Before photography, the only way to preserve a person’s likeness was through art. In early America, this responsibility fell to a small group of skilled portrait painters.
In this episode of American Legends, Tiffany Brannan explores the life of Charles Willson Peale, one of the most important portrait artists of the Revolutionary era.
Born in 1741 in Maryland, Peale rose from modest beginnings to become a leading painter of his time. Through determination and self-education, he developed his craft and eventually studied in England before returning to the American colonies.
He is best known for painting portraits of many of the nation’s early leaders, including George Washington, helping to shape how future generations would see the figures of the American Revolution.
But Peale’s contributions went far beyond portraiture. He was also:
• a soldier in the Revolutionary War • a member of the Pennsylvania legislature • a founder of one of America’s first museums • an early supporter of scientific study and natural history
Through his museum work, he collected and displayed animals, fossils, and artifacts, including one of the earliest reconstructions of a mastodon skeleton in the United States.
Peale believed that art and science both played a role in educating the public, and he dedicated his life to making knowledge more accessible.
This episode explores:
• the life of Charles Willson Peale • portrait painting in early America • his connection to the American Revolution • the creation of early American museums • his influence on art, science, and education
Discover the story of Charles Willson Peale, whose work helped preserve the faces and spirit of early America.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
In the late 18th century, some of the greatest artists were creating their masterpieces.
Meanwhile, the New World, the American colonies, were engulfed in a fight for freedom from
England, so they didn't have much time for creating recreational works of art. Nevertheless,
the New World was fascinated with these key figures whose images were worth immortalizing.
Since this was several decades before the advent of photography, the only way to capture someone's
likeness was through portraiture. Thus, portrait painters were very valuable artists. Though not
as lauded as more creative painters who would create religious works or fanciful pieces of art,
these skilled artists provided a very useful service by capturing the accurate likeness
of important figures of the day. One American painter in particular was one of the foremost
portrait painters directly before, during, and after the American Revolution, as well as being
a passionate patriot himself and the father of a large group of other artists. There aren't many
American artists from the earlier part of America's history whose names are really well known.
While we certainly know of the writers or other artisans of that time period,
many of the great political thinkers, yet the names of those early painters aren't well known
like their European counterparts. Nevertheless, their work speaks for itself, and I think anyone
familiar with basic American history will recognize the work of such men as Charles Wilson
Peale. He was born in Maryland in 1741. His father fled England because he was a bit of a criminal,
having been a forger and a thief, although he did come from a rather aristocratic background.
Upon fleeing to the New World, he hoped to become part of the landed gentry in America,
but he never was able to gain sufficient wealth to become a slave owner or purchase land. Thus,
he spent most of his life in America as a schoolteacher, and he had only 50 pounds to
his name when he died. His son Charles was only eight years old when he died,
and Mr. Peale Sr. left a wife and four children. At the age of 13, young Charles was apprenticed
to a saddle maker, and he learned this trade, but he later referred to it as servitude,
so he wasn't too keen on the art of saddlery. By the time he was 21 years old,
Peale had established himself as a saddler in his own right. He went to Norfolk, Virginia,
to get some leather and other supplies for his saddlery business, and while there, he happened
to observe some artists, some painters, and he was disgusted by their poor technique.
