The mid-19th century in America was a time of new ideas, deep reflection, and philosophical exploration. Among its most distinctive voices was Henry David Thoreau.
In this episode of American Legends, Tiffany Brannan explores the life and thought of Henry David Thoreau, a writer, naturalist, and one of the central figures of the Transcendentalist movement.
Born in 1817 in Concord, Massachusetts, Thoreau was shaped by a close intellectual community that included Ralph Waldo Emerson and other leading thinkers of the American Renaissance.
He is best known for two enduring works:
• Walden — a reflection on simple living and self-reliance • Civil Disobedience — an essay exploring the individual’s relationship to government
Through these writings, Thoreau examined questions that remain relevant today:
• What does it mean to live simply? • How should individuals respond to injustice? • What is the balance between independence and community?
His experiment at Walden Pond — living in a small cabin and recording his daily life — became a lasting symbol of the search for independence, even while remaining connected to the world around him.
At the same time, his ideas on peaceful resistance influenced later figures such as Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr.
This episode explores:
• the life of Henry David Thoreau • the ideas of Transcendentalism • the story behind Walden • the meaning of Civil Disobedience • his influence on later social movements
Discover the story of Henry David Thoreau, whose writings continue to shape discussions of nature, freedom, and individual responsibility.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
in our daily lives. The 1840s and 50s were a time of great philosophy and intellectual
change in the United States. During a time period that's been come to be called the American
Renaissance, some of the foremost thinkers of the young nation gathered together, particularly in
the New England area, to exchange ideas influenced by old works like the great writings of ancient
Roman Greece or the Renaissance, as well as new ideas about social justice and the equality of
man. Many writers associated with this time period include people like Ralph Waldo Emerson,
Henry David Thoreau, and even more fiction writers like Louisa May Alcott and Nathaniel Hawthorne.
However, it's the non-fiction writers whom we remember most associated with this period because
their writings, whether essays or narratives, explain the true ideology behind this movement.
In particular, Henry David Thoreau penned some of the most famous works which continue to define
esoteric thinking. Nevertheless, this side of him, talking about causes of justice and individual
personhood, are just one side of his literary output. He also was a great poet and a very
creative thinker. Henry David Thoreau is remembered for penning some of the most
famous literature on transcendental ideology, including his essay Civil Disobedience and his
narrative about his stay by Walden Pond. However, this part of his identity as the champion for the
causes of the underprivileged was only one side of his personality, yet it's the side which is most
commonly remembered. Thoreau is often recalled as the proto-anarchist, meaning that long before
anarchy was really a mainstay here in the United States, he and other similar thinkers
were, shall I say, promoting ideas of not necessarily outright rebelling against the
government, but gently and peacefully resisting it if it was believed to be unjust. Thoreau was born
on July 12, 1817 in Concord, Massachusetts. He would spend most of his life in this area,
eventually dying at the age of 44 in the same city. He was one of four children, including two
sisters and a younger brother. He was very close with both his sisters, older sister Helen and
younger sister Sophia, and they shared a great community of feelings in terms of the sensitive,
poetic nature they shared. His father was a pencil manufacturer, and throughout his life Thoreau
would engage in the family business of making pencils, often perfecting it by combining
graphite with clay in different ways to make a more cost-effective pencil. As a young man,
Thoreau went to college at Harvard, and there he studied the typical fields such as literature,
history, theology, the classic languages, but afterwards he found that he didn't want to go
into some of the more typical businesses which one typically would pursue after college, including
religion, history, medicine, law. He was interested in literature, which wasn't deemed the most
legitimate profession at the time, more something that one would do on the side. So he took to
teaching, the most common profession of those who were literarily minded. He and his brother John
started a school, but they quickly got into trouble because of the rather independent thinking
which Thoreau already was embracing, such as not wanting to administer corporal punishment. The
school was badly sidetracked when John died quite young of tetanus. That left his brother, who was
originally named David Henry but after college changed his name to Henry David, to scramble
around trying to figure out exactly what to do. He did continue teaching in several different
fields, and eventually he found his mentor and the person who would really bring him into the
right circles in Ralph Waldo Emerson. Emerson was 14 years older than Thoreau, and he took on the
role of a father figure to him for a good deal of his life. Emerson was a more established figure
in the New Transcendental Movement, which flourished in the New England area
beginning in the late 1830s. He was one of the founders of what was called the Transcendental
Club, and it included thinkers such as Amos Bronson Alcott, who was the father of little
women author Louisa May, as well as other great literary women like all of the Peabody sisters
or Margaret Fuller. These ladies and gentlemen were philosophers, publishers, and literary
critics, so Emerson found a good deal of community in their society. Nevertheless, he often wanted to
spend a lot of time by himself, and he struggled between the need for human companionship and the
desire to simply be on his own. Now, what exactly is Transcendentalism? It's a bit hard to define.
