The American Renaissance was not only shaped by great writers — it was also shaped by those who brought ideas, people, and works together.
In this episode of American Legends, Tiffany Brannan explores the life of Elizabeth Peabody, an educator, publisher, and one of the central figures of the Transcendentalist movement in 19th-century America.
Born in 1804 in Massachusetts, Elizabeth grew up in the remarkable Peabody family, where education, literature, and independent thought were part of daily life.
She became:
• a teacher and founder of schools • one of the first female publishers in America • a supporter of early American writers and thinkers • a key figure in the spread of Transcendentalist ideas
Her bookstore on West Street in Boston became a gathering place for leading intellectuals, including Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, and Nathaniel Hawthorne — a place where ideas were exchanged, writings were published, and new voices were introduced.
Elizabeth recognized talent early and helped bring many important writers to public attention, often before they were widely known.
She also played an important role in education reform, later working with her sister Mary Peabody to promote the kindergarten movement in the United States.
This episode explores:
• the life of Elizabeth Peabody • the American Renaissance and Transcendentalism • her work as a publisher and educator • her bookstore and literary circle • her influence on major American writers
Discover the story of Elizabeth Peabody, whose work helped shape the intellectual life of 19th-century America.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
There's an old saying that runs,
always a bridesmaid, never a bride. Yet for the first lady of the American renaissance,
the saying could have been changed to, always a sister-in-law, never a bride. While she befriended,
supported, and inspired some of the leading men of letters and literature and education in her day,
this particular educator, publisher, and muse never found a husband for herself.
The oldest of three daughters in a family of six, Elizabeth Peabody was one of the defining
characters in the transcendentalist movement of New England in the mid-19th century. As a very
intelligent, creative, and visionary woman, she was a great example of one of the more
independent facets of American womanhood in the mid-19th century. Early in life,
Elizabeth Peabody realized she would not be the beauty of the family. That privilege belonged to
second daughter, Mary. She realized she was not her mother's favorite. That was the third daughter,
Sophia, a sickly girl who was often restricted to her bed by her invalid attacks and thus who
required her mother's constant attention. She also realized she wasn't the most intelligent girl
who was studying at her mother's school, as she quickly learned that a neighbor child,
E.B. Hawthorne, who would ironically become her future sister-in-law, was a much quicker study,
a more bookish young lady. Of course, when her mother brought her over as inspiration to young
Elizabeth, who was certain her mother thought she was a dull little girl, E.B. was a few years older,
so it really wasn't fair. But Elizabeth realized early on that she had to make something of
herself. She may not have had the greatest natural endowment of talents or gifts,
but what she did have was fierce determination. She would grow to be a driving, guiding force
in the life of all her family members and her friends and business associates, as well as anyone
who would come in contact with her. Elizabeth Palmer Peabody was born in Billerica, Massachusetts
on May 14, 1804. She was the oldest daughter of Eliza Palmer, who eventually married Dr. Nathaniel
Peabody. Eliza was a very intelligent young woman who married young, partly for security,
and her husband was a rather ineffectual doctor and eventually dentist who dabbled in
experimental homeopathic remedies and often relied on his female relatives,
including first his wife and later his daughters, to help support the large family. The Peabodies
would first have three daughters and then three sons. The three sons proved to follow in their
father's footsteps of being rather sickly and weak, whereas the three daughters were very
intelligent and strong-minded like their mother. Mrs. Peabody supplemented the family income by
teaching out of their home while they moved around Massachusetts, oftentimes in Salem
and occasionally in Boston. As a result, the three Peabody daughters were part of this very
intellectual environment. They all studied from home, learning from both their mother and their
father, and as a young girl, Elizabeth studied history, theology, literature, and languages.
