James A. Garfield never aspired to the presidency—but his short time in office left a long-term impact. A self-taught scholar, preacher, Civil War general, and congressman, Garfield rose from poverty to become the last “log cabin president.” Though his presidency lasted only 200 days, his stand against political corruption and support for civil rights helped spark civil service reform. Assassinated by a man seeking political favors, Garfield’s death brought national attention to the dangers of patronage—and reminded Americans of the cost of honest leadership.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
The names of those who have served in some capacity for their nation are expected to be
remembered for years after their lives have left those of the living. Some names indeed have,
remaining very famous hundreds of years after their owners have died. Others have become
surprisingly obscure, being forgotten through the annals of time despite the important roles
they played. It's interesting to discover these people who are less well-known and analyze
whether they deserve a place among those who are considered the heroes of the nation.
For example, today we're going to talk about one of the more obscure presidents of the United States,
James A. Garfield. After the Civil War, the United States went into a period of reconstruction.
The smooth course which seemed likely to follow the end of the war was drastically and violently
ended by the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. You'd think that this first violent death of a
very beloved president would have warned the whole political system that candidates and presidents
were potentially in danger for their lives. But everyone viewed the assassination of Lincoln as
a fluke, a strange one-time event that it simply happened because of the Civil War.
After all, anytime there's a military conflict of that level, it's only natural that there would
be many people on the losing side who'd be very bitter. Nevertheless, just four presidents later,
another president would have his life cut drastically short.
James Garfield was elected to the presidency in the year 1880. He is the last of the log
cabin presidents. He was born in 1831 in poverty in Ohio. His father died when he was very young,
so he was raised by a poor but very strong-willed mother. He was a Christian growing up but he just
went to church because of his mother wanting him to do so. It wasn't until his teenage years
that he became more religious himself, attending camp meetings and eventually having a strong
conversion when he was 19 years old, leading to his being baptized. This would be a very important
aspect of his life because he would go on to become a preacher. As a matter of fact, he was called
the preacher president and he was the only U.S. president to be a member of the clergy at any time.
He was a member of the Christian denomination Disciples of Christ and his affiliation with this
group largely influenced his education. He didn't do particularly well in his early years
of schooling. In fact, he later lamented that his first 17 years of life were so uneventful,
so unproductive, that without either a father's guidance or enough money to have good education,
he really didn't make much of himself during those first 17 years. After that, though,
he began attending the Goethe Seminary, which is where he would meet his future wife,
Lucretia Randall. It was a co-educational school and he first studied there to begin his basic
education in the various fields and he became very interested in the classical languages,
studying Greek and Latin. Throughout his life, he loved learning about not only the dogma of
religion but the history of it, the philosophical thought behind it, and above all, the reasoning.
He was a big proponent of free thought and the ability and freedom to debate, to analyze things,
to have deep conversations. As a result, his government policy often involved the
laissez-faire policy, which means let be, let it be. It's similar to live and let live.
He believed very ardently in the separation of church and state. From 1850 to 1854,
he would attend the Western Reserve Eclectic Institute, which would later become known as
Hiram College, which was actually co-founded by Lucretia Randall's father. He, again, there
was a student, a fellow student of Lucretia, who was just one year younger than he was.
It was there that he really grew to love the classical languages. After studying there,
he began teaching. As a poor boy, he'd had to work his way through school. First, when he was at the
Freewill Baptist College for those two years, and then at this school, one of his early jobs
was working on a boat, tending to the mules, which worked on the ferry. He originally wanted to be a
sailor, but he didn't hold on to this goal for very long, because not long after getting this
job working on that boat, he fell into the water, and he couldn't swim, and he got a very bad cold,
so he realized that maybe the life of a sailor wasn't for him. Back on dry land, he would teach,
even work as a janitor at first, but eventually rise up to an important teaching position,
teaching many other students, including future wife Lucretia, whom he was courting by this point,
and then he also began touring around as a minister. Along the way, he began studying
the legal profession, and he became a lawyer. Like many politicians and eventual presidents,
he didn't do a whole lot with his legal practice. He would take occasional breaks from public
service to pursue his law practice, mainly so he could actually make some money, because not
much money in public service, of holding government positions at that time. But above all, this work
with the law gave him an understanding of government, of the legal principles of the
United States. In the year 1858, he married Lucretia, and it wasn't long after that that
the Civil War broke out. Right around that time, he was nominated for Congress, the U.S. House of
Representatives, representing Ohio. He wasn't expecting this, nor was he looking for it,
but he had already served one term in the state House of Representatives and shown his ability.
