Is This the Biggest Bubble Since the Dot-Com Crash? | Aman Verjee

Market Insider
175 followers
Early-stage startup funding is reaching levels that seasoned investors say they have never seen before, with large checks being written long before customers or revenue materialize. In this episode, Silicon Valley venture capital investor Aman Verjee shares what he is seeing on the ground, why today’s funding environment feels unusual even by Valley standards, and which signals investors and founders should watch as capital continues to concentrate. He also explains how underlying fundamentals are increasingly diverging in ways that echo past market cycles explored in his book The Brief History of Financial Bubbles.
Tags:
#investing #aibubble #venturecapital #startupfunding #marketbubbles #saas
AI Generated·May contain errors
Are we in a financial bubble right now?
And how's the economy doing?
Our guest today is Aman Virji,
who used to be the CFO of PayPal,
and he's an insider in the venture capital community.
He's here to tell us what he's seeing right now
in the venture capital space.
He's also done extensive research on bubbles
in his new book.
We're now seeing term sheets for AI companies
that don't have customers,
don't have revenue for 25 to $50 million,
and they don't really have much more than a business plan,
and three people who are writing some code.
That is very unusual.
I don't think I've actually ever seen that before.
So this might be the first time
I'm seeing those kinds of evaluations
for those types of companies.
I'm Siamak, and this is Market Insider.
Aman, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Thank you, good to see you again.
We want to talk to you about the situation with economy.
The markets are going up,
there are some booms in the AI area,
and there are other booms,
and there's conflicts internationally.
What is your assessment of the situation right now?
So I see this as a investor in technology, right?
So my lens is a little bit colored
by what I see and feel every day.
If I had to evaluate, I think I would say
the overall economy feels pretty strong to me.
At the end of last year,
we had GDP growth in the US of around 2% year over year,
which is okay, not great, but certainly not bad.
First quarter was a negative quarter.
We had a GDP contracting in the US,
but a lot of that was the threat of tariffs
and people front-running tariffs,
and so I think that was a little bit of a weird quarter.
Q2, it was 3.8% GDP growth.
Q3 feels like it's gonna be 3% or more.
We're now better than we were, I think, a year ago,
just in terms of the top line on GDP growth.
As you said, the stock market's at an all-time high.
Corporate earnings look like
they're growing at double-digit rates.
If you're in business and looking at companies
and investing in companies broadly,
especially in technology, I think there's a lot of good news.
I think the downside is there's a lot of anxiety about jobs.
I'm on the board of a college newspaper
at Stanford University,
so I talk to 18- to 20-year-old Stanford students,
mostly computer science majors,
although they kind of study everything.
They are very anxious about their job prospects.
The US unemployment rate is 4.3%,
which, when I studied economics,
I was taught that was full employment,
meaning everyone who wants a job has a job, right?
But these kids, you wouldn't know that.
If you just sat with those kids,
you wouldn't know that the unemployment rate is only 4.3%.
They're all having trouble finding the job they want.
They're taking six months to a year
to find the job that they want.
The number of jobs being created in the US seems to be,
I know we're not getting a lot of data
because the government shutdown has made it hard to get data
even if you can believe the data you get,
but even the payroll data just seems to be like
we're not creating a lot of jobs in the US.
That's causing the anxiety,
and so it's a bit of a, I guess, a have or have not
or a K-shaped economic growth period
where the return on capital is high,
companies are doing well,
especially the big tech companies doing well.
That's the upside of the K,
and then the jobs are trending flat or even down,
and that's the low side of the K.
I think a lot of that is just kids finding it hard
in an economy where people are focusing on automation
and AI is able to deliver work in a very efficient way.
The number of jobs being created is more scarce.
That's the downside.
It's just the job creation has been very slow, I think.
You have a view on the startup community.
You're involved with the VC community,
and how is that looking?
How does the investment into VCs
and how does this exit look like?
I think the investments into VC is,
it kind of peaked around 2020, 21.
Then we had a couple of very tough years.
The last year, year and a half, has been a lot better,
a lot more money flowing into venture capital funds
and a lot of venture capital-backed companies.
