattern that Iran has had in the past
with their satellite launches,
is launching on special holidays for the country.
And they missed that opportunity.
And since then, some of their officials
from the Iranian National Space Agency came out
and said that there would be
actually three different tests this year.
A lot of people thought that this test,
from this picture here, was going to carry a satellite.
This is just going to be a test flight of the Simyorg rocket.
Probably has a dummy payload.
And there'll be one more test flight of the rocket as well.
And both of those test flights
will only have two stages to them, liquid fuel stages.
The first and second stage are used on a previous rocket.
But on the third test flight,
well, probably actually I should call it an official launch
that they're planning to have later on this year,
it will also have a third and fourth upper stage engines
that are solid rocket fuel.
And that's the image that you're seeing right here.
And with this image,
oh, I'm sorry, I kind of threw that to you earlier.
Sorry about that.
But with this, you can still see
that it has two separate versions
of the solid rocket motor
that would be able to kick up payloads
into the orbits that they want to do.
And with this, according to civil sources,
they're saying that the problems
that they're having right now
is with this new launch site,
being able to keep the pressures
and the temperatures of the liquid fuel
for the first and second stages of this rocket
in acceptable levels.
And not only that,
but they also have restrictions on when they can launch
and due to shipping lanes and stuff like that.
And they have to cooperate a lot with their neighbors
on when they can actually launch.
So there's a lot of factors going into this,
but I mean, the rocket is on the pad.
And as soon as they figure out
whatever these problems are,
and they'll be able to launch this.
And Iran's space program
will only be able to keep moving forward from this.
And hopefully even their manned space program
will be able to get going on the next version of this rocket,
which we can talk about in a future space pod.
Cool, thank you, Space Mike.
And Cariann, take us into break with some space clothing.
Yes, I was super excited to hear about this.
So XCOR Aerospace,
which is based here in Mojave, California.
Well, here.
What?
Well, now they're based in Texas, aren't they?
They are currently building out in Midland, Texas.
They officially are still based in Mojave, California.
I did not know that.
According to their website, xcor.com.
So there's that.
They're halfway between mom and dad's house.
I'm sorry, say again?
They're halfway between mom and dad's house.
Yes, exactly, right?
They're adding another big brand to their collection,
which currently holds KLM, Philips, Unilever,
Luminox, and Heineken.
And this one is called Black Ladder.
At least, I think it is.
We're just gonna pretend like it is.
Which is a clothing supplier based in Sweden,
and they make extreme work garments.
Things like fire resistant, high visibility,
waterproof, that sort of thing.
I love this image, I think it is amazing.
So what Black Ladder is gonna do
is they're gonna make custom gear
for the engineers who work on the Lynx,
but also the training and flight suits
for the pilots and passengers on the upcoming flights.
Xcor, of course, is happy to have somebody
to be making, I can't speak apparently,
working with, to have someone who is making
the rocket test firings and liquid nitrogen loading
now fashionable, right?
Yeah.
And then Black Ladder is excited to possibly
send some of their customers onto the one hour,
150,000 4G and weightlessness trip.
So I think that's kind of the give or take there.
Yes, which I thought was really cool.
But they do make some really,
considering it has to be work gear
and it has to be that sort of extreme stuff,
they are actually making it quite fashionable.
I likened it to sort of a Dickies brand
or Jaloof company brand, you know, here in the States.
But they make stuff for all over the world.
If you want more information,
you can hit up blackladder.com slash Xcor.
Awesome.
All right, we're going to take a quick break.
And when we come back, we're going to be talking
about the speed of innovation in space.
Hashtag speed of space.
Stay tuned.
We'll be right back.
♪ Her face, determination in her eyes ♪
♪ She won't give up or quit or fall for lesions ♪
♪ This girl's a fascination ♪
♪ Don't think in her way, her destination ♪
♪ Cause she's fire walking, she's fire walking ♪
♪ And she keeps on moving, but it keeps on improving ♪
♪ Yeah, she's fire, she's fire walking to be free ♪
And welcome back to Tomorrow.
Now, before we get into our main topic this week,
first, actually, Donut, let's do a checkup
on where Jared's at right now.
Let's see how he's doing.
Let's see if we've got an update.
