Exclusive
Herbert Hoover: The Right Man at the Wrong Time

American Legends
361 followers
Often remembered for the Great Depression, Herbert Hoover was more than an unlucky president. An orphan, engineer, and global humanitarian, he brought relief to millions before entering politics. Yet when crisis struck, his quiet integrity and cautious approach were cast aside by public frustration. Was he truly a failure—or simply a man in the wrong era?
🔎 Discover the story of a president shaped by principle, not popularity.
#GreatDepression #HerbertHoover #americanlegends #firstladies #whitehousehistory #presidentialfamilies #presidentialhistory #classicamericanhistory #history #historyandculture #historyfacts #american #uncoveringhistory #uncoverthetruth
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
The president of the United States is the symbol who represents the whole country.
In times of prosperity, he often gets a lot of credit for good times, which he didn't necessarily
cause. On the other side, however, the president often receives a lot of blame when bad things are
happening in the country, even if he didn't directly cause them. Today, we're going to talk
about one of the unluckiest presidents because he happened to be in charge during the greatest
economic downturn our country has ever faced. I don't think there's ever been such an unlucky
president as Herbert Hoover. A man of many distinctions, he also was one of the first
really modern presidents. Now, I say that because of when he served in the White House. From 1928
to 1932, that's really the beginning of what you could consider the golden age of Hollywood,
and thus a time with which it's more easy to be intimately familiar. There are recordings of his
voice in radio broadcasts, countless photographs, and he seems much more approachable because he
was very much in the 20th century. His name is synonymous with the Great Depression, which
remains the greatest economic downturn the United States has ever faced. But looking deeper into
this man's life before, during, and after his time in the White House, was he really responsible for
the bad times which our country faced? Herbert Hoover was the first president born west of the
Mississippi River. He was born in Iowa to Quaker parents. His mother was born in Canada. He remains
the only president to be a Quaker. When he was only nine years old, he was orphaned, so he ended
up living with various relatives before eventually settling with his late mother's brother in Oregon.
This uncle reportedly wasn't particularly kind or generous to his nephew, but he gave him an
adequate upbringing. Hoover was a curious lad, but consistently not a very good student. Thus, it's
perhaps surprising that he did have a college degree, as throughout his youth he would study
mathematics, history, science, etc., but he proved to be, just in general, a rather mediocre student.
He was one of the first group of young men to go to Stanford University, part of what's considered
the pioneer class in the 1890s. He failed his entrance examinations on every subject except
mathematics. His first major was mechanical engineer, but he didn't prove too successful at
that, so then he switched to being a geology major. And even in this discipline, he wasn't that good of
a student, but he did prove to be a very active member of the school society, life on the campus.
He had a rather good personality and he helped organize different groups, although he was
vocally critical of fraternities and sororities. After graduating with his geology degree, that
sent him into the beginning of his career as a mining engineer. That makes him really the only
president to have a background in something like engineering, rather than being a lawyer, like many
presidents, or some other governmental official, or a member of the service, as many presidents went
through the battlefield to make it to the White House. That wasn't the case with Herbert Hoover,
and the US presidency is really the only elected office he ever had. After graduating, he got a job
working overseas in a geological capacity. Working for this firm, he worked in Australia first, and
then in China. When he was in Australia, he helped his mining company find the best and most valuable
sources of mines, particularly gold mines, to tap, and he helped the company become very wealthy.
He eventually became a partner of this company, and before starting his own geological and
engineering firm, which led him to become a very wealthy man in his own right. When he was at
Stanford, he met and fell in love with another geology student, Lou Henry, who was the first
female geology student to graduate from Stanford. She ended up accompanying him on many of his
overseas travels when he was stationed in Australia and China, and they both learned to speak Mandarin,
Chinese, to each other. This proved valuable in later years, as they used Chinese as a way to
communicate with each other in the White House, without anyone else knowing what they were saying.