It mainly was an ideology which prioritized individualism and self-reliance above being part
of a community. Now, on the flip side of that, the Transcendentalists were very close in their
own communities, such as gathering at Elizabeth Peabody's bookstore and sharing ideas there at
her salons, or having schools such as Amos Bronson Alcott started the Temple School,
where many other leading Transcendentalists taught or studied. They also occasionally started
different utopian communes. Again, Alcott was quite involved with that, such as Fruitvale,
and there they would all share it farming together. So, in a way, it was individualism
and self-reliance through the support of a community, and you certainly see that in Thoreau's
own life, as he often relied on the spiritual as well as financial and material support
of Emerson. For instance, one of the most vivid examples of the Transcendental
self-reliance would be the experiment of Walden Pond. Thoreau spent an extended period of time
living in a little hut he built on the banks of Walden Pond in the middle of the woods,
attempting to be self-reliant. He kept a record of all the supplies he had, how he built that hut,
and how he tried to live, basically separate from society. Of course, he didn't go to visit
his sisters, and they would come to visit him. But the irony of the situation was that Walden
Pond was on property owned by Emerson, so Thoreau's very individualism and self-reliance was
based on relying on another person, Emerson in this case, and he lived with Emerson and his
family for quite a bit of time, tutoring his children and learning from Emerson's thinking
himself. Another core principle of Transcendentalism was beliefs which would later become known as
civil rights, social justice, basically taking the American principle that all men are created equal
to a farther extent than it was legally recognized at the time, such as believing in the evil of
slavery and its necessary abolition, or the equality of women. Many early feminists in America
were part of the Transcendental Movement, and those conversations and lectures at Elizabeth
Peabody's bookstore with people like Margaret Fuller are considered the earliest seeds of
the feminist movement in the United States. Although these ladies weren't actively campaigning
for the right to vote, what they really wanted was the right to be considered as equals intellectually,
to have a voice in the conversation, and they certainly did in the Transcendental Movement.
One of Thoreau's key principles in life and in his, I don't want to say political, but his
sort of social view of the world was that if you disagree with something that the government is
doing, or you find that it's against the core principles of Americanism, you have the right
to not go along with it, or to not support it passively. He most famously expressed these ideas
in his famous essay, Civil Disobedience. This idea began as a series of lectures he gave in 1848,
which he called the Rights and Duties of the Individual in Relation to Government. He was
inspired to give these lectures after spending a night in jail because he didn't pay his poll taxes
for six years. He later revised this series of lectures into an essay which was called Resistance
to Civil Government. It was published in May 1849 in The Aesthetic Papers, a Transcendentalist
publication by Elizabeth Peabody. This is what is now known as Civil Disobedience. It was later
renamed that when it was published years after his death. And the ideas which he expressed in Civil
Disobedience inspired countless members of the Civil Rights Movement in the 20th century and
other social reformers. Probably the two most famous people who cited being inspired by it are
Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. They both said that they were very inspired by his
writings in that essay, which in some ways seemed very modern even over a hundred years later, even
150 years later. The two main points of contention for Thoreau at that point were slavery and the
Mexican-American War. One of the main points he expressed, which was held by most Transcendentalists,
was that it was sheer hypocrisy for any American to talk about equality and liberty as long as
a large part of the population lived in slavery in the South. And he especially held Northerners who
were in more a state of apathy and indifference responsible. Unlike the Southerners who were
actively involved in slavery, many people in the North no longer practiced it themselves or perhaps
never had, yet they believed that just ignoring it was the lesser of two evils. Likewise, with the
Mexican-American War, he believed that it was a clear case of a stronger nation invading a weaker
nation, the United States invading Mexico, for no good cause and that it was a completely unjust
situation. So he argued that anyone who paid taxes was supporting these two issues, whether he
personally agreed with it or not. The writing in that work goes back and forth between seeming
just very intellectual and innocuous and seeming quite inflammatory and even treasonous. Nevertheless,
he never denounced the very core of Americanism. He always seemed to believe in that. As I said,
we tend to remember him for that work and for Walden Pond, yet that's just a fraction of all
his writings and it's just one side of the Transcendental Movement. The other side of Thoreau
and the movement which he represents was one of loving nature, searching for the beauty in life,
and ultimately, prizing individualism so that the beauty of one's individual nature can shine.
