What did we really find on Mars? Could we find actual fossils there? How was the most detailed 3D-map of the Universe made? And in Q&A+, what's the deal with Iapetus and its huge ridge?
00:00 Intro 00:22 [@HanSolo__] Did we find marks of past primitive life on Mars? 05:15 [@geohondo] Could we find an actual skeletal fossil on mars? 07:18 [@louisnelsonsmith] How DESI works 16:50 The Q&A format
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
What did we really find on Mars? Can we find actual fossils there? How was the most detailed 3D map
of the universe made? And in Q&A+, what's the deal with Iapetus and its huge ridge?
All this in this question show. It's time for the question show, your questions, my answers.
As always, wherever you are across my channel, if a question pops in your brain, just write it down,
I'll gather them up and I will answer them here. Alright, let's get into the questions.
Han Solo, do you think we've found marks of past primitive life on Mars?
There have been some really interesting discoveries on Mars that have said that
maybe one explanation is that this was caused by life, but there are other viable explanations.
There are three main discoveries in the last couple of decades that have led people to believe
that there may have been life on Mars and there might still be life on Mars. The first one was
the Viking experiment. Viking was a mission sent in the late 1970s to Mars, and it was able to
scoop up some regolith and then put water and some nutrients in with the regolith. And then it was
detecting if any kind of gas was coming out of the regolith that would be indicative of microbial
life living in that regolith. And that it did detect some kind of output of gas, but there
have been arguments to this day about what it was that it found. One camp believes that it is
evidence of some kind of bacterial life in the regolith on Mars. Another camp believes that this
is just some kind of abiotic process that is just chemistry, something reacted, maybe the perchlorates
with the water produced the gases, and you got this result. And so right now, if you go and talk
to people, some will say that they found life, others will swear that it didn't find life.
The other big discovery that happened was that around the Curiosity rover on Mars,
they detected an increase of methane in the environment during springtime on Mars. And this
led some people to believe that the temperature was warming up, and this was causing methanogen
bacteria on the surface of Mars to kick into high gear and start to output methane around the
environment of Curiosity. But others think, well, maybe it was, it was caused by the rover itself,
that maybe it was settling or was rolling over the ground and something was, it was interacting
with this environment to release methane into its environment. But other spacecraft have detected
what seemed to be increases in methane in the area around Curiosity around Mars. And so one
possibility is that there is some kind of bacteria on Mars that has produced this methane into the
atmosphere of Mars. But there are other again, non biological ways that you could get this that
there could be volcanoes on Mars that are producing methane. And maybe as Curiosity is rolling across
the surface of Mars, it is compressing gas in the regolith and is sort of causing it to be expelled
around Curiosity. And then the other example most recent is a discovery by the Perseverance rover on
Mars, and it found this rock that had these stripes in it, and these weird little spots in it of iron
bearing compounds. These kinds of rocks are produced by life on Earth. And so this could
be an example of some ancient life form on Mars, back when Mars was a lot more habitable early on
its history, that was producing these iron compounds, and they were being sort of fossilized
into the rock. And Perseverance has taken samples of this rock, and now you know, they need to be
brought back to Earth by the Mars sample return mission to be able to find out. But the scientists
that were involved with this said that they'd essentially exhausted every non biological
source that you could get this kind of formation. And so all that remains, in their opinion,
was some kind of biology that was actually creating it. But you know, that doesn't mean
for sure that it was life, there could be some non biological process that they weren't
familiar with that could create this. So this is possibly the most important discovery that
humanity could make scientifically. If we find life on Mars, then that means that life is probably
everywhere across the cosmos. And so you got to be sure. And so even if there was a tree on Mars,
even if there were aliens waving to us in the cameras on Mars, we would go, I don't know,
what are the non biological ways that you could get this happening on Mars, and people would
probably be very, very reticent to fully jump in right away. But if the evidence is overwhelming,
eventually, right, eventually, we will have a spacecraft, go to this location, pick up the
samples from Perseverance, bring them back home to Earth. And then scientists will be able to study
in the lab to find out whether or not it was truly life. So this is a long, complex detective work
to be able to get an answer to this question. Geohondo, is it possible that we may find an
actual skeletal fossil on Mars? Or would it be all gone by now? If there are skeletal fossils on Mars,
and they're not that old, you know, maybe they are hundreds of millions of years old,
then theoretically, we could find them. It all depends on the preservation depends on the
conditions on Mars. And keep in mind that Mars has been incredibly dry, cold, has not had a lot of
active erosion on the surface of the planet beyond wind. And on Earth, I mean, we've got water,
we've got temperature changes, atmosphere, we've got biological erosion that is going on,
there's a lot going on to destroy any archaeological evidence of past life. But on Mars,
it is cold and dead. And so if you but it also doesn't have the same kind of like plate tectonics
that can reveal older features. But, you know, here on Earth, they have found examples of
bacterial colonies, going back to 4 billion years ago. And so theoretically, the same kind of thing
could be found on Mars, they're called stromatolites, I think. So these bacterial colonies,
that form these sort of rock formations. And so this is the hope that we will find these kinds
of structures on Mars. And then that would be evidence of some kind of past life form on Mars.
