LIVE: Senate Debate on the SAVE Act (Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act)

Live News Network
1.4K followers
228 Video Views·Mar 18, 2026
Senate Debate on the SAVE Act (Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act)
AI Generated·May contain errors
It has been used for a long time now, decades and decades and
decades, as the proof of who you say you are.
Why?
Because your signature can be traced.
I always find this very interesting in our state,
because it's not that fraud hasn't been committed.
The question is whether you're going to catch fraud.
In an incident in our state where we had a very close election, and
it got down to several votes, people started admitting
that they had voted for somebody who was dead or deceased.
Why? Because they knew we were going to catch them,
because it was based on your signature.
So a man who votes for his wife after she's died, to say she was really
enthusiastic about that governor's candidate and really would have wanted to
vote for him, but died before the election and didn't cast her own ballot.
Yes, that does not count, and we have caught voter fraud.
So the point is, is that states already verify that identity.
They do it, as I said, when you register in a registrant,
it says right on the registrant card, if you are not a US citizen, stop right now.
Stop right now.
It also, at the voter place, where it is checking your identification,
also, you have to say that you are a US citizen.
Now you can say many things about what kind of identification is used, but
I like this best because we are a vote by mail state, as my colleague from Utah is.
And we have very high turnouts, as does Utah.
And what does it take to make sure that you are a US citizen in
the state of Washington?
So every ballot, just like mine, that's from a few years ago,
says read the declaration.
It says right here, I can hardly miss this.
This is the outside envelope.
Read the declaration, sign and date below.
So I have to sign this again,
which is matched with my signature at the voter's office.
It is on a computer with voters,
basically witnesses, looking at my signature.
And in my state, they are trained by the state patrol to make sure
that signature matches the original signature that you signed up with.
Now, what I like most about this is right above where I have to sign this,
this little attestation with these words on it.
I know you can't hardly read them, so
I'm gonna make it a little larger for you to understand the whole thing.
It says, I do solemnly swear under penalty of perjury,
I am a United States citizen.
It says it right there.
Every time you vote in the state of Washington, you are attesting to that.
But the bottom part is what I think is most amazing.
Punishable by declaration of a maximum of imprisonment of five years or
$10,000 in fine.
And somehow people on this side of the aisle think that immigrants who won't
even go to the healthcare system, won't even go to the grocery store,
are afraid to take their kids to school.
And somehow you think they are signing up for
a felony or $10,000 or imprisonment of five years?
No, they're not doing that.
Because this system is checked, it's validated, it's verified.
You have to attest to it.
And so we have very, very, very, very, very, very little fraud.
And when we do, we catch it.
So the point is, why are we doing this today?
Why are we changing a system that has been in place for decades and
replacing it?
Because my colleagues say the trend is going in the wrong direction,
which is simply not true.
When you look at this, the SAVE Act, instead of basically protecting our system
for decades, could disenfranchise over 21 million people.
That is why you've seen this out here because it's been estimated by many
people, think about this, when this goes to the president's desk,
it's implemented immediately this year.
It means that you have to start producing additional paperwork.
What my colleague failed to tell you is that the system is based on
all the verification up front, when you are registered and
when you give your signature and identification.
And election day is about having the ease of going to vote
based on the fact you have already been identified.
But my colleagues would like to throw a big wrench in that and
make you find all sorts of documentations in the most unworkable chaos
I have ever seen in a system put in a bill.
It is simply not true that this is about ease of voting by them.
It is about disenfranchising millions of people and
making it very hard for them to vote.
Why do they wanna do that?
I don't know.
Frankly, I don't really know why they think that's a good idea.
I will tell you what my former Republican Secretary of State,
who served more than a decade, said to me in a statement.
Quote, neither the President nor
Congress should be in the business of micromanaging elections.
As a longtime Republican administrator official, I adamantly support
our nation's constitutional framers' decision
that the election process be decentralized to states.
Following, he says, quote, I oppose the SAVE Act.
It gives the federal government new powers of discretionary regulation.
It empowers ideologues to sue election administrators.
It forces states to turn over voter rolls to federal overseers.
It abolishes vote-by-mail, the preferred system in Washington,
Oregon, Colorado, Utah, Hawaii, Nevada, and Vermont.
In my experience, vote-by-mail best fits the modern lifestyles.
More important, it provides the opportunities for
voters to become better informed before casting their ballots.
He continues by saying, I subscribe to my party's fundamental and
historic commitment to local control.
It is a time-honored Republican principle
that government closest to the people is best.
This is importantly includes the conduct of elections, end quote.