Not looking so good, Jared.
Not looking so good.
I did want to thank all of the patrons of Tomorrow
who've helped to make this specific segment
of this episode happen.
These are people who've contributed $5
or more to this episode.
We are a crowdfunded show,
and you can learn how to crowdfund us,
help crowdfund us, over at patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
All right, let's go ahead and start talking
about our main topic this week, hashtag speed of space.
And that's talking about the speed of innovation.
This actually came from a tweet,
and I wish I had it handy.
This started from, hang on,
we're gonna awkwardly try to do this.
No, I'm not gonna be able to do it.
Oh, here we go.
It's from at ma, at Mackinsenia.
I don't know how to pronounce it.
At Tomorrow, it was through watching your show,
I realized how slow the march of space technology really is.
And it kind of got, you know,
we've mentioned a little bit before,
you know, space doesn't work at the same rate
as like, you know, a phone, right?
You see phone innovation,
although it's starting to stagnate a little bit,
but you see phone innovation happen
on a yearly or bi-yearly basis,
whereas rocket technology seems to innovate
on a decadal kind of like,
every couple of decades you get,
it seems like you get some sort of breakthrough.
Right, it feels maybe something interesting happening.
Now, that may not be entirely true,
but that's kind of how it feels.
So I guess that's kind of where we'll start,
which is, it was interesting in the Apollo era,
prior, you know, JFK made his very famous,
we choose to go, right, speech,
I don't know what to call that,
but you know the speech we're talking about.
Yeah, the moon speech.
Yeah, the what speech, Donna?
We choose to go at Rice.
The Rice speech.
Yeah, the Rice speech.
Yeah, but I feel like we choose to go is more,
anyhow, you guys know the speech we're talking about.
So he makes that speech,
and then less than a decade later,
humans walking on the moon.
Now, part of that is because it was a brand new,
we had never done that,
so the only thing you could do
was learn and enhance and create,
but then it feels like after that,
yeah, we have the space shuttle,
but there was kind of this stagnation
of nothing happened, right?
We got the space shuttle,
so we were able to kind of sort of figure that out,
but was that really any better than Apollo?
Well, we'll ignore that part of it,
but there was no real huge,
what am I trying to say?
Enhancement in space until recently,
and it feels like a lot of things
are really starting to speed up recently,
so that's the main topic I'll start with.
There's really no question, Mike,
other than, actually, I will give you this question.
Do we think that the speed of space improvement,
the speed at which we're able to explore space
is starting to get much faster now,
now that we have these new space entrants on the scene?
I definitely think so.
I mean, from my opinion, I guess,
I mean, we had 17 years of space shuttle
where we were launching communication satellites
and some cool science missions as well,
and I mean, we have Hubble to thank during that time period,
but I mean, 17 years of space shuttle
before we finally started construction
on the International Space Station,
and in recent years,
with all of these new space companies,
I feel like there has been,
and there actually was kind of a movement
like this in the 80s
that was kind of the first new space movement,
and kind of the survivor
or the big champion of that movement was Orbital Sciences,
which has now merged with ATK to be Orbital ATK,
and we have this new movement now
where we're having all of these private companies
and all of these investors getting interested in space
and making a lot of things really happen,
and it doesn't hurt, too,
that we had some kind of people with a lot of ingenuity
who set up all these competitions for some big things
and some small things
for different space innovation as well,
NASA included in that group,
and so I definitely think that there has been
a really big kind of renaissance in space, if you will,
over the past 10 years.
You know, a couple of great comments from the chat room.
How do you say that one?
Amur Tiger?
Yeah.
Amur Tiger.
Phones are also connected to Moore's Law,
which is always going to outpace space technology,
but I question why.
Why does that need to out,
why can't space technology be connected to Moore's Law?
Yeah, we have a lot of,
we're fighting gravity, which a phone isn't doing.
Right.
I mean, I guess it is when you drop it,
they're trying to make it more resilient.
A little bit easier than fighting gravity.
I get it, it's much harder in space,
but why can't it be connected
to something similar to Moore's Law
where it can actually enhance and get increased?
And I think that comes down to what someone else said.
Oh, I didn't star it.
But basically, the idea is that once businesses
are involved, and it's not just government,
the rate of advancement will increase.
