The competition for the North Doors of the Florentine Baptistery kick-started the Italian Renaissance. Ghiberti, the sculptor who won the competition, will spend his life casting first the North, then the East Doors, which Michelangelo would later call the "Doors of Paradise." The loser of the Competition, Brunelleschi by name, will become the greatest architect of the 15th century and will go on to build the Dome of the Florentine Cathedral, considered an impossible task. Still another sculptor, Donatello, cast the first bronze free-standing male nude, reviving Greek values. Behind all this stood the Medici family, the de-facto rulers of Florence, who encouraged (and paid for) these remarkable achievements.
Part I of II.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This lecture examines the transition from medieval craftsmanship to Renaissance art in Florence, focusing on the evolution of sculpture and architecture. Through the works of Ghiberti and Donatello, it illustrates the shift from rigid, symbolic forms to humanistic naturalism, the revival of classical antiquity, and the revolutionary development of linear and atmospheric perspective.
Hello everyone. Last time we looked at the art of the early Renaissance Florence and today we'll
be looking at sculpture and architecture. Since times medieval, the craftsmen inherited
their multitasking skills. In other words, they were responsible for building churches,
decorating churches, altars, civic buildings, painting altarpieces, building altars.
They indeed were extremely versatile and the Renaissance sculptor, artist, architect
could be one man. They were not the artists as we understand them today who spill their
inner greatness onto a flat space of canvas. They were craftsmen. They worked to commission.
They think of an interior designer shop. You go there when you want to decorate your house.
You commission them to hire upholsters, to hire carpenters, to hire all sorts of craftsmen.
Who are needed for the purpose. That was in fact the position of artists in the Middle Ages and
in the early Renaissance. They still had the same position. They worked to commission. They executed
what those who commissioned them desired. Whether they were private individuals or they were
ecclesiastical individuals. At the turn of the 15th century, one of the most important civic
buildings, civic and religious buildings in Florence was the Florentine Baptistery. It is an
octagonal building and at that time it still served both as church and as baptistery,
as a meeting place. It was very much the central building over the Florentine Republic because
the cathedral that began to be built circa 1300 still was not finished. It was the baptistery
that served the purpose. The baptistery's original doors were wooden doors but back in the 13th
century, Florence was becoming wealthy and it felt that it could do the bronze doors and that
was a true luxury to have bronze doors. However, no one in Florence really knew how to do that.
The castors of bronze, the best castors of bronze lived in Pisa and it is from Pisa that Andrea
Pisano was brought to Florence and asked to do the doors, the southern doors of the baptistery.
We are looking at the west end of the baptistery. Across from us is the east end, across from that
and then these are the southern doors and across of course would be the northern doors.
These doors were commissioned in the middle of the 14th century
just before the plague. The bronze doors were commissioned from Andrea Pisano right here and
as I said the bronze makers were in Pisa. The doors consisted of 28 rectangular panels right here
and they were designed for the south portal and because the doors practically stayed open at all
times, each door had to be read separately. Thus, each one consists of 10 scenes each
in the upper section and these sections portray the life of Saint John the Baptist. This is the
baptistery and then the four each on the lower register represented the theological virtues.
Andrea Pisano here used the medieval clover leaf or quatrefoil as you see here and fit his
depictions very neatly into those quatrefoils and here you see the scene of baptism and here is
another scene of baptism. I mean after all it is, as I said, the baptistery where every newborn
Florentine child was baptized. One can see the water that's done stylistically but one can see
quite well. The point of view onto the water is as the bird flies while it is the side view on the
scene itself. In this case, this is baptism of Christ by John the Baptist. Here is baptism of
someone else. The rocks just as with Giotto, one simply brought a piece of stone into one's studio
and then turned it into a rock. The figures themselves were gilded and part of the gold
gilding is shown here. Now by the year 1400, with the plague behind them and the fortunes of the
town on the increase as well, it was felt that now that the southern doors were done,
one they had to do the northern doors as well and in this case a competition was announced
to which many sculptors gathered to compete and at the end only two
remained. One was Lorenzo Ghiberti and the other was Filippo Brunelleschi. In the end,
it was the Ghiberti panel that won the day. Here are both of them. These are called the competition
panels and truly they in a way they kicked off the renaissance in Florence. Brunelleschi panel
is this, Ghiberti panel is that. The theme of each panel was the sacrifice of Isaac from the
Old Testament. To an average person, when one looks at these panels, one doesn't really see
much of a difference because they're both gilded, they're both in bronze, they both depict
the same theme. Here we'll start with the Brunelleschi panel. We see in the middle,
as is appropriate, is Isaac who is being sacrificed and his father Abraham is in fact
grabbing his head, twisting it in a rather abrupt fashion and has his knife ready to cut his throat.
