Grover Cleveland built his career—and presidency—on one unwavering trait: integrity. Known for his firm stance against corruption, he rose from small-town sheriff in Buffalo to mayor, governor, and ultimately president of the United States. At every stage, he earned respect for doing what he believed was right, even when it meant defying his own party. Cleveland vetoed hundreds of bills he saw as wasteful or unjust, stood up to political machines, and rejected patronage appointments. His commitment to limited government, fiscal discipline, and honest leadership earned him the nickname “Veto President.” While others played politics, Cleveland made decisions guided by principle—not popularity. He was the first president to serve two non-consecutive terms, but his true legacy lies in how he led: not with slogans, but with steadfast moral clarity.
Welcome to American Legends.
My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories.
But here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous, and some are obscure.
But each person deserves to be discovered,
because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans in our daily lives.
Throughout the history of the United States, there have been many presidents who have served two terms.
Of course, most presidents who have only served one term have tried again for a second, often unsuccessfully.
There are but two exceptions to this in the history of our country,
a time when a president was able to get back into the White House for a second but non-consecutive term.
Today we're going to talk about the first man to do this, President Grover Cleveland.
Grover Cleveland stands out for a few different reasons.
Of course, his most obvious claim to fame is the fact that he was the first and one of only two presidents to serve two non-consecutive terms in the White House.
He was the 22nd president of the United States, and then he was also the 24th.
He also was the first Democratic president since the Civil War.
He would be the only Democratic president for quite a few years during a very large block of time.
After the Civil War, between 1861 and 1931, there were only two Democratic presidents, of which he was one.
You could almost count him as two, because he was the 22nd and 24th.
He also was one of the last presidents to not have a college education.
This might be a little confusing when you read more about him and find out that he was a lawyer.
But like many other presidents, he was able to study law and pass the bar exam without actually going to college.
In those days, an undergraduate or some other basic college training wasn't a necessary precursor to going to law school.
In the case of many of these gentlemen, they didn't go to a formal law school, but they almost apprenticed under someone who was a lawyer.
Grover Cleveland was born in 1837 in New Jersey, but he would be raised in New York for most of his early life.
His father was a Presbyterian minister, and he would remain a Presbyterian for the rest of his life.
As a young man, Cleveland had, of course, some basic education, but his schooling had to stop when he was 16 years old because of the death of his father.
At that point, he started working various jobs, among them becoming a law clerk and eventually a lawyer.
In Buffalo, New York, in the year 1859, he was admitted to the bar at the age of only 22.
From there, he became the district attorney of Erie County.
Around this time, the Civil War had begun.
Rather than going to serve himself, Cleveland paid a Polish immigrant $150 to go in his place.
This might sound very unscrupulous and like draft evasion, but it was actually a common practice at the time, which was acceptable.
It wasn't that he didn't want to serve his country, though, because around that same time, in the year 1863, he became the county sheriff.
Eventually, he returned to private law practice, but as the county sheriff, which was one of his first main public offices,
Cleveland distinguished himself as a man who wanted to clean up corruption, someone who would fight for honor.
He personally oversaw two hangings of murderers, and he wasn't afraid to get his hands dirty in the job,
to get right in there and be a very active participant in whatever it was he was doing.
So it wasn't surprising that that position led to his being the mayor of Buffalo, New York,
and from there, to the governor of the state of New York.
Early in his career, Cleveland aligned himself with the Democratic Party,
but as he began to rise in prominence in the New York state politics, he was up against some political corruption.
In this era, after the Civil War, this time was known as the Gilded Age.
It was a time where a lot of money was available and a lot of opulence,
but at the same time, many people, particularly political bosses, were getting that money and opulence from rather unscrupulous means.
Party politics began to take a corrupt turn at this point, as political machines formed in both parties,
particularly in the state of New York.
There were rival machines up and operating by this time, in the 1870s, 80s, etc.
