LIVE: House Education and Workforce Committee Holds Hearing on Workers’ Rights and Workplace Accountability

Live News Network
1.4K followers
3 Video Views·Nov 13, 2026
The House Education and Workforce Committee holds a field hearing titled “Workers in Charge: Restoring Choice and Accountability in the Workplace” in Charlotte, North Carolina, on Nov. 13.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Committee on Education and Workforce will please come to order.
Quorum is present.
The committee meets today pursuant to notice
and without objection, the chair may recess
the committee at any point.
Good morning to all of you and welcome to Charlotte, North Carolina.
I want to take a moment just to thank my colleagues
for joining us here in our great state, as
well as our witnesses for taking the time
to participate in today's hearing.
We're here today because every American worker deserves
a voice in the workplace and the
freedom to choose whether or not to be represented by a union.
Our federal labor laws were intended to protect workers' rights,
but today's hearing will
We'll examine whether those laws
Truly give workers a meaningful say in the unions
that represent them and whether union
leadership is actually working
and acting in the best interest of its members.
Throughout this Congress,
committee Republicans have advanced proposals to strengthen worker
choice, improve union transparency,
and hold union leaders accountable to their members.
Our priority has simply been clear.
Put workers first, not union bosses.
Unfortunately, my colleagues across
the aisle see it the other way around.
For years, Democrats have catered to powerful union leaders,
often at the expense of the
hardworking Americans those unions are supposed to represent.
Committee Republicans believe workers should have the right
to decide whether they want union representation through a private,
secret ballot election.
That decision should reflect the will of a majority of all workers,
not simply a majority of those who cast a ballot.
It is ironic that the same party that prides itself
on protecting democracy seems unwilling to apply that principle
when it comes to union elections.
We also know that workers benefit when businesses succeed.
Businesses grow and create jobs.
In order to create those jobs, businesses need stability
and predictability in labor law to make those investments.
They need to know what the rules are today and what they will
be tomorrow in order for them to plan for the future.
Unfortunately, we've seen repeated swings
in labor policy whenever Democrats hold the
majority of the National Labor Relations Board,
often with little regard for the consequences
for workers and businesses.
Too often, those changes have served the interest
of union leadership rather than the people
those leaders represent.
And what are the consequences
when federal policies give union leaders more power while
leaving workers with less of a say?
Well, under current federal law,
unions are not required to allow their members to vote
on major decisions,
including whether to approve contracts or authorize strikes.
Yet these decisions can have major consequences for workers
and their families, affecting
their paychecks, their benefits, their working conditions,
their schedules, and job security.
When so much is at stake.
For workers and their families,
they deserve a voice in those decisions.
Greater transparency and meaningful member participation
are what help ensure that union members understand how unions operate
and that they have a say in the decisions being made on their behalf.
Unfortunately, come January,
Democrats will pass bills that take away any influence workers have
in the collective bargaining process
and on the contracts that actually shape their lives.
The Faster Labor Contracts Act, or FLCA,
would put government arbitrators,
not workers or business owners, in charge of writing labor contracts
without giving workers an opportunity to vote on the outcome.
Perhaps a more fitting name for the FLCA would
be the Filling Labor's Coffers Act,
because the result will be fuller pockets for union leaders
and less power for the workers
they represent. Committee Republicans have taken
our oversight responsibility seriously.
We've investigated reports of misconduct involving union leadership,
including abuses of power,
anti-Semitism, and the employment of a convicted child sex offender.
Our Democrat colleagues should be doing the same,
and instead they continue to push for bills like
FLCA and the Protecting the Right to Organize Act
to do the bidding of unions. We look forward to
hearing from our witnesses today about
the challenges that are actually facing American
workers and businesses and what we can do to address these challenges.
As we look ahead to
the next Congress, committee Republicans remain committed
to a simple principle, and it's this.
Workers deserve more choice, a stronger voice,
and greater accountability from unions that
represent them. So we will continue fighting
to ensure that workers, not union bosses,
have a meaningful say in the decisions that will affect their lives
and their livelihoods.
And with that, I'd like to yield
to Ms. Adams for her opening statement.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
and thank you very much to our witnesses for joining us today.
And let me welcome all of you to Charlotte.
But before we start, let me just make a slight correction.
And as I read some of the testimonies,
Bowman's testimony in particular,
this is North Carolina's 12th Congressional District,
which I am proud to represent.
And I'm happy that you're here and that you chose a great place,
Mr. Chairman, to have this meeting.
But before we start, I want to correct that.
I want to, first of all, disagree with the proposals put forth
by my colleagues on the other side of the aisle.
I'm glad that we could discuss labor policies in my district
because I can tell you firsthand
that the people here are hurting.
The cost of living in Charlotte,
as in so many other communities throughout our country,
is out of control.
