What's the best way to do science communication? Will Jupiter expand when the Sun dies? How would aliens experience their environment? Can New Horizons get new targets in future? Answering all these questions and more in this week's Overtime Q&A.
00:00 Start 00:59 How can Hawking radiation escape a black hole? 03:47 Will Jupiter also expand when the Sun expands? 05:08 Why don't astronomers use the exoplanet names? 07:05 Will the Indians beat everyone to the Moon? 08:11 Do I feel threatened by ChatGPT? 10:28 What's the best way to do science communication? 11:48 How would aliens experience their environment? 14:19 Is the surface of the Moon littered with minerals? 15:43 What is the Universe orbiting? 16:03 Will New Horizons find new targets? 16:44 Would I go back to school to become an astronomer? 17:31 What are China's plans for the Moon? 20:07 Thoughts on the newer aerospike engines? 21:53 Should we spread life in the Solar System? 23:16 What are my favorite moons?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
how can Hawking radiation escape a black
hole is it ethical to spread life in the
solar system and why don't we use the
official exoplanet names all this and
more in this week's overtime question
show well if you're seeing me outside
then you know that this is not this
week's Live question show this is
another episode of overtime questions
these are the extra content that we do
every week when we do the question show
and that's because I was off last week
in Europe chasing auroras so my kid and
I went to Iceland and Amsterdam and we
tried to see auroras did we see auroras
oh yes we did in fact there was like one
of the biggest solar flares in the last
10 years happened while we were in
Iceland and we got a chance to see the
auroras and it was epic anyway uh so I'm
going to talk a bit about how to see
auroras at the end of this episode so
stick around for that otherwise let's
get into the overtime questions RTX
agent how does Hawking radiation work
when nothing can escape a black hole's
Event Horizon the Hawking radiation is
isn't coming from the black hole it's
coming from the area around the black
hole and then the black hole is donating
the material so Stephen Hawking figured
out this idea of of Hawking radiation he
realized that black holes should
evaporate over vast periods of time and
the way to understand this is imagine
that if you just work in empty
space there was nothing like no no stars
no planets no energy nothing just the
vacuum of space with nothing in it no
Fields nothing and if you were
stationary you wouldn't experience
anything right there just be nothing you
had detectors on your spaceship you
wouldn't experience anything but if we
accelerate and this has sort of been
demonstrated been been proven in the lab
that if you accelerate then you start to
experience radiation and the radiation
is coming from just SpaceTime itself
there are just the fields that permeate
the entire universe and so when you're
just stable you're not interacting with
any of these fields but once you
accelerate then you start to experience
these fields and they appear as
particles that are kind of you
experience this radiation that's coming
at you only when you're accelerating so
not when you're just coing but when
you're accelerating and we know through
the equivalence principle that you know
Einstein figure this out that
accelerating is the same as being in a
gravitational well that they are
interchangeable and so if you're
experiencing a constant gravitational
well it should feel exactly the same as
if you are accelerating through the
universe and so when you have an object
that is close to a black hole if you
were sitting next to the black hole and
you were no longer accelerating through
the cosmos but you're instead in the
presence of this gravitational field
it's the equivalent of you acceler ating
you're going to be experiencing
radiation now radiation can't come from
nowhere it has to come from somewhere
and the somewhere that it comes from is
the black hole and so from an outside
Observer they're watching radiation
slowly come from the black hole which is
just the the consequence of this
equivalence between acceleration through
just space itself interacting with the
fields that permeate the cosmos and the
black hole's gravitational existence in
those field fi that permeate the cosmos
the two have to be identical and so
energy is released so does does that
explain the question um of why in theory
radiation should be escaping and the the
term for that is like unre radiation TS
Vlogs we talk about the sun will be
almost engulfing Earth the next 5
billion years we don't talk about the
neighboring mass of Jupiter will Jupiter
also expand similar to the sun since
it's also a gas planet no no Jupiter
will not expand if anything Jupiter is
Contracting so as it uh cools down in
the center it is Contracting slightly as
it goes and the sun isn't necessarily
growing I mean it will engulf the uh the
Earth in about 7 billion years when it
uses up all of the fuel in its core but
it's putting out more and more heat
increasing its Luminosity so like what's
happening is it's converting hydrogen
into helium in the core the helium is
forming this shell that is around the
outside of the core and it is sort of
causing the sun to put out more heat and
in the next billion years or so the heat
will become so intense that it will
actually wipe out life on the surface of
the Earth it'll boil the oceans and uh
end life on
Earth half a billion to a billion years