The knife is almost at the throat. It is at this moment that the angel appears very nicely from
one of the quatrefoils and describing in fact the circle of the quatrefoil and grabbing the
arm of Abraham to stop the sacrifice of his son and very conveniently and obligingly there's
a lamb nearby which will be sacrificed instead. By his determination, Abraham had proven to God
that God is more important to him than his family and his only son that he begot
in his old age and that was enough. Isaac was spared. Now the composition of the
quatrefoil. About three quarters is taken by the scene itself and then at the bottom, so that we
know how they got there, there is a donkey that brought Abraham and Isaac. On each side of the
are the two servants and both servants are done in the quite a renaissance,
rebirth of the antiquity style. In other words, this servant here on our right is done in a
brilliant foreshortening. Remember foreshortening. This is my Russian spoon. This is the full length.
Here you almost don't see the handle because it is foreshortened. Same thing with this figure and
this the other boy on our left is actually a reproduction of a very famous antique sculpture
of a boy removing a splinter from his foot and here it is. So these would be immediately
recognizable as forward looking. The boy is depicted quite realistically. His father is
determined. The angel is intent on stopping the sacrifice. So all is well and the composition
is lovely in a sense that it describes, as I said, the quatrefoil itself and the scene again
right in the center. Now we go to the other scene and Giberti here, Lorenzo Giberti is the name of
the sculptor here, he chose a different approach. Instead of planting Isaac immediately in the
middle, he removes this scene to the right and divides the composition diagonally by the rock
right here. So that is unusual right there. Interesting. The two servants are depicted on
our left with an ass but they are depicted behind the rock or it would also mean underneath the
rock so they wouldn't be able to see what went on. Abraham seems to hesitate. His knife is not quite
at the throat of Isaac and in this case it's the angel that's foreshortened as the
servant was foreshortened here. On top of the rock sits the lamb. Now even though Isaac is not
in the center of the composition, he immediately draws our attention because this is the first
nude of the Renaissance. It is not an independent sculpture, a discrete sculpture, that we can
walk around. It is still a relief. Relief meaning that the image is projected from the background
yet it is very boldly done. The boy looks in fact defiant as he's staring in the face of his father
and he is a beautiful, beautiful nude as one had not seen since antiquity because Christianity
forbid all nudity and in representation unless absolutely necessary and as we saw with Giotto,
it was not only necessary but Giotto clearly seemed to enjoy what he was doing but they were
not the ideal nudes, heroic nudes as they were in classical antiquity. This now is an ideal nude
right here. So it is almost as if Ghiberti cheated a bit because this nude was simply irresistible.
Also the proportions, the arrangement of the design, the composition were more unusual,
less traditional, less conventional and well Ghiberti won the commission which will essentially
take him his entire life to do because after the northern doors that will take him 20 plus years,
he will then be commissioned to do the eastern doors that will take him another close to 30
years and not only that but he will become a force to reckon with in the city of Florence. He
will have his hands in every pot, in every significant commission that will appear in
Florence after this time and so this happened between 1401-1402 and it kick-started the
Renaissance in Florence and now please compare the Pisano image from the early 14th century
and Ghiberti's image that came about 60 years later. Pisano is elegant, is very much contained
within his quatrefoil and definitely conveys what he wishes to, the story that he wishes to tell
but there's no emotion there. There is no expression as you see it here and needless to
say that of course there are no nudes. This one is almost spilled out of its quatrefoil that
contains it and it is not just the relatively conventional telling of the story but something
new is there. The human element is there very much and we are entering into the age of humanism.