They didn't have the money to send their daughters to the expensive schools which were available for
girls of the time, but instead the Peabody sisters learned something much more valuable,
how to educate themselves. Elizabeth particularly was a great example of this. At the age of 12,
she taught herself to read Hebrew so that she could read the Old Testament, and as a teenager,
she studied Greek from Ralph Waldo Emerson, one of the leading writers in the Transcendentalist
movement. Now, it's interesting to see the religious and philosophical background of Elizabeth
because she would become a shaping and guiding figure in both her sisters' lives. Their mother
was raised as a Congregationalist Christian, which was a form of Calvinism which was popular
in the New England area, but as she grew into being a young woman, Elizabeth became familiar
with the sermons of William Emery Channing. Channing was one of the foremost Unitarian
ministers, and his sermons and speeches inspired a lot of people in the area, particularly
Massachusetts as well as New England at large, to turn from the stricter Puritan background
of the area to, shall we say, the more liberal ideology of Unitarianism, which replaced the
doctrine of the Trinity with believing in the separate natures of God and Jesus,
and which placed a high emphasis on individual responsibility while maintaining the inherent
goodness of mankind as opposed to the idea of original sin. Because of its separation from
some of the stricter, more traditional aspects of Protestantism, Unitarianism went hand-in-hand
with the Transcendental movement. Although you could say that Transcendentalism was a little
more humanistic and based in philosophy and literature rather than religion, they embraced
a similar form of spirituality, and as a result, Elizabeth, who was a very moral-minded woman,
embraced both, and as a result, had a strong sense of social duty and the importance of advocating
for those who were less fortunate. She was a passionate abolitionist, a gentle advocate for
women's rights. I wouldn't really call her a feminist in the modern sense of the word because
she was very feminine and very romantic, but she believed in feminism to the extent that
women should have the right to express their opinions intelligently and be part of discussions.
She also was a champion for Native Americans, dedicating a lot of money and time to supporting
the opening of schools for different Indian tribes throughout the nation. Although she gave
little care to her appearance, Elizabeth was always a bit distressed by her curly, frizzy hair,
which she never could make look presentable. As a result, she didn't really care if her hair looked
good and she tended to let it be frizzy, which was to the distress of people like Ralph Waldo Emerson,
who felt that she should at least try to make an effort with her appearance. Nevertheless, he
acknowledged that she was a very young woman, that she had an amazing mind, which was far more
impressive than any kind of outward beauty. When she was 18, she began teaching, first at her
mother's school, and then she started her own school, which was short-lived. It only lasted
about a year. And then she began acting as a governess for several well-to-do families in Maine.
After a few years of doing this and getting her sister, Mary, some jobs as a governess,
the two of them started a school in Brookline, Massachusetts in 1825. This school proved quite
successful and they were able to manage it until 1832, at which point they lost the school due to
a bit of a financial scandal that involved some other board members. Thus, they returned
eventually to Boston. And in the late 1830s, a few decades later, after Mary had been married
and widowed, she returned to working with her sister on the cause of education. In 1860, the two
sisters founded the first kindergarten in the United States, building on the path and principles
of German educator Friedrich Froebel. They wrote on his teachings, publishing a notable book on
the idea of kindergartens, which became a handbook for early education. And they also
started a series of schools throughout the nation. For the remaining decades of her life,
Elizabeth continued to be a champion of education and the kindergarten system. The idea of the
kindergarten, which went right along with the Transcendental Movement, was that children
shouldn't be taught through fear or merely from books. They needed to embrace playing outside and
having physical movement, music, and creativity, as well as intelligent play from the earliest
stages of teaching, as young as four or five years old, so that that creative nature would
be developed. Harkening back to the idea that people are inherently good, educators like the
Peabody sisters and Horace Mann, who ended up being good friends with both Elizabeth and Mary,
they all believed that as a child is naturally very virtuous and creative, it is a sacred duty
of the educator to not kill that creative spirit or to corrupt that child's nature in any way,
but to instead inspire him or her to become the benevolent, virtuous genius that he could
possibly be. After her own school had failed in the early 1830s, Elizabeth went to teach
at the Temple School, and she also helped founded it. It was mainly started by Amos Bronson Alcott,
