Talinn Grigor | Persepolis After Lindon Smith: The Modernist Afterlife of the Ruins

Incredible Finds
2 followers
5 Video Views·May 5, 2026
ISAC Podcasts
Persepolis After Lindon Smith: The Modernist Afterlife of the Ruins
Presented by Talinn Grigor, UC Davis
Originally aired Tuesday, April 26, 2022
Talinn Grigor traces the art history of the ruins of Persepolis in the aftermath of its excavation by Ernst Herzfeld and artistic renderings by Joseph Lindon Smith in the 1930s, including Reza Shah’s 1930s urban reform in Tehran and Mohammad Reza Shah’s 1971 celebration of “the 2,500-year Anniversary of the Founding of the Persian Empire by Cyrus the Great.” This lecture is in connection with the OI Museum Special Exhibition, "Joseph Lindon Smith: The Persepolis Paintings," now on display.
Welcome and thanks for joining us for today's OI Museum special exhibition lecture.
I'm Kirsten Newman, a curator at the OI Museum, and I'll be hosting today's talk.
The Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago is both a pioneering interdisciplinary
research center and a world-renowned museum whose aim is to understand, reveal, and protect the
earliest civilizations of the ancient Middle East. With 350,000 artifacts excavated mainly
by OI archaeologists, the OI Museum houses the largest collection of ancient Middle Eastern
antiquities in the United States. Since its founding in 1919, a time when the Middle East
was called the Orient, the OI has pioneered innovative excavations and comprehensive
dictionary projects that serve as cultural encyclopedias of ancient civilizations.
Of the 350,000 artifacts that make up the OI Museum collection, about 5,000 are on permanent
display in the main galleries, which are divided up in regions of the ancient Middle East.
In addition to the artifacts, the OI Museum collection also encompasses an expansive
archive collection composed primarily of materials related to the OI expeditions
of the early 20th century, including field journals, object logs, and archival photographs.
Additionally, the OI collection also includes more contemporary art pieces,
including paintings of archaeological sites as well as photographs. An example of the last is a
group of six large-scale paintings by renowned American artist Joseph Lyndon Smith, painted at
the site of Persepolis in 1935, and which are the focus of the current special exhibition entitled
Joseph Lyndon Smith, the Persepolis Painting, to which tonight's lecture relates. The exhibition
is open through the end of August, and I encourage everyone who is able to attend to do so.
So without further ado, a few words of our speaker this evening. Taline Griger is professor
and chair of the art history program in the department of art and art history at the
University of California, Davis. Her research focuses on 19th and 20th century art and
architectural histories through the framework of post-colonial and critical theories, grounded
in Iran and Parsi India. She has published numerous articles and books on these topics,
and her books include Building Iran, Modernism, Architecture, and National Heritage Under the
Pahlavi Monarchs, Contemporary Iranian Art, From the Street to the Studio, and most recently in
2021, The Persian Revival, The Imperialism of the Copy in Iranian and Parsi Architecture.
She has held residential fellowships at the National Gallery of Art,
Getty Research Institute, and Cornell and Princeton Universities. Her scholarship has
benefited from numerous grants, including those from the Social Science Research Council,
American Research Institute of the South Caucasus, and Aga Khan Program at MIT. Her
current work project, co-authored with Hori Vaberian and under contract with Stanford University Press,
traces the representational histories of Armenian women in Iran,
from the reign of Naser al-Din Shah Kajar to the fall of the Pahlavi dynasty in 1979.
So I will now turn it over to our speaker to speak on Persepolis After Lyndon Smith,
The Modernist Afterlife of the Runes. Thank you so much, Kristen. Thank you for this invitation.
I was just thinking how extraordinary it is that we study institutions that are still there
a whole century later, and I thought that was really extraordinary. So I'll just begin.
In October 1971, Mohammad Reza Shah celebrated the 2,500-year anniversary of the founding of
the Persian Empire by Cyrus the Great. Through the three days of royal celebrations, Persepolis
became, according to official reportage, the center of gravity of the world. The international
guests and 69 heads of states included a dozen kings and queens, 10 princes and princesses,
some 20 presidents and first ladies, 10 sheikhs and two sultans, together with emperors, emperors,
vice presidents, prime ministers, foreign ministers, ambassadors, and other officials.