Works will be written by the middle of the century on the dignity of men. The scholars
will now be disagreeing with medieval thinkers who felt that man was a speck of dust in the face
of God and the polemics will begin about man being at the center of the universe. Man's mind
in fact created very much in the image of God's own mind and man's limitations having
no limitations. It is the exploration of one's own mind and one's own possibilities
that is the ultimate goal of man as opposed to abstract deity and here
there is a difference visual difference even between these two. This is as well as it is done
and of course it's dull and bronze which in itself is a great advance in practical arts
but it is still rather conventional. We see images like this in medieval manuscripts where
something like this is bursting with human passion human life human emotion and thus of course
and there lies the difference. In the end the north doors were dedicated to the life of Christ
not the old testament. It is the eastern doors that will be dedicated to the old testament
and following Pisano example all imagery is still contained within this platform as you see
and here they are. They were they too were gilded they are 28 panels as before depicting life of
Christ from the new testaments and the lower panels show the evangelists and the church
fathers. The Pisano lower panels four on each side eight panels show the various virtues whereas
these show the evangelists and the forefathers four evangelists four church fathers.
Here is an example of the adoration of the magi the magi the three kings that come to Christ's
cradle on his birth bringing gifts. They come from various parts of the world and here they are
the older magi is kissing Christ's foot Mary is holding him Joseph is standing at the back
and the relief itself is done very much at different levels from just very very small
projection literally a couple of millimeters to perhaps a whole inch to a high relief with
everything in between. The niche within which Mary sits in fact is projecting entirely out of its own
space and and Ghiberti decides to skip in fact the column upon which the niche rests because well
our mind always knows more very often than the eye sees and our mind knows that the column there
that there would be a column there but Ghiberti decided to skip it so that we could see the Holy
Family much better instead of it being obstructed by the column. The cluster heads that we had seen
with Giotto is repeated here also because the magi come with a suite of helpers and servants
and the head of the older magi is almost projecting again from the quatrefoil so as
opposed to Pisano again while Pisano is entirely contained within his quatrefoil this one is
spilling out it's almost it's expecting the next step to be something else to to let them be free
to let them come out of the quatrefoil and that in fact will will happen with the eastern doors.
As I said it took Ghiberti 20 plus years to finish the northern doors and it will take even longer
to do the eastern doors and there he had no competition he was the sculptor of Florence
his workshop was the most famous and needless to say he was given other commissions as well
but of course the doors were the major commission. In 1425 he got the commission
for the eastern doors and toiled on it for 27 years. Now as you see he completely abandons
the quatrefoil and the quatrefoil as you see here wishes to be abandoned it's almost as if the
figures inside it don't want to be contained inside and you anymore he divides now the doors
into five panels each and each one of them is a large square not only that but but renaissance
principles were advancing on a very on an exponential scale at this point and he now
applies the same scale to the buildings as he does to the people and as a result not only the
background and the middle ground now begin to make sense but the entire space around the figures
there's this exploration of space that is happening in the renaissance which
towards the end of the century as we know will in fact manifest itself in the exploration
of real space as Columbus discovered the new world so the exploration of physical space
whether it's visual optical realistic the true exploration all the aspects of the
discovery of the world will be very much embraced and here they are this is
this represents the old testament here is the comparison between the panels and you can see
how much larger the spaces are so he has he has room to maneuver one of the better known of these
of these panels is this one that depicts the story of Jacob and Esau both Jacob and Esau are
grand sons of Abraham sons of Isaac the one who was spared during the sacrifice and they were
twins they were twins however Esau was born first and then Jacob came after and in that society the
firstborn inherits all the privileges of his father together with his wife however
Esau is born very hairy and then as he grows up he prefers hunting to husbandry and it is seen
allegorically husbandry is a more advanced stage in human development than hunting and it is
Jacob who devotes his life to husbandry and to shepherding and the mother Rebecca loves