So same question to you.
The rate of advancement of space, is that the same,
is it getting better now?
Is it actually the same, but because we feel like it's new,
it feels faster?
Wow, yeah, I don't know that I know
how to answer that question, honestly.
I think the thing to maybe take note of
is that while we keep saying that phones or computers,
every year there's a new one,
there's something different about it, et cetera, et cetera,
and it feels like there's nothing new or different
about something in the space industry,
that there are a lot of things that I think,
like, I know you're gonna hate this answer for me,
but NASA spinoffs.
Yep.
Yep, okay, so there's a lot of,
it's sort of like a duck floating on water.
All you see is the duck.
It's a duck.
And I think we keep waiting for another duck to appear,
not realizing or understanding
that there's a lot more going on
than just the duck floating on water.
It's a bad analogy, I apologize.
But the idea being that there are a lot of innovations
that are being made that aren't necessarily
directly impacting the space industry,
but are coming out of the space industry.
So I actually. Does that make sense?
It does.
So for those who don't know, I have a huge,
I don't like the spinoffs argument.
Well, but let me clarify what I don't like about it.
I don't like doing programs, like a specific program,
simply so you can get the spinoffs from it.
Right.
If that's your reasoning behind a certain program,
just go do the spinoff, don't do the program.
Right.
Now, if you do a program and it serves a purpose
and it has a really good fundamental science thing
over here and you happen to get spinoffs,
I'm okay with that.
I don't mind the spinoffs.
But you can't use spinoffs as a primary way of reason,
primary reason behind a particular program
or a reason to do something.
I don't, just go do the spinoff instead.
Right, no, no, no.
And I agree with that.
If you really, for whatever reason,
you are determined to make a better helmet for football,
then just go out and try and make
a better helmet for football.
However, there are a lot of innovations
that have come out of, not just NASA,
but the space industry as a whole,
that, again, don't necessarily impact
the space industry per se, but are still innovations.
And so, it's hard to quantify how fast
or how well the innovation in space is going.
Does that make sense?
Yeah, but I mean, let's look at,
Space Mike, talk to us a bit about SpaceX
and how quickly they're moving through
some of their rockets and engines and whatnot
as compared to what we had before.
You know, I really compare SpaceX's program
to the early NASA days.
You know, in the early NASA days,
NASA and the organization before it
was going through different types of rockets all the time.
And at one point, we had six different rockets
being developed in the United States
before we actually had space launch capability.
And, you know, I feel like that with SpaceX,
even though they weren't going through
a whole bunch of different rockets at the beginning,
they were trying to be innovative
and improve on the technology.
You know, getting the base technology
that they started from and going from there
and finding all the techniques
and learning how to do rocket science in the first place,
and then finally being able to achieve,
you know, successful orbital launches.
And then just, you know, going from there
and plowing through with a new type of rocket,
a bigger, better rocket, and having even more plans
for bigger and better rockets in the future.
And, you know, even though, I mean,
I think SpaceX was officially started
or founded in 2001, if I'm not mistaken.
You know, so it's been a couple of years,
but no one had even really heard of SpaceX,
even within the space industry,
until like, I don't know, 2003, 2005.
And so, I mean, as they've been doing things,
I can look at it kind of like the same sort of
speed of development that NASA had in its first 10 years.
You know, but, you know, maybe not in the same way,
but under the same circumstances that SpaceX can,
you know, with the personal budget of Elon Musk
starting it off and eventually getting investors.
You know, they've been able to innovate
as fast as they possibly can, so it's not quite the same.
But that's the way that I look at it anyway.
I think another way of sort of applying these ideas
is that somebody, who was it, in the chat room,
EOR3061, said LASIK surgery existed before Hubble,
but the programs to understand what and how to fix Hubble
applied to make the surgery better.
So I think you can look at that as saying like,
I can give somebody, I can give a caveman
all of the ingredients and all of the proper tools
to make a quiche, but he's not gonna know
what to do with that.
It's not gonna mean anything.
So even though the tools exist,
and they're given to somebody,
so I think the way that we think about things
and having the correct tools at the right time
have something to do with the speed in which we feel
as though something is being innovated.