maybe 1.5 billion years but Jupiter
doesn't have the same process Jupiter
doesn't have Fusion in its core it's not
running out of fuel in its core so uh
Jupiter is just cooling down eventually
Jupiter will cool down to the background
temperature of the universe just take a
long time hon said why don't astronomers
use the official names of exoplanets is
it because they're terrible at naming
things and don't want to ruin a bad
thing so like I don't know the official
names of exoplanets and I'm the kind of
person who thinks that things should
have really cool names and yeah the
international astronomical Union has
bent to pressure and given exoplanets
proper names they voted they've made
them official and the names are cool
they come from mythology and they come
from from history and they come from
science fiction and they're very cool
and yet they're just not easy to get the
list of names and so I just never think
to get the names into my brain but
exoplanet names I
auu so formal how B is called
Dagon Arion
orbitar dimidium Galileo so the Planet
55 kry B is called Galileo
brah uh Hala finle hpaa Ager pully
yeah this like C there's and there's
like mythology for each one of the names
this is great and yet we just don't use
them and and now that you've reminded me
I think I'm going to I'm going to follow
up I'm going to try to get that list of
names more readily available I mean the
problem is there's like 5,000 exoplanets
right and yet I don't know 150 have been
given names this is what we've been
asking for they've done it they've
delivered the names now it's our job to
use the names like wasp 79b is polara
there you go right we always talk about
wasp 79b
and it has a
name so yes there you go Church
discography could India beat everyone
else to a human landing on the moon I
mean if
everybody doesn't land on the moon very
quickly then India could be the one to
land on the moon they are planning human
missions to the moon or at least they're
planning an astronaut program so they're
building a human rated rocket that can
carry humans to space they're planning
on building a space station and then
this is the tech stack this is the way
you move forward you build a space
station you send your astronauts into
space then you send missions farther
away and eventually you try to set foot
on the moon and of course there's very
well understood technology it was
developed by NASA and now the Chinese
and so the Indians should be able to
license technology and just follow in
their literal footsteps but it would
mean that the Chinese are not able to do
their missions to land on the Moon it
would mean that the emis missions are
canceled it would mean that SpaceX is
isn't able to get their act together and
and land humans on the moon then the
Indians have a have a crack at it but I
think like right now there's just
there's too much momentum by other
parties they're going to get to the moon
first Michael Ranger I realized that
mistakes aside chat is a personal
science Communicator how does it hit you
as a science Communicator it's crappy
it's it's not very good um at doing its
job yet it hallucinates it can't be
trusted uh if you're going to use chat
gbt as a science Communicator you are
making a mistake you need to uh trust
and verify the things that it says with
other sources to triangulate now as a
way to help you understand a complicated
topic it's terrific and I highly
recommend it but you use it in the way
that you would use a enthusiastic
assistant right someone who's like
really wants to help but you're not
entirely sure you can trust the research
that they do you need to double check
and and sort of build up a certain
understanding of the of of what they're
capable of and and so that's where chat
GPT is at now it's getting better um but
like am I worried about chat GPT taking
my job it's kind of like saying that you
are a
chef and are you worried about a
replicator taking your
job right so it's like if a replicator
shows up and it makes in it's a $100 box
like a microwave and anyone can put it
in their house and it makes an infinite
variety of food at low cost and the food
is as good or better than the greatest
chefs in the world could
produce then you just got out technology
you just got replaced and yet the
benefit is that human beings are being
fed right for inexpensive cost like how
can you be against that and so if or
when the large language models come
along and they are better than me like
they are just objectively better science
communicators than human beings and can
provide at an incredibly low cost if
very personalized uh education to
anybody who needs it um I will
gracefully seed the field I will step
away step aside but as long as people
want to continue the human touch I guess
uh then I'll have a job and whenever we
clearly see that nobody wants to be our
Patron anymore everybody who's moved on
um then I will retire and just switch to
The Lumberjack portion of my career
Chris eement uh from a science
communication standpoint what is the
best way to bring science communication
to the lay or ground level folks I mean
I think it's just you you do it what you
use whatever tools you have at your
disposal whatever skills you have to
communicate science to whoever is
willing to listen um I think there's
nothing more or less than that and so
you know you can set up a telescope
outside of a concert and do sidewalk
astronomy and we come and ask you what
they're looking at you can explain they
get excited they want to know how to get
a telescope boom you just did some