Again, a have and have not story.
There's AI companies on the one hand
that are able to attract a lot of capital
and very high valuations.
Seed stage valuations in the Valley can be 25 to 50 million
for a seed stage or a series A company
that's AI native and AI first.
If you are not doing AI, it's very hard to raise money,
and those companies are not finding investors
and not able to scale.
I think we've seen something like that
in the public market as well,
which also flows into the private markets.
We follow an index of SaaS companies at my firm.
These are mostly non-AI companies,
although some of them have an AI capability,
but they're fundamentally sound SaaS companies,
software as a service, growing, doing well,
most of them making money.
They're trading at six or seven times sales.
It used to be that those companies
would trade at 10 or 11 times sales,
so they've basically been cut in half from 2017, 18, 19.
But at the same time, the Magnificent Seven,
any open AI, big companies with an AI story
are getting sky-high valuations.
You mentioned that the seed capital
is 25 million to 50 million.
How odd is that in your space?
I used to work at 500 Startups,
which was the leading seed investor in the world
when I was there.
I was the chief operating officer,
and during my tenure, we made over 500 investments
in companies all over the world.
Our term sheet at the time
was $3.5 to $4 million valuation.
So if you came to our accelerator,
we would take a standard deal
and you would get a $3.5 to $4 million valuation.
Sometimes we would go, for a very special company,
we might go out of the box.
We might go to $8 or $10 million valuations
for certain companies,
but very rarely would we go more than that
for a seed stage company.
And for us, these stages, you have a business,
you have a real product, you've got product market fit,
you're scaling and you've got customers
and you know what you're doing.
We're now seeing term sheets for AI companies
that don't have customers, don't have revenue
for $25 to $50 million,
and they don't really have much more than a business plan
and three people who are writing some code.
That is very unusual.
I don't think I've actually,
I don't think I've ever actually ever seen that before.
So this might be the first time
I'm seeing those kinds of valuations
for those types of companies.
Do you think they're real?
Because there's these talks of AI bubble.
Yeah, I think we are, you know,
you got to think about different types of bubbles, right?
I've got a book coming out at the end of the year.
It's called The Brief History of Financial Bubbles.
And I talk about 10 different bubbles
over the course of history,
going back to Amsterdam in 1636 and tulips,
and then ending with AI and what's going on today.
There are some bubbles like the tulip bubble
where the prices went way up,
and then they came way down.
And they did that over the space of about a year,
a year and a half.
And you look back and you realize,
well, there wasn't a lot of economic value created there.
So that really was a creation and a destruction of wealth.
And there's some other bubbles that are like that.
Like there's their land bubbles in Australia in 1886.
I think 2008, 2009 in the US and UK and Ireland and Spain
was another very destructive real estate bubble.
Not a lot of value created.
Real estate prices went up, came back down again.
It was born because of interest rates being too low
and some financial engineering
that didn't create any value.
There are tech bubbles that do create value.
So the biggest ones are in the UK in 1845.
And then in primarily in the US in 1999,
that the dot-com bubble.
And I think the AI,
it feels like a little bit like that dot-com bubble period
where there were a lot of great companies created, right?
We had Nvidia, we had Amazon,
we had PayPal where I worked,
eBay and Yahoo, Salesforce.
Coming out of that bubble that did implode
and there were a lot of losers,
but there were a lot of winners in that space as well.
And with the profits from the winners,
other companies were created.
So when I was at PayPal,
the two founders were Peter Thiel and Elon Musk.
Peter Thiel took his money from PayPal
and he was the first big investor in Facebook.
Elon Musk took his profits and made SpaceX and Tesla
and the Boring Company and then, you know,
and bought X.com, right?
And so, or Twitter.
And so there's a lot of value created out of that bubble,
but there was a lot of losers as well.
I think AI feels like it's gonna be a lot of winners
and a lot of these companies
that don't have good fundamental business models
are gonna be losers.
Now that said, at the dot-com bubble,
the price-earnings ratio of the market
was 70 times earnings, north of that.
The mag seven today is 27, 28, 29 times earnings.
So it's expensive, but not quite the stuff
that bubbles are made of.