Do we have those tools now?
Are we at the correct time?
Because you can only push so far.
You can only hope and want to do X, Y, or Z.
You can only hope and want to do,
space elevator's a perfect example.
We've been wanting to do a space elevator
for I don't even know how long.
There's a huge argument for it.
Everybody, not everybody, but a lot of people really like it,
they really want it to happen, they think it can happen,
and we can only get nanotubes this big, right?
Or maybe it's this big now.
But regardless, we have a lot of these tools,
and we have a decent understanding,
but we can't just force it into being.
There's a lot of different things that come into play
where our understanding of things
and the new technology of things
and forming different metals or different products
and 3D printing things,
and maybe that'll help in a certain situation.
So you can't just say, yeah, the key shift tomorrow.
Thank you.
So it's hard to quantify the speed of something
because it's a lot of different things.
It's a lot of different factors.
It's our understanding of what's going on.
It's where we want to go.
How do we get there?
How do we make that able to be able to get there?
Making the tools that make the tools that make the thing.
You can't just make the thing.
But have we made the tools
that make the tools to make the thing,
or are we one step before that
before we'll start hitting that innovative pace?
Go ahead, Mike.
I think it almost goes into the realm
of you have to play it as you go.
I think the whole thing with innovation
is you need to be able to have a goal
for whatever it is you want to do,
and then have a very organized,
incremental approach to doing that
and having all of these sub-goals on your path
to getting to your ultimate goal.
And along the way, if you encounter problems,
the tool doesn't exist to do this,
or this doesn't do this,
don't let it stop there.
Figure out how to do that.
And if there is no way,
then adjust your plans
to still be able to reach your end goal.
So a lot of what we're seeing right now
for kind of this next generation of space is reusability.
This is something that's kind of,
people have dabbled in reusability for a very long time,
but now it's actually being taken very, very seriously
by more than one company.
I can name three just right off the top of my head.
And you couldn't even do that, say, 10 years ago, right?
It was, oh man, could you name,
I mean, was anyone actively doing it?
I'm not sure there was anyone at that point.
Other than Orbital Sciences, I guess.
So.
In space, in space.
Okay, so.
It was all the XPRIZE participants,
sorry, XPRIZE participants.
Yeah, yeah, that's reusable, too, yeah.
So, yeah, actually, that brings four, actually,
so that's pretty cool.
There was 10 or 12 that had started
in that contest, I thought.
Right, so are we at a point now,
because of reusability and because of these changes
and trying to push the technology to the next level,
is that where we need to be?
Or, there was actually a really good question
in the chat room from Green Jim 2, or II, or Ool.
One development we'll see in mobile phones is modularity.
That will increase innovation rate.
Do we need more modular rocket design?
So, because everyone's quiet, I'll answer with no.
And I'll answer with no, because we kind of tried that,
right, you look at the Atlas and you look at the Delta
where they're quasi-modular, right?
Not super-modular, but the whole reason you have a 401
versus a, what is it, a 501 or 542?
Okay, that's one argument.
One argument is, well, we tried that,
it didn't work very well, or we tried that and it was
expensive, or we tried that in X, Y, or Z.
Another way of looking at that is saying,
well, when we did it, we didn't have
this kind of technology yet.
That could be true, that could be true.
I'll say that I think the big thing we need to do right now
to open up space and to get that level of innovation
is to force that price down.
And that's where reusability comes into play
because it could potentially help bring that price down.
We haven't proven that yet, but it could.
Modularity won't necessarily do that,
not with today's technology.
So maybe, you're right, maybe in the future,
in the near to far, wait, wait,
once we've got old school Conan O'Brien there for you,
once we go a little bit further forward,
we've figured out reusability, that might make sense.
But I think right now what makes the most sense
is to help drive those costs down
is to start cranking out the Model T of rockets, right?
So you don't get to design much.
The rocket will be able to lift whatever your payload is,
you just can't, you can get it in white,
white, or white, and it's this one design.
So if you don't need that much, great,
we'll just won't put as much fuel on it,
or whatever it may be.
But I think that ultimately is what will drive
that cost down in the industry right now.
By driving the cost down, we'll start to see
more people be able to do creative things in space,
which will create more launches,
which will create more interest and innovation in space,
which will help drive costs down,
which will create more launches.
