Hidden Beauty Revealed — Restoring an Antique Without Refinishing

Thomas Johnson Antique Furniture Restoration
41 followers
202 Video Views·Mar 6, 2026
Tom Johnson of Thomas Johnson Antique Furniture Restoration in Gorham, Maine restores this handsome bureau.
t-shirts and bumper stickers are here:
buy yours at https://www.thomasjohnsonrestoration.com/category/all-products
Tom has been restoring furniture professionally since 1979. Visit our website at http://www.thomasjohnsonrestoration.com, or write us at [email protected]. And for those on the east coast looking for custom framing, be sure to check out Tom's daughter's shop, https://www.emcollier.com (@emcollierframes on Instagram).
AI Generated·May contain errors
I'm Tom Johnson, Thomas Johnson Antique Furniture Restoration in Gorham, Maine, and yes we've got
t-shirts in and bumper stickers. You can go to my website to order. This video is the restoration of
a chest of drawers that belongs to a family that I worked for for three generations over a period
of more than 40 years. A member of this family had passed away and he had used this chest of
drawers his entire life from childhood. As a result, it had tremendous sentimental value and
now one of his sons wanted to use the chest of drawers for himself. So it was really important
for me to retain the history of the piece. But it had some serious issues. The top was severely
gouged. No one seemed to have any idea how that happened or came about. And there was also extreme
gouges, circular gouges, where the plates of the handles had spun around. Now in anybody's book,
that top and those drawer fronts needed to be sanded down. But I decided, you know, why not try
without sanding them down? The worst thing that could happen is I'd have to just start over and start
sanding. Now when I say I didn't sand it, I did sand a little bit, you know, with 150 and 220
in a few areas just to prepare the surface for the ensuing treatment. Thanks to Elmer's
wood putty, which I was able to add stain to, I think it looked pretty good.
So if you enjoy this video, please hit subscribe, like, share it. I'd appreciate it.
This is a nice old chest of drawers. It has a lot of sentimental value to the family.
I first looked at it, I wasn't sure how old it is, but you notice at first an unusual drawer
arrangement, and you notice the legs. The top drawer is the largest, 8 inches or 20 centimeters,
then 5 inches, 12.7 centimeters, 6 inches, 15 centimeters, 7 inches, 18 centimeters.
Let's take the drawers out and see what they look like.
Nice hand-cut dovetails. Drawer sides are on the thin side.
The bottom is extremely rough and thick. You can see that the taper sides were
shaped by a hand plane. The inside of the cabinet is pretty much what you'd expect.
There are two rails that go side to side at the top of the cabinet. The rails are most likely
dovetailed into the side pieces. The top is held on by four screws. The other rails and the bottom
rail also appear to be dovetailed, and all these dovetails are hidden by a board nailed vertically
about three-eighths, one centimeter. The rear legs are just what you'd expect.
This of course is an extension of the side, and this is the back. It's unusual there's no glue
block, and it doesn't look like there ever was one. And that brings us to the front legs,
which really give us the best clue as to the age. So I'm going to say this piece is American Empire.
Legs have a lot to do with that because it's so simple. I don't think it was made in a big factory,
so I'll say 1830, 1840, somewhere in there. So there are two major issues with this piece,
and then some minor ones. First is this top. It's seen a lot of hard use. It's all worn,
it's scratched, it's actually gouged. The other big problem are the drawers.
