I Tested Viking Shields Against Medieval Weapons and Here's What Happened

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
9 Video Views·Nov 24, 2025
Ever wonder what happens when a few bros get their hands on some medieval weapons and a legit Viking shield? Well, we did the dirty work for you. We're launching javelins, chucking axes, thrusting spears, and swinging a massive sword to see if this shield can handle the heat.
Join us for some serious destruction and a whole lot of laughs as we find out if a piece of wood and iron can survive our onslaught. This is not a historical documentary, it's just a bunch of dudes having a blast and making a giant dent in history.
Comments are disabled for this video.
I can't thank you guys enough for how much Mongol bow versus Viking shield blew up.
In the comment section, many of you asked if we could use other weapons from the era
against this shield and today we're going to do just that.
It's a quick recap.
This shield is a recreation of the Gokstad shield,
but other shields like it are also found at Trelleborg,
which is in the Danish National Museum.
To cover my bases, I also slid into the DMs of Dr. Rolf Warming,
the author of the papers, which I based the shield on,
and he said it's a pretty decent recreation.
Now being just a history nerd, I'm going to take that and run with it.
This shield is made from pine planks from Finland.
It's 10mm at the center and 6mm at the edge and it's a gradual taper.
Front is covered in rawhide and the edging is also covered in rawhide.
The backing is not covered just because I didn't have the budget for it.
If I had to do it again, I'd probably do it because the shield took on a little bit of a warp,
which is a common occurrence with rawhide and shrinkage.
For this video, I'm going to need to call in some reinforcements.
You bellowed?
What are you wearing? Where'd you get this?
This is a meme channel!
Let's get started.
Here we have the shield rigged up.
This rig is going to let the shield pivot, but also pivot in the hand,
just like a real shield would be.
The purpose of this is to give the shield the best chance to protect its user
as it would have been because that's how these shields were recorded to have been used.
The ability to pivot allows the impact force to be reduced.
So let's see what happens when we start throwing things at this.
Let's start off with a javelin.
Ah, it's just the tip.
Oh, rejected.
Sometimes it slips out, right?
Didn't make an impact.
Little dense.
I want to give it a go.
Go for it.
Mongo can't throw.
Can't throw worse ----.
There we go.
That was the best one, actually.
Yeah, it did turn.
And it did what it's supposed to do.
It turned in the user's hand and it still protected them pretty well.
So guys, this is the best one of the day and it still only went in just the tip.
You'll notice here that we had two other impacts and they barely made it in.
So even though I missed a couple of times,
the Mongols still redeemed themselves with just the tip.
Let's move on to a heavier javelin.
Now we're going to try it with this heavier and thicker javelin.
There you go.
Holy crap.
That got in there.
I mean, I'm expecting...
Okay, it hit part of the handle here.
Yep.
Though you guys can see on this camera here.
Actually, you cannot because the handle's in the way.
But it's just the tip.
It's barely in there.
And at this point, most people are expecting this plywood shield to break.
It hasn't broken yet.
So let's see if I can get a little deeper.
This thing's a little fat, stubby, and slow.
Built just like you.
It's built just like me.
This is the inspired cosplay job.
Oh.
Oh, and it's spun.
Oh, man.
That's like the perfect impact.
This is the perfect impact.
Like, this is what you want the shield to do.
And it's still just the tip.
Shield planks are holding together pretty well.
This is the Francisca.
Now, when Vikings went up against the Franks,
these would have probably been thrown at them.
There are written accounts of them splitting shields.
So we're going to find out if that's true today.
I think you hit it edged on.
It just bounced right off.
And, you know, the shield pivoted.
Let's do it again.
I think the first one hit the edge here.
And it pretty much went, like, point in.
And if we look in the back,
you actually do see that some of the wood has split a little bit.
Second one nearby there.
And also some more split wood.
Here's the deal.
This shield was designed so that the handle goes against the grain.
So if you guys ever throw axes,
you'll know that this is like the expert level of axe throwing.
You kind of want the axe blade to go parallel with the grain
so you can split it.
So I have a theory.
What if we turn the shield the other way to easy mode?
Let's flip it and see if we can split this shield.
Well.
I think it went.
No, it didn't go in.
No, I hit it with the top.
Oh, do it again.
If Viking life doesn't work for you,
you can always go back to being a farmer.
Oh yeah, that hit.
All right.
That did hit.
Dude, honestly, it split less.
It split even less.
How did that not stick in?
I don't know.
I mean, that's a pretty sharp axe.
Like it's axe sharp.
So it must be the rawhide in conjunction with the wood.
We have accounts of shield splitting, guys,
and these shields are supposed to break.
Like when they duel, they have three shields for a reason.
So I don't know what's going on, but you know what?
Maybe this shield isn't as bad as everyone says it is.
Seems pretty good.
Let's try one more.
Yep.
Good impact.
Actually, it might have been the head.
I think you made another dent.
Yeah, right here.
Guys, even though we had some good impacts,
the split is actually less than it was on the other orientation,
which is surprising.
A lot of people in the comment section of the last video
says the shield's too thin,
but so far we've yeeted this thing.
Like we're not like baby handling this stuff.
Like you see the stuff flying off camera.
So, so far the shield is holding up pretty well.
Let's move on to the melee category.
Here's what we're going to do.
We're going to have you do a one-handed thrust first.
So let's do four like that.
Actually, then let's do an overhand.
And then finally we'll try a double hand, okay?
Two-handed thrust.
You can pick anywhere you want except for the boss.
Whenever you're ready.
Huh.
It's in.
Oh, it's in pretty deep.
But remember, the shield is not against the person.
Like it's going to be away from their body.