Jacob more and she very much wishes for him to be that he would be considered firstborn instead
of Esau however Isaac of course prefers Esau best because he is firstborn and as such Rebecca
conceives a plan once Esau is out in the woods hunting she places animal skins on Jacob's arms
and because Isaac at this point is quite old and doesn't see very well the time comes to bless
the firstborn and Rebecca brings Jacob to Isaac Isaac because of his blindness feels the arm of
Jacob he touches the fur decides that is indeed Esau and gives him his blessing as the firstborn
thus Jacob acquires the right of the firstborn by trickery as you can imagine when Esau comes back
he is not happy that's the story this is a narrative image and we see Rebecca pregnant
appealing to God asking him what is going to happen and God telling her that she will indeed
have twins here she is on the birthing bed having her children then the children are grown
and Esau is going off into the woods while he's gone into the woods Rebecca comes to
Jacob and conceives the plan of placing placing woolen skin on his hand and here is Isaac he is
extremely upset for good reason and here the two brothers face one another and quarrel
here's the story the most important thing about this however is not the story itself
as the execution as I said you might remember that this joto and even still
with Masaccio the scales that were applied to human beings and to architecture everything else
were different scales human beings were on the double scale as opposed to say architecture all
of this changes here in fact because Ghiberti has this entire large square to play with he
does so he projects the columns the space into its recession absolutely brilliantly
one space after another space after another space and never mind that this kind of
ancient Roman architecture obviously did not exist in the at the times of Jacob and
and Esau that is inconsequential what is consequential is the ability to project
a real space onto a two-dimensional surface and that is precisely what Ghiberti does he also
includes the dance of the women and that also is very much just a nod to classical antiquity
because the well there were three graces here we see four women and because they're dancing
he shows them from different sides and it's almost as if it's Ghiberti's signature look
what I can do I am so entirely familiar with classical antiquity and what they stood for
and that's why I can do all this it really was quite it was just as
much of an eye-opener as Masaccio was well Masaccio was painting pretty much at the same
time in the Brancacci chapel so all these men in the 15th century interacted and here is the
close-up you can see the the women dancing in this constant progress and advancement of human
understanding and the story here now you see these lines on the tile floor they are the
orthogonals that go to a one-point perspective and he placed his own head on the doors together
with other such little busts of other people he did have other commissions Ghiberti and another
very important building in Florence also sort of half ecclesiastical half civic building
was the building that's called the Orsan Michele right here right here or the kitchen garden of
Saint Michael it was originally built as a grain market and wheat exchange again in the 14th
century and then it was converted into a church as the plague subsided towards the end of the
century on the ground floor of the building there are these arcades but then the originally these
arcades were open because well this was a market and and housed one of the city's
grain houses and the the first floor formed elogia and then late in the 14th century again
the guilds were charged with with creating sculptures for the niches in the building you
see there are these niches in the building now sculpture in fact was becoming more and more
important gothic cathedrals in the north began to be decorated with sculpture and in the gothic
times the late gothic times sculpture was seen everywhere in the gothic cathedrals but also in
on the municipal buildings and as opposed to the altarpiece that one sees when one goes inside for
one's devotions sculpture especially the sculpture on the outside of a building is for everyone to
see for everyone who passes by so it is very obviously there one doesn't have to plan for
specific devotions one doesn't have to go inside the building one sees it in one's daily life so
the outside of the buildings very often were decorated with sculpture and also initially
being a civic building in addition to being an ecclesiastical building a number of sculptures
were commissioned but very few of them in fact were were completed in the 14th century well
obviously the plague however with the opening of the 15th century these commissions were in fact
being executed and here is one that is done by Gibertsy by the shop of Gibertsy and in his
sculptures now all of the sculptures interestingly enough they appear to be an individual discrete
sculptures that one can in fact if they were taken out of the niche one can walk around and one can
however the backs are not completed bronze was extremely expensive and with these sculptures