In this city, an adult would need to make about $25
an hour to meet basic living expenses.
And so many of my constituents make far less than that.
And I've met with working people in my district
who are forced to live in storage units and cars and on the street.
And let me say again that for my colleagues and for our witnesses,
that my constituents are living in storage units
and cars and on the street.
And I can promise you they aren't lazy.
These are people who get up every morning,
work hard, but simply aren't paid what they're owed.
Working hard is not enough if you don't make enough.
They are baggage handlers at the airport.
They are grocery store cashiers and restaurant workers.
And they live in a state that forbids local governments
from changing wage rates even when they want to.
And that's why the federal government needs to act.
And we must raise the minimum wage.
We must implement paid family
and medical leave and stamp out wage theft.
We need to give people a better shot at a decent life.
But workers in Charlotte don't want to sit on their hands
while the federal government debates policy.
They want to take action.
And they want to fight for better conditions themselves.
But our state has made it harder,
much harder for them to organize and bargain.
Workers in North Carolina and many other states
have suffered under so-called right-to-work laws.
Well, that name is a great marketing ploy.
But who wouldn't want the right to work?
It should be called the right to a low wage,
the right to poverty, and the right to be exploited by your boss.
Anti-labor policies in North Carolina
and across our country have led to a collapse in union density.
In the last 50 years, unions in North Carolina have gone
from representing around 10% of workers to around 3%.
And it's no surprise that in that same period,
wealth disparities between workers and executives have intensified.
Today, the wealthiest 1%
of Americans control more wealth than the bottom 90%.
And so if you look at the data,
as union density shrank over the last 50 years, wealth inequity grew.
And that connection is not a coincidence.
It is the end product of a coordinated attack on organizations
representing the interests of working people by organizations
representing the interests of the wealthy.
I see the interests of the wealthy
are well represented by our witnesses here today.
And that's why we must fight to restore the labor movement in America.
Because as Tom Donahue said,
the only effective answer to organized greed is organized labor.
And I don't know what changes to labor policy
my colleagues on the other side of the aisle
will try to pass in the next two months,
but I can say one thing for sure.
When Democrats take power in January,
we'll pass a strong pro-worker agenda.
We'll fight to put an end to so-called right-to-work policies,
and we'll fight to restore the National Labor Relations Board.
We will get the Faster Labor Contracts Act signed into law,
and we'll fight to pass every provision of the PRO Act
because House Democrats recognize the truth about the labor movement.
We know that the eight-hour workday
unemployment insurance, the minimum wage, overtime pay,
and so much more were only possible because
of the tireless effort and the heroic sacrifice
of ordinary working people. And as I think about
the labor movement in our country,
the words of Dr. Martin Luther King echo in my mind. As he once
said, the labor movement was the principal force
that transformed misery and despair into hope
and progress. House Democrats will spend the next Congress
Passing legislation to revitalize the labor movement
because working people
deserve a seat at the bargaining table.
We've got to restore that force for hope and progress
and we won't let two months
of lamed up legislating slow us down. Mr. Chairman,
I thank you. I yield back
and I regret that I'm not going to be here for the entire meeting
because I have some district things I have to take care of,
but thank you all again for being here.
Thank you, Ms. Adams.
Pursuant to Committee Rule 8C,
all members who wish to insert written statements into the record may
do so by submitting them to the committee clerk electronically
in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m. 14 days after this hearing.
And without objection, the hearing will remain open for 14 days
to allow such statements and other extraneous material noted during
the hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record.
I'll now turn to the introduction
of our witnesses that we have invited here today.
Our first witness is Mr. William Messinger,
Vice President and Legal Director for the National Right
to Work Legal Defense Foundation in Springfield, Virginia.
Our second witness is Ms. Jennifer Betts, Office Managing Shareholder
at Ogletree Deakins in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Our final witness is Mr. Terry Bowman,
Chairman of Institute for the American Worker
and an incoming quality technician
at the Ford Motor Company in Ypsilanti, Michigan.
First of all, we thank the witnesses for being here today,
and pursuant to committee rules,
I would ask that you each limit
your oral presentation to five-minute summary of your
written statement that was submitted.
I would also like to remind the witnesses
to be aware of their responsibility to provide
accurate information to the committee.
And with that, I will first
of all recognize Mr. Messinger for your testimony.
Thank you, Representative Harris, Representative Adams,
Representative Owens for the opportunity
to testify here today. It's fitting
that this field hearing is happening in North Carolina
because North Carolina's labor laws are a model
of voluntary unionism that the federal government
should try to emulate.
In North Carolina, no public employee can be forced to accept
to accept the union's representation against his or her will.
No public employer can be forced to bargain
with union officials against their will.
And no employee can be forced to join
or pay money to a union against their will.