The events opened at the foot of Cyrus's tomb in the nearby ruins of Pasargada,
followed by a series of gatherings in the tent city, camped southwest of Persepolis's terrace,
concluding with a parade under the gate of all lands. While Persepolis 71 was the greatest show
the world had ever seen, as the monarch had promised, it also sparked the beginning of a
mass movement that culminated in the fall of the Pahlavi dynasty. Today I would like to present
the modernist engagement with the ruins of Persepolis after 1935. So after 1934's excavation
of Ernst Hertzville and after the renderings by Joseph Lyndon Smith in 1935. While Iranian
Parsi and western fascination and active engagement with Persepolis has a long art history
going back to the 1722 fall of the mighty Safavid empire, Chicago University's intervention on the
site fundamentally altered the architectural quality and meaning of its subsequent appropriations
by the two Pahlavi monarchs. So the appropriation of the architecture and iconography of Persepolis
really has a very long history. As I mentioned, it goes back to the fall of the Safavid and the
turmoil of Iran. And in two places, the Persian revival had a parallel history. So this what
you're seeing are the Parsi temples in western India, very lavish borrowing, not really from
Persepolis, but from travel logs. And some of them are European travel logs.
By the 30s, through Parsi patronage of architecture, the Parsi brand of the Persian
revival actually is imported into Iran. But the Persian revival itself has an Iranian brand that
I have argued goes back to the Karim Khan Zand in Shiraz. And here you're seeing a parallel
between some of the reliefs during the Karim Khan Zand period and on the top from Persepolis,
which then was translated into full-blown architectural monuments by the end of the 19th
century, particularly in Shiraz. And where we're seeing these copying from Persepolis,
where historical accuracy was not really a priority, but rather artistic free will and collage.
And here I have on the lower right, I have Linden Smith's painting, and I will place a few of these
paintings building on Kristen's talk. I just implanted some of these paintings into my talk,
but I'm not going to directly address them. The history of the Persian revival in the 1930s
consisted of the Pahlavi dynasty's adoption of the style, itself shaped by two significant
developments. The modern coupling of archaeological knowledge to architectural design as a marker of
racial essence, and the espousal of architectural style by an autocratic state as a tool of national
propaganda, which was supported by the presence of German architects in the service of the Iranian
government. Not so gradually, the political meaning of the Persian revival transformed
into an official discourse as the state monopolized its patronage. The proximity of
the kings to the ruins set the stage for this new grafting of archaeology onto architecture.
Systematically, books and newspapers published photographs of Reza Shah at both ancient and
sites, actively inspecting and inaugurating. No longer were travelogues, lithographs, photographs,
and postcards passively to mediate between the two. In the royal person, always tall,
robust, and in military uniform, national time and space collapsed to heal its historical wounds.
An essential aspect of this grafting of archaeology onto buildings was the disappearance
of Qajar or Parsi eclecticism. All the curves, all the colors, all the mirrors, all the tiles
just disappeared. The excavations at Persepolis, led by Hertzfeld, provided a set of novel formal
qualities to the revival. Characterized by a modern, almost fascist aesthetics, these austere
landmarks represented and provoked broader Pahlavi agendas aimed at national homogenization.
In 1935, Iran was represented at the Brussels International Exposition by a perfected
Persian revival pavilion with the talar, the central element there, bull-headed columns,
the winged Zoroastrian icon from Persepolis, and reliefs of Persepolitan soldiers.
