Cracking the Göbekli Tepe Code: New Hypothesis | Ancient Architects

ancient literature
168 followers
Hello everybody and welcome to Ancient Architects.
Please subscribe to the channel for regular content on ancient architecture
as well as all of the latest news from the world of archaeology.
Ever since it came to light what was buried beneath the mound of Gobekli Tepe,
the site has become one of the most talked about places in the world because of a. its prehistoric
age, b. its enormous size, c. the magnificent megalithic structures and d. the incredible
iconography etched in stone. The site began life around 11,600 years ago,
after the Younger Dryas Cold Period, at the very beginning of the Warmer Holocene.
The people that lived here were hunting and gathering their food but during the life of
settlement, we likely saw the gradual evolution into an agricultural society,
which I believe ultimately led to the abandonment of the site.
In the past two decades, Gobekli Tepe has been the focus for countless books,
both academic literature and alternative ideas. It's been included in TV shows and documentaries,
and now there are dozens and dozens of YouTube videos and many dedicated websites.
The unique archaeological finds have truly captured our imaginations,
with the decorated T-shaped pillars quickly becoming an ancient wonder in their own right.
The iconography is fascinating, and for a long lost culture that had not yet developed writing,
these pillars and a few associated structures and stone artefacts
are the only record of the civilisation they left behind.
But what are the pictures portraying? What are they saying in their art?
What were the ancient people trying to tell us?
There are many interpretations already out there in the public domain,
including abstract star charts showing the ancient night sky,
geographical maps of the Near and Middle Eastern landscape,
calendrical markers, the memorialisation of important myths and legends, and the list goes on
and on. I have stared at these pillars for hours and hours. In the past I've started to formulate
my own ideas, only to scrap them when I've hit a brick wall. I find it frustrating that I don't
know with any certainty what the pillars are trying to say, and every seemingly decent idea
I've come across in the past few years always leaves me with nagging questions and reasonable
doubt in their accuracy. But now, after extensive reading, personal research and brainstorming,
I think I'm finally onto something. And so, in this video, which is part one of what will be
a two or three part series, it's time to take a look at the detail.
Any hypothesis regarding the pillar iconography has to be all-encompassing. An animal that's
being portrayed on one pillar has to make sense if it's also being portrayed on another.
We can't just cherry-pick one pillar, for example pillar 43, make a hypothesis and then try and
shoehorn the other pillars into it. For example, if a vulture is a constellation on pillar 43,
then surely it should be the same constellation on pillar 56, and also on this frieze from
Enclosure D, and on these statues as well. If a hypothesis works for one but not for all,
then, in my opinion, surely it can't be right. Whilst the iconography on some pillars is limited
to just one animal, some pillars are far more complex, with pillars 43, 33 and 56 clearly
showing a narrative. There is not just a selection of animals on display, but there are also clear
relationships between them. But we can't begin to understand what the pillars are telling us,
unless we have a solid idea of what the animals on the pillars actually are. Are these really
snakes as some have said, and is this really a spider? And this is extremely important,
because the wrong animal will make the puzzle impossible to solve.
If we have the wrong animal in the first place, well, we could stare at these pillars for a
lifetime and never make any sense of them. Identifying the animals on the pillars requires
knowledge of wildlife in this part of the world. It also needs logic, when we see animals in
context with each other. And yes, like any hypothesis, it will also require some calculated
assumptions and leaps of faith. The ancients did not leave us with instructions to follow.
The identification of the animals has to be in context with the rest of the pillar iconography.
And, if we manage to correctly identify each animal, then the same animal has to work in
context when we find it on other pillars as well. For example, if these are snakes,
then why are they associated so closely with two cranes? And why is a snake coming head to
head with an aurochs on pillar 20? Archaeologists such as the late, great Klaus Schmitt and his
colleagues at the German Archaeological Institute have laid the foundations for any study into
pillar iconography. They've documented the pillars, published photographs, drawings and
descriptions and have also offered interpretations. But in my opinion, it's the work of Professor
Dragos Georgiou that has taken the understanding of these pillars to the next level. Professor
Georgiou is an historical anthropologist and archaeologist and his studies focus on material
culture, ancient technologies and iconography. His work on Gobekli Tepe is up there with the
very best, but as far as I'm aware, most people have never heard of it. He's worked to identify
the animals on the pillars and, in doing so, he is, in my opinion, on the right track to a logical
and realistic interpretation. Enclosure D at Gobekli Tepe may well be the Rosetta Stone of
the Tastapella culture. It contains the iconic pillar 43 and also the amazing pillar 33,
and it's the relationships between the animals on the pillars that really helps us with their
identification. Georgiou worked with the assumption that the animal groupings were not random
and, as well as animals, the iconography also shows ecosystems. The imagery is therefore
not just zoomorphic, but it is in fact topomorphic, and then there are even deeper levels after that.