North Carolina's laws sort of exemplify free choice
and free association.
Unfortunately, federal labor law is based on government compulsion.
The National Labor Relations Act compels employees to accept
a union's representation, whether they want it or not.
compels business leaders to bargain
with union officials whether they want to or not,
and authorizes compelling employees to pay money
to a union just to keep their jobs.
Federal labor policy is a layer cake of government compulsion
and free speech violations.
So I urge the Congress to sort of adopt a model,
more towards what North Carolina has,
a model of voluntary unionism.
And the best way, the first step towards that,
would be to pass a National Right to Work Act
and guarantee that each individual employee has the right to choose
whether or not they want to join or financially support a union.
However, there's also a number of smaller reforms
that Congress can make to empower workers
or that actually the National Labor Relations Board itself could make
under its existing statutory authority.
I've outlined a number of those reforms
in my written testimony, but just in the interest
of time, I'm just going to focus on one of them.
And that's quite simply, the NLRB should stop
disenfranchising union represented employees.
A shameful statistic is that 9 out of 10 unionized employees,
union represented employees, have
never voted on whether they want union representation.
It's never voted one way or another.
And this is notwithstanding the fact that the National Labor
Relations Act grants employees a statutory right to request
an election on whether they want to remain represented by a union.
And in fact, that section of the act, Section 9C, provides
that if a question of representation exists, the board shall direct
an election and shall certify the results thereof.
And the National Labor Relations Act only puts one restriction on this.
The board won't conduct more than one election
in a year, which of course makes sense.
But notwithstanding the text of the act, the National Labor Relations
Board has taken upon itself to invent a whole host of policies
to disenfranchise union-represented employees and not allow them
to vote on whether they want to remain represented by a union.
This includes bars on elections, which just flat-out prohibit employees
from requesting an election during certain time periods.
This includes the recognition bar, which prohibits elections for up
to one year after the first date of bargaining after a card check.
The successor bar, which prohibits decertification elections
for up to one year after the first
date of bargaining, after a change in ownership.
And then worst of all, the contract bar,
which provides that employees are not allowed to
petition for a decertification vote
the first three years of a union collective bargaining
agreement, except for one tiny sliver of time near the end.
As a result of these bars, the NLRB base will
only allow employees to exercise their right
to decertification during tiny slivers of time, only every few years.
The NLRB also has a doctrine called the merger doctrine.
Which allows union officials to gerrymander units of employees
into one giant unit that is very difficult or impossible to decertify.
So the way it works is the NLRB will allow unions
to organize employees little groups at a time.
One facility at a time, sometimes one department at a time.
But then the union will take those smaller units
and start adding them to a bigger unit.
The bigger unit may be nationwide in scope.
It may have hundreds of locations.
It may have tens of thousands of employees.
And under the merger doctrine,
the NLRB will say the only appropriate union for
decertification is that giant unit, the merged unit.
And as a result, employees
in these merged units basically can never exercise their right
to vote because an employee at any given location will never
be able to get the support he or
she needs for an election.
And then finally, you have the blocking charge policy,
which allows union officials to block
decertification elections just
by making accusations against their employer.
Saying that the employer engaged
in unfair labor practice under the blocking charge policy,
the NLRB will stop the election
and just take weeks or months to investigate
while the election does not occur.
Looking at all these policies together,
an outside observer would be forgiven
for thinking the NLRB's statutory mission
was to suppress employees' right to vote,
whether they want to remain represented by a union.
But of course the opposite is true.
The NLRB has a statutory duty to enforce
this right granted in the act for employees to
request a decertification election.
The National Right to Work Foundation has filed
a rulemaking petition with the NLRB
requesting that it engage in reforms,
getting rid of all these doctrines, getting rid of
the merger doctrines, the election bar, and the blocking charge policy.
I hope the NLRB acts on that, and if not,
I hope that Congress makes them do it.
Thank you, Mr. Messenger.
I will recognize Ms. Betts next for your testimony.
Thank you. Thank you, Congressman Harris,
Congresswoman Adams, and Congressman Owens for
having me and for bringing this hearing
to beautiful Charlotte. My name is Jen Betts,
and I am a shareholder at an international labor
and employment firm known as Ogletree Deakins.
I've practiced labor and employment law for about 20 years.
The views I share today are my own.
They are not that of my law firm
or any of the clients that I or my firm represent.
On the labor side, I represent employers in union campaigns,
elections, bargaining.
In that work, I have walked clients through two
and sometimes three or more reversals
and precedent on the same exact issue.
That keeps lawyers like me very busy, but it doesn't serve employers,
it doesn't serve employees, and it doesn't serve unions.
I'm going to take as one example employee handbooks.
In 2004, before I started practicing law,
there was a case called Lutheran Heritage.