So we like AI.
We think it's a transformative technology
that will be on the order of mobile and the internet.
Those are the only two other innovations
I can think of in my lifetime that were as impactful.
So we like AI.
We do have some AI bets.
I'm just very concerned
that there are gonna be a lot of losers
and a lot of companies spending a lot of money
they don't have that are,
it's a CapEx-intensive business.
They, in order to finance the CapEx,
they have to raise money at higher and higher valuations.
That's not a good recipe.
And so when we see those types of business plans,
we try to stay clear.
You mentioned the investment in the infrastructure.
So when we are getting the $20 chat GDP
or other products a month,
how much power does that take?
How much is the cost of that for these AI companies?
Yeah, it does.
When you go to Google and search for something,
that search happens in about 0.1 or 0.2 seconds,
and you will get back an answer
and maybe a handful of links as to where to go.
When you do a search on the Google Gemini,
it's running probably 50 to 100 searches
and then synthesizing all that information
and then giving you the answer.
And so it's really 50 to 100 times more intensive,
even though it only takes a couple of seconds,
it does take 50 to 100 times more power,
more energy, more compute power
than what Google's traditional search does.
And so a company like OpenAI, which runs chat GPT,
or they'll be at a run rate for 20 billion in revenue
by the end of the year,
but their costs are probably three or four times that.
So they're burning 20, 40, $60 billion a year
in capital spend right now
just to power the searches that they're doing.
So I guess the short answer is no, $20 a month,
and as a subscription fee,
it probably won't cover all those costs.
A lot of that is capital intensive.
So they're building data centers,
which will then enable them to run the compute power.
So that's a one-time investment
that'll pay off over many, many years.
So it's not the operating power cost?
It's not the operating power cost,
although that's a big piece of it,
but the majority of it now is CapEx
to build out the data centers
and to be able to then scale later.
I do think that I would imagine
that the cost of power is gonna be,
a significant constraint on AI development right now
is energy and where you're gonna get it from.
Some of the deals we've seen from OpenAI and Oracle,
for instance, they announced a $500 billion deal
with doing OpenAI and Oracle,
and they wanna use that to build data centers.
Very few of them in California,
none of them in California,
actually, they're all gonna be in Texas and Phoenix
for, I guess, for cost and regulatory reasons,
but they don't have the money to raise right now,
so to spend that money.
So they're gonna have to go raise the money and finance it.
And the energy cost associated with that deal alone
is like two Hoover Dams or four nuclear power plants.
I mean, it is a lot of power that it's gonna be,
that'll be a demand on the grid for years to come.
So it is, I think, incumbent on the US as a federal matter
to be able to provide that energy in order to keep up.
But the payoffs are tremendous if you can do it.
You mentioned that you are involved
with a number of SaaS technology type companies,
like, I guess we can call them
traditional technology software companies.
You mentioned that they are not getting a lot of traction
in the markets, in the financial markets.
Where do you think that space is headed?
Yeah, I don't know.
If you were a SaaS company five years ago
and you were growing at 25, 30% a year,
even if you weren't making money,
you could raise money in an IPO
and be trading at 10, 12 times revenues.
Now those multiples are down to six or seven.
And there's more of an impetus on being profitable
or at least breaking even.
So it's become a lot more challenging to be a SaaS company.
I think all these companies are gonna have to make
a determination as to whether AI helps them or hurts them.
There's a lot of fear in traditional SaaS
that AI's gonna be disruptive.
It's gonna take their place.
Is that the fear?
Yeah, if you're a vertical SaaS company
and you're selling into,
like, you know, think of a,
let's take an example,
like a call center software company,
someone like, you know, Zendesk,
who for a long time had a good run in the public markets
and was a very valuable company,
but they do call, they operate call centers.
These are individuals who are answering phone calls
and things like, hey, where's my package?
You know, and I have a problem with my television.
Using the software, yeah.
Well, now if you can speak to not a person,
but an AI chatbot, right?
Maybe an AI company comes along
and displaces the whole call center software industry.