The Republicans really were in control of the Customs House, and the Democratic Party had Tammany Hall,
which was run by the big political boss, John Kelly.
But Grover Cleveland was not part of Tammany Hall, and he often made enemies there,
because he didn't believe in the party political system of favoritism and the machine.
And basically, what the different machines would accomplish would be
seeking favors from different groups in return for money or votes.
If you vote for this candidate or support him in his campaigning and his election,
then we will give jobs to all of your friends, and maybe even give some money in return.
So that was the main way that the system functioned.
And it got as high as the office of the White House and the presidential appointees.
But it led to too many people who really didn't serve a useful purpose in the government.
They were these civil employees, these government workers,
who had been given jobs and salaries that weren't really needed for running the country effectively,
but it added to the expenses of the government,
and the movement to clean things up had been going on for a few terms of office before Cleveland even ran.
It really started with Republican James Garfield,
who was unfortunately assassinated and then replaced by his vice president, Chester Arthur,
who had been very involved in the Republican machine,
but ended up turning against this machine politics and becoming a very powerful advocate for reform.
When he was unsuccessful in his bid to earn the title of president on his own in an election,
the Republican Party naturally turned to James Blaine as the next candidate.
Blaine had been very important in the Republican Party for a good many years.
He was the Secretary of State under Garfield and one of his closest advisors,
much closer, I might add, than Arthur was.
He was rising to prominence as Chester Arthur was in place.
He was more on the reform-minded side of the Republican Party
versus the stalwart party or branch of the Republican Party,
which was the machine part of it,
which Chester Arthur was a part until he became president and sort of turned on that side of the party.
Thus, the Republicans had James Blaine as their favorite candidate.
Around that time, only 11 years after he had really gotten involved in being elected for different offices,
Grover Cleveland became the favored Democratic candidate.
Now, there hadn't been a Democrat who had successfully won an election since before the Civil War.
The country was rather leery of the Democratic Party
because it was viewed that they were the party of the rebellion.
It was the Democrats who had mainly favored the Confederacy
and the whole problem which led to the Civil War in the first place.
Around that same time, the Republican Party had sprouted up,
led by the very powerful and noble Abraham Lincoln.
And thus, the Republican Party was viewed as the side of union,
the side of unity for the nation and reform, equal rights for all,
all these things which were viewed as very important.
It was called waving the bloody shirt when they would continually refer to,
remember how the Democrats started the Civil War.
By this point, it had been quite a while because we're now talking about the 1884 election.
This is almost 20 years after the end of the Civil War.
Nevertheless, there continued to be bad press against the Democratic Party.
And the slogan used around this time by Republicans against the Democrats
was that they were the party of rum, Romanism and rebellion.
This wasn't viewed too well by everyone, particularly the part about Romanism
because that was viewed as particularly anti-Catholic,
which, although still not the most powerful group in America,
there were many voters of that religious belief.
And the rum references to the fact that the temperance movement
was growing quite strong in the Republican Party,
whereas the Democrats weren't necessarily in favor of it.
Nevertheless, the issue of the 1884 election became one of honor
Grover Cleveland was viewed as a man who had a very pure political reputation.
He was in favor of reform and avoiding government waste,
very self-sacrificing and noble,
whereas James Blaine began to be viewed as a political wheeler dealer,
someone who had been in politics so long that maybe he had done some unscrupulous things.
At the same time, the Republicans began to find some dirt on Cleveland on the personal side.
Rumors began to be whispered about that the lifelong bachelor
had fathered an illegitimate child with a widow.
This child was called Oscar Folsom Cleveland.
She named him that, insisting that Cleveland was the father.
He neither denied nor admitted to this,
but he did say to all his followers, above all, tell the truth.
So in a way, he perhaps admitted to this, but didn't try to make excuses,
rather than saying, it's important to admit to your past mistakes and carry forward.
Some people believe that it was actually Mr. Folsom, who was the father of that child,
who would end up being the father-in-law, although he was deceased by that point, of Cleveland.