Now maybe that is why the senior senator from Kentucky is voting with us on this
side of the issue, because he understands what state rights are about.
States' rights are about running elections, so a demagogue or
somebody in the level of government cannot force the federal government
to say who's eligible to vote and who's not eligible to vote.
The notion that we would turn this over to DHS is preposterous.
In the notion that I had a constituent who basically got denied a Social Security
check because someone said he was dead, even though he went to the federal
building to the Social Security Administration and said, I'm not dead.
They had already ripped the check out of his, basically, bank account.
He basically then proceeded for
three weeks to continue to tell them he was not dead.
He showed up in other places in person.
He was on national TV, and did they get his check back?
No, it took him months.
Now, let's say that the federal government says the same thing about you and
the voter rolls on election day.
What are you gonna do then?
What are you gonna do on election day?
Not have a vote?
What are you gonna do?
Say, no, it's me, I'm right here.
But they're gonna say, no, you were dead, you're not on my rolls, you can't vote.
I don't care how long you've lived at that address, I don't care, you're gone.
I am not turning that over to the federal government.
And our constitutional founders did not want that turned over
to the federal government.
They saw mischief then, and believe me, the SAVE Act is mischief now.
This, as the League of Women Voters, the ultimate organization for
finding and pursuing policy to get people in America to vote,
basically said this about the SAVE Act.
It is a coordinated effort to make voting harder for eligible Americans.
Now, if you can't trust the League of Women Voters here,
I don't know who you can trust.
Because they're the ones who have had an organization that is about nothing but
getting people to participate in elections.
They are not Democrat, they're not Republican,
they basically are a great organization that hold all of us accountable.
And they basically do not like the SAVE Act.
This is why part of this effort is about protecting states and
protecting our rights.
As I said, our constitutional fathers have basically said,
this is what we should be doing.
And this is why here now, turning this over, I object to the fact that
the Homeland Security is gonna collect personal information,
demanding that a Secretary of State turn that personal information
over to them for a massive database by the federal government.
I object to that.
I am not turning personal information over to people
who just have other things to pursue.
Or maybe it's gonna be like Doge, and they're gonna sell it to other
organizations and make money off of our personal information.
I object to that.
But now, if basically a Secretary of State or
an auditor basically doesn't agree with Homeland Security,
what are they gonna do?
This bill also has a private right of action,
to say that you can sue them on a private right of action.
So now we're gonna create all of this chaos and mischief at a level
when somehow Homeland Security, which they've gotten it wrong before,
on the vote on information about who and
what information the federal government has got it wrong before.
Now, all of a sudden, you're gonna get it wrong again.
And what are you going to do?
So as I mentioned, Sam Reid, he's not the only Republican I've talked to.
We had a Republican on a press conference today who was an auditor.
There are Republicans standing up.
I don't see any Democrats agreeing with you on the SAVE Act.
But I see lots of Republicans across America agreeing with us
that it's a bad bill.
But as Sam Reid said, former Republican Secretary of State for a long time,
quote, neither the President nor
Congress should be in the business of micromanaging elections.
Why, why?
It's never been given to us.
Well, let's talk about this.
My colleague seems to think that there's a trend going in some direction.
Okay, what's the trend?
Because the Heritage Foundation, a group I'm pretty sure you believe in,
pretty sure you quote them a lot, basically said in my state since 1982,
since 1982 till now, there have been 15 cases of voter fraud.
Okay, in our state, in the state of Washington, 15 cases.
Okay, so hardly, hardly a big trend moving in the other direction.
Hardly a big trend.
Similar, the Heritage Foundation found that in the United States of America,
that non-citizen voter fraud is basically 0.00007.
So that turns out to be seven millionth of a percent.
It's not 1%, it's not 0.1%, it's basically 0.00007.
So seven millionth of 1% voter fraud in the United States of America,
based on the system that we have today.
And you wanna propose a system that would disenfranchise
millions of Americans by making it more complicated.
And yes, I don't know why you don't wanna stand up for vote by mail, but
trust me, I'm standing up for vote by mail.
Your last election had 84% turnout in the state of Utah.
You had 90% in 2020, I think that's a prideful thing for a state.
I'm prideful that our state has one of the highest turnouts too.
It's not, it's probably 83% in a presidential election.
I don't remember what exactly it was in the year 2000, but
that's what we strive for in the United States of America,
a voting system where everybody participates.
So when the outcome is something that other people don't like,
you can at least say the American people decided.
But if all of a sudden you start sowing doubt into the system,
then you have a problem.
And that is where President Trump is.