So it's a solid block and the shield is holding up.
All right, let's try an overhand thrust.
Oh, that's the other problem.
That's why shields worked.
Overhand thrust.
Would you say that's a little better?
Yeah, I think so.
Yeah, and one thing to consider guys is that
like when you're thrusting a spear,
you're pretty much going with the grain, right?
So this is a pretty deep thrust.
But again, shield is not on the body.
Drew, go ahead and try to pull your spear out.
Oh, I don't think it's going to be a good day for you, buddy.
Let's try a two-handed strike now.
And Drew's going to give it everything he's got.
Bro.
That's worse.
Yeah, he actually cut the shield.
You can see like the blade actually cutting.
This is a sharp wing spear.
This is a historically valid reproduction.
Drew, have you come to the other side?
He actually didn't penetrate as hard.
Now, Drew, how hard do you think it's going to be to pull this out?
That one's probably going to be easier since I split it.
Oh, not too bad.
So Drew, would you say that the shield did its job to protect the user so far?
I think whoever's holding that shield is safe.
Yeah, yeah.
Like, I think once or twice your spear got stuck.
Yeah.
Like how...
Yeah, the one-handed thrusts were stuck in there.
Yeah, how powerless do you feel trying to pull that thing out?
I think I'm getting disarmed.
Yeah, you're getting disarmed or the other guy's probably got a spear too.
It's a really bad day.
Hopefully, you have a shield of your own.
So now, let's move on to the axe.
The quintessential weapon of the Vikings.
Before we get started with the axe,
I do want to note that the shield is starting to split in some places,
which is normal.
This is a shield made of pine planks in general.
It's going to start splitting.
And remember, these are disposable.
Here, Drew's got a typical hand axe from the era.
We're going to just hit it straight on first.
If this doesn't work well,
we can go to the side of the shield to see if we can get a different angle.
Nothing!
Let's...
Okay, so it looks like you hit it pretty much...
Well, you cut the hide.
You hit it with the blade.
Try it with a point.
You know what I mean?
Like right there.
Let's give it a go.
Nothing.
It's starting to split back here, but it's still holding on.
I think this raw hide is really reinforcing the rest of the planks.
Let's have you...
Yeah, let's have you adjust.
Let's go to the side here so you can do like a heavy, like a hook.
Oh, there you go.
That's the one.
Now, do keep in mind that this is a very, very bad position for the guy holding the shield.
But yeah, axes do what axes do.
And it actually, because he's doing it sideways, it got into the grain.
Can you get it out?
Oh man, how boned are you?
Yeah, I'm out of a weapon.
You're out of a weapon, dude.
Like at this point, you let that axe go and you draw your...
Whatever you got left, your say axe or something.
Oh my goodness.
Guys, look at that.
Look at that hole, dude.
Delicious.
There's no point in doing a two-handed.
So axes do work.
I mean, that's why they use them.
Let's upgrade to a more refined weapon, a sword.
We're going to use the sword.
As you guys saw, the axe had some troubles getting through it at first.
But once you find the grain, it goes through.
Swords are different.
The force is not concentrated on one small area, but along a longer edge.
But we're going to try something.
People say that if you hit the edge of the shield, the sword will bite and get stuck.
And therefore, the user can be disarmed.
Drew's going to do that right now.
Is your sword stuck?
It is pretty stuck.
Yeah.
Oh dear.
This is not good.
Careful.
All right.
Real quick, guys.
That was a normal orientation.
And the sword bit in pretty freaking deep.
What if we turn it with the grain?
You think you can split the shield?
We're going to turn the grain up, straight up and down.
So it's basically parallel with the incoming blade.
Straight overhead.
Yep.
We're going to see if he can split the shield with this.
Because there are accounts in the sagas saying the shields were split.
All right.
Three, two, one.
Holy crap.
That thing is...
It's in there.
I mean, I don't think you're getting that out.
Not if you're in combat.
No.
I don't think any of them are getting out.
Yeah.
Like, this would be a really bad situation to be in if you're in a duel.
Yeah.
Two hours later.
So guys, these are full-fledged hits.
In combat, you're probably not doing these committed hits because you'll get got.
So what Drew's going to do next, once he retrieves the sword...
Oh, okay.
Cool.
He's out.
Is he's going to try to do just quick combat cuts.
See if it bites into the shield regardless.
Every single one of you saw it in there.
And he's not even putting that...
Try not to even put too much in there.
Oh, wow.
That's like a light tap and it's still going in.
It's getting caught on the edge.
All right.
I think that's good enough.
I mean, this shield is working.
Just as it was designed to do.
So Drew, when you saw this shield, did you think it was a little too thin?
I thought I was going to break through it.
Yeah.
Pleasantly surprised then?
Yeah.
It's definitely going to protect you.
Yeah.
I mean, these shields were used for a reason, guys.
Shields are not like two inches thick and 30 pounds, at least in this age.
Because one, you have to carry this thing all day, even with a strap on your back.
It's quite a bit of weight.
Two, it has to be light so you can still maneuver and fight with it.
Right.
And as you guys saw, if you commit to a strike on this edge, it's going to bite in.
And even if you get something on the shield itself, you're going to be stuck.
And when you're stuck, that's probably the worst time in the world,
because the other guy is not stuck.
He's going to be stuck in you.
Did you have fun?
I had a great time.
It was a lot of fun.
That is, that's all that matters, right?
It's all about having fun.
Again, we're not a historical channel.
We're a meme channel, but we sometimes like to get some things right.
Thanks for checking us out, guys.
If you like this video and you want to see more, leave a comment down below.
If you have video ideas, I'm always looking for more ideas.
Make sure you hit like and subscribe.