being placed in the niches and in fact having to be looked at exclusively from the front there was
no need to complete the decks so even though they're not reliefs but they're not completed
sculptures in the round either even though they appear as such Gibertsy had this interesting style
of almost armor blades or sword blades style that almost appear as if they can cut you if
you touch it and it is a compelling style that presents a sweeping form of the garment even though
to an extent it of course hides the body underneath this is the sculpture of Saint Matthew
who was the patron saint of the guild of the bankers because when Saint Matthew was called by
by Christ to become his apostle he was a tax collector at the time and as such he will become
the patron saint of the bankers now the scripture that was written by Saint Matthew that was a
different Saint Matthew in fact from the one who was the apostle of Christ the gospel writer
wrote his work perhaps 50 years after Christ's crucifixion but at that time those two Matthews
were confused and as such the Matthew who wrote the scripture was considered to be
the actual apostle of Christ who was originally the tax collector and as such commissioned by the
guild of the bankers and thus the guild of the bankers commissioned the statue
all crafts in Florence and in the majority of Italian cities at the time were divided into
guilds or arts they were called and the major guilds the wealthiest guilds were guilds like
those of the wool makers or guild of the bankers of course guild of the armors those were the
important guilds and then there were lesser guilds guild of carpenters a guild of apothecaries
actually the artists belonged to the guild of the apothecaries because it was the apothecaries
who who grinded their colors for them so these guilds were now each commissioned to
present the sculpture and here's the sculpture from Giberti and you see his style of art yet
underneath the garment as heavy as and as forbidding as the garment is we still see
the principle of contrapposto now this principle was devised by the Greeks
towards the middle of the 5th century BC because when sculpture began in ancient Greece
on a large scale and here for instance is a male nude that is housed in the Metropolitan Museum of
Art in New York and you see how rigid he is this sculpture belongs to the 6th century but even
before that 7th, 8th centuries BC whenever sculptures were carved at that time they were
the Greeks were probably looking at the Egyptian art which is rather rigid but within within 100
years towards the middle of the 5th century BC as you see this rigidity has disappeared and
this is a perfect example of the so-called contrapposto or counter pose in in which
every muscle every sinew every limb in fact balances off another limb in the human body
to make the human body proportional to make it harmonious to make it stable this is this is the
sculpture of the so-called spear bearer that was done by polyclators in Greek it is called the
durifers and as you see the Greeks realized that even in the standing position a human body is
very well balanced and as such here for instance he's called the durifers because a spear bearer
because there used to be a spear in his left hand that rested on his left shoulder and thus we have
that his left arm is engaged and so is his right leg because the entire weight of the body
is placed on the right leg while the left leg is free to move and support the body and the right
arm is free as well instead of looking directly at us as this kouros means youth in Greek as
as this young man does the stance is much more relaxed in the case of durifers and he is
in fact looking to the side and this stance in fact will be adopted by the renaissance sculptors
you see this sort of stance here already all the weight is placed on his left leg now and
the right leg is is free. Another sculpture that was placed into one of the niches of
was commissioned by a weaver's guild but it was commissioned from a man by the name of Donatello
because as much as Ghiberti was the number one man in Florence Donatello was ultimately the
greatest sculptor and in this case he is commissioned by the linen weavers guild
and their patron saint is Saint Mark same thing Saint Mark who was the evangelist was not
Saint Mark who knew Christ but that was disregarded and what Donatello does
here is very different from what Ghiberti does and in fact Donatello does his sculpture
somewhat earlier than Ghiberti as you see Donatello's sculpture falls between 1411 and 1413
whereas Ghiberti began his sculpture six years after this one was finished but what is
extraordinary about Donatello is that he really didn't want to do anything to rely
on any convention whatsoever even the Greek convention he wished to sculpt from the actual
living people and it seems that that's what he had done he would sculpt from a living man
a nude body and he would sculpt it in plaster at first and then he would arrange
the drapery he would wet the drapery in a very thin slip of plaster and arrange it around his
figure to his satisfaction so that the drapery would acquire drama where he wished it to be