He is saying he wants to eliminate mail-in voting.
But one in three voters in this country use it.
So he's the one who's inspiring my colleagues to write this legislation.
He's the one who's inspiring the details.
He would go much further, I agree, than what the SAVE Act is.
But let's hear what third parties are saying around the United States of America.
Let's hear what editorial boards who read the same judgment,
the same discussions that we've had here, and what have they said?
In my home state where we've had one of the closest elections in
a congressional district,
they basically said the SAVE Act is a threat to our democracy.
What did the Seattle Times say?
It said, Congress should reject the SAVE Act as unconstitutional voter suppression.
That's not Democrats saying that, that's a newspaper saying that.
And what did they say in the Maine Herald?
Maine voters do not wish to be saved by the SAVE Act.
So now we know that third party validators, who pretty are expert in voting,
women like the voters, don't want this.
Newspapers who basically have looked at this issue also are calling this for
what it is, suppression.
And I ask my colleagues to turn this down.
Now, if my colleague wants to continue debate, I will stand here,
as long as you want to stand here to debate this issue.
I will stand here and get more facts and figures to show you that this voting
system today has empowered Americans, has increased opportunities for
Americans to have their votes cast, and
has gotten rid of generations of suppression that existed before.
But if you want me to talk about all the voter suppression that's existed in
the United States, starting with laws that basically disenfranchised
various segments of our population, I'm happy to talk about them.
Because every generation should be about fighting to get the voters to cast a vote,
have a robust democracy, and distinguish the United States of America
from other countries as a beacon of democracy, where free and
fair elections stand, and we are confident about the results.
We don't need the SAVE Act.
It will cause chaos.
What we need to do is continue to fight for democracy and
continue the path forward for a vote-by-mail system.
I thank the President, and I yield the floor.
Madam President.
Senator from Utah.
Madam President, I appreciate the skill and the passion that my friend and
colleague, the distinguished Senator from the state of Washington,
brings to the table on this.
I appreciate her thoroughness in making the case that she has made to the Senate.
I'd like to address a few of those items, which I think call for a response.
One of the arguments that she points to,
all the arguments that she points to in one way or another,
remind me how important it is to turn back to the central objective of what we're
trying to achieve here, to make it easy to vote, but hard to cheat.
Again and again, she refers to the desire to make it easy to vote.
But as to the hard to cheat point, she goes off on a number of tangents, and
I'd like to address a number of those right now to make sure that we set
the record clear.
One of the arguments that she makes, right out of the gates,
has to do with the fact that this is a constitutionally protected right.
And she's right there.
We've got a number of freestanding constitutional protections in various
parts of the Constitution that protect your right to vote.
The fact that it is a constitutionally protected right doesn't mean that it
doesn't matter that we make it easy to vote and hard to cheat.
In fact, it makes it that much more important to do it.
The fact that something is a constitutionally protected right doesn't
mean that it has to be uninhibited.
And in fact, very often, as is the case with voting,
if we make it easy to cheat, then your constitutionally protected right to vote
will mean less and less with each passing election.
And our failure to take these risks seriously further undermines
the public perception of the legitimacy of the rights in question.
Now, the mere fact that something is a constitutionally protected right doesn't
mean you can't make it harder for people to break the law and gaining access to it.
Otherwise, there would be all sorts of things that would be off in our society.
Take, for example, the Second Amendment, the right to bear arms.
Yes, we have a constitutionally protected right to bear arms.
And it's a fundamental right that is available to individuals.
And yet, when you decide to exercise that right by going into a federally licensed
firearms dealer to purchase a firearm, guess what you have to do?
You have to produce identification.
And you have to wait a period of time.
It might take a few minutes.
It might take a few hours.
But you've gotta wait till they run your identification and
your information through some databases to make sure
that you are eligible to purchase a gun.
It still is a constitutionally protected right.
It doesn't cease to be a constitutionally protected right,
simply by virtue of doing that.
Now, never in a million years would you see my colleagues
on the other side of the aisle, or many in my party, I assume, saying, okay,
all that we need to do in order to deal with this issue,
since the right to bear arms is protected by the Constitution.
Yes, we have laws about who may purchase what firearm, and when, and
under what circumstance, and when they might be disqualified based on a prior
conviction or otherwise from purchasing a firearm.
All we need is a signature.
Because according to my colleague's logic,
a signature is all the identification you need.
Well, is it?
Well, signatures can be forged with increasing ease they can be forged.
In other circumstances, they can be presumed not to be checked.
And in some cases, that might pan out to be more true than in others.
