Why Do Shields Have Different Shapes? Pros and Cons of Every Shape.

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
4 Video Views·Feb 23, 2026
Why do shields have so many different shapes? And what are the advantages of every of them? Let's find out!
Hello everyone and welcome.
So you've probably noticed that shields come in a ton of different shapes.
This one is rectangular, this one is oval, this one's round, and this one's hexagonal,
and so on.
So the question is, why do shields have so many different shapes, and what is the advantages
and disadvantages of every single one of them?
Well, let's find out.
Okay, so before we start, I just want to mention that, of course, a big reason why shields
have different shapes is just a certain cultural preference.
A certain culture will prefer a round shield, while another one will prefer a rectangular
one, even though it's not necessarily the best shape.
But shapes also have main advantages and disadvantages, and that's also a big reason why different
cultures use those different shapes.
So let's get started with the first shape of shield, which is the oval shield.
So some of the first evidence we have of shields even being used very often show oval shields,
or rectangular sometimes, but mostly it will be oval shields.
And an oval shield is a great kind of shield for several different reasons.
First of all, it has a very, very good range for shield bashes and stuff like that.
If I hold out the shield like this, I have the range of my whole arm, but then I also
have this whole section here of the shield as range, so I can hold my opponent away or
do a shield bash or something like that very easily with an oval shield because it has
so much range between the handle and the actual end of the shield.
It also has very, very good protection.
Now, of course, this will depend based on the size of the shield.
That is the main factor that will change how protective it is, but the shape also does
change to a certain degree because for the same size, like this shield here, is in surface
area just a little bit smaller than this one, yet this one actually protects me more because
it covers more of the parts of my body that I actually need to protect.
If I hold it like this, it will basically protect my whole body from the shoulder down
to a bit under my knee.
And it does that very well because with this oval shape, it protects the whole length of
the human body instead of a round shield that will take a lot of this surface area
and place it out on the sides where you don't actually really need protection.
If I hold the shield like this, I always protect from the shoulder down to, like, mid-thigh
or something like that, so not as much as an oval shield simply because for the same
surface area, the round shield has more protection out to the sides where you don't actually
really need it because, well, you are not that wide.
So, overall, this is a really, really good shield for just protection and also just range.
Overall, really good shield for fighting with, but it does have some problems.
First of all, it is extremely impractical to make a formation, like, how do you make
a formation with an oval shield?
Of course, it's possible, but it's way harder than with some other kinds of shield like
rectangular or round or something like that, and that is simply because, well, the shields
don't really have a way to, together, if you have a lot of them, protect a surface
without leaving any big gaps.
The oval shield also has a relatively bad durability.
It's not very, very tough, and that is simply because instead of the round shield that takes
all its surface area and assembles it around one single center, the oval shield kind of
draws it out, and that just makes it easier to break.
A long, thin stick will be easier to break than a short, thick one, even though they
weigh the same and have the same volume.
And then, the oval shield also has a bit of a minor problem, which is the fact that it's
not very easy to carry around.
First of all, if you walk with it, it's kind of going to touch your leg all the time because,
well, it's long, and if you try to wear it on your back, well, of course, you can wear
it on your back.
The problem is that, again, it's going to touch your legs while you're walking, and
it's not the most practical.
You can also not sit down, for example, with an oval shield on your back.
So, overall, it's not the most practical to carry around.
It is, of course, perfectly possible to carry around, but it's not the most practical.
Okay, so up next, we have the hexagonal shield.
Now, this shield is very, very similar to the oval shield.
It has good protection because it's long, it has good range.
It's not very durable because it's long, and it's not too good to make a formation.
Now, I will say it is a little bit better to make a formation because it kind of has
straight edges and you have more of a way to make the shield have interlock to make
a better formation.
It still is bad, but it's a little bit better than the oval shield.
Then it's also a little bit less protective because if you look at this shield, you kind
of have these straight lines.
An oval shield with the same dimensions will have its edges going like this and just going
to go a little bit further out here.
While on the hexagonal shield, you're kind of cutting that away, so you're losing just
a little bit of protection.
Not a lot, but just a little bit.
And finally, the hexagonal shield is easier to make than an oval shield because, well,
you're just measuring a very geometric shape and you can just cut it out very easily by
cutting straight lines.
An oval shield is kind of hard to cut out.
But overall, the hexagonal shield is just very, very similar to the oval shield.
And the fact is that these advantages of the hexagonal and oval shield just shows why they
were used by Gallic tribes or Celts or something like that because they did not really make
any formations and focused way more on individual fighters fighting on their own and using their
shield to protect themselves and not really the other ones in their army or in their formation.
Okay, so next up we have the rectangular shield.
So this will be like everything like a scutum like this one or like a pavis shield or something
like that.
Now, the rectangular shield has the big advantage of having a very, very good protection for
its size.
Of course, this is a very big shield.
Of course, it protects a lot, but for its size, it protects a lot because you have a
very long shield that is not so wide that you don't need the protection on the side
like kind of on the round shield.
And yeah, it just will offer very, very good protection overall.
Now, the biggest advantage that the scutum or rectangular shields in general have over
an oval shield is the fact that they are very, very good at making formations like the Romans
made a lot of formations with rectangular shields.
And of course, well, rectangles will cover up an area without any gaps very, very easily.
And that's just why you can make very, very good formations with rectangular shields.
Now, the problem with them is that they are generally speaking very heavy for their size,
meaning that while a rectangular shield, yes, it protects a lot.