If you're a company like Five9,
which is in the public market,
or Zendesk, which was in the public market
and got taken private,
you might be thinking,
wow, my business just got very severely challenged
almost overnight from AI,
which has just disrupted my industry.
And it's not just, you know, call center software.
Like, if you're running a law firm,
I gotta think every law firm is thinking,
if AI can do contracts and figure out legal agreements
around nondisclosure agreements or rental agreements
and do it for half the cost and half the time
as a paralegal or an associate,
that's a disruptive technology.
So a lot of SaaS companies I think are gonna be
in a place where that AI can really disrupt what they do
and take away their business.
On the flip side,
they can use AI to enhance their capabilities.
Like one of our investments is in Canva,
which is a software company that does online collaboration
and builds presentations.
And they've built and acquired an AI company
and built it into their functionality,
where you can use that to design presentations
and make them a lot more beautiful
and a lot more usable, a lot more functional.
Some software companies that are SaaS companies
that are doing Excel spreadsheets
or financial planning and tools
can now use AI to help you build your Excel models faster
or your financial planning tools faster,
do budget scenarios better.
And so it can become a positive or a negative.
And I think there'll be winners and losers.
And I think for that space in general,
the winners will unlock vast new markets
and become a lot more valuable.
The losers will have to focus on getting profitable.
And maybe if they can be public
or if they can't be public at whatever valuation,
then some private equity company will come in
and buy them out and then redo the cost structure
and figure out how to bundle up a bunch of these companies
and package them up
and just make them a lot more efficient.
But that's typically what happens
to legacy technology companies.
Aman, based on what you're seeing out there,
where would you invest?
I can tell you where we, the areas that we like,
we are, so I described the market before
as being a lot of haves and have-nots,
a lot of very hot, hyped AI companies,
especially even at the seed level,
they're getting valuations that are very high
and I think unsustainably high.
I think that feels like a bit of a bubble
where there'll be a valuation reset.
Do they have competition?
Yeah, we have a lot of competition.
Everybody wants to invest in AI.
Everybody I know wants to find a way
to get into open AI or Anthropic
or chase some of these very high-profile companies.
They're very good companies, but they're very expensive.
We, as investors, we're not gonna get a deal
getting into a company like that
if you're not already in it.
If you're in it, already great.
If you're trying to get in now,
I think it's very late to get in.
But there are a lot of AI-enabled companies
that are off that beaten path.
They're not one of the top 10 well-known names,
but they're like one level down.
But they're making hundreds of millions in revenue.
They see the opportunities that AI can create.
They can become profitable using the efficiencies
that AI can generate.
And because they're off the beaten path,
they're not getting overbid by all the competition.
So there are lots of opportunities
in that second category that we like.
And then we're also, our firm focuses
on secondary investments, which means
that we buy out existing investors
from companies that we like.
So rather than going and buying from,
let's take an example like Canva.
They're not a public company,
but they wanna give liquidity back
to their shareholders and employees
every six months or every year.
And if they were on the public market today,
I think they'd be much more valuable
than they are right now.
But by being in the private market
and buying in their secondary offers
and buying out their early employees,
we think we can get a discount
to what that company is worth in the long run.
So we have our niche of where we like to focus on,
and it tends to be these well-known,
but not the elite eight or the top 10 private companies
that everyone's chasing.
It's usually one step down
and usually through a second level.
Can you explain those?
Like what are the sectors that you think
will benefit from this boom?
Yeah, I think the ones that I think
are seeing a lot of growth,
we know that FinTech is going through
a lot of transformation, a huge renaissance,
a lot of companies that are very successful.
They're doing everything from payments to online lending.
They can use AI to come up with smarter credit scores
as a, for instance, underwrite small business loans
better and faster.
There's a whole wave towards stable coins
and stable coin issuers
that I think is gonna be another profitable area.
Web 3.0, decentralized finance,
companies using blockchain to create tokens and businesses
I think is also very valuable.
So those are some of the spaces that we've been looking at.
We do like SaaS companies.
We think there are a lot of high growth SaaS companies
where AI is a capability
and they're using it to accelerate their growth
and their profitability.
That's another area.
Our biggest company right now is SpaceX.