What's happened is that the back plates of the handles have carved very deep grooves
around the handles. I'm not quite sure how that happened. I'm going to start with these drawer
fronts. I want to fill this damaged area with epoxy putty, and so I want to experiment mixing
stain with the epoxy putty, see if I can get the exact right color. By using epoxy putty,
I'm going to minimize the sanding. I don't want to sand this, or I'll put it this way,
I want to keep sanding to an absolute minimum. This piece has a lot of texture to it. You can
even see what appear to be hand plane marks like in the top. Okay, I want to fill these big defects
around the knobs in such a manner that I hopefully won't have to like sand them, maybe not even sand
them at all, and so it's going to be tough. Each drawer varies in color. I'm going to use Elmer's
wood filler, which is a water-based filler. I'll use Mohawk blend-all stains as a colorant. I'm
using those because I have them. I think any powdered pigment will work, or acrylic colors,
probably a lot of different kinds of colors. I've already been experimenting a bit. I'm using
rock maple, dark brown mahogany, and dark red mahogany. This stuff seems a little dry even
though this is an unopened can. I have had it for a while. A little bit of water seems to have
revived it fine. Just a couple drops. I would advise anyone to buy a brand new jar of putty
to do something like this. This one was unopened, but I've had it for a little while. I'm not sure
how long. Literally drops of water if needed. Now some brown mahogany. Checking the color.
Got a ways to go. I keep adding drops of water and more of the colorant, the dark brown mahogany.
Starting to get there. I want to add some of the red mahogany and a little more of the dark
brown, I should say. I've got a good color here, I think, but I forgot to do something. I got a
little ahead of myself. I just want to clean this drawer front first, and I'll use a crud cutter
spray rag. Okay, now this is slow drying. Not too slow, I mean it'll dry in about,
I think about 15 minutes or so, but it gives you plenty of time to smooth it out. Dip my rag in a
little bit of water, just a little, and start cleaning off the excess. I don't want to drag
my rag over that deepest part there. This is a big razor blade type scraper. I'm going to let
this set for about 15 minutes, and then I'm going to go over it with a gray scotch-bite pad and
water very gently. Okay, this has dried for about a half an hour, actually, so I'm going to scrub
it now with a gray scotch-bite pad with a little bit of water on it, just gently. Cleans off the
excess. Now I won't know till this dries, and I put a little shellac on it, how I did with the
color. I let this dry overnight. I realized you can't really rush water-based products,
and now I'm going to go over it lightly with a dry scotch-bite pad, and then brush a little
coat of shellac on that area, see what it looks like. Yeah, I think that's good. It's a good
level of darkness, and, you know, I'm going to stain these other light areas a bit, so it's going
to work out pretty well. So I've applied the putty to each knob area, and I'm kind of smoothing it
out with a wet putty knife. I want to take off as much excess as possible. At the same time, I don't
want to, I found the first one, I was dishing out the big area, so I just want to be careful not to
dish it out, but smooth it out. I'm going to keep watching my clock, going back to the first one.
This one's been about 15 or 20 minutes. I'm going to carefully, you know, attempt to level it off
with the scraper, and all this is to minimize how much sanding, how much sanding I'm not going to do.
At least I hope not to. I'm still trying to figure out the optimum amount of time to let this dry
before I try to get rid of the excess. This has been drying for about an hour, and I'm taking
the gray pad and water and just really gently. I don't want to dish that out. Looks good so far,
but I'll leave it alone. You can see that the others aren't ready yet. I mean, these really
deep areas are still wet, and I could work around the edges here a little bit to smooth this out.
Okay, I let these dry overnight. I could tell I was working them too much yesterday. I was afraid
of dishing out those deep areas I filled, especially because this putty shrinks a bit
as it dries. This area is now dished out a little bit, so I've got to redo it. So I want to see what
I can do with this one, which I didn't wipe off too much yesterday. I'll see what I can do with this
scraper. Okay, I think I've done as I've gone as far as I can go with the scraper, and so now I'm
going to sand very lightly. 320 gold and a block. I'm sanding very lightly. I'm barely putting any
pressure on the block. Luckily, this putty sands easily, so I'm hoping I can get it to where I want
it without going through the existing finish. I'm getting there. Just taking my time. This stuff
sands easily. Okay, I think I got this where I want it. It's nice and level. I'm going to apply a little
stain to this area. I'm going to use an oil-based medium brown walnut stain. I think any oil-based
stain that you might get would work. I like this Mohawk stain. It's heavier bodied, has more pigment
in it, which can be good and bad. It's also very fast drying time. The assumption here is that the
stain will only take effect where there's raw wood in this repair area. It won't have any effect
on the areas that are finished. I was so worried about my putty not being dark enough. Now, of course,
it looks too dark. I'm not going to worry about it. I'm going to let it dry. I won't really know what it
looks like until I put some finish on it. Okay, I've got all these repair areas sanded. I'm ready to
stain them, but I also want to stain all these really ragged edges and places on these drawers.