He thought to himself, I can do better than that, so he began studying painting. He observed the
work of some local painters when he returned to the town where he was living, and he also studied
a book on painting, Handmade to the Arts by Robert Dossey, which taught him some basic techniques
and what supplies were needed. After gaining some basic technique of his own, he went to one
of the foremost portrait painters of the day, John Heselius, and he traded him a fine saddle
with all of its furnishings in exchange for three lessons, which he observed in his studio. He
watched him painting a portrait, and he learned through these sessions. After this training,
he began advertising in a publication that in addition to his saddle business,
he could do some sign painting. Now, this was in the early 1760s, and he had a few other businesses
along the way. He tried his saddlery for a while. He fixed clocks, but by his early 20s, he really
began realizing that he enjoyed painting, particularly portrait painting, more than
anything else he had tried, and he found it to be his life's work. So he studied with all the local
painters he could find, and eventually, he pooled his resources so he could go to England, where he
studied with Benjamin West. Along the way, he painted portraits of just about anyone he could
find, both in the old world and the new, and he began to be quite renowned as a painter. Meanwhile,
before he left the United States, which wasn't the United States yet, he began to have interest
in something besides art, namely politics. In 1764, he joined the Sons of Liberty, which was a
political organization in the 13 colonies that would eventually become the forerunner to the
revolution in 1776. Many of the founding fathers were part of this group, and it was basically
a group which could be peaceful and could be rather violent, but which advocated
the independence, or at least the potential independence, of the colonists, particularly
pinpointing the phrase that there shouldn't be taxation without representation. So Peale was
interested in this. He was opposed to the government overreach, you could say, of England in Maryland,
and he was interested in these new thoughts that were circulating in the new world.
So he went to England, he learned how to paint better, he came back, and he was becoming a very
successful portrait painter. In the early 1770s, he married a woman named Rachel, and they began
having children. Because of his interest in art, he would name just about all his children after
renowned artistic masters, having children with names like Raphael, Rubens, Rembrandt, Titian,
and even his daughters had names which were inspired by artists, or some other kind of
creative individual, because he also had interest in science. So he named a few of his children
after more scientifically minded people. In 1771, he painted his first portrait of an important
rising leader in the colonies, George Washington. But a few years later, he would do more than
paint him. As he was sitting for him, he would end up fighting alongside Washington. As the
revolution was stirring, Peale relocated to Philadelphia, which was the capital of the
colonies at the time, so that he could be right in the middle of all that activity. As the revolution
was coming to a head, he joined the Pennsylvania militia, and he fought in some of the foremost
battles of the revolution. After the revolution, as the new country was being established, Peale
became involved in the Pennsylvania legislature, taking a slight interest in politics, while also
resuming his more peaceful activity of portraiture. He painted hundreds of portraits throughout his
life, having some of the greatest leaders of the country sitting for him, including several
of the early presidents, and other political leaders, as well as people who aren't so famous,
just important individuals in the colony. He made a good living from painting these portraits,
painting replicas of these portraits, and then painting more portraits inspired by his own
portraits. For instance, he painted seven portraits of George Washington, which were from sittings by
the eventual first president of the United States, but he would paint 60 portraits in all of Washington
based on those seven sittings. Basically, all those portraits of Washington are very recognizable in
some of the best-known depictions of the president. One of them, in particular, was Washington at
Princeton, which he painted in 1779, and this painting would sell in 2005 for 21.3 million
dollars, which is the most ever paid for an American portrait. It was sold to Yale University,
which is sort of ironic because it's Washington at Princeton. Although he was a great artist and
renowned portraitist, whose work is instantly recognizable to just about any American citizen,
that was just one of his many talents. He had a very wide variety of interests, including
in the sciences. He was a self-taught taxidermist who stuffed many of the wide range of interesting
animals to be found in New England, particularly birds, and he began establishing some of the first
museums in the United States, such as the Philadelphia Museum, and he displayed all the
different types of animals which he could find and taxidermically stuff, but he wanted more than that.
He also wanted examples of other continents, so he had a correspondence with museums back in England
and he traded stuffed birds from North America for an equal amount of stuffed birds from England,
so that he could have a wider variety in his collection. He believed that North America had
the greatest diversity of animals compared to other continents, and he used his taxidermy
and his different paleontological studies to try to prove that. For instance, he believed that
mammoths, which are called mastodons today, were to be found in North America and even still were
the northernmost part of North America, which would be modern-day Canada. He believed that they
still were wandering around at that point, and he went on what's considered really the first
scientific expedition in the United States to collect these mastodon bones and reproduce this
mammoth in a museum. He used three-dimensional technology of putting together these bones,
similar to how dinosaur fossils are displayed today, so that you could really see the size of
these great animals. He studied them, he wrote about them, he started these museums. He often
funded them himself, as a lot of his museums and other display endeavors failed because he wasn't
able to get the government funding he'd hoped. Shows that that was something people tried and
failed to do back then too, but that never stopped him. If one thing didn't work out,
he'd just try something new. And he also studied a lot of other sciences. He was a true renaissance
man, considered second only to Benjamin Franklin in terms of being a renaissance man of the
colonies. He also did a lot of writing, and he inspired his whole family to have similar endeavors.