In that case, the National Labor Relations Board would ask
the question of whether employees
could reasonably read a rule to restrict
their rights under federal labor law.
If so, it may be unlawful.
In 2017, those rules changed.
There was a new decision called Boeing
that moved to a balancing test with some rigid
rules.
Then in 2023, the rules changed again.
There was another new case called Stericycle.
And now the NLRB's general counsel
is looking to change that rule once more.
That means three standards for governing
the exact same issue in a period of only about 10 years.
Take as another example, who exactly is the employer of employees?
For 30 years, the test turned on who
is actually controlling the work of employees.
That changed in 2015, then in 2020 it changed again,
then it changed again in 2023, then it
changed again just recently by the National Labor Relations Board.
This is a fundamental question,
who is the employer that dictates the rights of employers, employees,
it implicates contracts,
and it keeps bouncing around and changing every couple of years.
Take union recognition for about 50 years.
If an employer received a demand for recognition from
a union, the employer could ask for what's known
as a secret ballot election. That changed in 2023
with a decision known as CEMEX.
This year, a federal circuit court rejected the CEMEX decision.
And then another federal circuit court approved of it,
but only in a limited fashion without
reaching the question of whether that decision was right.
Now the NLRB general counsel says she's going
to ask the board to overrule that decision.
The process through which a union can represent employees
is absolutely fundamental and it should
not shift with administrations.
These changes are not happening because the workplaces are
changing. They are happening largely because the people
who are making the rules have changed.
Every change means new policies for employers,
new training, reopening contracts, and significant legal bills
Big companies can absorb those changes.
Small companies often cannot.
I would also like to add a caution about proposals
for binding arbitration of first contracts.
The act itself requires good faith bargaining,
but it does not compel either side to reach
any particular agreements or any agreement at all.
That has been the case for the entirety
of the National Labor Relations Act.
An arbitrator imposing wages
and other working conditions on terms that neither side agreed to
would be a significant change in NLRB practice and precedent.
A lot of employers are pleased with where
the National Labor Relations Board is headed right now,
but I would be saying these same things if it were the other way.
What's needed are clear, sensible, durable rules that last over time
and that do not shift with changes in administration.
The committee can help this by enacting common sense rules,
legislative changes that ensure future predictability
for all stakeholders in this arena.
Thank you. I appreciate the time.
Thank you, Ms. Betts.
Next, I'm going to recognize Mr. Bowman for your testimony, sir.
Thank you, and good morning, Congressman Harris,
Congresswoman Adams, and Congressman Owens.
It is an honor and a privilege to testify today here
in the beautiful city of Charlotte, North Carolina.
My name is Terry Bowman,
and I'm an incoming quality technician, which is an hourly job
and a UAW-represented job
at Ford Motor Company's Rawsonville plant in Michigan.
I have worked at Ford for over 30 years,
and my family has worked at the company for three
generations. I also serve as chairman
of the Institute for the American Worker,
an organization that advocates for policies that empower workers.
My message today is simple.
Workers like me need more freedom, information,
and protections so that we can do what's best for
ourselves. This vision will not be achieved
by simply giving more power to union officials.
As I can attest, that typically means taking power
and dignity away from individual workers.
Workers like me need real reforms that put us in the driver's seat.
I am particularly concerned by two pieces
of legislation that are either under consideration
or soon could be in Congress.
The Faster Labor Contracts Act would hurt workers
while falsely claiming to help them.
This legislation would give a government-appointed arbitration panel
the ability to force workers
into union contracts without workers' approval.
No worker should be forced into a new contract without a vote.
The PRO Act contains a slew of policies that claim to be pro-worker
but are, in fact, anti-worker.
It would prevent more workers
from becoming independent contractors with greater flexibility,
ban employers from holding meetings
that give workers more information about the effects of unionization.
It would repeal state right-to-work laws that free workers
from mandatory union dues or fees as a condition of employment.
And allow unions to gain monopoly representation
without giving workers a chance to vote.
Congress should instead promote real reforms
that actually benefit workers like me.
Last year, this committee's Republican
members introduced a package of five bills
to improve the Labor Management Reporting and Disclosure Act,
and I would like to praise three of those in particular.
The Fair Access to Justice
for Union Members Act would give union members more options
To defend their rights outside of lengthy
and often unfair internal hearing procedures.
The Ask the Union Members Act would require contract votes
to be held by secret ballot
and bar unions from authorizing a strike without a majority vote.
And lastly, the Endorsement Transparency Act would
require union executives to poll their membership
and share their results with them before endorsing
a candidate for President of the United States.
Workers like me need our elected leaders
in Washington to fight for our interests
and defend our rights.
They should pursue real reforms that empower workers instead of giving
union officials more power over us.
They should grant us more protections and give us more personal
freedom in the workplace. That's what I need
in my own work in one of America's great manufacturers.