but also would reveal the relationship of the various human limbs underneath the drapery and
that is what we see here while Saint Matthew that was done by Ghiberti is entirely covered
in this almost the an armor of drapery instead Saint Mark looks to be wearing the real cloth the
real garment and the real garment shows his body it almost becomes the wet drapery that in fact
was used also by the Greeks in the middle of the 5th century on their great temple called the
Parthenon and such is Donatello that he recreates the idea of wet drapery with this
statue and even though it was astonishing it was perhaps a little too astonishing for the times
and although Ghiberti did his sculpture later Ghiberti was a man to be reckoned with Ghiberti
was not looking at anything that others did he knew best and as a result this is the statue
that he produced also a beautiful statue but incomparable in terms of human quality to the one
produced by Donatello. Another sculpture also for Orsan Michele was commissioned to him by the
Kirosmakers and that is of Saint George who was a military knight and who was the patron of the
Kirosmakers and so there he stands because he is a military figure he has to wear armor and
underneath armor one cannot see the body very easily so Donatello had to do what he could
with his cape around the shoulders which is tied in a knot which creates tension and one
always has tension where great sculpture is concerned. He looks to the side and he is
supported by a shield he used to have a sword that projected into the actual space but the sword
is now lost. Even more interesting than this the statue itself is the image right here of the
but before we leave the statue remember the face right here on the statue because Michelangelo
in executing his David sometime later will also look at this face but here is the
the assistant piece at the bottom of the sculpture. It is Saint George the Saint himself
with a dragon delivering the maiden in distress and what is truly extraordinary in this little
it's revolutionary it is done in projection it is done in relief and relief traditionally
had always been done by carving either carving out the image to a flat space as a background
or in terms of plaster or wax one added to a flat space as a background in either case the
background was always solid flat space and this is something that Donatello changed because the space
behind the our saint killing the dragon and the maiden it is all carved with trees
with clouds with landscape it's infinite it's essentially this Donatello does here what
Masaccio had done with his atmospheric perspective and as such he had changed centuries upon centuries
of idealized imagery whether that idealized imagery was in fact realistic or whether it
was conceptual it was still an idealized imagery as opposed to optic imagery here he introduces
the visual optic principle which in fact will continue to the impressionists he introduces the
principle of what the eye sees must be conveyed back to the eye and he does it in this
in this little predella and as a result here we see the constant play of light and shade
as light falls on the carving behind the knight and the maiden who stands in front of the classical
colonnade that disappears into into that distance so that's that's very important what he had done
here here is the one point perspective that i had mentioned before our railroad or here it is
as the eye sees it in in reality another example of the same and again we are with Donatello
and this time we are we are in Siena where he was commissioned to to cast in bronze decorations
for the baptismal font right here for the baptismal fountain and we are looking at it and
the Sienese cathedral is one of the most stunning beautiful cathedrals
the world around it really is extraordinary and this is the panel we'll be looking at it is by
Donatello it's called the feast of Herod and that has to do again with the story of John the Baptist
this is a baptismal font and John the Baptist who was arrested by King Herod but King Herod had
enough troubles on his hands did not wish to execute him however his wife Herodia
had a bone to pick with John the Baptist she wished him executed and she arranged with her
daughter from an earlier marriage whose name was Salome to dance at the at the dining feast and
Salome was a beautiful beautiful dancer and at the end of the dance Herod was so overcome with
her grace with her beauty that despite himself he exclaimed anything you wish will be done and
Salome then wished for the head of John the Baptist at which point Herod could not break
his word that John the Baptist was executed and a platter with his head was brought in fact
to the feast that's the story this was done in 1427 it was probably done in fact before
Ghiberti did his panel of Jacob and Esau because he only got the commission for those doors in 1425
so while doing the panel and doing that one point perspective and doing the
the consequence of the arches he certainly knew what Donatello had done here
and here we have it as you see here again the one space follows another and it is all done
in the one point perspective their space is there with just people doing some adjunct