So, where do we start? Well, it has to be pillar 33, my favourite T-shaped pillar at Gobekli Tepe,
an absolute work of art. We see animals on the T-head, the two broad sides and also the front
narrow side. Starting on the left broad side and we see two cranes. In nature, these large birds
can be found in grassland, fresh water and wetlands. They can be found hunting for fish
in marshes and on the banks of rivers, areas with shallow water and also high reeds.
With that in mind, what could these animals be around them? Most researchers say they're snakes,
but if the pillars are showing us specific ecosystems, then this really doesn't make much
sense. Yes, they're snake-like in appearance, but Georgiou believes their narrow heads and long bodies
are also like those of freshwater eels, such as the Mesopotamian spiny eel.
They're wiggling their bodies as they swim around the feet of the two cranes, which are there
trying to catch their next meal. There is a central band on the narrow face of the pillar,
and the professor interprets this as a shallow river or flooded valley, and the eels are moving
from the wetland swamps and marshes into the valley and then downstream. But if this is a
river or shallow waterway inside a valley, why do we see two spiders inside it? Well,
calling these spiders is another popular assumption, and the more you look at them,
in my opinion, the less spider-like they appear to be. In nature, spiders have two pedipalps at
the front of their body, but they don't appear to be bent backwards like this, and who would portray
the legs of a spider in such a manner? So if these are not spiders, what are they?
Well, if this band on the front of the pillar represents shallow water,
these animals must live in such an environment. They must be arthropods.
They have a short thorax, bent legs turned upwards and curved antennae, and according to the
professor, they're most likely narrow-clawed crayfish, which is a species native to Turkey.
They have curved antennae, bent legs turned upwards, but the two pictures on pillar 33
don't show the large keelie, the big pincers at the front. But as professor Giorgio explains,
the undifferentiated shape between the keelie and the feet in the carved image could be explained
by the fact the keelie of the astracus females remain isometric throughout their life. They
could also be young crayfish. Giorgio says, when the water temperature is high, the young crayfish
with no developed keelie spawn, therefore the offspring of the animal are an index for the
summer hot days. Staying on the narrow side of the pillar and above the symbol in the form of a
capital H, we have more eel or snake-like animals. This upper group have large heads, but their
bodies are notably smaller compared to the lower group and those seen on the broad side of the
pillar. Yes, they could still be eels, but Giorgio believes the difference in form is by design.
He thinks the large head and short body could be portraying the Mesopotamian catfish,
a species found in Iran, Iraq, Syria and Turkey. I'll come back to the H and I symbols later in
this video, because for now I want to focus on the animals. Further down the pillar and we can
see what looks like an animal crossing the shallow water, and to me it may well be a leopard.
Leopards are predators, and they're also strong swimmers, and they're one of the few cats that
actually likes water. Leopards are opportunistic hunters, so if the crayfish, eels and catfish are
bringing out the water birds, this will ultimately bring out the predators. These big cats will eat
birds, fish, amphibians, reptiles, pigs, rodents and so on. So, on pillar 33, we're seeing a whole
ecosystem develop. We're seeing the animals in context. The cranes are stood in waterlogged
marshes or shallow water, following the eels into a body of water that also contains crayfish.