It'll be kind of a cyclical thing, I think, at least.
I mean, that could, I could be completely wrong, too,
I have no idea.
Yeah, I, yeah.
Sounds like the chatroom, ha ha,
I don't get to say this much,
sounds like the chatroom's agreeing with me on that point.
Where's the spin-off technology?
No, but everything old is new again, to a certain extent,
that just because something didn't work in the past,
doesn't mean that you can't revisit that idea
with new understanding and new technology.
I think it's totally valid, yeah, absolutely.
I mean, that's kind of the whole spirit of engineering,
is to look at something old
and make it better with new technology.
Yeah, I mean, that's kind of what we're doing
with rockets today, isn't it?
And that's essentially what the Falcon
and the Vulcan rocket are doing,
is just basically taking old school 1960s technology
and just optimizing the bejeebers out of it,
make something new and more efficient and better
and more awesome, essentially.
That's what's going on.
Lighter, better, faster, stronger.
So then I guess it comes back down to,
is now the core time,
or are we still missing a few steps, right?
Are we still a few tools away?
I mean, how do we know until we get there, right?
You can't cross that bridge until you come to it.
I don't know if you'll ever know.
And you can't anticipate all the bridges.
Well, that's gonna suck when you need to build a bridge
and you're not sure where to build it.
That's why you have to be flexible.
Yep.
Be like water, my friends.
All right, so I'm curious to know
what you as a community think.
Are we in an age of innovation right now
where the speed of space is increasing
and where we're able to do things,
you know, not this fast, right?
This is scary fast.
We're not gonna get a new rocket every two years.
We're also gonna get new rockets every five to 10 years.
That's a little bit faster than before.
I would say close to every five years or so.
So are we at a point where the speed of innovation
is increasing to the point
where it's starting to become interesting,
where it's actually starting to become something
that could change humanity
and create a true space-faring civilization?
We are currently a space-visiting civilization,
but we don't really do a lot
other than like six to seven people.
Not a lot of people work in space.
They may work on Earth for space,
but they don't work literally in space.
Are we at a point of innovation
where that will be changing in our lifetime?
Leave your comments.
Leave them on YouTube, Reddit, Twitter,
using the hashtag speedofspace.
And speaking of comments,
when we come back,
comments from our last week's show, Cosmopolitics.
Stay tuned, we'll be right back.
And welcome back to Tomorrow Now.
Before we start talking about hashtag Cosmopolitics,
I'd like to,
Carrie-Anne's giving me a hard time.
I'd like to thank all of the citizens of Tomorrow
who helped make this specific
segment of this episode happen.
I do that every week.
You'd think I'd actually be able to get it out
by who I know.
Maybe call it an episode for once.
I do.
I call it an, why?
Episode?
What's wrong with episode?
You trip over it every time.
No, these are the people who contributed $2.50
or more, they're gonna get a copy of After Dark
immediately after this,
as soon as it's posted, at least.
Also get access to the monthly-ish hangouts that we do,
and their name in the show,
and a bunch of other really cool things.
But wait, there's more.
If you can contribute as little as one penny per show,
that's right, you'll get your name in the show
and a few other perks as well.
I'd like to thank all of the people
who helped crowdfund our shows,
and if you'd like to become a person
to help crowdfund the shows of tomorrow,
head on over to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
All right, let's get started with some comments
from last week.
I don't have a pretty slate this week,
so I'll just tell you,
the last week was,
how do we make space exploration politically relevant?
Hashtag Cosmopolitics.
She hates that I do this.
She wants to do this instead.
Hashtag Cosmopolitics.
All right, first up, Capcom.
This one comes from Doug Space off of tmro.tv.
There's a wall of text right there.
Yeah, but it's a good wall.
I frequently ask people who the first man on the moon was.
About 70% get it right.
Buzz Lightyear.
Okay.
Then I ask who was the first person
on the International Space Station,
and to date, no one has known.
Buzz Lightyear.
Not even me.
My point is that the reason
that space isn't politically relevant
is that in human spaceflight,
we aren't doing inherently amazing things.
Waiting 20 years for a crew to go to the vicinity of Mars
isn't going to help.