Eventually, around the year 1916, the Hoovers settled in the United States for the first time
in their married life. By this time, World War I, then called the Great War, was raging in Europe,
but the United States hadn't joined yet. When it did join, Hoover became involved, serving in the
capacity of providing relief. He helped raise money and provide food to the impoverished, war-torn
countries, which were being greatly attacked by the Germans. And in that capacity, he began to
earn some public esteem, particularly in the government. The higher-ups saw that he was a
man who knew how to get jobs done. He knew how to raise funds, raise awareness, and provide relief for
countries and peoples who were struggling. In fact, he became regarded as sort of a hero in some of
those European countries. In Finland, the word Hoover became synonymous with the word to help,
because Hoover was really helping them. After the war had ended, he remained in Europe for a while
and continued helping with the millions of people who were struggling with poverty and famine after
the war. Returning to the United States, he saw that he then had a position to get into politics,
and he was hoping to be nominated for the presidency in the year 1920. At this point, he
wasn't particularly aligned with either political party. He didn't really care which side he was on,
and he wanted to keep it that way, hoping that one or both parties would approach him with
a nomination. As he was feeling out the potentials that year, he decided to go with the Republican
Party, because he found that he aligned a bit more with them, and they were more supportive
of some of his views, and also he thought that they were likely to win. That proved to be true,
but he did not gain the nomination himself. As Harding became the Republican candidate, Hoover
put his support behind him, and this would bode well for Herbert Hoover's emerging political career.
Hoover had an interesting stance politically at this point, because he didn't stick too closely
to either party lines, which is why it makes sense that he was neutral before the 1920 election.
In general, he was financially and fiscally conservative. He tended to support more taxes
that were more Republican in nature, but on the other hand, he was supportive of the League of
Nations and minimum wage, and some other similar concepts which were more aligned with the Democratic
Party, and they were principles which Woodrow Wilson was advocating, as he was the Democratic
president at that point. After Warren Harding won the 1920 presidential election, he offered Hoover
a position in the cabinet. He was given the choice between two different positions, but he ended up
going with Secretary of Commerce. This seems like a surprising decision, because it was considered
a more minor cabinet position at the time, but Hoover saw the potential for that to become a
much more important position, so that's why he accepted it, and it proved to be very powerful
with him in that position. He quickly proved himself to be a strong leader in that capacity,
and he actually served in a lot of roles which weren't necessarily his, because of that position.
A lot of people, jokingly or somewhat bitterly, said at the time that he was the Secretary of
Commerce and the undersecretary of all the other cabinet positions. He worked very closely alongside
Andrew Mellon, who was a more conservative Republican, and another important cabinet
member in Harding's cabinet. Mellon and Hoover were two of the only cabinet members who weren't
badly blackened by the Teapot Dome scandal, and the other corruption which was running rampant
in Harding's cabinet, particularly with all the other Ohio politicians who had helped Harding win
the election. After Harding's death in the year 1923, his vice president Calvin Coolidge took over
and Hoover remained in his position as the Secretary of Commerce. He became an even more
influential cabinet member at this time, as Hoover was one of the ones who was not removed
from his cabinet position. Coolidge worked with him, but he began to resent him more and more. He
didn't completely agree with all Hoover's policies on commerce, but that didn't keep Hoover from
becoming a very important cabinet member and guiding Coolidge toward making some very momentous
decisions. Calvin Coolidge surprised everyone, including Herbert Hoover, when he announced that
he would not be running for technically a third term, but it would be his second time being elected
in 1928. This gave Hoover a chance to run for the presidency himself. He had tried very hard to
maintain good relations with Coolidge, even though he didn't agree with him on every point, because
he was hoping to be the next candidate in the Republican Party, and to continue the prosperity
which was very evident in the United States throughout the majority of the roaring 20s.
And that also would continue the Republican stronghold, which basically was the entire decade,
beginning with Harding's election in 1920. Coolidge personally didn't support Hoover to be his
successor, but he didn't want to divide the party by making a stance against him, so he didn't really
advocate strongly for or against him publicly, since he didn't want the Democrats to get in.
