Bigger Body Parts in Space, Venus VS Mars, Favourite Moon | Q&A 283

Fraser Cain
378 followers
769 Video Views·Dec 31, 2024
what will happen to Phobos and damos in
Mars orbit what happens to different
body parts in space could Venus be a
better destination for human exploration
than Mars answering all these questions
and more in this question show it's time
for the question show your questions my
answers as always wherever you are
across my channel if a question Pops in
your brain just write it down gather
them up and I'll answer them here all
right let's get into the questions ninja
guy Dan are Phobos and damos drifting
away from Mars like our moon or are they
getting close
so this is really interesting with you
know we've talked quite a bit about how
the Moon is drifting away from the earth
and this is caused by the uh by the
tidal forces between the Earth and the
moon so if you imagine the Earth has
handles it has like water that is
bulging out from its sides when the
Gravity from the Moon is sort of pulling
on the Earth when the Gravity from the
Sun is pulling on the earth then it
causes the Earth to kind of warp a
little bit and then as the moon is going
around the earth um and as the Earth is
turning then these handles of the Earth
the sort of squished of the earth it's
like a little bit is sort of getting
pulled by the moon and the Moon is
attempting to slow down the rotation of
the earth and as that's happening then
to sort of preserve the total amount of
momentum in the system the the Moon moon
is drifting away from the earth and this
happens because the moon takes about 28
days to go around the Earth Earth takes
24 hours to turn once on its axis the
Earth is turning faster than the moon is
orbiting around it and so what this gets
you is the Earth's rotation slows down
and the moon drifts farther away but
with
Phobos it's the opposite so Phobos takes
just shy of8 hours to orbit around Mars
and Mars takes a little over 24 hours to
turn once on its axis and so you have
the opposite situation where it's much
faster for Phobos to go around Mars than
for Mars to turn once on its axis and so
you get the opposite situation so now
phobos's tiny gravity is trying to pull
on Mars and speed up its rotation and as
it speeds up Mars's rotation that causes
Phobos to drift closer and closer to
Mars and at some point in about know 50
million years from now it will get so
close it'll cross within the RO limit
and it'll be torn apart and Phobos will
collide with Mars and this is just the
situation that you get that if the moon
orbits faster than the planet rotates
then the moon will drift Inward and if
the moon orbits slower than the planet
rotates then the moon will drift outward
and of course like where are all the you
know phobus is the only one and it's
going to be gone within 50 million years
or so you think about all of the other
moons it must be out there or that were
formed since the beginning of the solar
system that had uh orbital speeds that
were faster than the rotation speed of
their planet and they are long gone
because they orbited in and crashed onto
the planet but damos uh takes like 30
hours to orbit around Mars and so it's
going to drift outward or crimes I heard
that in space your body becomes bigger
does this extend to every part of your
body
no this just means that you grow a
little bit when you're in space no this
just means that you become a little
taller in space so it's the same thing
that happens actually while you're going
about your regular day here on Earth
when you lie down in bed your spine is
able to stretch out and then when you
get up over the course of your day then
your spine compresses down a little bit
and so you lose a little bit of height
you know and that's going to happen in
space because there's no gravity that
holding you down and you're going to
sort of freely uncompress to your
largest size but also um you know like
when you're on Earth gravity is pulling
blood down to your lower extremities and
when you are in space you no longer have
that gravity that's pulling the blood
down and so the fluids in your your body
redistribute and so that can make your
face very puffy it can even cause fluid
to collect around your eyeballs and
cause problems with your vision so you
know there's a lot of problems with
space flight that a that scientists have
figured out solutions to you know we
know that your bones weaken that your
muscles weaken when you're in space and
it turns out that if you just do a lot
of exercise hours and hours a day of
exercise then you can overcome most of
those problems but it's this fluid
redistribution problem that people don't
really have a great answer for it one
possible solution is that you
would sleep in a uh sleeping bag with a
negative pressure and so it would be
sort of like a a you'd be sleeping in a
vacuum cleaner and it would be
attempting to bring the fluids from you
know where they've redistributed around
your body down into your lower
extremities and that would help sort of
fight that and this is still an ongoing
test and if that works then we're down
to just a couple of issues you know
downsides of being in in zero gravity
for Astron in Bartles 87 if Venus were
less harsh environmentally would it be a
better candidate for our first planet to
set foot on instead of Mars is it easier
to get to yeah Venus would be an amazing
planet for us to to visit if it didn't
suck and it really sucks you know if
you're down on the surface of Venus you
are experiencing about 90 times the
atmospheric pressure that you experience
on Earth it's the equivalent of you
swimming down 1 kilometer below the
surface of the ocean like imagine right
you're down under a kilometer of ocean