First, I'll hit those edges just with 220. You can feel a little splintery or ragged.
I just brought up a splinter right there. I want to smooth them over a little bit.
This drawer front has a lot of nicks and scratches over the front of it. Okay, now on to the
case on top. Okay, the first step is going to be just to clean this. I'm going to use a crud cutter,
which is just some kind of, well, they call it a degreaser. I'm going to mix it with water.
This is concentrated, so I'm going to add about four ounces, about 120 milliliters of crud cutter
in two quarts of water, and that's about two liters. Starting from the bottom and going up
helps prevent streaking. I forgot I got to do something about, I got to plug these holes.
Yeah, this leg is loose. These screws above.
Yeah, after I clean this, I got it. The next thing I'll do is take care of this leg,
figure out what's going on with these screws.
Hammer marks. I imagine there's a nail there. There's a big nail there.
Got to love these hammer marks, though. These might be dowels. Of course, you can see a couple
of Phillips head screws there. The other leg, the left leg, has three screws, maybe a couple nails,
but it's solid. There's two huge holes for screws on the inside, but there's no screws in them.
These screws are so short, they barely had any purchase in the block they were supposed to hold.
There's a small dowel in there. I think there's another small dowel up in there. I may just
break this thing off. Could be a dowel or a nail up in here.
This is amazing. This thing looks like it's been maybe having problems very early in the game.
I'm going to scrape these surfaces clean and glue it back where it belongs.
Okay, let's see what we got. Man, that's good and sturdy. Okay, a bit of a mess here.
These are, you know, wooden pegs or dowels. I'll see if they hammer back in there. I'll put a
little glue on it. This is a screw hole. I'll put a screw back in there, a longer screw.
This screw hole, the screw, you can see there's a screw in there. That's the one I put in from
the other side. In fact, it went in so deep it protruded, so I took it out, cut it off,
put it back in there. I'll fill these with putty. I'm going to work a little glue into these pegs
and then see if they'll go down where they belong. If they don't, I'll cut them off and
just putty it up along with the rest.
I'm going to use the same putty I used on the drawer fronts. This leg has the same situation,
three screws, but they're working fine and luckily these holes are the right size for some plugs.
All this sort of scraping and stuff on the top, it all seems too shallow to try to fill or
anything, so I'm just going to sand the entire top, not down to the bare wood here, but just
to finish. I'm going to use this 3M Free Cut 220 paper. The top feels really smooth now, but I
kicked up quite a bit of dust. You know, a lot of people would make the case that this top should
have been sanded down because of the extensive damage. I was thinking about that while I was
sanding it, but number one, the customer did not ask me to refinish this piece of furniture. They
asked me if I could repair all the ugly damage to it. And number two, if you sanded this down,
you'd lose the texture, which looks like hand planing marks. That's what it looks like anyway.
If you did the top, well then you'd start looking at the sides and the rest of it.
You might end up refinishing the entire cabinet. Once again, I'll use the Mohawk wiping stain,
medium brown walnut, and I'm going to go over the entire piece because I want to catch all these
edges. Okay, I'm anxious to get a coat on this, especially the top. I'm dying to see what it looks
like. I'm going to be using the Waterlox tung oil varnish. It's a very, very beautiful finish
for antiques, especially if you brush it on. It's an old-fashioned varnish, but also it's
extremely durable, which is why I like it for these tops that are likely to see hard use.