In contrast to some stricter forms of Christianity in the United States at the time,
Transcendentalists didn't believe in the fallen nature of man but in the inherent goodness of the
instead believing that society corrupts, hence the promotion of returning to nature,
living in the country rather than the city, and gentle education so that children would be
educated to be gentle, kind, intelligent, creative people rather than trained to be part of a system.
One of his more beautiful writings was an essay he penned near the end of his life called
In it, he talked about the sheer but often overlooked joy of walking around in nature
in the middle of the night, being guided by the moon rather than the sun, and how even the
simplest landscape becomes a wonderland when viewed with the shadows of the moon and with
the stars as a guide. In it, he shows his very vast and impressive literary background as he
quotes poems of writers anywhere from the Renaissance to ancient times, and he references
mythology as well as scripture and saints of old, again showing how he truly was a Renaissance man
and how this time period was not merely one of civil disobedience, a rebellion, but also one
of a great enjoyment of literature, music, art, and poetry. Although best known as a man of letters,
Thoreau was also a musician, and he enjoyed simple music, particularly which he liked to play on the
flute, which seems to have been a very popular instrument at that time period. He and his sisters
enjoyed sharing music together. There's been a lot of speculation about Thoreau's love life because
he never married, nor is he known to have had any particular woman in his life, but like many members
of this ideological movement, I think he most likely was so in love with the idea of romance
and certain philosophies about life that it would be difficult to find a real human being in daily
life who could live up to such ideas. In his life, Thoreau wrote many different poems, but one of the
finest of them is called Away, Away, Away, Away. It begins with these first few lines,
Away, away, away, away, ye have not kept your secret well, I will abide that other day, those other lands
ye tell. Has time no leisure left for these, the acts that ye rehearse? Is not eternity a lease
for better deeds than verse? He goes on to talk about the heroes of old and the springs of fame,
combining poetic musings on nature with dealings on the temporal nature of earthly fame.
He also references his religious struggles, as most transcendentalists had, as they wrestled with
the Christian background with which they were raised, yet the new philosophical ideas they
were embracing. None of them wanted to completely abandon the idea of God, that's why many of the
leading transcendentalists were Unitarians, which was viewed as a gentler, milder form of Christianity.
Nevertheless, in this poem he talks about even wrestling with an angel, concluding that if he
should defeat the angel, tell heaven not to spare, for I will be her champion new, her fame I will
repair. I think in that he's referring to the idea that perhaps the heavenly principles, which
were originally intended by the Bible and the scriptures of old, had been changed by mankind
over the years, and that a new form of philosophical ideas would replace it. Similarly to how he
believed that those who would gently rebel against the government were actually greater
champions of Americanism than those who blindly followed it. If you're in the wrong light, I think
that writings by people like Thoreau and even Emerson could be a bit un-American or even
anarchistic, but they are very informative in showing us, really, that the concerns we have
today are not new ideas. It's easy to look around and see the problems in our government, in our
political system, in our society, in our education, and even in our religion, and say, oh, we have all
these problems today. If only we could live in some other time period. Yet to study the writings
of different individuals in said time periods, we see that people have always had similar concerns.
While different time periods may have prized traditional values that now are being laid by
the wayside, there always has been a sense of abandoning the principles which were good in
the past or that mankind does want to corrupt things which began as being good. Ultimately,
there is great wisdom which can be gleaned from the Transcendentalist movement, primarily the
idea that one must take responsibility for one's own actions and that there is great creativity
to be found in the individual. Perhaps Thoreau's life and writings can be summed up in some of the
quotes he wrote, such as saying that life is frittered away by detail. Simplify, simplify.
Indeed, today we could take his example, at least with a grain of salt, of seeking to return to
a simpler life and find the beauty of nature to inspire us as well as great art. Thank you
for spending this time with me. I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.