He did privately say, though, that he had received six years of unsolicited advice from Herbert Hoover,
most of it bad. In the 1928 election, Hoover was running against Democrat Al Smith, who was the
first Catholic presidential candidate. That made religion one of the main issues on the ballot that
year, as well as prohibition. Of course, prohibition had been in effect for the entire decade, but that
didn't make it any less controversial. Many people were against it. As a matter of fact, more people
were against it than for it, really. There really was no president who was 100% in favor of it.
Many congressmen were, of course, but by this point the Republican Party was basically in support
of prohibition, at least in theory. So Hoover went with that. Al Smith, on the other hand, was very much
against prohibition, and the Democratic Party was very divided by the late 1920s because of
the issues of prohibition and religion. And this weakened their side enough, as well as the fact
that the Republicans represented peace and prosperity. There had been a great decade of
peace and economic security, financial prosperity, so why not continue with the good thing? That was
basically Herbert Hoover's platform. And on that platform, he managed to win by almost a landslide,
gaining 58% of the popular vote. That doesn't sound like that much of a landslide, but that is
a pretty high margin of a majority. And he really defeated Smith in the Electoral College. Upon
winning the election, Herbert Hoover made a speech talking about how, with God's blessing and his will,
the United States would be able to build on the eight years of prosperity beforehand
and eradicate poverty. These words would look rather foolish seven months later when the stock
market crashed on Black Friday, plunging the nation into the Great Depression. Now, with that stock
market crash, as so many bad things start, not everyone realized what was going to follow.
Back in 1920, 20 through 21, there had been a little depression, mainly connected to farming
problems. And Hoover thought it would just be like that. It wouldn't be that big of a problem and that
the United States would be able to quickly recover. And that remained his platform, basically, for his
four years in office. Things are going to get better, just keep going, the government shouldn't
intervene too much, we've got to basically trust the process. But his words started to look more and
more foolish as the country really began to struggle, and people saw him as out of touch,
unsympathetic, cold, and uncaring. This public persona he developed lost him not only the 1932
election, but it also lost Republicans' control of the White House for a long time. It made people
question the whole idea, because people began to think that principles which Hoover had put in
place, and looking even farther back, Coolidge, perhaps even Harding, that these three Republican
presidents were responsible for the Great Depression. Now, people debated that in 1929, we're still
debating it almost 100 years later. No one person deserves all the blame for the Great Depression.
Obviously, he'd only been in office for seven months when the crash took place. The biggest
criticism could be, how did he handle it? Did he handle it well? And also, did he ignore some warning
signs? Both Hoover, in his early days of the presidency, and Coolidge had been warned of growing
inflation and things that were happening with the stock market. It was getting too hot, it was too
big, it was too much of a bull market. It was a bubble, and whenever a bubble like that is going
to get bigger and bigger, it could burst. There also were a lot of problems with farming at this
time. Now, Hoover's own father was a farmer, so he was very sympathetic to the plight of the farmer,
and one of his campaign promises was that he was going to help farmers, and one of the things he
wanted to do was to adjust taxes to make it easier on the farmer. But all the things he had in mind
really fell by the wayside because the nation was just plunged into the Depression. It's interesting
if you watch films from around this time, namely 1930 through 32, when you have these early
sound films. They did talk about the Depression, but Herbert Hoover did not get nearly the amount
of publicity you could say as the next president, Franklin D. Roosevelt, who was probably the most
photographed president during his time in office. And I think that's because people
weren't happy with Herbert Hoover, yet there was still a sense of patriotism, respect, and Hollywood,
although the film industry lacked a whole lot of moral fiber at this time, felt they would be wrong
to just out and out malign the president. But that doesn't mean that people weren't criticizing him,
and if you read more about this time and do research on the Great Depression, you'll see that
the name Hoover became a byword for basically anything bad during the Depression. A Hoover
hog was a name for a rabbit because you couldn't afford to eat pork, you'd have to catch a rabbit
and eat it. A Hoover blanket was a newspaper you'd use to cover yourself up. Hoover leather was taking
a piece of cardboard and sticking it in your shoe to mend a hole. A Hooverville was a name for
a shantytown or a bunch of little hobo villages, people who were living really out of their cars
or in makeshift dwellings. Even some later artistic works about the Great Depression
sometimes refer to Herbert Hoover and this negative feeling people had toward him, most notably the
stage production of the musical Annie. There's a song called We'd Like to Thank You, Herbert Hoover,
which didn't make it into the movie if you're familiar with that, but probably more so than
any other song in that score, it captures the Depression-era mentality. And I think it's
interesting to read more about this time, read books on the Great Depression, and to see what
people were thinking about him. There's a term, Pollyannaism, and it's referring to, of course,
the very beloved book, Pollyanna, about the little girl who always looks for the glad side of things
and plays the glad game. But sometimes that term was used as a negative, meaning you're being
maybe a little naive with your optimism, almost foolish. And people referred to Hoover's continued
insistence that things would get better next month than just a few months down the road as
Pollyannaism. He was just saying things were going to get better, but that they weren't really.