And that's what every worker needs to chart their own future
and secure lasting success.
Thank you for this opportunity to testify.
Thank you, Mr. Bowman.
Thank all of our witnesses for your testimonies.
Now, under Committee Rule 9,
we will now have opportunity for questions of the witnesses
under the five-minute rule,
and I'll recognize myself for the first five minutes.
And, Mr. Bowman, you referenced H.R. 6142.
The Ask the Union Members Act,
which I had the pleasure of introducing, which requires
unions to hold a secret ballot vote on contract ratification decisions
and strike authorizations.
Can you kind of elaborate on why it's important
for workers to participate in ratifying their
contracts and actually deciding whether to strike?
Well, sure. And first of all, thank you for that question.
Workers like me depend on having a good
contract for our lives, not just for ourselves,
but for our families as well. The idea that
workers themselves would not have the ability to vote on a contract,
it just does not seem like it should
be logical to even argue this point.
Good morning.
On top of that, it's not just that.
It's to have a secret ballot vote on these kinds of issues.
You know, during union organizing votes,
one thing that unions can do is something called card check,
which means a union organizer can walk right up to a worker
and shove a card right in their face and say,
please sign this if you would like union representation.
And they can do it right out in public in front of other workers.
So a secret ballot election is something very important
to workers on a contract ratification vote.
Because...
There's a lot of workers out there that might
not fall into the category of the collective
bargaining process,
and what I mean by that is the collective bargaining might say it's
good for everybody, but there's individual workers
who might say, you know, that collective
bargaining contract is not real good for me.
Maybe I'm a farmer, and I would...
Rather give up a dollar-hour wage if I could have
the choice of a shift that I want
instead of what's being proposed in the contract.
So I want to vote no on this.
Well, they need to have that secret ballot election
so that they can protect their vote
and they can vote their conscience without any worry
or fear of reprisal.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Mr. Messinger, the Biden-Harris NLRB issued
a final rule expanding blocking charges,
and its decision in the Reith-Riley construction case expanded
the power of blocking charges.
Can you explain this policy and how you have seen unions abuse it
in such a way as to gain a strategic advantage?
Thank you.
The Biden-Harris regulation basically provided
that if a union files an allegation of an
unfair labor practice after an employee files for an election,
the NLRB generally will block
the processing of the election
while it investigates whether that charge has merit, and that could
take weeks or months.
So basically, it gives the union the ability
to stop any election from occurring and to
remain in power just by making accusations against their employer.
And then the Reith-Riley decision makes it even worse,
is that if an NLRB region decides to issue
a complaint making allegations against the employer,
the employee's decertification petition will just be dismissed
while the NLRB processes that unfair labor practice complaint.
And as a result of that, it could take years
to resolve an unfair labor practice case.
We have clients who filed petitions
for decertification over three years ago,
and they're still waiting for an election
because of blocking charges and because of Ruth Riley.
Both are things the Trump board can fix, and I'm hopeful they will fix,
by issuing rulemaking to get rid of the blocking charge policy
and overruling Reith-Riley.
Thank you, sir.
Ms. Betts, your written testimony calls for clarity
and predictability in labor law.
How has the CEMEX decision
and the board's related decisions muddied the waters and made
it difficult for employers to navigate union representation disputes?
Yeah, I mean, the CEMEX decision is a perfect example.
Employers do not have clarity right now,
particularly small employers, about what the
rules of the road are.
The circuit courts are evaluating the decision,
and at least one, as mentioned, has struck it down.
So depending on where you are in the country,
the rules of the road may be different.
And if you're not reading Labor Law Digest every week,
and you're a small or mid-sized employer,
you may not understand that you have 14 days to make
a decision about whether you want to push for an election.
That doesn't seem fair, and it's not consistent
with the language of the National Labor Relations Act.
Certainty is important.
Let me ask you this.
What should be done to facilitate free
and fair union representation elections, you think?
I think every citizen in the United States who's an employee
should have the opportunity to exercise their right to vote.
I think that is fundamental to this country and to the process.
Makes sense.
Well, thank you.
Thank you.
Let me now recognize Ms. Adams.
Oh, I'm sorry.
Let me go to recognize.
Mr. Owens, for his series of questions.
Thank you. Thank you so much for being here.
I'm excited to be here today in North Carolina
to talk about the needs of the workers.
As the lifeblood of the American economy,
our workers deserve the very best.
That includes having a voice in the workplace and having freedom
to make choices and decisions upon their union representation.
Workers also should have more accountability from their unions
to ensure that union leadership is representing
and working toward the interests of their members.
I come from a remarkable state of Utah.
I'm very, very proud to say that it's also a right to work state.
And what are the benefits?
What are the outcomes of that?