science communication um you can
organize science in the pub in your
local town where you bring in guest
speakers maybe at the local University
to talk about the projects they're
working on in a casual setting those are
really fun and you know regular people
love science they really do um and it's
just that people don't get organized
about making these things available I
mean you have scientists selling out
theaters to give talks about science
like it's it definitely works and
there's definitely an interest there
it's just that people need to be
organized and coordinate things so so
think about how you can coordinate if
you have a podcast if you want to create
videos if you want to write there's lots
of ways that you can reach an audience
in the public normal wolf I love the
thought experiment of an intelligent
alien species with different senses what
would be the minimum for them to know
outside their world that's really
interesting I mean I think about these
potential alien species that are trapped
underneath ice on a on a water world and
it's like what do they know there's no
illumination you know maybe there's some
kind of chemical illumination and yet
for whatever reason they've evolved an
incredible amount of intelligence and so
like what can they perceive they're
probably very good at perceiving in the
darkness they can maybe use so andr to
be able to to
understand their environment and detect
prey and detect predators and threats
and maybe over time you know because it
was a complicated environment they had
to build up a large amount of
intelligence they built society and
knowledge um problem solving I mean the
kinds of things that human beings did
and you can imagine they would know that
you could chip away at the uh at the ice
that was above your head and then maybe
you could grab hot rocks that were down
at the bottom of the ocean and carry
them up and use them to melt your way up
through the ice and and you can imagine
this sort of incredible multigeneration
project as they were trying to figure
out what was at the top of the ice and
they would have a horrible Discovery
when they actually got up there to the
top and then they would figure that out
and they would problem solve and
eventually they would understand their
true place in the cosmos so so I think
there's like a lot of Worlds you know we
sort of Envision life forming on planets
like the Earth where you've got a
terrestrial planet in the habitable zone
of a of a sunlike star with trees and
stuff but but we don't know what various
flavors and forms that life can take
but we know that that here on Earth like
life has developed the senses to adapt
to the environment that they find
themselves in you know we see in the
colors that are most useful for the kind
of Illumination that the sun gives off
we hear based on the on the way sound
moves through our atmosphere um we feel
based on the kinds of substances that
we're going to be coming across we taste
based on the kinds of chemical
that go into our mouths and so alien
species would be adapted to whatever
environment they find themselves in but
but many of them are going to be like us
and so you would expect them to have
evolved the same kinds of Senses they
would probably have some kind of vision
they' probably have some kind of hearing
they probably have the ability to feel
in their surroundings busy Billy B
through3 is the moon surface littered
with precious rare Metals delivered by
meteorites yeah yeah I mean like when
you think about some of the most produc
Ive Minds on Earth things like um nickel
right there's a in Sudbury here in
Canada there's a nickel mine and it's an
old asteroid impact that people are
mining the asteroid impact and so there
are going to be concentrations of metal
on the surface of the Moon where
asteroids metal asteroids have slammed
in the surface of the Moon and
theoretically the metal is still
available so the problem is that on
Earth we have the atmosphere and so if
you have a meteor right hit the
atmosphere it slows down and you get the
shrapnel raining down and landing on the
surface of the Earth and that's why you
can walk around and you can pick up a
meteorite just picking up off the
surface of the Earth you can pick up a
an iron meteorite and they're very cool
but on the moon there's no atmosphere
and so all of the objects are hitting
the moon at the full speed they're all
going 10 km/s and so they vaporize so
you don't get you probably won't get the
little meteorite in the way that we have
them on the surface of the Earth like if
there was a thick atmosphere even like
what you have on Mars like Mars has
enough atmosphere to slow down
meteorites so they can hit terminal
velocity and land gently on the surface
of of Mars but you don't get that on the
moon because there's no atmosphere pjan
if everything seems to be orbiting
something what is the universe orbiting
the universe isn't orbiting anything
because the universe is everything that
is if everything was orbiting something
else then now you would have to include
that something else in the everything
and so you can never uh end that sort of
thought experiment Jack wesy do you
think that New Horizons will find
another Target flyby I hope so uh you
know the machine that's going to be able
to do this will be the ver Rubin
Observatory it's going to come online in
2025 like we're just six months away
from first light for ver Rubin and then
once ver Rubin comes online within a
couple of months it should find a whole
bunch of new hyperbuilt objects that are