That's probably our number one position in our second fund.
Anduro is probably one of our big positions
in our third fund.
So those are aerospace and defense technology.
So we have a pretty broad remit as to what we like
but we're looking for companies
where the growth dynamic is really, really good.
They're going after a big industry that's disruptive.
They've got founders and management teams
that we really love.
And the technology we can understand
that we think will be disruptive
and give them a defensible moat in the future.
You mentioned that these software companies are worried
and especially the SaaS companies are worried
that they're gonna get replaced completely by AI.
How likely is that?
Yeah, it depends on the industry.
I think inevitably every industry will be reshaped
and disrupted by AI.
It's just a matter of time.
The obvious first ones are call centers
where you've got a lot of people doing repetitive tasks
off of a script and AI can do that very well.
It turns out that autonomous driving works pretty well.
Those cars seem to be safer than humans
in terms of their accident rates.
If you're driving Uber or DoorDash
or if you're a, I guess even an automobile company,
like that is all gonna get disrupted and changed by AI
over the next three, five, seven years,
maybe even faster in some of those cases.
Law firms, for instance,
we know that AI is able to provide contracts
and create documents that now takes lawyers a lot of time
and a lot of money to do and AI can do that faster.
So some of those are very obvious,
but I think almost every industry will become disrupted
and challenged by AI.
So every company has got to think about
when is AI coming for me?
How am I gonna use it as a capability enhancer,
something that'll improve my business?
And how do I defend against the encroachment on my business?
You've done a lot of research on your book about bubbles.
Can you tell us more about these bubbles?
Yeah, they're all fascinating.
I did 10 of them in my book.
The very first one was the Amsterdam bubble in 1636 and 1637.
The very last one was the 2020, 21 bubble,
which I call the everything, everywhere, all at once bubble.
I'm a movie fan.
And so it was like a global asset bubble
and multiple current countries and asset classes
for the first time in history.
And so I kind of finish on that one.
One of the fun ones that I really got into,
which I think is also, it's a really interesting one
just for maybe for your audience is in 1720,
there were two bubbles, one in England, one in France,
the South Sea Company and the Mississippi Company.
And both of these were like trading monopolies
that the government created.
And so those companies became very valuable in 1718, 1719.
But the way that the governments
went about creating those bubbles
and then the ending
and how they put their countries back together
was really interesting.
In the case of England,
the South Sea Company was,
it became a $6 trillion company in today's dollars.
So more than NVIDIA today.
And they had the trading monopoly
between England and Spain and the New World,
which for them was the Spanish South Sea.
So they were just a trading company.
They were just a trading company.
Kind of like doing the trade.
Yeah, they were running slaves
and spices and commodities to the New World.
That never really became a big operation for them,
but there was a lot of hype
and a lot of like profits from the New World
that people thought would become a valuable company.
But it was a lot of financial engineering
and not a company based on fundamental underlying
moral business that they thought
would ultimately be successful
and live past these slave trade agreements.
And the bad news for France,
they had the Mississippi Company.
They saw what England was doing
and the South Sea Company.
And they said, well, we better get in on the action too.
Because if England is able to create this big monopoly
and get a lot of money out of it,
and then they can take on the English debt,
then that's gonna put them ahead.
And we have to keep up.
So they created the Mississippi Company
and did the exact same thing.
Gave them a monopoly with the New World,
which for them were the North American French colonies,
the Louisiana Territory.
And so bit by bit,
they kind of went into this challenge, this war.
The South Sea Company would raise money,
the Mississippi Company would raise money.
South Sea would go,
then the Mississippi Company would go bigger.
And eventually Mississippi became a $9 trillion company.
That would have been the biggest company of all time,
bigger than Nvidia, bigger than Microsoft.
But France made one really big mistake.
In 1719, they gave away the banking system
to the head of the Mississippi Company.
That guy was named John Law.
He was a fascinating character in history.
He was actually a convicted murderer who is Scottish.
He escapes from Scotland at the tender age of 23,
a convicted murderer.
He breaks out of jail.
He leaves Scotland never to return.
And he bounces around Europe for 15 years or 20 years.
