Rutherford B. Hayes became the 19th president through one of the most contested elections in U.S. history. Though critics called him “His Fraudulency,” Hayes proved to be a principled leader who ended Reconstruction, promoted civil service reform, and championed education and racial equality. A decorated Union general and devout Methodist, he banned alcohol from the White House and introduced modern technology like the telephone. True to his word, he served only one term, then spent the rest of his life advancing public education and civic responsibility. Hayes may be overlooked—but his legacy is quietly enduring.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories.
But here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous, and some are obscure.
But each person deserves to be discovered,
because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans in our daily lives.
It's amazing how quickly things which seem like a huge story can fade into oblivion
within not even a generation or two, but even just a few years.
As you delve more into any chapter of history,
it's amazing to realize that there are so many names which you rarely, if ever, hear.
And beyond those names were very real people,
each of whom served an important role in his or her part of the world.
Today, as we continue with our discovery of U.S. presidents,
we're going to talk about one of the less well-known ones,
the 19th president, Rutherford B. Hayes.
Terms like voter fraud and contested election are very relevant today.
We see those in the newspaper all the time, especially within the last few years.
But these are not new phenomena.
There have been contested elections far back in American history.
For instance, one of the most hotly debated presidential elections
was that for the 19th president of the United States.
President Rutherford B. Hayes won in the 1876 election,
marking the 100-year anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
Running as a Republican, he did not win the popular vote.
By a very small margin, his Democratic opponent beat him
for 50.6% of the popular vote.
However, the electoral college would be the deciding factor.
Nevertheless, Rutherford received 20 less electoral votes
in the original election counting.
This was where the controversial part came,
because many people felt that those 20 votes were not properly counted
or properly assigned.
Hence, this hotly contested election.
The matter ended up going to the House of Representatives,
as was described in the Constitution.
And it came so close that when Hayes boarded the train
to go to Washington on March 1st,
because at that point March 4th was the day that new presidents were inaugurated,
he wasn't even sure whether he would in fact be inaugurated.
It wasn't until a compromise was reached
that any sort of a conclusion could be found.
You see, the different members of the House of Representatives
had to decide which way they were going to vote.
If they voted along regular party lines,
Hayes would become president.
But the only way that this could be reached
and that the Southerners could be appeased
was to reach a compromise regarding the post-Civil War situation.
After the war, the situation was known as Reconstruction,
and that was the way the country was built up.
Naturally, the Southerners didn't have quite as many rights as they did before,
because there needed to be some sort of punishment or at least overseeing.
After all, one of the main points of the Reconstruction
was granting rights of citizenship and voting to former slaves.
The Southerners were still not so keen on granting such rights
to the former slaves and the newly freed black Americans.
To achieve this final peaceful decision,
which would become known as the Compromise of 1877,
Hayes agreed to remove all the remaining Union forces from the South,
thereby officially ending the Reconstruction era and returning to full peacetime.
And mind you, this was over ten years after the actual end of the Civil War.
But it takes a lot longer to build something up again than it does to tear it down.
In so doing, he was able to achieve the presidency.
But he also received a lot of criticism for this,
because many of his detractors felt he had bargained
or made some kind of a compromise just to win the presidency.
As a result, he gained two unflattering nicknames,
his Fraudulency and Brother Fraud B. Hayes.
Despite this, his presidency was one which couldn't have been much further from fraud.
In fact, he was noted for having a very fair, honourable and dignified time in office.
Hayes was from the state of Ohio.
He was raised by his widowed mother and bachelor uncle,
because his father died two months before he was born.
The young lad would end up studying at Kenyon College
and eventually studying the law for a year
before taking his actual legal training at Harvard University.
After becoming a lawyer, he would begin his law practice in Ohio.
After establishing himself as an excellent lawyer,
during which time he would often defend runaway slaves,
he became part of the Republican Party as an abolitionist.
His family didn't originally hold strong abolitionist beliefs,
although they weren't slave owners,
but it was a combination of this defence of runaway slaves
and the influence of his strong abolitionist wife,
which made him fully adopt the idea that not only was slavery wrong,
which he always held, but that abolition was not too strong a move
and that it was necessary.