We're the very best state in terms of ranking.
We have an economy outlook that's number one.
We're one of the fastest growing and opening more new businesses.
And what we have to understand is what makes
our culture what it is, is our middle class.
Our middle class is what draws everyone here to this country.
And the more robust it is, the freer, the most productive it is.
And what powers the middle class are business ownership.
And businesses do not have a predictability,
they're not going to thrive.
And when you start to see the lack of predictability,
the lack of success in the business ownership process,
you see an empathy-free elitist group and a hopeless dependent group.
And that middle class is shrinking.
That's what we've seen over the last few years.
How do we get that back?
Allow the business to have productivity,
to build their businesses, to make a profit,
to turn that back into making sure
that their employees are living a better lifestyle
because they want to keep them and hold on to them.
And that's how we do it.
It's the old-fashioned American way.
We have to get back to that.
So that being said.
Ms. Bowman, you call for increased union transparency
in your written testimony.
I introduced the H.R. 2952,
the Start Applying Labor Transparency, the SALT Act,
which amends the Labor Management Reporting Disclosure Act
to require union SALTs to disclose
their union affiliation to the Department of Labor.
We believe that workers should know whether their fellow workers
are being paid by a union to organize a workplace.
Congressman Owens, thank you so much for this question.
The reason why is it seems blatantly obvious
that the answer is obviously yes.
Workers should know when a SALT worker is in their business hoping
to infiltrate and convince all the workers that they
are somehow victims of the employer that they may have
been with for years and are perfectly happy.
To think about this SALT situation is very interesting.
A union can pay a SALT worker to infiltrate a business.
They then get hired by a business that they're trying to infiltrate
and getting a paycheck from that business.
And then they have to go in and,
like I said, try to convince workers somehow
that they are victims and only a union can solve all of their issues.
To me, it's not only should workers know about it,
but in my opinion, it should be illegal, quite frankly.
It's deceptive, it's malicious, and it should be banned immediately.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Ms. Betts, the NLRB standards for judging whether employee handbooks
and workforce rules comply with the NLRA.
Ping pong, which you mentioned back
and forth several times over the last 20 years, could
you describe those shifting, you've done it already,
but just maybe highlight it again,
what that should be done to create a common sense
and consistent approach in this area
of law?
I'll just give you a really easy, simple example.
Under the current standards,
an employer in the United States could have a rule in their
handbook saying that employees have to treat one another with respect.
And that employer would have no certainty of whether that law
was in violation of the National Labor Relations Act.
That just doesn't make sense.
We should all agree that we should treat
one another with respect in the workplace.
And we should have common sense, easy to follow and understand
rules about whether that is the case or not, that that's lawful.
Ms. Messenger, your written testimony discussed
the importance of secret ballot elections
and potential abuse inherent in the card check process.
What options do we have to protect
the workers' choice in secret ballot elections?
It's simple for Congress. Congress can simply
mandate secret ballot elections and that unions
cannot come into power through a card check.
And the NLRB itself under its existing authority can
go a long way in that direction by overruling Cemex
and making card checks not mandatory
again. And also by requiring that unions prove they actually have
the support of a majority of
all the employees in a unit,
as opposed to just the support of majority of employees who voted.
That issue is before the board in a case called Constellation Energy.
And the board can go a long way to empowering workers
by voting the right way in that case.
Thank you.
Thank you, and I'll go back.
Thank you.
The gentleman yields back.
We'll be right back.
We have some time here, so we're going to have
a second round of questioning, if that's all right,
to continue to learn from the expertise of our witnesses.
Mr. Bowman, your written testimony articulates
your concern that H.R. 5408,
the Faster Labor Contracts Act, would hurt workers.
As I shared in my opening statement,
I think that is indeed something that we are anticipating
that we will deal with in the next Congress.
based on what happened in the previous elections.
Can you kind of expand on why you believe this bill
is bad for workers and help us understand that?
Yes, and again, thank you for the question.
Thank you for the question.
You know, I think this kind of goes along with,
we discussed the Ask the Union Members Act.
It goes hand-in-hand with that, and I also think something,
another bill I believe introduced by Representative Onder called
the Workers' Enfranchisement Act.
I think all of those kind of go hand-in-hand where
the Faster Labor Contracts Act can set up a scenario.
where no union member gets to vote on a contract,
on whether or not they approve of a contract.
And it's a contract that might be,
it's not just a recommendation from an arbitration panel.
It is a dictation from an arbitration panel
of what this contract will be.
And one of my big concerns about this is,
number one, the secret ballot vote.
Again, I have to emphasize that all...
unionized workers should have
a secret ballot vote on any contract negotiation.