So, as the country was beginning to be torn apart by the two rival factions with the beginning of
the Civil War, he was showing his ability as a strong leader. He was a passionate abolitionist
and a very strong pro-union advocate. He received a commission in the Union Army
as a colonel originally, and before long, he rose to the prominence of general. He served under some
very important higher-ranking generals during the Civil War, including Rose Kranz, who was
in charge of the army at one point before Lincoln eventually replaced him, seeing him as inadequate.
He was just one of many generals whom Lincoln replaced for being inadequate before settling
on Ulysses S. Grant, who ended up helping him win the war. There were a few noteworthy times when,
as a commander, Garfield showed great ability. After a year or so in this position, he became
quite ill with dysentery, so he had to go home and be nursed back to health by his wife.
Around that time, one of their children died, leaving him quite grief-stricken, and he felt that
he would do better to get back out on the battlefield, away from politics, as that would
dampen his spirits even more. So, he went to Lincoln and talked about it with him, but President
Lincoln advised him that there were plenty of generals on the battlefield, but not enough
able statesmen. You see, Garfield had already shown that he was good at doing the behind-the-scenes
political work of war. Before actually going on to the battlefield, he had helped raise money,
recruit soldiers, purchase muskets, so he showed that he was good at that behind-the-scenes
getting the necessary supplies, and thus he agreed to keep his position in Congress, serving
with that seat, although earlier he'd not wanted to campaign, like some other presidents, too, who were
torn between being on the battlefield or being in Congress at that time.
So, he ended up being in Congress there, and he would actually serve nine terms in the U.S. House
of Representatives, always as a very strong Republican. In fact, he was still in the House of
Representatives when he was elected to be president, making him the only president who was a sitting
congressman at the time of his election. He wasn't the biggest fan of Lincoln. He referred
to him at one point as a second-rate Illinois attorney, but that quote is actually usually
taken out of context. All too often, you see, oh, Garfield called Lincoln a second-rate attorney,
but what he really was saying, if you see the full quote, was that this was after he heard his
emancipation proclamation, which greatly impressed him. He said, it's amazing that a second-rate
attorney from Illinois would end up being a man to make a speech like this at such a time.
He was really marveling at how someone of seeming lowly background could become this leader, and
he himself had a similar path of coming from a log cabin to becoming the president of the United
States. He was critical of some of Lincoln's policies, but he did admire him for his abolition
stance. I think originally and initially, he was a bit concerned by the moderate view which Lincoln
was trying to take to keep some peace between the North and the South, both during and then
after the Civil War. At the time of Lincoln's assassination, he famously made an impromptu
speech talking about God's providence and how God was still in heaven in control despite this tragedy,
but remarkably not saying really anything about Lincoln himself, or what a great man he was. But
later, a few years after the assassination, he conceded that Lincoln was one of the only men
whose wisdom increased with power, rather than leading to corruption. He was a supporter of
Andrew Johnson, and a friend of his actually, who was the vice president for Lincoln, who ended up
taking over as president. But he began to be very critical of his political actions, as Garfield was
a member of Congress at the time, and Congress, which was very Republican, did not like many of
the things Johnson was doing. So he was a big part of the impeachment movement for Johnson. Although
Johnson remained in office, maybe even because Johnson remained in office, Garfield became more
and more critical of people who hold important political positions. Now, by the time that the
1870s were coming to an end, there were two very strong, growing factions within the Republican
Party. The Democrats hadn't been able to gain a foothold again, really, since the Civil War, because
they still were able to, as they said at the time, wave the bloody shirt. It was very easy to remind