But nobody would seriously suggest,
particularly those who like these background check laws,
they wouldn't be content with somebody just signing their name.
Even if it said, I hereby declare, under penalty of perjury,
that I am entitled to purchase this firearm, that I am an adult,
I am a US citizen, I have not been convicted of a felony offense,
which would disqualify me under 18 U.S.C.E. section 922G.
Nor do I trigger any of the other exclusionary factors articulated
in the various subsections of 922G or under any other federal law.
The signature wouldn't do it there, and that's a constitutionally protected right.
This is a constitutionally protected right, but we're still making it, yes,
easy to vote and hard to cheat.
You've got to have both.
You don't get that if you have a mere signature.
So, too, with the purchase of alcohol or tobacco by minors,
even if you had people sign something saying,
I hereby attest by signing this under penalty of perjury,
that I am in fact entitled to purchase alcohol.
I am, in fact, at least 21 years old.
We wouldn't do that.
Well, why?
Well, it'd be really hard to enforce the law at that point.
When we turn to the examples, and as I believe,
I tried to count the number of times she said it, but I think she said,
and I quote, very, very, very, very, very, very, very little fraud in elections.
Okay, I understand that.
Election fraud is extremely difficult to detect,
and therefore rarely prosecuted.
There have been very few cases of voter fraud actually being discovered,
detected, prosecuted through to completion.
Well, we would likewise with other laws,
if all you were required to do was check a box and sign your name,
there'd be a lot of other instances of legal wrongdoing that would be
also very hard to detect if that's all you had to provide.
We've got this known vulnerability in our laws here, and heaven help us all
if we don't acknowledge the vulnerabilities that we face and
take reasonable steps to close those loopholes.
The fact that we are requiring documents here, yes, it adds a step.
Now, a couple things I need to be clear about.
Number one, if you're already registered to vote,
this doesn't undo your existing voter registration.
We're not going to make hundreds of millions of Americans already registered
to vote go back and start the process over again.
That wouldn't make any sense.
But it would apply to new voter registrations.
If you move, you register to vote in a new state or a new precinct,
and you've got to establish a new voter registration file
after this becomes law, then, yeah, you'd have to do that.
But again, if you are an American who has ever had a job anywhere,
started any new job at any point in your career with a new employer,
you've already had to supply the same documentation.
In fact, you've had to supply a much more rigid set of documents
than what this requires.
Because this, unlike that, allows you to prove it,
even if you have not a single document, not a single one of those.
Again, going back to page 12, line 22, and
the sentences and paragraphs that follow, it makes abundantly clear.
Even if you're missing all of it, we've taken that into account.
And we can put the onus back on the state to go back and prove you wrong.
That is very different than just checking a box and signing your name.
Even if it does have some warnings attached to it,
that's very different than having to supply the necessary information
about how and where you were born if you are a natural born citizen.
Meaning if you were a US citizen as of the moment of your birth,
based on the circumstances surrounding your birth, either born on US soil or
born elsewhere to US citizen parents, then you've got to establish that.
That's very different than simply checking a box and signing your name.
And yes, signing your name can be used to identify a person under some
circumstances, but it's a lot less information than we're required
to provide elsewhere.
Now, she then makes this about what she refers to as states' rights.
I don't like to use that term because I think it's a misnomer.
It also conjures images of a bygone Jim Crow era in which the Democratic
Party subjected substantial swaths of the American population
to a set of racist, evil, exclusionary laws.
Has a George Wallace connotation to it that I don't like.
Besides that, states don't have rights, they have authority.
Authority is sort of the inverse polar opposite of a right.
It's the yin to the yang that is a right.
States have authority, people have rights.
Rights are a check on authority, and that's what we're talking about here.
Regardless of whether you want to call that state sovereign authority,
federalism, whatever you want to call it, it is not implicated here.
And remember, this objection is coming from the same party.
That no less than five years ago, through a vehicle that in the Congress and
panel between 2021 and 2023 was run by Democrats during a Democratic
administration that under the auspices of a bill commonly known at the time as HR 1,
tried to undertake a wholesale takeover of our federal voting and election system.
Among other things,
it would have subjected every voting jurisdiction in the United States
to the status that today we equate only with Section 5 jurisdictions.
And what that means is anytime any voting jurisdiction in the United States,
anywhere, no matter how large or small, whether tribal, local, state or otherwise,
wanted to redistrict, they'd have to go to a political appointee at
the US Department of Justice and obtain preclearance.
It's a mother may I of sorts from Uncle Sam and Aunt Sam.
Something that is fundamentally un-Americans,
something is fundamentally contrary to federalism as we know it.