This is the area that was so badly damaged. It looks good. You can see there's areas around
this top where it's trying to fisheye like crazy. So I'll get as much finish off my brush,
and then I'll just try to keep gently smoothing it out as it dries here. Of course, this is a very
slow-drying finish. There are different ways to deal with fisheye, all depending on what finish
you're using and how you're applying it. With this brush-on varnish, the first thing I do is
what I'm doing now. No matter how you're doing it or what finish you're using, the basic idea
is to get that contamination sealed in under the finish. So let this dry and see what we've got.
I've got to coat the rest of it. All right, I put this coat on, the first coat on yesterday morning.
It soaked in and dried so quickly that last night off-camera, I snuck in here and put another coat
on, which has soaked in pretty well too. Now I'm going to go over this entire thing with a scotch
brite pad and give it a third coat. I'm hoping it's the last coat. The top may need yet a fourth.
We'll see. These surfaces are not, you know, flat at all, and there's a lot of defects. That's why
I'm not sanding. I'm just knocking the gloss down with this scotch brite pad, and that'll be fine
for the next coat. I'll put a little piece of tape on places that need some touch-up, and then after
I go over everything with the scotch brite pad, I will do all the touch-ups at the same time.
Okay, I've gone over everything with the scotch brite pad, caught a few more touch-ups that I'd
missed previously. I got them with a marker, and now I'm going to put on a coat of satin
waterboxx varnish. This will be the second coat for the drawer faces and the drawer sides,
the third coat for the top.
These have dried up just fine overnight. They're great. It looks good. I think I'm just going to
give these a quick rub out. By rub out, you mean any procedure that you follow after the final coat
to get the sheen, to get it as smooth as you like, or to change the sheen or whatever.
Anything that you do could be called a rub out. At first glance, this surface doesn't look like
it needs a rub out, but very quickly, just by feel, there's like just thousands of little
teeny nits on here. It's not perfectly smooth, just airborne particles. Remember, this is a
very slow drying finish. Also, the finish, the sheen is not even in areas. You can see streaks
that are a different sheen, and they also sort of follow the unevenness of this top also.
And of course, that indicates that it could probably use another coat. I don't want to
give it another coat because I don't want to put a lot of varnish on this thing. I put three coats
on the top, two otherwise. I'm going to see if I can get rid of these nits and then go over it
with some steel wool and wax and see if that evens out the unevenness of the sheen. I'm going to take
a piece of craft paper. This is cut from a paper grocery bag. Smooth as the proverbial baby's
bottom. Now I'll take some 4-0 steel wool and some Howard's Feeding Wax polish. I don't think
we're ever going to know for sure what caused all this damage around the knobs. Typically,
these things don't spin. You can see this shaft is square, and usually this is a square hole. In
this case, they're round. It can spin, can spin around. And then I think the knobs were loose.
Everything spun around together.
So the escutcheon pin will keep that plate from spinning, and the lock washer
should help keep these from spinning also.
Well there you have it. A really nice antique chest of drawers. Some sort of
maybe American Empire period, 1830s, 1840s. It was pretty beat up when it came in,
and you know this piece of furniture, this chest of drawers, was used by a gentleman his entire
life, from childhood. And so it's very important to the family that it be preserved. So I didn't
sand it. I just tried to get rid of the ugly parts. You know you can't blame anyone for
wanting to take a sander and sanding this thing down, given the way that it looked.
But it's funny to me because, well, people all over are taking their palm sanders and
sanding these tops down in furniture factories all over the world, building reproduction furniture.
There's furniture finishers like myself trying desperately to make that furniture look like this.
I love the texture of the top. All the scars and signs of wear and tear and use and history.
I've got about 20 hours in this job, and these are the tools and materials I used.
If you're interested in the tools and materials I've used, you'll see in various places a button
that says View Products, and also in the description there's at the bottom of the
description it says More. Click on that. And if you like my videos, comment, like,
share, and feel free to repost them on other platforms. I'd appreciate it.