who was the father of Louisa May Alcott, who wrote Little Women. She was one of the primary
educators there, but she ended up leaving in the late 1830s because of some religious differences
with Alcott, and a few differences of opinion over some of his educational ideas, which he
expressed in a rather controversial publication of his. She felt that he was being a little too
explicit about how he taught children on biology, religious ideas, and she cautioned him against
such things. He didn't take her advice, and he probably should have, so they amicably parted
ways. In 1840, Elizabeth bought a house in the central business district of Boston at 13 to 15
West Street. This brick federal row house became a home for her parents, her siblings,
and it also included an art studio for her sister Sophia, a lending library, and in the front parlor,
a bookstore, the West Street Bookstore. This was the first foreign language bookstore in Boston,
and there she published and sold translations, as well as original language copies of very
intellectual works by foreign writers, as well as first editions by some of the foremost thinkers
in this new group, a lot of times before they even were regarded. She published many works by
Nathaniel Hawthorne, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, as well as female writers like
Margaret Fuller. It also became a place where salons were hosted, evenings where people in
the Transcendental Movement would come and exchange ideas, ideas on philosophy, literature, religion,
the rights of man, the rights of woman. It was the site where Margaret Fuller delivered her
famous conversations, speeches. Elizabeth Peabody was the first female publisher in Boston,
if not in the entire United States. She worked for Margaret Fuller's transcendentalist publication,
The Dial, being a Spain publisher for a while, and she also briefly published her own transcendentalist
publication, Aesthetic Papers. She was a great patroness of the arts, and even more so a
recognizer of genius. She's been called an empresario for the way that she would observe
the talent in people long before others did, or even before they saw it in themselves. By giving
these fledgling writers a platform, and oftentimes some much-needed encouragement,
she helped introduce some of the great poets and ideological thinkers of the day to the New
England area. And that's why I call her the first lady of the American Renaissance.
She certainly was a powerful figure in the American Romantic Movement. As a publisher,
literary patroness, and great recognizer of talent, it's no wonder that Elizabeth Peabody developed
deep bonds with creative men, whose relationships with her often proved to be more than friendship
and professional, but perhaps less than honorable. In 1833, shortly after their school closed, the
Peabody sisters, Elizabeth and Mary, were living in a boarding house in Brookline, Massachusetts.
There, they met Horace Mann, who was a politician and would eventually become one of the foremost
educators in the United States. But at this point, he was deep in depression because he'd
recently lost his wife. While at this boarding house, he mingled with many other Unitarians,
and particularly formed a deep bond with both Peabody sisters, because they helped soothe his
grief, and they shared many intellectual ideas with him. He greatly admired their intelligent
conversation, particularly that of Elizabeth. And Mary, who quickly developed an attraction for him,
was jealous of the deep metaphysical conversations that he would have with her sisters,
since she felt she wasn't quite intelligent enough to enter into them. When Mary was away in Cuba,
taking care of her sister Sophia, she was very jealous when she heard from letters from Elizabeth
that Horace was paying at least one visit per week to Elizabeth, so that they could spend evenings
together, reading, exchanging letters, exchanging ideas, and in very intimate friendship. Now,
Elizabeth continually defended their relationship and said it was nothing but platonic and true
friendship, although she admitted that a lot of people didn't seem to understand that.
One of whom was Mary, who wouldn't take her sister's word for it, that he was mainly coming
over to hear news about Mary. Nevertheless, Elizabeth continued to insist that it was
a brothers and sisters love on both sides. When Mary eventually returned to Boston, two years later,
she found that her sister had been being truthful. Although Horace was perhaps spiritually closer to
Elizabeth than to anyone else, because he was able to really share ideas with her and be truly
consoled by her kind friendship, it was Mary for whom he felt romantic love, and they eventually
were wed, and they shared a joint passion for education and social reform. Of course, Elizabeth
was nothing but delighted for her sister. The case was slightly different a few years later,
when she met another young man, who eventually would become known as the New England
Transcendentalist scene most eligible bachelor. In 1837, she met Nathaniel Hawthorne, who at the time
was a very unimpressive young writer. He'd published one volume of short stories, but he was
mainly noted for being a recluse. He knew that he was very handsome, so he would try to compensate
for his very reserved, retiring nature by dressing very showily, often wearing capes and cravats.