But what you're talking about, like, what if there was like a dinosaur fossil, right? Like,
that would be very cool. And it would just depend on the conditions of what it was preserved in.
And then how much erosion has this happened to get to the point where it's at right now? Yeah,
it depends on the age, you know, how long ago would there have been animals on Mars?
500 million years ago, so it would be the same thing as Earth.
It's time to shatter all the new $5 patrons and above. Bruce Katter, Glennie Pete, Rich in DC,
Klaus K., Scott Chelberg, Rene Larique, Joseph Walker, Mikkel Jorgensen, James Carey,
and CyberBanion. Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Louie Nilsen Smith, can you explain how DESI works? And how is the instrument being used to
detect dark energy? And what is dark energy anyway? Yeah, I can try. So DESI is the Dark
Energy Spectroscopic Instrument. It is one of the major experiments that are being done
to discover or understand the nature of dark energy better. And so the big question,
the effect of dark energy is that it seems to be accelerating the expansion of the universe
that astronomers went and looked at this very specific kind of supernova, type 20 supernova
that is known to give off a very specific amount of energy when it explodes. You know how much
intrinsic brightness is in the supernova. And so when you find one of these objects, and you measure
its brightness, you know how bright it should be. Therefore, that tells you how far away this thing
is. And so when astronomers were measuring all of the type 20 supernova that they were seeing,
they found that the ones that were older were farther away than they should be and what you
would expect in the expansion of the universe. And there's this very sort of smooth curve. And
it appears that there's this additional expansion that's happening in the universe above and beyond
just the regular expansion, thanks to the Big Bang. And so this was coined, this is dark energy,
we don't know what it is, we don't know what's causing it, we don't know how it started. It just
seems to be that the universe is more than just expanding, the expansion of the universe is
accelerating. So once you discover this new thing, once you discover this collection of observations,
then you need to make better observations, because people have a ton of questions. And
so there was a whole bunch of surveys that were developed to be able to help understand this.
There is the DES, the Dark Energy Survey, which wrapped up its first, I think, five years of its
survey, and it was taking images of the sky. And then they're using that to kind of measure
the galaxy clustering and looking at supernova and things like that. Then there's, of course,
Vera Rubin, which has just come online, and it's going to be able to detect tons and tons of
supernova, over a million of these type 1a supernova. So we'll give astronomers much better
data on finding these, it's going to find other events related to that. You've got the Euclid
mission, which was launched by the European Space Agency. And this is essentially taking
infrared images of the sky to determine the composition of galaxies, as well as visible
images to see how light is being distorted around galaxies. And that allows you to kind of measure
the dark matter is and be able to understand the history of the universe at different time
slices. There's the upcoming Nancy Grace Roman telescope. But the one you're talking about is
DESI, which is the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument. And this is a is a ground based
telescope. And it is doing a survey of the night sky. And it just wrapped up completed 13,000
degrees of the night sky, the whole sky is about 41,000 degrees. So it's like a little under a
third of the entire sky. So what happens is, and this is sort of a technology technique that's
been done for a long time, which is that you want to measure the chemical composition of a galaxy.
What they used to do is they would use a plate of aluminum plate that they would put in front
of the telescope, and it would block all the light from the telescope, except for the galaxy.
And so they would take the telescope, they pointed at the at the region that they were
going to look at, they would put this plate in front of the instrument that the camera that
measures it, and then only the light from the individual galaxies would be allowed through
these little pinprick holes in the plate. And then they could expand the light from each one
of those galaxies to do spectroscopy on that light and determine what that galaxy was made out
of. And then you can tell which are the galaxies that are relatively close to us, which are the
ones that are very far away, which ones have been heavily redshifted, and are seen earlier on into
the history of the universe, but it's a laborious process. You can imagine, you can take a new
picture, you got to pull out the right plate, put it in front, drill new holes in, right.
So with the DESI survey, they have this field of little fiber optic cables that are on these
little actuators. And so then they line up, they know all the galaxies are going to see in the
field of view, they line up all the little fiber optic cables to line up perfectly with the positions
of the galaxies, and then they take their picture. And so the light from that one galaxy goes down
the fiber optics, down this one channel, and they're able to separate the light and be able
to analyze it separately from all the other stuff that's out there. And that gives you really good,
clean data on that. And so what DESI is doing is that they are looking at the history of
the universe. They're looking at what was the expansion rate of the universe at different
times in its history. And they just wrapped up their five-year observing campaign and are in
the process of releasing all the data. And so the scientists are going to be able to use this
to calculate. And what you're going to get is just, you will be able to see these are the
galaxies that we're seeing relatively nearby. These are the galaxies that we're seeing a billion light
years away. These are the galaxies we're seeing 5 billion, the quasars that we're seeing 5 billion
light years away. And then you can measure the expansion rate of the universe at different times
in the history of the universe. And that'll allow you to see is dark energy changing over time?