One problem that Hoover faced was the fact that he was just a very serious, almost morose person,
naturally. Maybe it was his Quaker background. Maybe it was the fact that he was orphaned at
the age of nine. Maybe it's that he was a scientist. But he didn't stand a chance up
against the grin and the winning personality of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, who was really
the first president who popularized smiling. Before that, presidents were supposed to look
very serious. And certainly the two presidents who came before him, Harding and Coolidge,
were very serious and refined gentlemen. I mean, Calvin Coolidge was known as Silent Cal.
And although Herbert Hoover perhaps spoke more, he, too, was rather solemn and quiet. He didn't
like to make too many speeches. And that led people to just have sort of a false impression
of him. For one thing, he and his wife both contributed a great deal out of their personal
funds to charities and relief. But they were very benevolent about this, and they didn't make it
public. So people just saw them as living in luxury while the nation was starving. They saw
him as being very out of touch with the nation, with the plights of the people. He didn't even
really want to run for a second term in 1932, but he reluctantly did. And despite his lack of
popularity, he didn't lose by that great a margin. I've read that they said FDR won by a landslide.
Yet he won 57.4% of the popular vote, while Hoover had won 58% in his election, which says that
FDR didn't even have as much of a landslide. And I think that's because deep down, many people were
against FDR. And we'll get more into that by studying his presidency. But Hoover just got a
bad rap in the media, I would say. And it was very easy for people to be negative, but it wasn't just
toward Hoover. It was toward Americanism in general. Because of his lack of intervention
and the fact that he wanted to leave the handling more to the individual states, Hoover has been
ranked rather low among presidents. But I think that if you read his personal quotes, you can see
that he actually was a very wise and intelligent man, who believed so strongly in the theory of
American government. And he stuck to that. He wasn't a very reactionary person. And ultimately,
that's kind of the wisest thing to do. FDR got far more results than he seemed to be doing things.
But to do that, he implemented some strategies that were very contrary to previous ideas on
American government. It seemed that Herbert Hoover would have been just the right person to have
during a time of crisis, because he had been very successful during previous crises. World War I,
this little depression in 1920 and 21, helping the nation kind of rebuild after the first World War,
and then the thing which really catapulted him to enough of the public limelight to get the
presidential nomination in 1928 was his handling of the Mississippi flood in 1927. As Secretary
of Commerce, that was his moment in the limelight. That was the biggest and most deadly weather event
which took place in the South until Hurricane Katrina. And it left many people impoverished and
stranded without resources. He reacted very efficiently to that incident, and that made him
a public hero. But that was in one place, and he saw it as his job to go and provide relief.