you're experiencing incredible pressure
we've seen Subs fail uh that's what you
know you that's what you would
experience but then not to mention
you've also got the temperature which is
you know more than 400 celsi everywhere
on the planet no matter where you go if
you're at the poles if you're at the
equator it's 4 like 60 Celsius really
hot and so that's hot enough to melt all
kinds of things that you might want to
use um and so there's just no living on
Venus and so the question you're asking
is well like could it be like if it
wasn't so bad then could we go there and
like it just kind of depends on how not
bad you're talking about like if it had
the same atmospheric pressure as Earth
you know like Venus is the same size as
Earth or almost the same size it's
almost the same density as Earth it is
really a twin of the earth if it wasn't
so awful you know it's closer to the sun
hotter has this higher pressure this
carbon dioxide atmosphere rain sulfuric
acid it's not great but if you could go
and just Tinker with various aspects of
Venus change CH its atmosphere so that
it has like an atmospheric density of
Earth has a oxygen nitrogen composition
like we have in our atmosphere that
would be amazing uh imagine if uh you
know you could bring those temperatures
down if you have liquid water on the
surface of Venus then it would be a
really intriguing place for us to try
and go and and visit in fact you know
for the longest time science fiction
authors wrote about Venus as this sort
of hot steamy jungle world that they
assumed you know the thick Cloud Tops on
Venus just meant that we couldn't see
you know it was eternally in these these
clouds but actually it was very much
like a jungle down at the bottom and it
wasn't until the Soviets started trying
to land spacecraft on Venus the vanera
program where the spacecrafts died one
after the other that they finally
realized just how awful it is down there
on the surface of Venus so the second
question then is like would it be easier
to get to than Mars and not
necessarily so the Delta V that's needed
the change in velocity to go from Earth
orbit to Mars and the Delta you required
to get to Venus is roughly the same it's
about 5 1 12 kilometers per second
generally it's pretty tricky to get to
planets that are closer to the Sun in
the solar system but it's also pretty
tricky to get farther away from the Sun
to climb out of the gravity well to get
out into the outer solar system and a
lot of times missions will use the in
planets for doing gravitational assists
so we've seen that issa's juice Mission
did a flyby of Venus is going to do a
flyby of Earth is maybe do you know you
see missions do multiple flybys of inner
planets so if we wanted to send a human
mission to Venus it would be about as
difficult as sending a human Mission to
Mars but if you had this thick
atmosphere you know like the Earth's
atmosphere then it would be much easier
to land because you know this is the big
problem with trying to land heavy
payloads on Mars it has a very thin
atmosphere it's too thin for you to able
to do a really proper atmospheric
breaking in the way that you do on Earth
and so if you sort of come in and try to
use the atmosphere to slow you down
you'll crash onto the surface of Mars
but it's too thick to do this propulsive
Landing in the way you might land on say
the moon where there's no atmosphere you
sort of really nicely easily put
yourself into propulsive landing and you
land uh it's sort of like right in
between and so it's actually been pretty
tricky to land heavy payloads on the
surface of Mars but if you had a you
know a thick atmosphere to do an
atmospheric entry into uh like Venus
then that would be a lot easier it's
funny so with with
Venus the atmosphere is so thick that
when the veneer spacecraft sort of come
in they don't really have to think about
Landing they are sort of you know it's
more like you're dropping a rock in
water you know they just sort of slow
slowly sink down to reach the surface of
Venus so it's a totally different
situation they had to deploy a parachute
at the end I think but but it's very
easy to land on Venus just you don't
want to land on Venus if you want to
support the work we do at Universe today
consider joining our patreon club your
support lets us have a minimum of ads
and no sponsorship messages patrons get
no ads on univers today.com for Life
want the extra parts of the live stream
that aren't in this edited version you
can sign up for a special Patron only
podcast feed and get the over time
segments as well as other special behind
the-scenes episodes including our
monthly Patron only question show thanks
to everyone who has already subscribed
and Welcome to our recent newcomers frog
boy Russell Brier technomatic bear
Lemley n Tha flick shoot Zed 234 join
the club at patreon.com universetoday
for NAA do you have a favorite Moon I
don't have favorites for almost anything
um but I do have a bunch of moons that I
really like for different reasons so uh
I think my favorite right now is Titan
uh and that's just because it's such a
cool Moon of of Saturn right it's one of
the largest moons in the solar system
it's like the second largest after gamed
it has an atmosphere that's one and a
half times as thick as Earth's
atmosphere and so um you could walk
around on the surface of Titan without
having to wear a space suit now you
would still have to wear a breathing
mask because the atmosphere is you know
you know not breathable for us um and
it's incredibly cold so you would need
to have like like a you know an
Antarctica coat on that would keep you
warm in that kind of a temperature but
uh but then you would be able to walk
around on Titan it would be kind of
amazing but you know we know that there