When the Civil War broke out,
he volunteered and became commander of the 23rd Regiment in Ohio.
He started out as a major, but before long he became a major general.
In one of his earlier conflicts, he was very badly injured.
As a result, he didn't see too much more combat for a few years,
but then in 1864, he was again in some very dangerous combat
and he actually had four horses killed from underneath him.
He was able to get through the war successfully
and while he was still a soldier in 1864,
he was nominated for Congress.
He refused to campaign for this position,
saying that he thought any soldier who would leave the battlefield
to campaign for some sort of political office should be scalped.
This statement was very well received by civilians and soldiers alike,
proving that he was a true patriot
and it helped elevate him to a position of prominence in the political scene.
He did end up winning that congressional seat
and he would win again in 1866.
He resigned from Congress in 1867
to become the governor of the state of Ohio.
After serving two terms, he briefly resigned and returned to private life
before running again for a third term.
He established himself as a man of great dignity, fairness,
honour and integrity during his years as first a congressman
and then a governor.
After the former General Grant completed his second term in office
and did not successfully run for a third term,
Hayes, who had actually served under him during the Civil War,
was a logical choice to be the next Republican candidate.
This would mark a significant running streak for the Republicans
as he was now the third Republican in a row to win the presidential office.
This was largely because of the Civil War.
It was seen that most of the Democrats were more southern inclined
and were sort of a losing party.
It was strong Republicans like Lincoln and Grant who had won the war
and kept the Union together,
so it's no wonder that they were in a position of prominence at this time.
Once in office, Hayes was able to overcome his initial scandal-ridden entry
and actually turned quite the tide from Grant's situation.
Ulysses Grant's time in office had been noted by a lot of corruption and favour-seeking.
It wasn't necessarily on his part. A lot of it was from people around him.
But to avoid this, Hayes made a strong principle of cleaning up the qualifications
for people who were in positions as civil servants,
removing any kind of spoils system, no favour for a favour,
and instead making sure that people who were in cabinet positions
or other important government jobs truly had earned them.
He helped pull America out of its financial downturn,
which had begun with the Panic of 1873 under Grant's watch,
but not necessarily his fault.
And he strengthened the economic system greatly,
increasing job opportunities for the lower income
and trying to create more of an even playing field
so it wasn't just a system where the wealthy could thrive
while middle and lower classes struggled.
He was a man of very strong moral convictions,
a devout Methodist, and quite a strong member of the temperance movement.
He may not have been a total abstainer himself,
but he shared his wife's views, who was also quite an abstainer,
in believing that temperance was an important part of the Republican Party.
And this was where it became a political issue.
He may have personally indulged in some alcohol within moderation,
it's not known for sure,
but he believed that the dry movement was becoming very prominent
in the American political scene,
and it was very closely aligned with the Republican Party.
He thought that the Republican Party could easily be divided
if the whole group didn't take a strong stance in favour of temperance.
Thus, the White House became dry under his watch.
Many people said that it was his wife Lucy who advocated this,
but it is now believed that it was in fact President Hayes
who made this standard practice.
It may have been because of one of the first political banquets
given under his watch, which was in April of 1877,
it was to honour a Russian dignitary, Alexei Alexandrovich,
and apparently there were six glasses of different types of wine
at each place setting at this feast.
Originally the idea was to just ban hard liquor but allow wine
because foreign dignitaries seemed to expect it.
Apparently this was a rather noteworthy event.
I think some of his political allies were shocked to see that wine was being served,
and I believe one of the Russian dignitaries, perhaps Alexandrovich himself,
overindulged significantly on that event.
So after that there was a strict alcohol ban during his time in the White House.
Although the Reconstruction era had officially ended by this point,
Hayes continued to work for the rights of the freemen,
those freed slaves, and to promote equality among the races
in the United States at that time.
He had earlier voted on the 14th Amendment,
which was one of the constitutional amendments which granted rights to former slaves,
and he continued to advocate for equality,
although partly because of the Compromise of 1877,
many of the southern democratic political leaders were imposing Jim Crow laws
and increasing segregation in the South
in a way that was not what Lincoln, Grant, or Hayes had hoped would be the post-Civil War situation.