We need a lower cost strategy
for returning to the moon
to establish humanity's first permanent foothold in space.
Yeah, that's a show we should actually do
is hashtag moon or Mars first.
Have we done that one yet?
Yes.
We have done that?
Yes.
All right, nevermind.
So that's a show I should go back and review
is moon or Mars first.
We do a lot of shows.
That's where we need to bring in two guests in studio
and have a debate.
Oh, that would actually be fun.
We need to do it all political style, right?
Make the moon great again, make Mars great again.
Yeah.
That would be...
A lot of people are moon first.
Madison's on the moon first side, right?
Yeah, who do we get?
Oh, oh, Zubrin.
Matt, oh, oh my goodness.
That would be fantastic.
I don't think Dave would show up if Zubrin was here.
But that would be fun.
That would be fun.
Buzz Aldrin might show up.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, Buzz Aldrin's all about going to Mars.
We could try to argue for Mars.
That would be amazing.
That would be awkward, I think.
I think that would be super awkward.
All right, so yes, I actually, I agree.
I think we need to shorten these timelines.
Actually, much to today's show's point of speed of space
is if we can do things faster, make them more interesting.
We're living in a society now with instant gratification
and the speed of aerospace just isn't keeping up.
And we need it to if we want to keep people interested
and investing and doing really cool things.
I think that's happening.
I think hopefully it's happening
and we'll start to see some neat stuff,
which will eventually lead to a permanent colony on the moon
and I think a permanent colony on Mars, too.
I'm in the moon first camp as well.
So, all right, next up, Capcom.
This one comes from CodySB05 off of YouTube.
I believe one of the best ways
we can get people excited about space
is simply just to bring up space topics in your daily life,
whether it is to your coworkers, friends, or family.
Create a conversation and show them
the amazing things that there, that there have been
and are possible to accomplish.
I can't believe how little some people are aware of.
Absolutely, and I think one of the keys,
which is really hard to do and I fail at constantly,
is not to mock them, because I like mocking people.
But if someone doesn't know something, so what, right?
That's just, that's ignorance.
You can give them the knowledge and if they're interested,
it's a great way to relight that passion of space
that I think most people had as a child, right?
You look up, you see the stars,
there's this connection that you feel,
at least I will speak for myself,
there's a connection there that you kind of lose
in your teen years because hormones,
and then you can, you may or may not get it back.
And so if you can help someone find that connection again,
what a really cool, what a really cool thing.
And then show them the show,
because hopefully they can become part of the community.
Yeah.
Did you just snort?
Because that was hilarious.
Our biggest fan boy's always been Mike.
Next up, Capcom.
This one comes from Damian Sellis, also off of YouTube.
Oh goodness.
I believe Star Trek had an average of 20 million viewers
and maybe 30 for the premieres.
If all of them somehow were inspired to contribute
the cost of a satellite TV subscription, around $80,
but paid once a year,
private space exploration could be going ahead
with 2.4 billion annually.
Yeah, I mean, I actually do believe that someday,
you know, we were talking earlier
about you need certain things to be in place
before you can move on.
And I think crowdfunding,
obviously we believe in crowdfunding on this show,
which was a huge 180 from my,
you go back to like season three,
and I'm like, crowdfunding.
And now we crowdfund this show almost entirely.
So, you know, I think crowdfunding is growing.
I was obviously wrong about crowdfunding.
It's fricking amazing.
And, you know, the neat thing is then it's partly yours,
right?
So you help crowdfund a space program.
You, you're part of that space program.
You help make that space program go.
That's not something you can,
I mean, yeah, you pay tax dollars for NASA,
but there's something different about going,
nope, I'm going to actively give you additional money.
I'm going to give you money.
This is something I choose to do.
I am part of this.
I think there's something very powerful there.
I also do not believe that crowdfunding is to the level
in which we could raise 2.4 billion annually.
I think the biggest crowdfunding programs
are still in the millions,
or I mean, many, many millions,
like tens of millions, right?
Anyone know for certain?
This is 10, I don't think-
I think the only way that that would ever happen
is if NASA could crowdfund.
There'd be a lot of legal,
I brought that up before,
and there's no way it's legal to do that.