The leading newspaper, Etelad, published a photograph and assured its readers that it is
built based on the historical heritage of Takht-e Jamshid, Persepolis. The Pahlavi reign
thus secured the Persian revival with the state affiliation it had lacked since its invention
by Parsi industrials and philanthropists in the 1830s Bombay. The mushrooming of Persepolitan
facades in the heart of Tehran separated modern Iran from Muslim Arab art history and tied it to
Indo-European culture stretching from India to the Germanic lands, as had argued Iranian
nationalists since the mid-19th century. In 1937, Tehran Journal published another article
drawing similarities between German and Iranian architecture as evidence of the Aryan origin of
the two nations, further reinforcing arguments made in staunchly nationalist periodicals
such as Iran-Boston. The Persian revival permeated both international and the domestic
scene. The December 1935 issue of Le Journal de Tehran hailed the growth of the capital under
Reza Shah, evident in the erection of the first national bank, publishing a photograph of its
eastern facade. Like the pavilion in Brussels, the bank featured a talar and a large farahavar,
lined with Persepolitan crenellations along the roofline. The two wings of the bank initially
only contained four bays, were later expanded into L-shaped wings. In August 1933, a few years
earlier, French architect and founding director of the Faculty of Fine Arts at Tehran University,
as well as the first director of the Archaeological Services, Andrei Godard, met
Russian architect Nikolai Markov to examine several proposal drawings. The same evening,
they dispatched a report to Hossein Rolikhon Nabob, who at age 70 was charged with the
supervision of the erection of a new building for the bank. His past had prepared him well.
Infamous for nepotism, Prime Minister Khan Nouri had in 1886 appointed his 22-year-old son as the
Consul General of Bombay, where he must have witnessed the Parsi brand of Persian revival.
From there, Nabob's career had taken off, eventually serving as the ambassador to
Germany at the zenith of the Berlin-based Iranian nationalist movement in the 1910s.
Godard and Markov reported to Nabob that a new plan, executed by a certain Mr. Hemrick,
had to be free from the constraint of the present, with a large entrance hall and two staircases.
When, on the following Saturday, Hemrick presented the new drawings, Godard wrote to Nabob that the
undersigned architects declared that these plans architecturally perfectly respond to the program
set by the Directorate of the Bank. On the grounds, master builder Haj Hossein Beheshti
worked alongside Hemrick to meet Reza Shah's demanding timeline. And actually,
most of these buildings were built with this kind of European and Iranian cooperation.
The inauguration in 1935 inspired the construction of the Bank's other branches,
as well as the printing of new banknotes adorned with views of Persepolis.
These, in turn, helped disseminate Iran's modern look as the heir to the Achaemenid Empire.
Printed in 1938, one banknote included a perspectival view of the Bank itself,
whereas a 1976 banknote carries the Bank's elevation drawing. The edifice and its mobile
replicas worked in tandem to compress national time and space and enable leaps from Persepolis
to Tehran. The connections between ancient archaeology, modern architecture,
ancient institutions such as the Persian monarchy, modern networks such as the banking system,
as well as the ties of legitimacy between king-father and king-son were made visible
through these visual strategies invented in Persepolis as image.
European architects dominated the design of most of these Persian Revival buildings in the 1920s
and 30s, most of them in the heart of Reza Shah's capital city, which was being reformed and going
through huge transitions. The rare western-trained Iranian architect participating alongside them
between 1926 and 1934 was Karim Tahrirzadeh Behzad. In 1907, he joined the constitutionalist
fighters in Tabriz, but soon after their defeat, he escaped to Berlin and became one of the young
members of the Berlin circle of Iranian nationalists who often contributed to Kaveh
and Iranshahr. Both of these are nationalist periodicals being printed in Berlin at the time,
while conducting research for German orientalist Friedrich Saar at the Kaiser Friedrich Museum.
After his 1926 return to Iran, Tahrirzadeh Behzad deployed the Persian Revival to translate the
words of the editor of Iranshahr, Hossein Kazemzadeh, who was actually his roommate as well,
who had insisted that the ancient civilization of Iran is the best means of awakening the
nationalist feelings in the hearts of the Iranian people. And so he was tasked by Reza Shah to turn
these feelings into stone, into new architecture. Ferdowsi's tomb in Tuz, Reza Shah's school in
Tabriz, and Reza Shah's hospital in Mashhad were only the beginning of his revivalistic works.
The Iranian parliament remained his legacy. Chosen as the building of the National Assembly
by the first constitutional prime minister, Mirza Nasrallah Khan, whose son Hassan Pirnia
was a prominent historian of ancient Iran and four-time prime minister of Iran.