everyone that it was the Democrats who had supported the South, and if you wanted to say, were the ones
who led to the whole secession and then the Civil War. So the Republicans naturally stayed in power
for one president after another. Within the party, there were different groups. The two groups were
known as the Stalwarts and the Halfbreeds. The Stalwarts were connected to the New York political
machine, and I don't use the term too lightly, because a growing system of favoritism and
political spoils was gaining power within the Republican Party, particularly in the New York
area. The leader of the Stalwart party was Senator Roscoe Conkling, who was a very prominent member
of the New York political machine. In fact, he ran the whole thing. The other side of the party
was the Halfbreeds, and they believed that there shouldn't be the spoils system and the purchasing
of political positions, and Garfield found himself more and more in that group. James Garfield never
sought the office of president for himself. It was never one of his aspirations. He did seek
important positions in Congress. He was briefly in charge of the Ways and Means Committee,
which he really liked, because he was very interested in the financial situation,
and that was in charge of it. But he was removed from that position because he wasn't quite lining
up with his party in terms of the whole tariff issue, because at the time, the Republicans
held very strongly to a strong tariff to guard American interests, but he believed more in
free trade. One thing which he held very strongly throughout his life was the gold standard. He
believed that money needed to be backed by gold, and he was against the greenbacks, the money which
was just being printed during the Civil War. Leading up to the 1880 election, the Republican
Convention was torn between two people, Ulysses S. Grant, who was trying to run for a third term,
and James G. Blaine. There was a third candidate whom Garfield supported, which was actually
John Sherman, but he came in a very slow third. Grant and Blaine just kept going
up against each other, being tied time after time, and finally on the 36th ballot,
people began to say, we need another candidate, and someone suggested Garfield. He immediately
said, no, please, I'm loyal to Sherman, don't nominate me, yet they started voting more and
more for him, and pretty soon he had the majority. As was typical of the time, he didn't too actively
seek the position, because that was deemed bad form. Over the summer, he and his wife held some
brief front porch campaigns, allowing people to come and meet them at their home, but again,
he didn't really campaign, and he ended up winning, beating out Hancock, who was the Democratic
nominee. He appointed his good friend and political ally, James G. Blaine, as his Secretary of State,
but the only way that he was able to have any balance with the Republican Party was the fact
that Chester Arthur was his Vice President, who was very much part of the stalwart group in New York.
As a result, they weren't too good of friends, because they had very conflicting opinions.
Once in office, after his inauguration on March 4th, 1881, Garfield faced a lot of opposition
from Conkling, particularly over the Customs House Director, who was in New York. Conkling wanted to
have say over who was put in the Cabinet, and he was very annoyed to see that none of his friends
and supporters were being put in important positions. So, to make matters worse, or really
just to bring them into the open and to show that he would no longer be part of this favoritism,
Garfield removed the man who was Conkling's protege, if you will, at that Customs House
in New York, which was an extremely lucrative position. Basically, all the money that was coming
into the United States from the trade with the Customs House went into that man's pocket,
and as a result back into the political machine which was run by Conkling.
And to put a stop to it, Garfield got rid of him and put in a new man, Robertson.
And Conkling was sure that he was calling his bluff and he wasn't going to let that happen, but
when then-Congress backed up Garfield, Conkling was so angry that he left the Senate, as did a
was establishing an excellent precedent for having some kind of a system of merit or experience, or
hopefully both, for people being put in such important positions. Not, I helped you get
elected, so I should have this position. Unfortunately, whenever you stand up for
something and you take a strong stance, you can be putting yourself out in danger.