He was a good family friend.
Either way, the child ended up being raised under a different name by an adoptive family
because he was taken away from his mother since she was deemed to be an alcoholic.
Regardless of what the actual situation was, the Republicans latched onto that
and a common taunt, if you will, used around that time was,
Ma, ma, where's my pa?
How that particularly relates to him, I'm not sure,
but there are a lot of cartoons and illustrations from this time showing Cleveland
trying to walk away from a woman holding a crying baby.
Despite all this, people still viewed him as the more morally upstanding candidate
because, meanwhile, a rhyme being said about his opponent was,
James Blaine, James Blaine, the continental liar from the state of Maine.
So they decided to go with the somewhat rough-around-the-edges
but basically honest Grover Cleveland.
He won the popular vote by a small margin
and the electoral college vote by a much larger margin
and he was inaugurated as the 22nd president.
During his time in office, he focused on continuing the cleanup
of favoritism and corruption in the government,
trying to make the government focus on really serving the people.
He was not in favor of a lot of welfare and supporting people
who weren't working for themselves
because he believed very strongly that hard work was the basis of the nation.
He dealt with issues like the tariff and immigration during his time in office.
The tariff was still very high at this point because of the Civil War.
Since the government was in a decent financial state at the time,
he sought to lower the tariff but the businesses weren't too keen on that idea
so he wasn't completely able to do that.
He also dealt with the currency of the day.
Some people at that time wanted paper money to be backed by silver as well as gold.
This was particularly advocated by those states in the West
which mined a lot of silver such as Colorado.
But Cleveland believed that the gold standard was the most reliable form of currency
so he stuck to that and enforced it during his time in office.
He also dealt with the immigration issue regarding Chinese immigrants.
There had been the Chinese Exclusion Act for quite a few years under other presidents
which was keeping Chinese people from immigrating to the United States,
particularly on the West Coast.
This was largely because of the railroad situation
and a lot of American workers were concerned that they were taking too many jobs from Americans.
Cleveland held an interesting position on this.
If you read the quotes that he said about it and what people were saying at the time,
it's not unsimilar to the situation we have today
with the immigrants from South American countries, particularly Mexico.
On the one hand, there's a lot to be said for tightening up immigration rules
and advocating particularly jobs for Americans first,
most notably if it seems like the immigrants don't really want to be part of American society
and don't care about gaining citizenship.
On the other hand, our country was based on being a nation of immigrants,
so is it hypocritical to exclude others from coming into this nation?
The first quote from him on this point is,
the laws should be rigidly enforced which prohibit the immigration of a servile class
to compete with American labor with no intention of acquiring citizenship
and bringing with them and retaining habits and customs repugnant to our civilization.
Yet, in contrast, he said,
it is said that the quality of recent immigration is undesirable.
The time is quite within recent memory when the same thing was said of immigrants
who, with their descendants, are now numbered among our best citizens.
The stances which Cleveland took on many points
reminds us that the political parties then were entirely different from what they are now
because Cleveland was more decidedly against issues which today we would call civil rights issues
and they're considered more in the liberal or democratic side,
yet he was not completely in favor of open immigration.
He was leery of granting more civil rights to former slaves and other black people in the United States.
He was against women's suffrage
and he wasn't in favor of giving a lot of welfare to people who are not working or in need of some help,
as the Democrats would say now.
He also cut off many pensions from the Civil War as he was trying to help the economic crisis going forward.
He became known as the veto president
because he thought that Congress was sometimes up to no good
and he considered it his duty to keep them from passing any bad legislature.
He wasn't the first president to be called the veto president.
That distinction belongs to Andrew Johnson.
But he earned it even more because just his first term,
he vetoed 413 pieces of legislature,
which was twice all the other presidents before him combined.
So he certainly wasn't afraid to veto anything that he thought was against what should be the right policies.