Sebah Salar Palace was shelled on July 4, 1908, by Russian-backed royalist troops. After a fire
in 1931, Tahrirzadeh Behzad was appointed to renovate the building, now the seat of the
parliament. On the northern facade, a long portico of bull-headed columns is divided into five
sections with a protruding central talar. The uniform and perfected white columns,
recalling the hypostyle halls of Persepolis, aimed to change the nation it intended to
reawaken and modernize. Like the nation too, a Qajar edifice had been transformed into a Pahlavi
discourse on Persepolis. The Persian revival under Reza Shah, even at its zenith in the late 1930s,
however, was never so hegemonic as to gain everyone's support. Despite its widespread
views by the state, it remained a style that generated mixed feelings. Arthur Pope,
the American orientalist who was instrumental in making sure that Herzl leaves Iran,
was an adamant advocate of Persian revival. Despite his passionate cries of turn back,
turn back, look to the orient, old Persia can save us, not everyone felt that this national style
was expressive of Iran's modernity. Bartan Hovhannesian, a pioneer of Iran's modern movement,
criticized it vehemently and insisted that bulls and lions were better kept at the zoo.
The popularity of the style dissipated, or rather transformed, into other stylistic debates
away from revivalism, as Iranian architects began to favor the international style in the 1950s and
after. Mohammad Reza Shah, who secured the throne in 1941 following his father's exile by the Allies,
was committed to the rapid modernization of the country's economy and infrastructure,
while he prevented the liberalization of its political institutions. Like his father,
he was convinced that a better future for Iran was possible by maintaining cultural ties to
Iran's antiquities, paired with skipping the pitfalls of modernization by technological
shortcuts to the future. Persepolis as a discursive image, and later as the king's
utopian vision of the great civilization, remained pervasive in Iranian royal and public life
throughout the 40s to the 1970s. And so I found a couple of interesting images. So this is
in December 1959, President Eisenhower's visit to Tehran, where actually it's a Qajar tradition of
these ceremonial arches that were temporarily placed in different nodes in Tehran. And so this
is one of them, basically two of the Persepolitan arches that have been or
thresholds that have been enlarged. You see the soldiers on two sides, the barabar, a very large
barabar on the top, and one of the paintings of the lion and the ox. This is another one on the
same occasion, a little bit different. I thought this was really interesting. The Statue of Liberty
facing one of the Persepolitan soldiers, again, connecting not only geographies and cultures and
through them diplomacy, but also connecting time together. And this is another photo of
literally six days later, in the same year, where Mohammad Reza Shah is marrying Empress Farah.
And so these are some of the carpets, these are Sasanian revival carpets, and these are some of
the guests. By 1971, the buried fragments of Persepolis had emerged as a vast ancient city
with royal palaces and throne halls, residential quarters and harems, and a sophisticated decorative
program with exquisite examples of high reliefs. In that October, the complex was selected to house
the festivities that included five major events. The opening speech at the foot of the Tomb of
Cyrus at Pasargada, two dinner banquets in the 10th city followed by fireworks over Persepolis,
the viewing of the Great Parade of Persian History under the grand staircase of Persepolis,
and finally the conclusion of the celebrations in the modern capital of Tehran.
Careful architectural and technological measures were undertaken not only to render Persepolis
and Pasargada user-friendly to dignitaries, but also to provide them with a modern look without
impairing their antique allure. A fine-tuned synthesis of the ancient and modern aesthetics
was intended to guarantee the symbolic and practical success of the undertaking.
On October 12, at the crack of dawn, Muhammad Reza Shah launched the ceremonies with his famed
address. Standing in front of Cyrus's empty tomb at Pasargada, the king assured the historical
figure that after the passage of 25 centuries, the name of Iran today evokes as much respect
throughout the world as it did in thy days, and that he, Cyrus, should rest in peace,
for we are awake to guard thy proud heritage. These slides are interesting because you can
see the comparison between how the archaeological site was cleaned out or sort of sanitized from
its medieval use, where we had all these medieval columns, where the monument had been used as an
open-air mosque, and then on the top photograph you can see how it's completely cleaned out.