His earliest days of the presidency were filled with being hounded by people coming and seeking
jobs in the new administration. Partly because he wasn't just using the spoils system, many people
thought he might be looking for employees, and he and his Secretary of State would interview the
various people. One man whom he interviewed at least once was Charles Guiteau. Now, this man was
a strong Republican, he'd been involved in the campaigning, and he believed he'd helped get him
elected. Now, he never had really been allowed to speak because he wasn't that successful of an
orator, but he had written one pamphlet which was praising and supporting Garfield during the
election, and he felt that he should be rewarded with the position of Minister to France. Despite
the fact that he didn't speak French, nor did he speak any other foreign language, he really was
not qualified, but he was insistent he should have that job. So he ended up talking to Blaine,
who sort of deflected by saying that he was too much part of the stalwart branch of the party,
Garfield wouldn't want to appoint him because of that. That led to Guiteau becoming obsessed
with the idea that Garfield was dividing the Republican Party. He was sure that a more
moderate person like Vice President Arthur, who was, by being part of the stalwarts, wasn't really
causing the division, would keep peace in the party and end up giving him a political position.
So he got it into his mind that Garfield must die. He didn't hate him, he really hadn't, didn't have
that much of a grudge against him personally, he just saw him as being in the way, and get rid of
him, Arthur would be in charge, the party would be united, and he'd get the position he wanted.
It's now believed that he was schizophrenic or had some other kind of psychological disorder,
because, as I mentioned earlier, assassination wasn't something which was widely feared,
so presidents weren't heavily guarded, and their comings and goings were often reported by the
press. So as it was getting into the hottest part of the summer, in late June, early July,
Garfield was planning to leave the city, to go to a cooler climate, and to leave the humid,
unhealthy conditions of Washington. His wife, who was suffering from malaria, had already gone
to New Jersey, and he was going to join her there. Guiteau knew that he had to get Garfield before
he left the city, and for weeks he hounded him. He lost his nerve a couple of times when he
either couldn't get close enough, or his gun didn't work, or one time he took pity on him
because he was with his wife, as he was seeing her off. He purposely chose a gun which he thought
would look good in a museum, and on the very day that he was leaving, he was at the train station
on July 2nd, Guiteau was hiding in the crowds by the ladies' waiting room, and Garfield was
distracted because he was deep in a conversation with his Secretary of State, James Blaine. In
fact, a good deal of the cabinet was there with him, discussing some last matters before he left,
and Guiteau jumped out and fired two shots at him. He ended up being arrested and brought to jail,
and he said, I shall be arrested, but Arthur will be President. And they dragged him off,
but Garfield did not immediately die. One of the people, ironically, who was at the site of the
assassination was Robert Todd Lincoln, who was Abraham Lincoln's son and a member of the cabinet,
and he ironically, and quite tragically, was present at two assassination attempts after his
own father had, of course, been assassinated. Now, unlike Lincoln, Garfield did not immediately
lose consciousness or die the next morning. He lived for a few months, but he never was able
to fully recover because one bullet grazed his arm and the other lodged in his abdomen.
Doctors immediately began trying to remove the bullet. At the time, the usual practice when
someone was shot was to figure out the path of the bullet and get it out if possible. Of course,
that makes sense, but the problem was that they basically were just sticking their dirty hands
in his wounds. They didn't wash them or anything, and maybe they washed them, but they didn't use
the kind of sterilization which would have been a good idea, and they never were really sure where
the bullet was. The main physician who was in charge of the situation, whose last name was Bliss,
sadly let pride ultimately kill the president. He was so intent upon the fact that he must be in
charge that he wouldn't always listen to potential ideas that could have helped him. For instance,
Dr. Joseph Lister, who is the namesake of Listerine, had been doing some very positive
research on antisepsis, blood poisoning, from which comes the word antiseptic, ways to kill
infection so that you don't have to die of blood poisoning, but they never called on him, and no one
in the circle of all the numerous physicians and surgeons drew on anything like that. Alexander
Graham Bell was called in to try to use an electromagnetic device to find the bullet.