Number two, the Worker Enfranchisement Act requires
a two-thirds quorum of
everybody in the bargaining unit in order
for that contract to be valid and
One of the things that bothers me is a union that is just organizing
and working on their
first contract, if the workers don't like the contract,
the union can put their hands
up and say, well, it's not our fault.
It's an arbitration panel.
So it wipes any kind of responsibility
from the union on an initial contract.
And I think that's probably why they want it.
I got you.
Thank you, sir.
Ms. Betts, your written testimony warns about
the potential risks of adopting binding first
contract arbitration.
Why do you believe that binding arbitration could
be a source of instability and reduce
the durability of collective bargaining
agreements between unions and employers?
I have negotiated many a first contract in my career.
One of my concerns with mandatory binding arbitration
is that it's going to lead both
sides potentially to be very inflexible with their positions
and their opening offers.
What arbitrators tend to do is split the baby,
meet somewhere in the middle.
And if you know that going in, you are going to make on both sides.
Really rigid, hard stances
and not have a lot of motivation to negotiate because you lose
your leverage if you get closer to the middle because you're going
to get something even worse than what you would have expected.
And so I have a lot of concerns from a process perspective about how
that's going to work out for both sides, right,
for both the employer and the union side.
Thank you.
Thank you. Mr. Messenger,
Section 9A of the National Labor Relations Act states
that a union can be an exclusive representative if, quote, designated
or selected for the purposes of collective bargaining by the majority
of the employees in a unit appropriate for such purposes, end quote.
You and I know that NRLB allows unions
to represent employees if they receive the majority
of votes cast, regardless of whether a majority of workers vote.
What would you suggest can be done to ensure
this provision of the NLRA is enforced as
written?
The NLRB can simply change its policy on that.
I mean, for a long time, as you've said,
the NLRB has just assumed that if the union wins
the majority of those who vote,
that's enough under Section 9A to make
a union a monopoly representative.
But that's simply contrary to the statute.
The statutory text says a majority of those in the unit.
And under Loper Bright or in the wake of Loper Bright,
the NLRB must return to the text of the statute.
It can't just make up policies on top of it.
As I mentioned before, this issue is before
the board in a case called Constellation Energy,
and I'm hoping the board rules the right way in that case
and requires a true majority.
Thank you, sir.
I'm going to yield back.
I'm going to go to the next round of questioning to my colleague,
Representative Owens.
Thank you.
Mr. and Ms. Betts, in your written statement, you discussed
the turmoil caused by the 2015 Browning-Barris Industries decision.
Since that decision.
The joint employer standards change every few years.
How destructive is this shifting standards
determining when employees have a joint employer?
Yeah, thank you.
The most common question that I get from clients
when we talk about joint employer under
the National Labor Relations Act
is when is it going to change again?
And I say that somewhat glibly, but it's truly serious
because it keeps changing year over year.
The turmoil is real.
Contracts need to be renegotiated.
If you're an entity that has contractors and subcontractors
that are staffing individuals to work in your workplace,
you need to understand the terms of
that contract and how you negotiate
the business relationship for those individuals. When the
rules change, those contracts have to be reopened.
Big businesses, they have the resources,
the manpower, the money to absorb those changes
and those renegotiations.
Small businesses, maybe less so.
And again, for employees,
understanding who the employer is and who controls their work
and who they can go to about changes
and negotiate collective bargaining agreements with, that's
important for them as well.
So these are not esoteric legal issues.
They impact people in the real world.
And so what can be done to settle this area of law?
There could be common sense legislative fixes by,
I leave the policy decisions to you all,
but there could be legislative fixes to make clear
the definition of employer under the NLRA.
Miss Bowman, Democrats have asserted a push to protecting
the Rights to Organize Act next year.
Your written testimony states
the bill will only empower union officials, not workers.
Why do you believe that?
Well, again, thank you for the question.
And let me make my position clear.
I am a private sector union worker.
All public sector workers in the United States,
since the SCOTUS decision of Janus v. AFSCME,
all public sector union workers have
the ability to choose for themselves
whether or not they want to pay dues to their union or join.
Thank you.
I do not have that ability.
Apparently, I must be somewhat of a less person
or my rights are not the same as theirs.
But I am forced as a condition of employment in Michigan
to support my union.
So the Protecting the Right to Organize Act,
first and foremost, it bans states' rights
and it bans a state from being able to choose for themselves
whether or not they want to be a right-to-work state.
And in my 30-year forced unionization experience,
There's no better tool for a worker to be able
to hold their union answerable and accountable
to the membership than having a right-to-work law,
where a worker can say, thank you, but
no thank you, I'm not interested in supporting
an organization that I have problems with.
So first and foremost, that is the biggest issue.
I also have issues with the fact that the PRO Act will force employers
to give and employees all their personal information
to a union organizer, their home phone, their home address,
their cell phone, their home or their personal email, their work email.