After the initial ceremony at Pasargada, the event continued at Persepolis. The biggest
intervention on the site was the erection of the Tent City, or Golden City, proposed by the French
interior design firm of Jensen on the ruins' southwestern section. The area was described by
one invitee as 160 desert acres covered with some 70 tents sumptuously decorated with French crystal,
china, and linens, and hung with red silk and velvet and glittering chandeliers. The king had
insisted that his 600 foreign guests should camp outside Persepolis as had done the ancient
Assyrians, Lydians, Armenians, Arabs, and Babylonians in the time of Darius I. The star-shaped
encampment was organized around a large fountain. The pair of tents, totaling six residential
villas, projected out to create five axes, each named after a continent. Each tent of yellow,
beige, and royal blue fabric contained a sitting room, two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a kitchenette,
and a service room. At the end of the main axis, a large tent was erected as the banqueting hall
to house the evening gala of October 14, catered by Chez Maxime of Paris. The evening concluded
with fireworks over the ruins, where actors draped in ancient-style textiles recreated the rituals
of Achaemenid kings. To accommodate the high-tech spectacle, the site was equipped with amplifiers,
loudspeakers, transmitters, projectors, hi-fi set, recorders, television cameras,
and other light and sound systems, all of which were concealed behind partitions.
So, it's very interesting how one's brain functions or doesn't sometimes.
When I visited the site in 1998, I had written a graduate student paper on the celebrations,
and when I was at Persepolis, I was sort of looking around the area, and to my dismay,
I noticed the tip of this tent, and I could not believe that it was still there.
And so, I asked my taxi driver to take me there, and lo and behold, it was there,
the way that you're seeing it here in this picture, where the tent city had been vandalised,
but had been preserved in this vandalised way, with addition of a few slogan posters here and
there, sort of teaching the visitors the lessons of history. And then, in 2007, when I returned,
and I was, of course, photographing Persepolis, looking at all the details, all the reliefs,
and then when I was done with sort of photographing the ancient site, and I sat
somewhere, and all of a sudden, I saw these things, these very old, clearly outdated, and
non-functioning technology on the site. And the moment that, and first, I was sort of interested,
I mean, I was sort of surprised that I had not seen it in 2008, when I was there.
And when I started to see one, then all of a sudden, I kept seeing more and more of them,
and they were everywhere. And it dawned on me that these were, in fact, the debris of 1971,
and they have become ruins, sort of, they are additions of the ruins to the Achaemenid ruins,
they're the Pahlavi ruins on the Achaemenid ruins. So, the rituals of modern diplomacy
were a prelude to the historical parade of the following day, which involved a decade of
preparation through scholarly research and production, rehearsals, and over 6,000 men.
With the help of French companies, including Jensen, Chez Maxime, Lavin, and Limoges,
an Iranian team devised the costumes for the parade of Persian history. It showcased 10 periods
in the military history of Iran, from the Achaemenid Empire to the Pahlavi state,
described as a panorama of 2,500 years of history on the march in the full splendor of their age.
They represented the armies of major dynasties that had ruled the Iranian plateau. For several
months, rehearsals were organized, soldiers were prevented from shaving, benches were assembled,
and the ruins of Persepolis were thoroughly refurbished. Shiraz and Tehran likewise went
through strategic urban renewal plans. Streets were asphalted and cleaned up,
major building facades were remodeled, lampposts were installed, squares were redecorated, avenues
were blocked for security, and in Shiraz, shopkeepers were provided with blue jackets.
Later, historians noted that at Persepolis, Muhammad Reza Shah remodeled Persian history
to his own heart's desire, as he had insisted that it helped immensely to establish Iran anew
in Western perceptions. Others remarked that the parade surpassed in sheer spectacle the most
florid celluloid imagination of the Hollywood epics. And to this 1916 film, I would definitely
add Zack Snyder's 300, which was definitely a feat of imagination, and then its sequel in 2014,
which actually depicts Persepolis in really fantastic ways, fantastic in terms of fantasy.
After the end of the third day of celebrations, the foreign dignitaries were flown back to Tehran.
This change of location from Persepolis to Tehran spoke to the link between the ancient city of
Persepolis as the capital of the Achaemenid Empire and the modern city of Tehran as the capital of
the Pahlavi state, an evocation of change and continuity of antiquity and modernity.
As put by one state spokesman, it was a jump out of history into the nation's future.