Very different when now the whole nation is struggling. And he also saw some of the biggest
problems happening in the United States during the Great Depression as not just being American
problems. Over in Europe, there also was economic collapse in many of the different nations. At the
same time that communism was beginning to spring up and dictatorships, Hitler was coming to power,
and he saw that the last thing the United States needed to do was to start handing out free money
and put everybody on the dole. He stuck to his principles. It lost him the election. It lost him
a good reputation. And that's something I've observed in so many of these presidents. A lot
of these one-term presidents didn't get a second term, not because they didn't do a good job
necessarily, because they were in hard times and they didn't do the popular thing. They didn't do
the emotional thing. But maybe they did the smart thing, just from a purely rational point of view.
For being such an unpopular president, I found that Hoover has a great many inspiring quotes
which are actually very informative and appropriate even today about government as well as
personal citizenship. The first thing he said was,
every generation has the right to build its own world out of the materials of the past,
cemented by the hopes of the future. That's a running theme that you find in his quotes,
talking about the rights of each new generation to build a good financial situation, a time of
prosperity. He also was quoted as saying that children are the greatest natural resource in
the United States. And I think as an engineer, someone mining, he was all about natural resources,
planning for the future. And he was willing to let the adults of the day suffer rather than create a
crippling future for the next few generations. He also was quoted as saying prosperity is just
around the corner, which is the motto that lost him a lot of popularity, because it seemed like
a slap in the face when he kept saying that. But he strongly believed that if we just stuck to the
idea of the United States and didn't abandon ship, that prosperity would be around the corner.
Along those lines, he said, economic depression cannot be cured by legislative action or
executive pronouncement. Economic wounds must be healed by the action of the cells of the economic
body, the producers and consumers themselves. Similarly, he saw that this could be a time for
dictators to rise to power, saying, it is a paradox that every dictator has climbed to power on the
ladder of free speech. Immediately on attaining power, each dictator has suppressed all free speech
except his own. He also said, when there is a lack of honor in government, the morals of the whole
people are poisoned. As more of an expert on culture and entertainment from the 20th century
than politics, I know more about the movies of the 1930s and probably other aspects. So those early
years of the 30s are famous for being the pre-code era, a time when films were full of
shockingly scandalous content as Hollywood was trying to draw the impoverished nation to the
And I think Hoover represented the old guard of the conservatism morally, which seemed to be
being tossed to the wayside with the crime of prohibition and this newfound liberalism of
women not wanting to be traditional, and just traditional morals being tossed aside.
So one of his most stirring quotes, I think, is, quote, our strength lies in spiritual concepts.
It lies in public sensitivities to evil. Our greatest danger is not from invading armies.
Our dangers are that we may commit suicide from within by complacence with evil or by public
tolerance of scandalous behavior. I think a lot of the positivity and the beginning of relief,
which happened in the mid-1930s, really had nothing to do with Franklin D. Roosevelt,
but much more with the moral revolution that was happening in America, particularly related to his
entertainment. But unfortunately, poor Herbert Hoover was long out of office by that point.
After he left the presidency, though, he actually served in an advisor capacity
to two future presidents, including President Truman, in helping him during World War II and
afterwards doing the same thing he did in World War I, helping with the rebuilding after the
detriments of the war. People who were conservative, but also moderate in terms of
looking at both sides, respected him for the fact that he wasn't just so stuck to one party.
He tried to look at the rational side of both, being, many saw, the middle ground between
capitalism and socialism was sort of a corporatism or an associationalism,
two terms which were applied to him, as he tried to really support the idea of business,
but business which was fair and allowed every individual the chance to make something of
himself. If he had had the good fortune to be president during another time, say, if he had
won the 1920 election instead of Harding, I think he could have had a much more successful
and well-regarded presidency. As it was, he did the best he could to serve his nation during the
very difficult time when he happened to be in office, and eventually he died in 1964 at the age
of 90. Herbert Hoover remains one of the least illustrious presidents, but perhaps one of the
most misunderstood, and I think he deserves at least a closer look as we study the politics,
the economics, and the social changes of the mid-20th century. Thank you for spending this
time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.