This is the same party that's now making the federalism objection to this.
While we're on this federal objection to this, let's remember the whole reason this
is necessary in the first place is because of an existing federal law passed in 1993
by Congress, the National Voter Registration Act.
So the whole reason it's necessary to begin with
is because of an existing federal law.
Don't tell me this is an insult to federalism, especially if you're one of
those people from that party that supported a wholesale takeover of our
entire electoral system as recently as four or five years ago.
None of us should be surprised that leftist media establishments
in the mainstream news media have come out against this.
Because, let's face it, they're leftists.
They're hardcore Democrats.
Of course they don't want this.
And of course they use this inflammatory language in their headlines.
This is a threat to our democracy everywhere.
This will disenfranchise 21 million American voters.
You want to change that sentence to make it correct?
Well, it could be a whole lot of people who are not citizens.
The only people we don't want voting are those who are not citizens and
are not eligible to vote.
That's all this does.
Easy to vote, hard to cheat.
Using documentary standards that are far more generous, far more flexible,
far more easy to comply with than any other system that we have access to.
You can still do it.
You can still satisfy this standard of proving citizenship,
even if all your documents have suddenly disappeared.
You supply the necessary information under oath, penalty of perjury, and
then it becomes the state's burden to either confirm or refute those things.
But with this specificity, we find it a lot easier to prevent fraud.
As far as chilling voter activity, we've got data from studies,
a number of different studies, showing that in states that have adopted voter
ID laws, you don't drive down voter participation, in some cases it goes up.
It works out perfectly well.
We need not, we ought not, we must not fear this.
If we fear this particular issue, we risk running afoul
that which we hold most dear about our electoral system.
Sometimes we get confused about what we ought to fear.
You see this in nature, we fear the snake, we don't fear the deer.
And yet a few years ago, my wife and I were having this conversation,
I don't know how we got off on this tangent, but we decided to look up your
chances of dying as a result of an interaction with a rattlesnake as
compared to your chances of dying as a result of an interaction with a deer.
Now deer are cute, who doesn't love Bambi, and Bambi's mom, and Bambi's dad,
and it's all so great.
Your chances are way higher of being killed by Bambi than they are
from a rattlesnake.
And yet we fear the rattlesnake because it's creepy, it's scary.
When we fear the wrong things,
we leave ourselves vulnerable to that which can harm us.
And perhaps we don't fear enough what happens when our elections
lose their credibility, because we don't take reasonable safeguards
to make sure that only those who are legally entitled to vote in them
are in fact allowed to vote.
So as far as the private right of action goes,
that private right of action exists under previously enacted laws.
I believe that one applies as a result of the original NVRA,
and possibly some of it could be under the Help American Vote Act.
There are existing federal laws that make that exact private right of action available.
And all this does is it extends it to the obligations
that arise under the Save America Act.
And those two are generous.
They are generous to those state officials that are complying with them.
If somebody identifies a problem with the way that the law is being implemented,
if they're not complying with the terms of the Save America Act,
there is a notice requirement to the state elections official in question.
And it gives a certain period of time.
I don't remember whether it's 30, 60, or 90 days.
I think some of it may depend on the exact context.
They have the ability to cure the harm or to make the argument
back as to why they're not in fact violating it.
So there's nothing scary about this private right of action.
It's just a way of, without growing the bureaucracy,
making sure that there is a means by which you can procure
a court order requiring compliance with a law so that it doesn't become dead letter.
Look, personal information.
The Department of Homeland Security wielding personal information.
If that's the case, there are all kinds of things.
And if that's on the table, I mean, a lot of Americans don't much like
how much personal information the IRS has.
That gets leaked sometimes.
A lot of people that don't like how much personal information can be found
and the databases that are used in connection with the background checks
that one has to go through when purchasing a gun.
That's just the beginning of it.
There are all kinds of things where people are not comfortable
with the government having access to too much information.
Look, I get it.
I'm one of those people.
I don't like it either.
The fact is the government does have that information.
Why not allow the government to use that information lawfully
to make sure that those who have a particular right
are the only ones who are allowed to wield it
so that it doesn't get cheapened or diluted or bastardized
by those who would flagrantly violate the law.
At the end of the day, this is in fact about making it easy to vote and hard to cheat.
The Democrats in this chamber seem so far to be very comfortable
with the first half of that equation, but not the second half.
We have to pay attention to both.
We ignore either to our own detriment and the detriment of those we represent.
Thank you, Madam President.
Under the previous order, the Senate stands adjourned until 12 noon tomorrow.