in the area where New Horizons is it
should find planet nine um so hopefully
it should find new targets and New
Horizon still has fuel in the tank it
still has uh destinations it could reach
within its sort of flight cone as it's
moving forward and I know that all Stern
and the rest of the people on the
horizons are really hoping they can do
more science with this Robert Allen
would you consider going back to school
to become an astronomer no I don't want
to be an astronomer I'm happy being a
science journalist like I think there's
a need for people like me to explain the
things that are happening to focus on
the educating the public about what's
going on with space and astronomy and
there's a place for the people who are
actually doing the research and you know
it is a symbiotic relationship maybe a
parasitic relationship I don't know if
I'd enjoy being a scientist I kind of
really like being able to flit around
and look into the kinds of things that
I'm curious about and I think I would
have a hard time just sticking my head
down and focusing on one very specific
kind of research for a long time I just
I don't have the the attention span for
that I think Giovanni falo are the
Chinese trying to send people to the
Moon yes the Chinese space agency has
laid out in Fairly concrete detail their
exact plans for sending humans to the
Moon So currently they've done five
missions to the moon the chonga series
chongas 1 through five um chonga 6 is
coming soon it's probably going to be
it's going to be another sample return
Mission ch
7 is going to be an insitu resource
utilization Mission and then come 2030
they're going to have their mission
their human mission to the moon and
their plan is going to be very similar
to what they did with the Apollo era but
but I think it's sort of a bit of an
improvement so they're going to send two
identical heavy lift Rockets so imagine
like two Saturn fives one is going to
have the capsule and the the service
module and then the other is going to
have the lunar lander and the Ascender
on board so the people on One rocket and
the lunar Hardware on the other rocket
and then the two rockets are going to go
to the moon and then once it's all in
orbit the astronaut's are going to get
into the lunar lander they're going to
go down to the surface of the Moon
they're going to do their moonwalk um
and then they're going to get back in
their Ascent module and they're going to
come back up to orbit they're going to
meet with the capsule they're going to
fly back to Earth they're going to ditch
the lunar lander and the uh the surface
module and return Earth through the
capsule and you know they've tested out
most of the parts of this Mission I mean
they're building the big rocket but it's
going to be an evolution of their
existing heavy lift rocket they've gone
through this process of developing a
mission to the moon landing on the moon
taking off from the surface of the Moon
with their sample return Mission and
also they've tested out keeping humans
alive in Orbit on on board the Chinese
space station so they have tested out
all the different bits and pieces of
this plan to send humans to the moon
it's now just about putting all of the
hardware in place putting you know
building the heavy lift rocket building
the the final version of the capsule
service module the lunar lander and then
sending that all to the moon and I think
you know so far they have been following
their plan I mean their plan is like 20
years long right and they've got it in
excruciating detail what comes after the
first mission the second mission like we
know what their long-term plans are and
um they're hitting Milestones they're
following it step by step by step and so
you know if if NASA doesn't get to the
Moon by 2026 the chines will get there
by 2030 lost in space what are your
thoughts on the newer aerospike Rockets
So aerospike engines are a great idea so
the the way they work is that the kind
of engine that you need to get out of
the atmosphere of the earth is different
a different shape than the kind of shape
of the the rocket Bell that you use in
vac and you can look at this example
when you look at the rocket engines in
the bottom of super heavy they're very
small very compact when you look at the
ones that are the bottom of Starship
they have the three uh surface rockets
and then they have the three vacuum
Rockets they're much bigger and so it's
just that you know when you've got the
pressure of the atmosphere pushing
against the exhaust plume coming out of
the rocket a different shape makes more
sense and so the idea with an Aeros
spike is that you can change the shape
of the rocket plume depending on the
density of the atmosphere that's around
the Rockets you start out you're at
surface level you have one shape and
then as you pass through the atmosphere
you can change the shape and sort of try
to optimize your flight the entire way
as opposed to what SpaceX does with just
they have the surface level and they
have the or the
air version and then they have the
vacuum version of their of their engines
um so like is it a good is it a good I
mean they're they're potentially very
exciting and NASA was working on Aeros
Spike engines and there was you know
they're planning to have one on their
x33 The Venture star and for various
reasons the x33 was cancelled and with
it went their work on the Aeros Spike
engine but there are other companies
that are working on Aeros spikes and I
know uh Tim DOD everyday astronaut he