And then he ends up in France
where he's friends,
gambling buddies with the Duc de Noailles.
The Duc de Noailles is,
he works for the Regent of France, the Duc d'Orléans.
And John Law convinces him,
hey, give me the Central Bank of France, the Banque Royale.
And so now he's got not only the biggest trading monopoly
of all time, but also the Bank of France.
And this kind of gets back to morality
and business integrity, right?
What does he do with the Bank of France?
Does he keep it independent?
No, he prints a lot of money
and he creates a massive inflation
by creating all this fiat currency.
And the result of this,
and then he uses that cheap money
to feed the Mississippi Company flotations
and makes the Mississippi Company
become the most valuable company ever.
Well, the result is in January of 1720,
inflation is now running at 23%.
Now the peasants rebel.
They Paysans in France are like,
we've had it with this inflation.
No more of this fiat currency.
And they go to the government
and they try to get the government
to eliminate this debased fiat currency.
Government doesn't agree.
They actually side with John Law.
The people are saying,
we want to use gold and silver to buy stuff.
Government resists and says,
nope, we're gonna outlaw gold and silver as legal tender.
So you have to use this fiat currency
as the only way to buy and sell things.
And that makes it even worse.
Now people can't own gold, they can't use gold.
If you've ever been to France,
you know how they love their jewelry
and their gold and silver.
Big mistake.
So now they turn on John Law.
They have no choice.
The people are now very angry.
By April, they've eliminated the fiat currency.
They're back to a gold standard.
By April of that year, John Law's out of a job.
By May, he's under house arrest
and ostensibly for his own safety.
By the end of the year, he's like out of the country
and he's gotta flee again.
And so now the bubble pops
and France goes into a dark depression.
Interestingly in England, at the same time,
they never compromised their banking system.
Some of that's by design.
Some of that is just the Bank of England
was a Whig-controlled company
and the South Sea Company was Tory-aligned
and so they remained independent.
England has a very mini-recession,
but they maintain central bank independence.
The credibility of the government,
after taking that early hit, recovers.
They actually had a great prime minister out of it,
Robert Walpole, and he consolidates power
under his authority as a Whig.
And he becomes their prime minister for 20 years.
He runs a very tight ship.
They pay down their debts.
They're able to protect the securities markets
in Exchange Alley.
Within three to four years, the economy is growing again.
They can raise money whenever they want to.
So despite the loss on that bubble.
So the number went to zero,
like the company essentially went.
South Sea Company basically goes to zero or close to it.
It gives up all the gains from 1719, 1720.
It goes back to where they were in 1717, 1718,
just a minor league trading operation now.
The slave trade never amounts to anything.
They eventually go defunct in 1732,
so they bobble along.
But the English government says,
okay, if you invested in the bubble and you lost money,
we're not gonna make you whole.
Buyer beware.
If you made money during the bubble
and you profited from it,
as long as you didn't engage in fraud, okay.
They catch the South Sea Company directors
who were paying bribes to government employees
and they kick them out.
A couple of them go to the Tower of London.
So they take a responsible view
of how to put the company back together again.
And they never compromise the banking system.
And then by the 1720s, the economy's growing.
England's actually stronger than they were before.
They're paying down their debts.
They can raise money, so they have a standing army.
They build the most powerful Navy in the world.
France, meanwhile,
because they've compromised their banking system,
loses a central bank.
Nobody trusts a fiat currency.
France doesn't have a fiat currency for another 120 years.
It takes Napoleon to bring back the central bank
in the 1800s.
And now they're on the gold standard.
And when you're collecting taxes and gold
and having to pay your bills in gold and not paper currency,
you have to be fiscally disciplined,
which France can't do.
They default on their debt, crown debt, in 1726.
So now their debt is uninvestable.
Now they can't raise money.
People don't like paying taxes.
They can't raise a standing army.
They can't build a Navy.
By the 1730s, they lose the war of the Polish succession.
1740s, they lose the war of the Austrian succession.
By the 1750s, they lose the war to England.
They're three times bigger than England,
but they lose the war of the Seven Years' War to England,
this tiny little country in Northern Europe
with its stupid Navy and its British accents.