But if they could, I mean,
I wish I could donate more than that tenth of a penny
from my taxes to NASA.
I would, pfft.
I don't think that's the only way though.
I don't think that's the only way.
I think the timing right now is indeed wrong.
I don't think it would work right now.
But if someone had a viable plan,
let's use Dave Masson as an example.
He's not doing this, but I'll just throw out an example.
He's got propulsion tech.
He's got landing tech.
He's got a good chunk of the tech necessary
to go to the moon.
If Dave Masson said, you know what?
I want to crowdfund Mastin's space program.
Let's see how far we can go,
and can actually make some glossy things
that keep people interested.
I bet he could get pretty far.
He wouldn't get 2.4 billion annually,
but I bet he could get enough to land something
or someone on the moon pretty quickly.
However, I don't know how sustainable that is
in the long term,
because something like this needs recurring revenue,
like a Patreon model.
And I just don't know if, as society,
we're quite at that level.
Will we trust crowdfunding yet?
We trust that the program would follow through
and it would get us what we want.
But how amazing would it be?
The space program of tomorrow, wouldn't that be cool?
Yeah, that would be really, yeah.
Because for instance,
I don't know how many people shop on Amazon.com,
but you can go to Amazon.com,
and one of the cool little side things that they do
is that you can actually sign up to do these donations,
and you can pick your charity.
And it's pretty much automatic for the most part.
You pick it out and you go,
yep, every time I purchase something,
some little bit goes over there.
I'm totally cool with that, no big deal.
Don't have to think about it ever again.
And it would be nice to have something like that
for either a space program that I believe in
or a space company that I believe in.
If Blue Origin gave me more data,
like a particular project that I believe in.
Right, if Blue Origin told me more stuff,
or even if they limited it to people
who just gave them some money on the side
through Amazon purchases or something like that,
Bezos Bezos kind of thing, I would totally do that.
I would give Blue Origin, yeah, right?
But right, if you're ordering,
because we order a boatload of stuff,
I can't tell you how many Amazon boxes
we have sitting back over there.
Stupid amounts.
Stupid amounts, right?
Because it's awesome.
But if I could say, all right,
round up to the nearest dollar
and give the rest to Blue Origin,
all's I want in return is,
you can't keep your launches secret from me.
Yeah.
Right, I need to know what's going on.
And if you told me what's going on,
I would totally do that.
I would absolutely back them like that.
I think that's a great idea.
Yeah.
And you know, even when you do crowdfund space projects,
so there's already been a lot of different space projects
that have been successfully crowdfunded.
I mean, Planetary's Lightsail,
Planetary Resources,
Arkyd Spacecraft.
And I mean, so there have been a lot of successful projects.
And when I've donated to projects,
it makes me feel, you know,
exclusive to get all the different updates on it.
And then when it doesn't-
You're part of the project.
You're part of the process.
Absolutely.
But I mean, so I'm not talking about projects, right?
Obviously projects work.
I'm talking about a recurring program.
I'm talking about an entire space program.
I'm talking about building a space program
designed to send humans to the moon,
or humans to Mars, or something of that caliber.
Not just a single, like,
we're going to build a spacecraft.
Don't get me wrong.
Those are very cool, very impressive,
and it's awesome that we're at that level
where they could do that.
10 years ago, not possible.
Possible now.
Maybe in 10 years,
it'll be possible to crowdfund a space program,
but I don't think it is today.
If I thought for a moment,
tomorrow could crowdfund a space program today,
we would absolutely do it.
But I just, I think the timing is wrong.
Anyhow, moving on, moving on.
Next one comes from Tiawan John.
Well, we need to do that.
Yeah.
Tiawan John?
Tiawan John, sorry.
We'll crowdfund the shows of Tomorrow Tomorrow.
Yeah, yeah.
Exactly.
Tiawan John, sorry.
Off of YouTube.
Be careful what you wish for.
Are you yelling at me?
Maybe.
The political relevance of space
is what gave us Space Launch System.
I almost just said SLS.
We need more political relevance anyway.
The broad majority of people
support a robust space program
and will continue to do so
as long as NASA continues to provide
dramatic success stories and gorgeous eye candy.
A better question is,
how can we unfetter more of NASA's budget
from cost plus oblivion?