The leopard heads across the water, likely to hunt the large birds. We're seeing a natural
food chain. On the capital of the same pillar, we see four birds identified by Klaus Schmidt as
bustards, a species of bird specific to steppe life. The capital of this pillar is therefore
symbolising the other side of the ecotone, the dry land. Back to the lower wetland setting,
and the triangular chevron shapes higher up the pillar define the upper section of this waterway,
the space the fish can move in. These chevrons could be portraying mud or sand ripples,
or the waves created by the ebb and flow of water passing by reeds, like this. Maybe they're showing
vegetation, maybe they are the reeds themselves, or it could be showing higher ground as the water
runs through the valley. But why are eels entering the waterway from the left? Well,
eels can live in swampy environments. They can also burrow into mud. In fact, some can even
survive drying ponds and that's because of their ability to breathe air. They are also migrating
animals and can move from streams and rivers to large lakes and even the ocean. For example,
a study released in 2016 shows how European eels migrate from their freshwater enclaves
and end up in the Atlantic Ocean where they mate and, well, die. Eggs are laid,
they hatch and the young eels make their return journey back to Europe. With all this in mind,
as well as being a marker for an ecosystem, could pillar 33 also be a time marker? Is it showing a
time when eels are on the move, migrating to their spawning ground, and attracting the large
birds to feast on them as they do? Could the use of the eel symbol specifically be an indicator
of time, as well as a marker for a specific landscape and ecosystem? Pillar 33 is one of
the most complicated pillars at Gobekli Tepe. There is so much to think about, but getting
the correct animal is so important. Moving on, and from what we learn from
pillar 33, we can also use it to interpret pillar 20. According to Giorgio, the rectangular band
we see on the narrow side of a pillar represents a valley, and whether it's wet or dry depends on
the animals we see. On pillar 20 we have a catfish with its large head and shorter body,
indicating wet conditions, but it's now face to face with a bovid, maybe an aurochs.
The bovid animal is positioned vertically and not horizontally, which Giorgio believes
represents a dead animal, a carcass floating on the water, a flooded valley. Apparently,
the catfish is considered more of a scavenger than a predator, so a catfish face to face with a bovid
may not actually be a strange pairing. In fact, this pillar could well be a teaching aid for a
hunting society. And the lesson? If you see a dead animal in the water, it may well attract
scavenger fish, which can be caught by humans and eaten. And the same can be said with pillar 30,
where we see on the narrow side more possible catfish or eels, swimming alongside a vertically
positioned drowned animal. Like the catfish, eels are also scavengers. And also on the edge
of pillar 43, we have a feline positioned vertically, meaning it's dead. It's also
face to face with a crayfish, although this piece of art appears to be unfinished.
Crayfish, like catfish, are also scavengers. The famous broadside of pillar 43 does have more
difficult imagery to interpret, and that's because of the other symbols in relation to
the animals. I'll discuss this in a forthcoming video. But staying in enclosure D, and on pillar
38 we can see a vertical series of animals, which according to Giorgio is a canid, possibly a jackal,
sitting above a wild boar, and this is above what looks like two cranes and a duck,
which are of course water birds. You would find all of these animals in a swampy waterlogged
environment, possibly a riverbank. This pillar could also be a teaching aid, and it tells you
where you find one of these animals, you'll probably find them all. It's another ecological
marker. And the same with pillar 2, where we're seeing aurochs, a fox or jackal and a crane,
animals we could expect to find in muddy riverbanks. The H and I symbols look to symbolise
some kind of barriers, possibly man-made, maybe even animal traps. On pillar 33, the H symbols
straddle the waterway, and the bottom one looks like a barrier stopping the catfish from travelling
further. It's a barrier that fish can't penetrate, hence why they stop in front of it. We also see a
number of I symbols in front of the cranes, which are also positioned around the water that contains
the catfish. We're humans making barriers around certain bodies of water, keeping the animals away
from the fish, and also stopping the fish from swimming downstream, and this was also the humans
could catch them. Is this evidence that people were engineering the landscape in such a way to
manage the wildlife, to manage their own sources of food? Giorgio thinks that this H symbol could
be a net fixed between two poles, and whilst he may be correct, I think the H and I symbols were
more generic, universal symbols that were used on pillars to indicate a barrier of any kind,
humans demarcating the land to manage the land and hence the animals. On pillar 43,
we can see another I symbol barrier, and again it's stopping a crane, and then a catfish or eel
looks to be going around an H barrier and down, maybe showing how barriers can be used to stop
and then direct the fish to swim in a certain direction. On pillar 1, Giorgio says that these
are fish, possibly catfish that are caught in a net, but this doesn't work for me, because the
so-called fish are next to a ram, a sheep or a lamb. These are typically mountain animals,
and are not really associated with wetlands. So what if this is just a net, and these are
not fish heads around the edge, but they are in fact weights. Having weights around the edge of a
net makes it easier to throw. The animal that's being caught is the one directly below the net.