Artists aren't known for having extremely lucrative careers, although he, as a portrait
painter, probably made more money than people who just painted for art's sake. Yet he was able to
over the course of his life support three wives and 16 children. Of course, he did not have three
wives at the same time. He was happily married to Rachel at first, and together they had 10 children.
She ended up dying, so then the next year he married another woman of Dutch descent,
whose name was Elizabeth. Sadly, after having six children, she also died, at which point he married
a Quaker woman named Hannah. She didn't have any children, but she helped him raise his younger
children from the two previous wives. And of course, by this point, many of his children from
his first wife were long grown. For instance, he had two sons whom he named Titian after the
great painter. The one son sadly died at the age of 18, so when he had another son the next year,
he named him Titian II. But for that era, many of his children survived to adulthood,
since out of his 16, around 10 of them lived long and very successful lives. And a remarkable amount
of those children became very famous and respected artists in their own right, including ironically
mostly the sons who were named after famous painters. Ruben, Raphael, and Rembrandt all
were successful painters, but each one used his art in a different way. One became a portrait
painter. One is considered the first landscape painter in America. Another one was more of a
museum founder. He also had children, both male and female, who were ornithologists.
So you can see that he provided opportunities but also great inspiration for his children. He was
a truly loving and caring father and an excellent husband. In his later years, he also was a farmer.
He purchased a plantation, a property known as Belfield, and there he experimented with different
growing methods and cultivated the land, which was a true pleasure for him. Without a doubt,
the most high-profile and recognizable contributions of Charles Wilson Peale are the
excellent and highly realistic portraits which he created of the founding fathers of America.
Without the work of brilliant and skilled men like Peale, we would have no idea what people like
George Washington looked like. But because of the many different portraits he painted and other
individuals, we get to see how even with a bit of artistic license and human frailty of painting,
we have a very accurate idea of what Washington and other similar men looked like because we see
the consistent features across the different paintings. Washington was indeed very happy with
Peale's work. He considered him a personal friend and he respected him as a patriot as well as an
excellent artist. You can see how by going to Europe and training himself and just studying
meticulously on his own, Peale became a better painter. For instance, if you look at the portraits
of his first main teacher, John Heselius, you'll see just how much better the technique is of Peale.
It's so realistic with the excellent brushwork and depth of painting colors and light that it
really looks like a photograph. He would use symbolism as well, but ultimately he wasn't trying
to be famous or to be really creative. He was just trying to make a good portrait and he did a
good job of that. He's considered a proponent of the trompe l'oeil method, which is a form of oil
painting, and he's really one of the main examples of such painting from the United States. Charles
Peale lived a long and happy life, eventually dying in 1827, having seen his beloved new nation
go through several presidents and establish itself as one of the foremost powers of the world
in the early 19th century, surviving a few different wars and proving that it had the
stuff needed to prevail and be very successful. He also saw his children become successful artists
and other leading citizens of the new nation. Through his excellent artistry and accurate
portraiture, Charles Wilson Peale is an example of the dual natures which existed in Americans.
True, he was a creative individual, an artist, yet he was a great example of the American dream in that
he didn't come from affluence. He didn't have a very good background. His father was a common
crook. He didn't have a good education. In his early letters, you can see that he had terrible
spelling, capitalizing all over the place, putting random punctuations, since he was very poorly
educated. Yet his writing got better because he read, he studied, and he was almost a self-taught
painter who then realized the need for good techniques, so he got all the education he needed
so he could become one of America's greatest portrait painters. He truly deserves the title
of American legend. Thank you for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time
for more American Legends.