I think that's actually a very good point.
However, I will say,
I don't believe a broad majority of people
support robust space program.
I believe the latest numbers I saw,
and this may be incorrect,
the latest numbers I saw was only 51% support NASA.
And 49 do not support NASA program.
So that is not a broad majority.
It is a majority, but a barely majority.
I don't know if those numbers are correct or true.
So hopefully someone in the chat room
or anyone watching can correct that data
if it is incorrect.
But your ultimate point of a better question
is how can we unfetter more of NASA's budget
from cost plus oblivion?
I'll actually tweet,
Space Mike, would you like to comment?
Go ahead and say what you were gonna say first.
I was gonna say, I'm not sure it's necessarily cost plus
because there are, don't listen Mike,
cover your ears, I can't quite do it.
I can't make it happen.
Cover your ears Mike.
There are times when cost plus actually does make sense.
They can also be super duper abused.
So the rate at which we use it and how we use it is wrong,
but it actually is a program that could make sense.
What we really should be looking for
is how we remove political influence
into the engineering part of NASA.
Politicians should not make engineering decisions
on vehicles.
If we can remove that, you remove the need
to do certain things in a certain way.
You remove the need to use 1960s technology
in a modern 2016 vehicle.
And now you can use modern manufacturing techniques,
modern technology, and actually help reduce
the cost of these vehicles
for the same kind of payload to orbit.
You can see companies doing this right now
that aren't NASA.
So that's what ultimately needs to happen.
Make it not a jobs program.
So Mike, cost plus.
I think that you summed that up pretty nicely.
And I think the only thing that I would add to that
is I guess accountability.
I guess there needs to be more accountability
when that sort of cost plus model is being abused.
You know, when we are, like we discussed earlier,
when we do come across problems that we didn't foresee
and don't know how to deal with,
that's where cost plus scenarios might work
and might be needed,
especially for something that we have decided to do.
In the case of NASA as a nation
that we've decided to do or whatever.
But where it becomes abused
is where the problem comes from.
And that's where a lot of difference,
I guess waste has come from over the years.
And so I think that you nailed it pretty good though.
And there just needs to be
just a little bit more accountability, I think, for that.
Also, you can abuse any program.
If you're given enough time,
you can figure out how to game the system,
you can game the system.
A COTS-like contract, I'm sure,
can be gamed as much, maybe not as much,
but could be gamed like cost plus could be gamed.
I'm just saying.
I don't know how, but-
I think that-
Accountants are clever.
Cost plus it the way that Werner Von Braun cost plus things.
You know, he abused the system
so that we could eventually have all these extra Saturn Vs
and do cool things with them, so.
That's okay.
I'm okay with that, but that's just me.
All right, and finally, Capcom, take us out.
What's the last comment?
Last comment comes from Jason Hunt off of Facebook.
Don't.
Make it socially relevant.
I actually kind of agree.
The question was,
how do we make space politically relevant?
And so don't make it politically relevant,
make it socially relevant,
which will then inadvertently make it politically relevant.
Okay, so then the question is,
how do we make space socially relevant?
Maybe that's a topic for a future show?
I think we've kind of already done that.
I feel like we've already covered that.
Maybe, a little bit?
We've touched on it.
Maybe not.
So I think they're kind of hand in hand, but I agree.
Make space socially relevant.
Easy way to do that.
Launch more, bring the cost down,
make it relevant to people in their everyday lives,
and that will make it socially relevant
and important to everyone.
All right, that's our show.
I'd like to thank everyone so much for watching.
After Dark is up next.
I will be out next week.
Jared, do we have another status update on Jared,
by the way?
How's he looking?
Oh, well, looks like he's out.
Looks like he's out.
That's good.
That's better.
Hope that's just mud and not a popped tire.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Assuming, yeah, is that a popped tire, Donna?
No.
Is it just mud?
Yeah, it's just caked on mud.
Hopefully Jared will be back.
He said, got a little too close to the lake,
should have taken the higher route access or across sand.
Oh well, learned something new today.
Hopefully he'll be back.
Hopefully not very badly sunburned.
He'll be hosting next week as I will be out.
Thank you everyone so much for watching.
We'll see you next week.