When the second half of the celebration was launched in Tehran, the king dedicated the
imposing Shahyad Aryameh monument, which is actually a linear museum where you go up,
and at the very top, under the stone, the Cyrus Cylinder was borrowed from the UK,
and it was displayed there. The monument itself, the arch here, is actually a replica of the arch
of Stasiphon that was copied by André Godard in the 30s, and so both of them are referring back
to the last seat of the Sasanian monarch who left Stasiphon and was murdered, and that was the end
pre-Islamic Iran. On the final day of the celebration following the inauguration of Shahyad,
additional parades took place in the newly inaugurated 100,000-seat Aryameh Stadium.
The celebration concluded at the tomb of Reza Shah in Ray, south of the capital city.
That the events in Tehran were staged against the backdrop of revivalistic modernist architecture
contributed to the impression of compressed time from Cyrus the Great to Reza Shah the Great.
These articulations of nation's history were meant to show off Iran's considerable
recent achievements to the outside world, and at the same time show Iranians how respectfully
the outside world would treat the official ideology. While the court minister insisted
on 17 million dollars, by the end of the week the Iranian state had spent somewhere between
100 to 300 million dollars. Local critiques immediately began to express their opposition
to Persepolis 71. Sociologist, translator of Frantz Fanon's anti-colonial works,
and later dubbed the ideologue of the Iranian revolution, Ali Shariati insisted that the
nation was being molded through a return to the wrong roots. For us, he wrote,
return to our roots means not a rediscovery of pre-Islamic Iran, but a return to our Islamic,
especially Shia roots. On the eve of the celebrations, Ayatollah Khomeini issued a
from his exile in Iraq, calling it a devil's festival. Yet within the ideological matrix
of late Pahlavism, the celebrations served their purpose, which according to the king was to
reawaken the people of Iran to their past and reawaken the world to Iran. When in March 1976,
Mohammad Reza Shah decreed the substitution of the Muslim solar calendar with the royal calendar,
the 2,500 year celebrations were recalled, endorsing not only the temporal shift,
but also its historical exactitude. Equating performance with political power, time itself
was reset at Persepolis 71. As the royal 2535 replaced the Muslim solar 1355,
Prime Minister Hoveyda insisted that this is indeed a reflection of the historical fact that
during this long period, there has been only one Iran and one monarchical system, and that these
two are so closely intertwined that they represent one concept. In response to public
confusion and outrage, the king vowed that this reorientation of time would put Iran ahead of
the West, since from now on, they would look forward to us. The extravagance of the celebrations,
the exclusion of ordinary Iranians, the use of archaeology to legitimize power,
the theatrics of the performances, and the expression of elite aesthetics on the ruins
of Persepolis in due course came to contribute to the image of a detached monarch in the eyes of
the Iranian masses. Few were persuaded by the events, and even fewer understood its potential
counter-colonial underpinning. The king had by no means convinced his subjects of the symbolic
truth of the events. At the time, however, Western popular journals and newspapers
earnestly endorsed the events. Ten days after the parade at Persepolis, next to
the illustration of a rather bored Iranian soldier dressed in Achaemenid military uniform,
Parimach more boldly claimed that they have not changed in 2,500 years.
So I just want to conclude with raising the issue of, again, this is Lyndon Smith's painting in
comparison to one of the 19th century Shirazi palaces, and my question is why some iconography
and some archaeological sites keep making a comeback? What is it that
attracts copying, appropriation, revival, if there is a purely aesthetic quality,
or the recycling itself becomes an incentive to recycle more? Some of the recycles here,
I again wanted to make these aesthetic comparisons. This is a 2002
hotel in Kish Island. Again, the same iconography is being revived and appropriated, and finally
ending with Napa Valley Winery from 2014. Thank you. Thank you very much. That was
an extremely interesting and informative talk, and wonderful pictures to follow along with.
That was really great. Thank you so much. I would like to encourage everyone to check out
especially the recent one from 2021, if you're interested in looking more into this topic.
And I've also shared a link to the current museum's special exhibitions website,
the Joseph Lyndon Smith Persepolis Paintings, where the link to this talk will be posted,
as well as circulated by email. The link to the previous talk that I gave for the opening of the
exhibit is also there, as well as some other links to reading and materials about the OI's
expedition there, and the history of those paintings. I want to thank you everyone again
for joining us this evening, and we hope to see you again soon. Thank you. Thank you, everyone.