Perhaps that's why he grew less popular at the end of his first term and thus was not re-elected.
He did technically win the popular vote when he ran for re-election in 1888,
but he lost the Electoral College vote.
So he left and then Benjamin Harrison, a Republican, took over.
But he ran again in 1892 and he won that time,
making him the first non-consecutive two-term president
and one of the few two-term presidents from around this time.
Unfortunately, his second time in office was significantly marred by something which really wasn't his fault
and that was the Panic of 1893, which began before he even was inaugurated.
This became the greatest economic downturn the country had experienced up to that time
and it was a significant depression.
It involved stock market crashes and the next year it was coupled with the railroad workers' strike,
the Pullman Union strike.
He began cutting back on a lot of pensions at this time
and trying to reinforce the stock market as well as reducing the tariffs
and trying to solidify the gold standard.
A lot of people at the time didn't think that he or other politicians really cared that much
about the welfare of individuals, such as Civil War veterans
and just other poor people who were struggling during this time,
saying that if a starving person were eating the grass on the White House lawn,
rather than offer him some food, Cleveland would tell him to go into the backyard
because the grass was taller there.
I think that's a little on the harsh side because he tended to look at the whole political equation
as the problem from the philosophical standpoint
rather than getting caught up in the emotions of the individual.
Both are important, of course, but he tried to focus on the policies
which he thought would strengthen the nation rather than just handing out a bunch of money
because he thought that would only make the problem worse.
Some positive things for reform which he did during both terms in office
was returning land which had been purchased or sometimes just taken
for the building of the railroad but where railroads had not been built.
So he was able to get those back into private ownership.
Largely because of the panic of 1893, which he tried to handle the best way he could,
his popularity had dwindled by the end of his term
and he was unsuccessful in his bid for a third term in the 1896 election
because bear in mind that at this point there still was no actual legislature
saying that a president could only serve two terms.
It was simply tradition and custom and a few had tried.
Besides being called the veto president, Cleveland was often known as Uncle Jumbo
because he was quite a portly man.
His image changed drastically during his first term in the year 1896
when he got married for the first time.
He had been the second bachelor president up to that point after James Buchanan
who never did get married, but Cleveland was the most eligible bachelor
until he unexpectedly married the much younger daughter of his late friend, Mr. Folsom.
Whereas Cleveland was quite rough around the edges
and sort of a beer-drinking alderman, you could say,
he was viewed as much more refined because of marrying this lovely young lady
who was a charming hostess.
Frances Cleveland definitely bolstered his reputation
and she became a very popular figure with her image being used
on a lot of the materials for his re-election.
Everyone loved her as a first lady and was very eager to have her back.
Their marriage was the only time that a sitting president was wed
during his time in office and the only time a president was married in the White House.
One of their children was also the only child to be born in the White House
because usually the first lady is much older and has already had her children.
Cleveland is yet another example of a president who actually lost a re-election
and lessened in favoritism because of how honorable he was.
He didn't always align with his party's politics and he gained a lot of enemies
because he tried to do what he knew to be right.
And his quotes reflect that.
One quote he said which stands very well outside of politics is
a cause worth fighting for is worth fighting for to the end.
He also said men and times change but principles never.
He also is quoted as saying above all tell the truth.
After leaving the White House he was on the board of Princeton University
where he often got into arguments with the president of the college
and who was a future U.S. president himself Woodrow Wilson.
He and his wife had five children together and a very happy marriage
until he eventually died in the year 1908.
His last words are recorded as I have tried so hard to do right.
Cleveland usually is only remembered for the fact that he served those two non-consecutive terms
which has come up again as the most recent president is doing the same.
But he deserves a lot more of a reputation than simply that odd coincidence.
He should be remembered as a president who tried to do what was right,
who fought for lost causes, who was unafraid to go against his party,
who sought to root out corruption,
and who continued to advocate for justice and equal rights and freedom
for all the citizens of the United States.
Thank you for spending this time with me
and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.