That to me is the most logical interpretation. As we can see it's an isolated animal,
but wild sheep such as the Mouflon of Europe are not solitary creatures. Maybe the lesson here is
to isolate one animal, likely a lamb. Maybe the ancient people wanted to catch them alive,
so they could bring them back to the settlement and keep the fresh meat. Or maybe this was the
very beginnings of animal husbandry, bringing a young wild sheep into a domestic setting,
and this was how you did it. Although the catfish and eels identified by Giorgio do have heads that
are similar to the edges of this net, it would be a unique and strange way to represent them,
and there really isn't a natural context to have a sheep and fish in close proximity.
Therefore I don't think these are fish. There is so much more I could go into in this video,
but because I am looking at animal iconography, I will just mention Pillar 56, another incredible
complex arrangement of animals. And it looks like another wetland scene. We have the eels or
catfish swimming towards the left, and they're surrounded by waterbirds, which I think are there
for feeding. But behind the waterbirds we have leopards in pursuit, and this is a visual
representation of the food chain in a wetland setting. And in the middle of the pillar we see
a vulture in flight, which would circle overhead, waiting to pick at the remains left behind by the
leopards. This, of course, is a lot to take in. There is a lot to think about, and I could go
into more detail and look at more pillars, but what I wanted to get across in this video
is just how important it is to first of all identify the animals correctly.
Calling the eels or catfish snakes completely changes the context of every pillar that
features them. But when they're identified as wetland wildlife, it gives the waterbirds context,
and also the felines that follow. The people of Gobekli Tepe and all of the Tastapela sites in
this region were masters of the animal kingdom. Being hunters, they must have had a deep knowledge
of the natural world, knowledge that was passed down from generation to generation. And what better
way to decorate the pillars than to impart your wisdom? It's a way to visually teach the youth
of the community how, where and when to find specific types of animals, and also the dangers
associated with them. A young person in a hunter-gatherer society needs to know that where
there are waterbirds, there could also be leopards. They need to know that these big cats can and will
swim across rivers. The pillars could have been used to teach the young how to manage the land,
how and where to raise barriers, how to make fish swim in a certain direction,
how to isolate a stretch of water, and how to isolate a lamb and then catch it with a net.
They can also learn that carcasses in the water will attract scavengers like crayfish.
This video is really just an introduction and there is a lot more I need to go into.
The animal behaviour shown on the pillars can sometimes indicate a particular time of the year
and this adds another dimension to the iconography. In his work, Professor Georgiou goes a stage
further discussing the shaman's role inside the enclosures, how he or she may have used it.
To him, the overriding story of Enclosure D looks to be the flooding of the land at the end of
winter, when vast landscapes were covered by the floodwaters of the Euphrates and its tributaries.
From the flooding, the carcasses of drowned animals were floating on its surface.
The narrative could also be about a riverine landscape at the beginning of spring,
with quiet running waters filled with fish and water birds, with aurochs and boars hiding in
the muddy banks as the leopards and jackals lie in wait. Enclosure D could be a shamanic sanctuary
involving the world of water, where details of the natural world were taught to the people,
with stories and maybe also beliefs and mythology weaved in.
Identifying animals is just the beginning. Working out a logical interpretation for
the associated symbols is the next stage, and then we do need a realistic and logical explanation.
We must also consider the anthropomorphic pillars and why in the later phases of
occupation at Gobekli Tepe, human iconography overtook the animals.
But I think this new line of research finally helps us to make sense of the pillars of Gobekli
Tepe, and then we can hopefully relate it to the iconography of Karahan Tepe and the rest
of the incredible Tastapela sites in southeastern Anatolia. Thank you very much for watching this
episode of Ancient Architects. If you enjoyed the video, please subscribe to the channel,
please like the video and please leave a comment below. Thank you very much!