The effect apparently made quite an impression on Elizabeth when he and his two sisters
paid a call to her one evening, as she reported to her sister Sophia that he was
handsomer than Lord Byron. It seems that to the American romantics, as to the European romantics,
Lord Byron was an example of what a romantic yet tragic figure should be, especially as a writer.
And Nathaniel Hawthorne proved to live up to the idea of being a Byronic hero.
He would spend most of his time indoors, only going out to wander the streets at night,
be extremely reserved, yet unlike some other Transcendentalists, he didn't really enjoy
this solitude, and he would often complain that his life wasn't really living. Elizabeth
immediately saw his great talent, and she began publishing some of his early stories,
introducing him to important members of the Transcendentalist movement and
bringing him into her literary circle. She introduced him to Horace Mann, hoping to get
him to write some children's stories that Mann could have published. She even got him a political
position at the Custom House, so that he could have a steady income with enough leisure time
to do his writing. Of course, he found that stifling, so he didn't do much writing at all.
But above all, she offered him great personal support and unconditional love. And it seems
that at first, he acted like he returned that to her, because he often would visit her in the
evenings and would allude to the fact that he wanted her to come visit him and his sisters,
but he hoped that she would really just want to come see him. Meanwhile, somewhere around this
time, he also met her younger sister, Sophia. Now, Sophia was an invalid. She oftentimes wouldn't
leave her room, and she wouldn't always listen to her sister Elizabeth when she tried to coax her
to come downstairs and meet people. At some point or other, she did meet Nathaniel Hawthorne, and
he would often come up and visit her in her room and see her paintings, where she was an artist,
and they began exchanging letters. Elizabeth quickly saw that the younger, perhaps more
attractive Sophia could capture the heart of Nathaniel in a way that maybe she couldn't.
She tried to continue supporting him despite what seemed like a fickle nature. For years,
people have long believed what she said in her last decades, that she had nothing but sisterly
love for Nathaniel Hawthorne and professional admiration. The Peabody sisters' recent biographer,
Megan Marshall, unearthed an unpublished biography of her from 1904 by Mary Church,
which included a few interviews from her with the closest friends that proved otherwise. It seems
that, indeed, Elizabeth did have very strong personal feelings for Nathaniel Hawthorne,
and may have even been engaged to him at one point. Now, it's indeed true that people thought
she was engaged to both the men who would become her future brothers-in-law, and while it seems to
have not been anything romantic with Horace Mann, there's very good evidence that she was, in fact,
in love with Nathaniel Hawthorne. Despite the fact that he eventually decided to marry her
sister Sophia, that didn't cause a rift between her and her sister, whom she cherished and
supported in everything she did. She acted as a very loving sister to both her former confidants,
and remained a devoted supporter to both sisters. Instead, she dedicated herself wholeheartedly to
her causes of education, literature, and social causes, continuing to support them throughout
her long life, as she lived to the age of 89, outliving all her other siblings. Many female
writers of the time never married, and people will often speculate that they had no interest in men,
or that they were such feminists that they didn't like the idea of marriage. That certainly isn't
the case with Elizabeth Peabody. She was a very romantic young lady who wrote some poetry of her
own, as well as non-fiction works, and who, in her letters, greatly romanticized and cherished her
relationships with intelligent men. But I think it's easy to understand why she never married,
when we see that her two sisters married probably the only two men she ever loved. Nevertheless,
she's an excellent example of a very virtuous and generous example of sisterly love, as she
was nothing but glad for her sisters as they found family lives and had husbands and children,
while she instead dedicated herself to educating other children and helping other young people
through her schools and her writings. Elizabeth Peabody is not a well-known name in the history
of America, yet she certainly deserves her place among other American legends. Thank you for
spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.