are seas of liquid methane on the
surface of Titan it rains methane and
it's believe that you know on the
surface of Titan you've got this
atmosphere you've got this surface where
it's like the ice has become the
mountains the ice is the rock on Titan
but then it probably also has a liquid
water ocean that is underneath the ice
and so it's sort of got everything it's
got hydrocarbons on the surface it's got
water underneath it's thought that the
kinds of chemicals that they're going to
find on Titan are very similar to the
kinds of chemicals that we might have
had on an early Earth so it's just a
really exciting Place Enceladus is
probably another one of the candidates
that I'm really excited about of course
we know that it's got these tiger
stripes at the bottom of this Moon that
are blasting water ice out into space
and that based on Cassini observations
of this water ice that's going out into
space we know that it has dissolved
hydrogen gas in this water we know that
it has various kinds of other chem
chemicals kinds of things that life
might need and because it's being thrown
out into space It should be relatively
easy to be able to sample the stuff it's
probably the best place for us to search
for life in the entire solar system
better than Mars better than Europa
Enceladus should be our number one
priority and then just for like crazy
weird moons I really like iapetus which
is another Moon of Saturn so I guess
I've just picked moons of Saturn now
Saturn is my favorite planet so I think
it makes sense but iapetus is is really
strange uh yingyang Moon where one half
of this moon is bright white and then
the other half of the moon is is very
dark and believe it's believed that it
ate a ring which made it white on on one
side so uh it's a pretty cool Moon so
I'd say those are my sort of three
current favorites right now but then I
really like Triton orbiting around
Neptune yeah don't make me choose
Francis Tony when did it become okay to
look for aliens as a scientist are there
currently any taboo subjects for an
astronomer so this is a question that
I'm actually really fascinated with and
so there was a conversation that I had
with an astronomer a couple of years ago
and this exact question came up where I
was saying why astronomers not able to
get funding for projects like seti and
things like that and fairly recently
this has sort of turned around and now
in fact NASA is funding techn signature
searches there's actually some funding
for for people to be able to go out and
look for aliens and you know he was
saying uh it was it was Jason Wright and
he was saying you know it's kind of
funny you know for the longest time
you're like it's okay to look for dumb
aliens but why isn't it okay to look for
smart aliens and I'm like I'm
researching this right now this is my
current Obsession what was the chain of
events so if you go all the way back to
like the 1950s the
1960s you had Frank drank with project
osmo where
he started to propose that we listen to
various stars with giant radio
telescopes to detect the signals and
then you got this kind of giggle factor
for a while there where people said well
that's ridiculous we're not going to
look for aliens and so there was no
funding for seti and so there was a sort
of dark period in the 70s and the 80s
and the '90s where anyone who wanted to
do research and especially the people at
the city Institute they had to find
their own sources of funding that didn't
come from the government you couldn't
get National Science Foundation funding
or NASA funding or things like that and
then in the
1990s scientists started to find
extremophiles here on Earth so they
found bacteria in Hot Springs they found
bacteria in nuclear reactors they found
bacteria high up in the atmosphere 10
kilometers below the Earth's surface and
people started to realize that life was
everywhere and when you think about the
fact that you know like where wherever
we find liquid water on Earth we find
life and they realize that well there's
lots of places that there could be
liquid water around the solar system so
it makes sense for us to start looking
for life on other worlds and this
created the field of
astrobiology and so now you've got
astrobiology and so people are saying
like what are the different ways that we
could search for evidence of of
biological signatures well Along Comes
exoplanetary astronomy and astronomers
say well the next generation of telescop
like James Webb are going to allow us to
look at these other planets detect the
atmospheres of these planets and maybe
measure the presence of the kinds of
gases that some sort of life is going to
be producing into this atmosphere and
then some astronomers said well couldn't
we also look for things that advanced
civilizations would be producing like
chlorofluorocarbons or if they're having
nuclear Wars or if they're in the middle
of the Industrial Age and the answer is
yes that James Webb is capable of
protecting chlorofluorocarbons around
planets orbiting around various stars
like if there was a an advanced
civilization on the trapis one worlds
and they were producing
chlorofluorocarbons James Webb could
detect it and now you kind of can't deny
that that you know searching for aliens
searching for technos signatures is a
legitimate way to search for bios
signatures to find out if we're alone in
the universe and so it sort of had this
really long and really fascin ating
Journey so uh that's a story that I want
to tell and I'm sort of thinking about
how I'm going to actually tell that
story so thank you for for bringing that
up cbia why do most science
communicators talk about an
interplanetary future when it's becoming
ever clear that we will never achieve