Because this is one of the big questions that we have. We know that the expansion of the universe
is accelerating, but is it a constant acceleration? Or is the actual strength of the dark energy
changing? And the initial results from the dark energy survey, the DES said, actually, it looks
like dark energy is dynamic. It's not this constant, that it appears to be decreasing over
time, which is good news. Because if it's increasing over time, that could lead potentially
to the Big Rip, right, where the universe tears itself apart. So it appears that it's the opposite
of that, that there is a slight decrease in the amount of dark energy that is entering the universe
for every cubic meter of space. But there are four different methodologies for measuring dark energy.
So you have the Type Ia supernova, you have the galaxy clustering, you have the
gravitational lensing, and you have the baryon acoustic oscillations. And the problem is,
is that two of the measurements done by the dark energy survey indicate that it is more consistent
that the universe is the amount of dark energy is decreasing. But then two of the measurements
methods give the opposite. And so that is confusing. That is not what you would expect.
And so now we're going to get these additional surveys, the DESI survey, Nancy Grace Roman,
Euclid, Vera Rubin, and on and on and on. And so at this time when we have all these questions,
where this mystery is unfolding, we also happen to have the perfect tools for the job.
Five different brand new top of the line spacecraft have been launched with the
capability to give us an answer on this question. And so we will look back on this time,
say 10 years from now, in the way that we look back at pre-Gaia data. Before Gaia, we're like,
where are all the stars? Which stars are moving? I don't know. Gaia told us where 1.8 billion stars
are, where they're moving, what they're made out of. It's incredible. And that's the same kind of
revolution in historical, astronomical, cosmological data that we're about to get,
thanks to all of these missions. So DESI is the second one out now. You have the DES,
now you have DESI. And we're just going to see more of this information come out over the coming
years. Did you know that you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question over
on Patreon completely for free? I'm going to call it Q&A Plus. And this week's bonus question,
what's the deal with Iapetus and its huge reach? I'll put a link in the show notes.
All right, there's all the questions that we had this episode. Thank you, everyone who put
your questions into the YouTube comments, everybody who joined me for the live show.
We do the live show every Monday at 5pm Pacific Time, right here on this channel. Now I'm going
to answer some questions about the format of the question show. But first, I'd like to thank our
patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Petretti, Bailey Gruffin, Brian Bovey, Caribou, Chuck Hawkins,
Commander Baylock, Darkfinger, David Giltanen, David Matts, Evan Lindstrom, Evan Dot Pro,
James Clark, Janice Smith, Jeremy Mattern, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Sitz,
Michael Purcell, Nordspace, OneStepAnimals.org, Follow My Nephew at vbrick6984, Ren Kiety,
Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Feiler-Munley, Team 49, Telescopes Canada,
Vlad Shiblin, Wolfgang Klotz, and Zeldaborg Galactic to thank you for supporting us
at the Master of the Universe level. And all our patrons, all your support means the universe to
us. Luviz says, I miss the longer edited Q&A videos that were like 45 minutes long. They
were much more immersive. So up until about two years ago, we used to release Q&As that were about
45 minutes long. And the Q&As came from the live question show that I do every Monday here on the
channel. So we would take two hours of a live stream, and we would edit it down to the best 45
minutes of it. And then we release that as the question show. And now we release two episodes
every week that are about 22, 23 minutes long. So if you do the math, we've just turned what was
one episode into two episodes. And the reason we do that is because we got a ton of feedback from
people saying 45 minutes is too long. I don't have time for that. I would rather you made your
question shows shorter. And so we listen to people's feedback and turn them into two episodes.
But essentially it's the same thing. It's just split up over two episodes. And the feedback was
that was good. And the audience retention, you know, as you obey the algorithm that told us that
we were moving in the right direction, this was the right thing to do. I totally get that people
want things that are just longer that they can just leave on and just play. And so the decision
that we made very recently was that we now make all of the live streams public. So before we were
turning them unlisted after the episode wrapped up, and this was just sort of placate the YouTube
algorithm. So we can get punished for having big, long live streams on our channel, which used to
be the case. And now it seems to be fine. So now we have not only made all of the two hour live
streams public going forward, but we're now going back into our back catalog and cleaning them up
and putting the older ones live as well. New thumbnails, sort of trimming them down a bit,
but essentially you will have an unlimited number of these longer episodes. And then of course,
for the patrons, we do the patrons question show, which is audio only, but it is much longer. So
the one that we did, we just released the one this week. It was three and a half hours long.
So they've been upwards of five hours long. So if you really want an immersive question show,
definitely sign up and become a patron. So I know that we can't win, right? That if we made them
longer, then people would say they want them shorter. If we make them shorter, people would
say we make them longer. We release them in shorts. People hate shorts. Other people love shorts.
We're just gonna just keep producing content and sometimes it won't be perfect for everybody.
All right. We'll see you next time.