But if you take an oval shield, it's basically the same.
Only you have cut out these angles here, and you just have the most necessary part
of the protection.
On a rectangular shield, these angles here on the side add up just a little bit of weight
and just makes the shield heavier overall for the same size as an oval shield or something like that.
Generally speaking, it's also hard to use from horseback because you have these angles
down at the sides that will kind of hit the side of the horse with each step.
And it's just going to be harder than to use something like an oval shield that will like
taper down and only protect your leg without hitting the sides of the horse too much.
Now, of course, this is mainly due to the size of the shield.
But as a general rule, rectangle shields are going to be harder to use from horseback.
And as the oval shield, they are also very impractical to carry around.
For the same reason that they are long, they will hit your leg very hard to wear on your back.
Even harder than the oval shield because they don't really shape up to the human body.
They have these angles that will kind of protrude from your shoulders and stuff like that.
They are just going to be more impractical to carry around than even an oval shield and
even more impractical than something like a round shield or something like that.
So next, we have a kite shield.
Now, this is not exactly a kite shield.
It's actually more of a heater shield.
But I don't really have a kite shield, so I'm just using this to illustrate the point.
A kite shield will basically be this shape here.
Only it will have a longer point down here than this heater shield.
And it will also usually have more of a rounded top than this heater shield.
Now, the main advantage of a kite shield is that it's really good for cavalry.
Simply because of the fact that that long tapering point down at the end of the shield
acts as a really good protection for the leg of the cavalryman.
And of course, when you're riding a horse, you will only have one leg exposed.
So you don't need such a wide protection as you have on an oval shield or something like that.
You only need that small section just to protect that one leg that is exposed when riding the horse.
And that the kite shield does really, really well.
The problem with the kite shield is that it kind of is impractical to fight with in general.
Because it has that long point protruding downwards
that just makes for a bit of an unbalanced shield in a certain kind of way.
It's also really, really bad to make formations.
Because, well, if you put kite shields side by side, there will be big gaps in between them.
So you just cannot really make a good formation with them.
Of course, you could make some sort of formation, of course.
But it's not as good as some other shields like rectangular shields.
And finally, the durability of the shield is not the best.
It's not horrible, of course, but it's not the best.
Simply because that long point protruding down longer than this one.
This is only a heater shield.
But the long point has higher chances of breaking.
Not very high chances, but it has higher chances of breaking.
And now we come to, well, the heater shield.
So this one.
Now, the good thing about this shield, mainly, is that if I hold it like this to protect myself,
it will protect very, very well the most vital parts of your body.
It has that V-shape, basically, that will protect most of your upper body very, very well.
Now, of course, again, this depends a lot on the size of the shield,
but the shape does help a little bit.
And second advantage is that it's also relatively okay to use from horseback
because it still has a little bit of this extension down towards it.
It's not the best, but it can perfectly well be used from horseback
and will still protect the rider relatively well.
Now, as the kite shield, it has a problem that it's not really good to make formation.
It's not as bad as the kite shield, but it still is not the best at all
because, well, it has this kind of weird shape
and you cannot really interlock a lot of these shields together to make good formation.
It also has the problem that it has a relatively bad range for its size.
Of course, this one is strapped, so this matters a lot,
but if I was holding it in the middle, well, the problem is that the shield is not very, very wide,
so it kind of lacks a little bit of that range that you could get from other shields.
So, finally, we come to the round shield.
Now, the round shield is kind of a weird one because it doesn't have any major advantage
but it doesn't have any major disadvantage.
It's a good overall shield, good for everything, but not the best for anything.
Now, I will say it is probably one of the most durable shields.
Of course, what's going to matter the most for durability is, like,
the thickness of the shield, the material used, and that kind of stuff.
But, as a general rule, if you want a durable shield,
you should probably make it round simply because it doesn't have, kind of,
any weak spots like other shields would where the part of the shield is thinner,
like on this oval shield.
Everything is just exact same size and that just makes it more durable
for the same thickness and material used.
The main disadvantage it has is that it doesn't have a particularly good leg protection.
There is nothing extending down to protect the legs.
It is not very, very long, so if I have to protect my legs right now,
I have to bend down like this all the way down and then my head is exposed
and it takes a long time to, like, go down like this.
So, it doesn't have the best leg protection.
But other than that, well, it can be worn on the back very easily.
You can also walk with it relatively easily because it doesn't extend so far down.
That is impractical and will hit your legs all the time.
It is perfectly usable to make a formation,
like the Vikings made shield walls and everything like that,
the Greeks and everything like that used a round shield to make formations.
So, it's very good to make formations.
It can also be used from horseback.
Of course, not the best to use from horseback, but it can.
So, overall, well, it is not the best for anything,
but good as an overall shield if you don't really have a particular thing
that you need to do with it, but you just need a shield for general use.
Okay, so that was it.
And, of course, those are only some shapes of shields,
but they are the most common ones.
Of course, you could have some other shapes,
like crescent-shaped shields and stuff like that,
that will also have their particular role.
But these ones were the basic and the most common ones.
And, of course, well, not only the shape will affect how the shield is used
and what are its advantages.
Of course, the thickness of the shield, the material used,
the hand construction, the size, all of that will matter a whole lot
for how the shield can or is used.
But the shape does play its role.
And, well, I think it was interesting to explore the shape of these shields.
So, anyways, I hope you enjoyed the video, and I'll see you in the next one.