He had done this successfully in the past, but he wasn't able to do it successfully this time,
largely because Bliss was micromanaging everything, and he had a very strong opinion about where the
bullet was, and he didn't really want any opinions to the contrary. At first, Garfield was kept
in Washington at the White House, and he was able to sit up, write, talk, even do a little bit of
government business, but then eventually, when he was stable enough to travel in early September,
they brought him to New Jersey, where he would be able to overlook the ocean and hopefully recover.
People were initially very cheered and hopeful and positive that he would get better.
For the first couple of weeks, it seems like he was improving well, but by late July,
he started to suffer from more pain and to really, really go downhill. Some of us think that his
gallbladder ruptured at some point, and that may have led to his death, or that he did have
infection. There are various theories on what really happened to him. We don't know for a fact,
and many historians will say with great certainty he could have survived with modern medicine.
Some people even think he could have survived with medicine of the day if it had been handled better,
whereas others believe that he'd had injury to his spine and some very vital organs, and so he
really couldn't have survived. Either way, he ended up dying on September 21st, just a few
months after he was inaugurated, and Chester Arthur took office. Now, Arthur received some threats on
his life when it came out that the assassin had been a proponent of Arthur and had wanted him to
become president, and that also created a lot of animosity toward the Stalwarts. I think that they
had inspired such violence. Once the president had died, his assassin was tried for murder, and
he gave a very sporadic defense of himself, which led to his being, which led to his attorneys
giving a plea of insanity, but he boldly stated that he didn't think he should be on trial for
murder. He thought that rather the physicians should be on trial because he'd not died from his
bullet, but from their malpractice. Since he said everyone had said it was a wound from which he
could have recovered, so he hadn't killed the president, the doctors had. Be that as it may,
he still had fired the bullet, so he was killed by execution in July of the next year. Garfield
holds the record as the second shortest time in office of any president, after only William Henry
Harrison, the ninth president, who died of natural causes a month after his inauguration. Of his 200
days in office, only 80 of them were active ones for Garfield, but in a strange way, his death was
not in vain. His death almost hastened the reform which he had attempted to instill.
Because he was killed by this disgruntled person who thought he should have some political position
as a favor, it really cast a spotlight on this whole favoritism system. If it hadn't been for
that, the country may have become more and more engulfed in this favor for a favor and buying of
positions. Because of his death, his successor, Chester Arthur, became very inspired to remove
this favoritism and to instill a merit-based system for civil service. His whole presidency
is surrounded by a big what-if. Would he have done more great things, or had he basically accomplished
everything he could? Had he set things in motion and was perhaps his legacy more powerful because
of his sadly premature death? Because of how short a time he was in the White House, Garfield is often
overlooked and sometimes not even included in political rankings, but historians who have really
looked at him and analyzed his life have realized that he stood for some very great things. He was
a passionate abolitionist long before it was popular. Although a deeply religious man, he
called for the separation of church and state. He backed the gold standard. He was a very intelligent
man, proving the Pythagorean theorem, a very learned and a strong advocate of education.
Having come from a background of poor education himself, he believed that the public needed to be
well-educated. He strongly called for a lack of corruption in civil service, whether that was in
Congress, in the cabinet, or in the presidency, and he was a passionate supporter of the civil rights
movement. When I hear that term, I often think it sounds like the 1960s, because we hear about that
with the second wave, but that really was the second wave, because civil rights began in the 1860s
right after the civil war. He believed not only that Africans shouldn't be held as slaves, but that
black people and people of all colors and backgrounds should enjoy the full liberty of
the rights as a citizen. He was very bold about that and very critical of anyone whom he thought
wasn't supporting such things, so he deserves a lot of credit for that.
And his short-lived presidency is marked by really an unexpected turn of events. He wasn't trying to
become a president, and it was a very short time that he was, yet during that time he tried to just
do a good job, just like he did in Congress. And his name, which is quite obscure, I think deserves
a bigger place in the annals of American history. Out of everything he did, I think he would want
to be remembered as someone who tried to serve his people honestly, and he would want us to
really take responsibility for the people who are our leaders, because he famously said,
the people are responsible for the character of their Congress.
Thank you for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.