Shield thickness - a thin shield does the job.

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
3 Video Views·Feb 19, 2026
People are often surprised at how thin shields were. In films, actors aim blows at shields. In a real fight this is seldom a bright thing to do. Instead, people aim around a shield, and so the parrying of blows is done with the edge and not the flat. Edgeways on, shields are very thick.
Lindybeige: a channel of archaeology, ancient and medieval warfare, rants, swing dance, travelogues, evolution, and whatever else occurs to me to make.
How thick is a shield? I mean, take this shield here for instance, it's a little buckler.
Is it very thick? Well, you may say there's a very simple way of finding out how thick it is.
What you do is you get a pair of calipers, and you measure the distance between where my
finger and thumb are now, and that's the thickness of the shield.
OK, there's some variance with the dome and so forth, and this edge is rolled round,
but, you know, broadly speaking, that's the thickness of the shield. Simple, right?
Well, I put it to you that in fact that measurement there is perhaps not the most important one
in determining the strength of this when it comes to parrying, say, a sword attack or whatever.
Maybe this is actually about this thick, which is the distance between the edge and my hand.
Why would that be the case? Well, because I tend not to parry with the thickness of the shield that way.
I tend to parry with the edge. If you're attacking me over there, I will hit you with the edge.
If you're coming there, I will hit you with the edge.
This is more noticeable with big shields. This is a really big shield.
If you're attacking me, you're incredibly unlikely to aim a blow at the centre of the shield,
because, well, it'll just hit me in the centre of the shield, and I won't have to do anything clever to parry that.
You just, fine, you hack away at the centre of my shield, and I'll attack something a bit more useful of you.
You're going to be aiming not at the shield, you're going to be trying to get around the shield to hit me.
In which case I'm going to be parrying, and I'm going to be parrying with the edge.
And so if you're going to chop into my shield, you're going to be chopping from the edge into the woodwork to get at me.
So in fact, this shield you could say is four foot thick, because the edge is what does almost all of the parrying in melee.
Now of course against missiles it's not quite so straightforward, is it?
If I parry a missile with this, then it probably is coming in from the front.
But if I'm holding it away from me, even a fast-travelling missile is ...
obviously a bullet from a high-velocity modern rifle will just go straight through this.
I'm not talking about such a thing. But an arrow, say, is going to turn the shield when it hits it.
It's going to take energy out of the arrow and make it much less dangerous to me.
If I've got the shield braced against me, and I get hit there, then yes, fair enough, the arrow can then penetrate much more easily.
But if I'm holding the shield out, and if I'm expecting people to be shooting arrows at me,
I'll be doing that, putting some distance between the shield and me.
Then I've got this buffer zone, this buffer zone here, and this turning effect.
It of course doesn't turn right on the boss, but there I've got a nice big bit of iron to hit, so I should be all right.
If shields didn't protect people against arrows, then why did people use them to protect themselves against arrows for so long?
Presumably they did protect people reasonably effectively from arrows.
And if they didn't, then archers would have been super deadly.
And yet there were plenty of armies that weren't particularly strong in archery.
Take the Romans, for instance, you know, they weren't particularly archery specialists.
And yet, I'm told, they did terribly well in the ancient world.
Lindybeige!