services the main scene is right here and what they have is a servant bringing a platter with
the head of John the Baptist and it's like an exploding grenade because everybody is horrified
and there's a great expression of that horror that's conveyed here even Herod himself
cannot believe what he had just done while Herodia is perfectly at peace and Salome here in
also in that in that same graceful position as we saw the maiden in the Saint George's
predella which stands right here but again it's not even so much the content it's the execution
it's the allowing of space for all individuals within the panel and extending the space so
there's no longer this two-dimensional contracted space the space is infinite it goes room after
room after room and then it almost appears as if it's endless whereas of course again with this
relief the whole thing is probably one inch and yet the optical illusion is spectacular here
perhaps you can see it better there's the platter with the head of John the Baptist
everybody's horrified here's Salome other servants Herod can't believe what he had done
and here's Herodia and then back looks like something like a school perhaps kitchens
what have you but everything is determined by that one point perspective we see columns we
see pilasters we see the mason reconstruction it's it's really something to behold and then
he does something that truly hadn't been done since the antiquity a beautiful beautiful
male nude now we saw one with Ghiberti around the year 1401 when he did his competition panel
but that still was a relief this is the actual separate discreet nude that one can walk around
and this is his statue of David which he cast about 1440. It is famous as the first unsupported
standing bronze a work of bronze uh the renaissance well Donatello was was homosexual
and he did spend quite a bit of time in Rome studying ancient sculpture whatever there was
whatever there was whatever was left from from the ancient times and he admired the classical
appreciation of a male nude and particularly in Greece the male nude was greatly appreciated
not only that it was also considered that an ideal male nude reflected the the ideal
signs of heavenly movement the harmony the proportion the music of of heavens was reflected
very much in an ideal male nude and this is what Donatello has undertaken it has nothing to do
with David of the Bible who obviously was not nude when he went to combat Goliath but that
really wasn't what interested Donatello though what interested him was human beauty and it's
not even a classical nude either there's I mean there's nothing heroic about it perhaps ideal but
even idealism here is compromised in the sense that um if one looks from the side his uh his
stomach is somewhat protruded his muscle is indicated but he certainly doesn't have a six
pack as the great Greek athletic nudes had he is standing there he's lost in thought
there's no determination in fact Goliath has been defeated right there he's uh he was struck with a
stone and he fell down at which point David severed his head and now he's standing there he is entirely
nude except for the booties the open-toed booties and with his left foot he's kind of playing with
Goliath's enormous mane right there on his head and the only are the another article of clothes
is his hat that is crowned with a lot with the laurel wreath right there definitely perfect
but it is uh sort of a realistic idealism if one can say so because the boy is soft the body is
soft it's made of bronze but especially when one sees it with real life there's so much sensuality
about him one feels as if the surface will in fact be warm and he has his huge
sword in his right hand and interestingly his left hand is akimbo and still is holding a stone
the even though that stone had flown a long time ago from uh from his sling
but these are different moments in time presented in uh in one image and here we have it here's his
face uh looking nowhere just lost in thought he is certainly not shown as enormously proud
of his victory which he should be he is alone which of course he wouldn't have been
after such an incredible conquest he'd be surrounded by others he'd be smiling he'd be
glorified but he presents but donatella presents him as a person in time and as david
was looked upon by christianity as precursor of christ and christ was the new david here is
here is the defeat of iniquity by righteousness and and such stands alone right here but
as i said these statues uh very human while idealistic as well uh it's uh it looks like
a beautiful young boy not a very muscular boy either i mean you almost see uh little breasts
and as i said the uh the stomach protrudes a bit uh and here he is again and here you can see it
and here he is well donatello also extended the the helmet of goliath to to reach up
upward between david's legs and the way he holds his sword may also be suggestive
so he certainly unites here all sorts of human interests whether it's ecclesiastical physiological
interest donatella is there very much to deliver it in fact when the statue was its first
cast and was cast for the medici a number of people considered it inappropriate