that what makes you think that we will
never achieve an interplanetary future
you know a lot of people think that I am
you know unnecessarily skeptical about
Humanity's future in space that I poooo
the idea of of us building a city on
mars or us building a city on the moon
or us doing asteroid Mining and all that
kind of stuff and I like I really want
to set the record straight for me it's
just about time frame so uh you know do
I think that we're going to have a city
on Mars the way Elon Musk and other like
big fans of of Mars space exploration no
I don't think we will have that Within
by the end of the you know you know by
2100
but Humanity's ability to go out into
space is on an exponential curve we are
developing better and better technology
and that you know eventually it's
inevitable that we will become an
interplanetary species or we'll be dead
and like maybe that's what you're saying
like maybe you know you're cynical about
the future of humanity and so you don't
think we stand a chance of doing
anything that we're just going to wipe
ourselves out and it doesn't matter and
like obviously that's a possibility you
know that Humanity's uh story will come
to an end at some point but I am a lot
more hopeful and optimistic about our
future and so and so for me it's it's
not that I think we won't have that kind
of a future I think it's inevitable that
we will as long as we survive that our
technology will increase that we will
eventually trivialize the kinds of
things that it takes to travel to and
live in space and that more and more of
humanity will be living very various
places around the solar system I just
have a longer time Horizon like I just
think that's the kind of thing that
we'll be doing 200 years into the future
not 30 um but yeah I think you know like
fundamentally if you go back and look at
the rise of our uh just total energy use
gross domestic product the uh the amount
of resources that every human being has
you know available to them uh these are
on exponential growth curves that are
going up by a couple of percent per year
and if you just chart that forward uh
within a couple of hundred years the
only way is if we are spanning across
the solar system using a lot of the
resources across the solar system you
keep running that forward the only way
is that we've created a Dyson Sphere so
uh you know I Humanity has had this
growing use of energy and capability for
its million years that it's been around
um so I wouldn't bet against us
continuing this growth all right those
were all the questions that we had this
week thank you everyone who put your
questions into the comments on YouTube
and especially everybody who joined for
the live stream which we do every Monday
uh the time changes depending on uh on
which part of the planet we are
targeting but uh so definitely check the
upcoming schedule to find the show
that's going to be right for you now I'm
going to give a big thanks and let you
know a little bit about what our plans
are for 2025 but first I'd like to thank
our patrons thanks to Abe Kingston Adam
Schaefer andram gross SP Lake Roofing
David Gilton and David matz Dennis
alberie Dustin cable James Clark Jeremy
M Jim Burke Jordan young Josh Schultz
Paul robach Sean Sergeant spiders swap.
Steven fer Munley and Vlad chiplin who
support us at the master of the universe
level and all our patrons all your
support means the universe to us well we
are nearing the end of 2024 and that
means that we are now going to go into
2025 and you know we've got some big
plans ideas for content for new streams
we're going to be doing a lot more of
the telescope streams a lot more really
interesting interviews a lot more
special projects that we're working on
and the thing that makes me so excited
the thing that I am looking forward to
is shutting off advertisements on the
universe today website and you know we
can't do it today but I feel like we are
four to six months away as long as more
people still come on as patrons to get
to this point where we can actually shut
off Those ads and when that happens then
we are
95% covered financially by Patron and
that's it just thousands of individual
space enthusiasts who have decided to
support the work that we do to support
the salaries of all of the journalists
that we have on Universe today to
support Anton Chad our video editors
producers and of course me and when that
happens then then we will be kind of
bulletproof we're we're no longer going
to have to wait and see what kind of
strange things Google does with
artificial intelligence and how they try
and take away search engine traffic
because they're just scraping content
and replacing it with their own on
Google itself you don't have to worry
about Facebook algorithms changing the
way they plan to do things it's just
going to be me trying to create the best
possible space journalism and reporting
for you the fans of space journalism and
Reporting it seems surreal and yet I
feel like we're very very close to doing
this and I think in when I do it it's
going to probably be a little early
we'll be able to lean we'll have to uh
be very careful about how we handle our
spending and at the same time the
freedom and sort of lack of fear
of us running a foul of an algorithm or
whatever is feels really liberating and
in a time when journalism is under
attack from every direction this seems
really exciting and so if you want to be
part of helping us get there you know
shorten the number of months it'll take
uh please join our patreon uh but even
if you don't I hope you get as much
value out of this content it helps you
know increase and uh improve your
awareness and excitement for space and
astronomy and space exploration and I
will see you in 2025