Some of his less favorable actions during his time in office include the Chinese Expulsion Act.
Many people felt that the economic downturn from the Panic of 1873
was largely because of the Chinese immigrant workers on the West Coast,
who were, they claimed, taking jobs away from white American laborers,
and he effectively banned some immigration,
which was later viewed as a rather un-American action,
going against the principal core beliefs of the United States
that it's supposed to be a place where all immigrants can come
and to not target any particular racial group.
And the other less glowing moment in his presidency
was during the railroad strike,
when he sent actual federal militia to settle it down,
and they started firing on civilians,
and around 70 citizens were killed.
Of course, all of these incidents, whether good or bad, under any president's term,
were rarely a unilateral decision.
There always are checks and balances and public pressure,
opinions from many different people, which lead to any action being taken.
Hayes was a great pioneer of technical advancements,
and as a result, he brought a lot of new inventions to the White House,
thus introducing them to the rest of the country.
It was under his watch that a primitive telephone
was first installed in the White House.
Running water was also installed in the White House
for the first time while he was president.
He oversaw a demonstration of a recording machine by Thomas Edison,
and he also had a phonograph in the White House for the first time.
He and Mrs. Hayes were the first presidential couple
to visit the West Coast during his presidency,
and in 1878, while president, he helped mediate a dispute
between two South American countries,
leading to his being the namesake of a region in Paraguay,
which was one of the two countries.
When he took office, he had declared that he would only serve one term,
and he stuck to that.
After leaving the White House in 1881,
he returned to his home in Ohio,
but he remained very active in public service
by being involved in the state and county government of his area,
serving on the board of trustees at a university in his area,
and continuing to advocate for equal rights of the races
and improved education.
He strongly felt that one of the best ways to raise
the moral tone of the whole country was to increase education,
because he believed that ignorance often led to crime
and to many of the other ills which our country was facing.
His home was later turned into the first presidential memorial library.
Hayes took his role as president very seriously,
declaring,
the president of the United States should strive to be always mindful
of the fact that he serves his party best and serves his country best.
He also said that conscience is the authentic voice of God to you,
and he always tried to follow his conscience in serving his country,
serving in the military field, in Congress,
and eventually in the White House.
He believed that the individual was very important
for the survival of the country,
and that voting was a big part of that.
Perhaps that's why he thought it was so important
for all races to be able to vote.
And he declared,
to vote is like the payment of a debt,
a duty never to be neglected if its performance is possible.
Speaking about his personal politics,
he stated,
I am radical in thought and principle,
and a conservative in method and conduct.
It's interesting to note the term conservative
was taken quite differently then than it is now,
meaning now it tends to align with traditionalism,
whereas at that time,
it meant more what it literally means,
to be more sparing with things,
to be a bit cautious.
Conserving, as opposed to be liberal,
would mean to be more generous,
more free and open with things.
And of course, the terms liberal and conservative,
as they're used now,
do still to a degree align with those,
but some of the views which are held to be conservative now
would be quite radical, really,
compared to what other people think.
And I think that what Mr. Hayes said
sort of represents that.
He was radical in the fact that he was very strong
on the points of abolition,
even before it was really a popular thing to do,
and temperance.
And in so doing, he helped establish even stronger
what the Republican Party's beliefs would be
going forward from that point.
I think of all the presidential names I've encountered,
Rutherford B. Hayes is the one which is the most obscure to me.
Every time I see his name,
I say, there was a president named Hayes?
Rutherford B. Hayes?
Partly because his first name was so unusual.
You don't meet many people named Rutherford today.
But despite this anonymity, at least to me,
I find him to be an excellent member of our history,
and a very important figure
in the hall of records of American citizens.
He was very important in the efforts of rebuilding the country
after the Civil War,
and of course he also played an important role in the Civil War.
As a combination of a good statesman, a good soldier,
and a good politician who put public service ahead of mere party politics,
he is an excellent example of what it means to be a good citizen.
And I think that his life deserves more recognition,
and that his legacy should be better researched.
Thank you for spending this time with me,
and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.