Thank
That can be very intimidating and very worrisome for workers,
knowing that union organizers
now know where they live.
And we know union organizers in the past have showed up
you
at people's houses and pounded on
the door.
very
So for those reasons and more,
I think the PRO Act definitely empowers union officials
much.
over us and takes away some of our rights and dignity.
Ms. Messinger, your written testimony talks about
your representation of school bus drivers employed
by a private company in Washington State.
Will you explain how this illustrates the ways
the merger doctrine disenfranchises workers?
Yes, so the case involved a company called First Student,
which provides school bus services to school districts.
And what the Teamsters had done there
is taken these individual school bus drivers
who serve various school districts and added them into one giant unit.
The unit covers 20-some thousand employees nationwide at 260 locations.
And so, as a result of this merger doctrine, the only appropriate unit,
according to the National Labor Relations Board,
is the entire nationwide unit.
And so when a group of school bus drivers
in Battleground, Washington said,
we want an election to deauthorize the Teamsters, which means
not to pay union dues to them as a condition of their employment,
the NLRB refused to process the petition because saying
that 170 group of school bus drivers in Battleground, Washington
were subsumed into this giant unit,
and that was the only appropriate one.
And as a result, employees at First Student will never be able
to obtain an election on any matter until that doctrine is changed.
Let me just read real quick,
just to highlight what right as a work state means.
Because Utah, again, is one.
Union membership cannot be required to keep or get a job.
The law protects workers whether they choose to join a union or not.
And you think about what the foundation of our country,
life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.
You can't have happiness if you don't have a choice.
You can't have happiness if you go to work.
And the work you put in, the effort you put in,
the money you save towards your dreams
is not dictated by what you truly want to have happen.
I'll say one of the things that I've
been very impressed with when I look back on history
is when our GIs came back from World War II, got the GI Bill,
and we had something called productive capacity.
We had the greatest middle-class growth ever,
cross-border diverse in our country's history
because people came out, they were hopeful, working hard,
knowing that the effort they put in,
they would get back to buy their homes,
to build their dreams, to have their vacations,
to stay at home if they wanted to do that.
Anything that disrupts that is anti-American.
Anything that disrupts the ability for us to dream,
to have the freedom, the choice that we deserve in a free country,
to have our money go in the ways that will benefit us is anti-American.
So we have to understand this, and I think education is why I'm
so thankful to be spending time with my colleague here.
Education will help our new generations come up to understand
this process and get back to where we have the freedom to go out
and build our dreams, keep our money, build the things we want to,
and continue to improve this remarkable middle class we have.
So with that, I yield back. Thank you.
Thank you, Congressman Owens,
and that's going to conclude our questioning rounds today.
I do want to thank Congressman Owens for coming to Charlotte
and being a part of this hearing
today, representing the great state of Utah,
and has been an incredible colleague of mine
in sharing our time together on the Education
and Workforce Committee, and very grateful
for his service and his willingness
to be engaged on so many different levels.
I also want to take a moment today to thank
our witnesses for sharing their perspectives
on the importance of protecting worker choice in union elections and,
quite frankly, promoting
stability and predictability in labor law.
I don't know.
I think we talk a lot of times when we think about it as legislators,
the importance of
certainty.
I mean, we talk about it, we hear
from business leaders everywhere we go.
I hear it from farmers in the agricultural industry,
the reason we need a farm bill.
All of those kind of things,
you've got to have certainty in order to make decisions
about your businesses so that they can grow,
they can invest, they can create more jobs.
And we're seeing too much of a whiplash,
as we've heard here today so many times.
Unions hold a privileged position
as the exclusive representative of millions of American workers.
But with that position comes responsibility to listen to their members,
to steward their
dues appropriately,
and to exercise their influence in ways that respect and reflect
the diverse views of workers they represent.
As today's testimony has demonstrated,
the NLRB election procedures too often fall short
of putting workers' voices first.
Workers seeking to decertify
or replace their union face processes that are unnecessarily
complex, burdensome, and difficult to actually navigate.
Workers should not have
to overcome needless procedural hurdles in order to have their
voices heard.
Free and fair elections are essential.
To ensuring that workers have confidence in the process
and a meaningful opportunity
to choose the representatives that they actually want.
So I want to thank again all of you
that have come to be a part of this hearing,
the witnesses, my colleagues that have been a part of this.
And I really do look forward to working together on this committee
and with the administration to protect the freedom
and the dignity of workers,
to promote greater accountability and responsiveness from the unions,
and ultimately to advance a stable and predictable labor law framework
that works for workers.
And so with that, I again want to thank all of you for being a part
of this, for taking the time to travel and at your own sacrifice
to be a part of this because you love this country
and because you understand the importance of what we do.
So without objection, there being no further business,
this committee stands adjourned.