did a whole Deep dive into aerospikes so
he can answer that question better than
I can William R would you be in favor of
seating life elsewhere in the solar
system it just depends on whether
there's any native life elsewhere in the
solar system so if we explore other
planets in the solar system like Mars
like Europa like Enceladus and we are
certain that there's no life there and
that's a really tall order like you know
to be it's hard to confirm an a negative
right you keep looking and maybe there
could have been life there but you just
didn't look comprehensively enough but
if we are sure that there is no life
then yeah absolutely I think life is
better than non-life trees are better
than rocks so I think it would be uh
interesting interesting and useful and
good for the universe if we spread life
beyond Earth because life on Earth has a
limited time frame it's a matter of time
before the sun boils the oceans and
Cooks all life on Earth and destroys the
planet we are on a timeline here people
and so uh we are an actual being that
has appeared on this planet and we have
within our power the ability to spread
life out there into the universe and I
think it's our responsibility to do so
but that assumes that we're not going to
destroy any indigenous life that's
already there so Step One is absolutely
make sure that there is no indigenous
life on any of the of the planets or
moons in the solar system and then step
two is see if we can grow stuff there
let's let's spread life to those places
Jack jenin what are your top three moons
in the solar system
Titan Triton and iopus so like Titan
obviously ganam
Okay g I'm going to go for four so Titan
obviously like no explanation needed
Triton this is the large Moon of Neptune
it orbits backwards from the rest of the
solar system probably a captured
hyperbuilt object it probably has
geysers like Enceladus does that's cool
place I apodus just looks bizarre it's
this weird yin-yang Moon half of it is
is bright white the other half is dark
how cool is that I would love to see and
it's got this weird Ridge that is like
10 km high that goes around the whole
Moon I would love to have this place
explored and then ganim and ganim is a
moon of Jupiter that's larg enough that
has its own intrinsic magnetic field
it's probably got a thick sheet of ice
around a liquid ocean in its interior as
well it's just as interesting as Europa
maybe more so because of that magnetic
field so so those are my four moons out
of your three which ones are important
to explore scientifically all of them as
promised I'm going to talk about how to
see auroras but first I'd like to thank
our patrons thanks to Abe Kingston Adam
Schaefer Barry Lake Roofing David Gilton
and David matz Dennis alberty Dustin
cable Jeremy murn Jim Burke Jordan young
Jos Schultz Paul roorbach scienceworld
rec.org spiders swap. Steven Kaki step
flyy and Vlad chiplin who support us at
the master of the universe level and all
of other supporters on
patreon so I'm sure at this point as we
approach solar maximum you're seeing
more and more information about people
seeing auroras in the sky and you're
wondering how do I get in on that action
and so as we're approaching solar
maximum we're seeing more and more
activity coming from the Sun more
powerful flares Corona Mass injections
that means that the auroras are visible
farther away from the poles than they
normally are and so for example in North
America if you normally can only see the
auroras in Iceland or Northern Canada or
Alaska during really powerful solar
storms we can see them down where I live
on Vancouver Island but even into
Northern California you can see them
into the middle of Europe Europe and
then for the people in the southern
hemisphere people can see them in
Tasmania or in New Zealand or even sort
of around the Sydney area so there's a
lot of options if there's a powerful
solar storm so you have to do a couple
of things first you have to find out how
to track the current strength of solar
activity and Noah has a website where
they'll give you forecasts on what the
various space weather conditions are and
give you predictions for how much space
weather you're going to have in your
location you can also download apps and
I I'm sorry I don't have any
recommendations but you can download
apps it will send you a notification
when there's going to be an aurora in
your area and then you can sort of use
that to judge but generally you just
want to you just want to stay on top of
what is the space weather there's lots
of websites out there that'll tell you
that and then the second thing is that
you've got to find your spot and so you
got to find a place that gives you a
clear view towards your closest poll so
for me I want to look to the north
people in the southern hemisphere you
want to look to the South and if you are
sort of at around the 45th latitude or
above closer to the pole then you stand
a reasonable chance during a powerful
solar storm of being able to see it in
the sky but you actually have to go out
and do it and so you have to commit you
have to go to your place we'll give you
Dark Skies view to the pole and when you
get strong Aurora activity alert then
you have to go spend a couple of hours
in in the cold maybe watching and
waiting and we're going to see increased
auroral activity into 2025 so you're
going to get a lot of chances at this
most of the time you're not going to see
anything but every now and then it's
going to blow your mind and it's totally
worth it all right good luck and we'll
see you next week