And they lose that war.
And in that war, they lose North America,
which is why we're speaking English today and not French.
And now the French are demoralized.
They can't pay their bills.
Their treasury is depleted.
They can't win any wars.
They've lost their colonies in North America.
This impacts their economy, their trade.
1770s come along.
Now the king is hiding out in Versailles
with the aristocracy.
By the 1780s, they're like one bad harvest
away from revolution.
It happens in 1788.
By 1789, in France, you have the French Revolution,
and then the king loses his head in 1793.
But all that dates back, that 70-year history
all goes back to the bubble in 1720, 21,
and just how they put their respective countries
back together again.
This is a very fascinating story.
And you mentioned they lost the fiat currency.
What's the value of fiat currency?
Some people criticize the fact that we have a lot of debt
in the dollar and we should go back to gold standards.
Some people are saying that.
But what's the value of the fiat currency in your thoughts?
Any kind of centrally bank-created currency,
I think it has pros and cons.
Actually, John Law wrote about this.
In addition to being a rogue and a gambler
and a scoundrel and a cheat,
he was a brilliant economist.
And he writes about this in 1705
in a book called Money and Credit Considered,
or Trade and Credit Considered,
I think is the name of the book.
It's like 75 years ahead of its time.
And he goes into the merits of a fiat currency,
which is, if you're only doing gold and silver
as a legal standard or on a gold standard,
the money supply can go up or down
depending on sentiment and how much gold you have.
And when you have a depression or a downturn in the economy
and you need to create liquidity,
the gold standard doesn't let you do that.
And the US learned this lesson the hard way
in the 1930s during the Great Depression
when the money supply was contracting.
We were on a gold standard.
And the first countries to leave the gold standard,
Britain being the first one in 31
and the US being near the end,
the ones that left the gold standard earliest
did the best during the Great Depression
because they were able to reflate their economy.
So there's a benefit to having a fiat currency
where you can increase demand in a downturn
and create legal tender.
I think the challenge of it, though,
is it's easily abused.
So when you give the government the monopoly
on the currency, they have every incentive
to print, print, print, print, print.
And then by reflating the currency
or inflating the currency too much, you create inflation.
We just had this debate in 2020-21
where the prior administration and the Federal Reserve
thought they could just print money during COVID.
It wouldn't have consequences.
Then we got inflation and then inflation was transitory.
And again, don't worry about it.
And then pretty soon inflation goes up to eight, nine, 10%.
And measured the right way, it was really close to 18%.
That's really where inflation peaked.
And that's all because you had too much money
chasing too few goods.
And every economist I know will explain to you
that too much money chasing too few goods creates,
we teach this in our textbooks.
And yet somehow the administration
and the Federal Reserve and all those PhDs
forgot this very basic lesson.
The benefit I think of a gold standard
is just to get monetary stability.
And the bubbles, the book that I wrote on bubbles
makes this very clear.
Every single time there's a financial bubble,
including the 1720s example I just gave,
1845, 1825 in the UK, Japan in the 1980s,
the US and Western Europe in 2020-21.
Every single time easy money was a predicate to the bubble.
It lit the kindling which set the fire ablaze
every single time.
And so having constraints on the money supply,
even if you have a fiat currency,
you can have a monetary rule,
you can have constraints on the money supply.
I think there's a real argument to do that.
And the rise of Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies,
Bitcoin is also limited in terms of supply.
You can't print, you can't make more Bitcoin,
I guess unless you hack the algorithms
and then create more Bitcoin.
But it's designed algorithmically to be permanently fixed
at a certain supply of Bitcoin.
It is a version of a gold standard
or a crypto standard, which has the benefit of stability.
I like that a lot.
I like really tying government policy
to something like that.
Aman, how can people find your book?
The name of the book is
A Brief History of Financial Bubbles.
You can go to bigbubbletrouble.com right now
and you can read all about it
and then you can also pre-order if you want.
Thank you.
Let us know what you think of the current valuations in AI.
Do you think we're in a bubble or not?
I'm Siamak, this is Market Insider.
We'll see you next time.
