Response to Matt Easton / Scholagladiatoria on the medieval 'norman' Kite Shield

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
30 Video Views·Jun 11, 2025
Comments are disabled for this video.
Greetings, I'm Shad, and this is a response to the excellent video that was recently put up by Matt Easton on,
well, you can probably guess, the Kite Shield.
So if you have watched the video or not, it doesn't really matter because if you're interested in medieval combat, weapons,
shields, and other things like that, you'll find the things that I wanted to discuss fairly interesting.
Now, if you don't know who Matt Easton is, I kind of consider him the resident medieval weapons and combat expert on YouTube.
That's not to say that I think he's a hundred percent correct all the time,
but he has a lot of credibility in the things that he talks about. He is a
instructor in HEMA, Historical European Martial Arts, and he also has a background in
archaeology, and so he approaches all his videos with a lot of practical experience and a very,
I find, an admirable mindset in how he kind of assesses how these weapons would have been used in history.
So I'm a good, I'm a big fan of Matt. I reckon he does a really good job.
So do check out his channel if you get the chance. Now, when I say that I don't think Matt is right in everything
he says, that's the exact same thing that everything I say can't be correct.
In fact, it's impossible to be correct in everything that we talk about, us medieval enthusiasts, when we're talking about
medieval combat and shields and things like that, for the very simple reason that we were not medieval people.
We didn't live in that day, which is the only way you could definitively
answer many of the questions that we often talk about in regards to how swords were used, how shields were used, and also
armor and medieval combat, and just that kind of thing in general.
So everything that Matt has to say about this topic in general is definitely well worth listening to, and should not be disregarded, because he
approaches these questions,
yeah, like I said, in a really admirable way, a correct way, where he really tries to
consider how things were used and such. And so Matt has recently done a video on the kite shield.
I'm thrilled about that. Absolutely thrilled, because the kite shield is my favorite shield, and like I mentioned in my own videos on the kite
shield, I feel it's so often overlooked and
underrated as a shield amongst the classic types, where I think it's the best type you could pick.
In certain circumstances, okay, so if you're wondering what those are, go watch my videos.
So I'm going to paraphrase a little bit of
Matt's video, and I apologize because I'll be doing it an injustice, because if you really want to
hear what Matt has to say about the kite shield, you should watch his video.
Don't rely on secondhand information to form an opinion on other people's views.
But some of the core points that I kind of got from his video is that
he felt that to think that the kite shield was solely a cavalry shield is a huge
misconception, and I completely agree with him in that regard.
I personally feel the kite shield shines most, like when it really, you get the most out of it on foot,
not on horseback. Now as an extension to what he was talking about, in his analysis of the kite shield,
he felt that, or he feels, I should say, that the kite shield is quite a rubbish shield to use on horseback.
Now, I'm open to that
idea. I mean, it's not something that I ascribe to at the moment, nor have in the past.
I've generally considered the kite shield to be very useful on horseback. Not to say the most useful or not,
but very useful. I didn't think it was a
like, it was useless, and I don't think Matt does either.
Even if you watch his video, I'm pretty sure he acknowledges that, of course, you get a use out of it.
It was used on horseback, but he thinks it's nowhere near the best, that a round shield
is far better than a kite shield on horseback. Now, like I said, I'm open to changing my view on that, but
for me to alter my opinion that I have of the kite shield,
I feel there are some questions that needs to be answered, and unless these questions are answered, and for me, they're kind of, well,
yes, but what about these circumstances?
What about these things? And I think these things that kind of refute that concept that the kite shield is terrible on horseback,
but if those are answered, I
will change my views, and so I put it out there, of course, to Matt to give me his opinion on what he thinks, and of
course, what you think in this response as to why the kite shield is still a decent shield to you, to be used on
horseback. So Matt makes a few points, and look, they're very insightful points.
There's some of the things I haven't even considered as well, one of the reasons why I
really appreciate and enjoy watching Matt's videos, because he often says things that I haven't considered yet,
and I'm like, that's a good point.
And so these are some of the points that he mentions, and again, don't rely on this, because it is secondhand information.
Please watch Matt's video,
but he feels that
because the kite shield has the extended
bottom, it gets in the way because you can't really protect
this side of
yourself when you're on horseback, and so if you're holding a kite shield, it can only protect your left side,
which leaves your right side open. So I'm using my heater shield in demonstration
to look at this point in a bit more depth, because my round shield, it's just way too big.
I mean,
size is very important, and this is one of the points
I think Matt is talking about in regards to
the kite shield on horseback, is because he feels it's too big, and therefore, you can't get it over to protect that other side, and
this, I feel, my round shield has that same issue that he's talking about. It's too big,
and so if it was strapped or cinder gripped, you're still going to run into those issues, because it's so blasted big.
And so pretend that this was a more round-type shield,
but it's got the size, which is important in this regard, and so you can pretend that I'm on a horse.
He's saying that you could go and protect this side, and look, that is absolutely correct. It does not take much
twisting or movement to fully protect this side, and so it's a very good observation.
So I'm going to hold my kite shield as if it was strapped to my arm, and
yeah, like, it'll just be knocking the horse, and there's no way you get to protect that side.
You wouldn't be able to leverage it over, because look how far the shield is extending. It's quite cumbersome, so he is
correct in that regard, that
this shield does not adequately protect this side, the right side, on horseback.
But my question is, does that really matter? Because
the other side of the coin is that this shield is protecting your left side
fully. Like, look, you barely can see me, and so
it's a bit of a give-and-take there. Now,
this is interesting, and it goes back to my question of, does it really matter?
But for this reason, if you are in a full melee, where
everyone is everywhere, and you're fighting, and you've got guys on this side,
and you've got guys on that side, not being able to maneuver the shield to one side, the right side, is a big problem.
But an important question to ask is, is that how most
battles were done in the medieval period? And the answer is, no, not really. Like, full melee's
where both armies broke ranks, and just everything was chaotic, and you had people everywhere,
you had bad guys over there, you had bad guys over there, and everything, that was actually quite rare.
Battles were done in ranks, in formation, and they would approach in formation, and they would engage, and they would fight, and
interesting thing,
generally, the lines would only hold until one side lost around 10% casualties. These are loose numbers,
they're approximates, and there's always exceptions to everything I'm saying here,
but generally,
one side would break when they lose 10% casualties, because when you're a guy, you're an army, and you're seeing all your mates get
killed left and right, I mean,
it's very rare where they say, well, I'll fight to the death too,
then you say, I don't want to die, and they leg it, and
then one side would pursue until the other side would either get free or can reform ranks again, and they'd do it again, and
so,
rarely, do you have battles just be completely chaotic, where it's all crazy, like you see in the movies so often, Braveheart, and everything like that,
it's not how it was done, and to my knowledge, this isn't how the horse was employed in combat either, like,
yes, they could get stuck in big melees and everything like that,
but they wouldn't be thinking when they're making their ranks that the horses are there
for, to get into the melee and fight people, no, no, no, the horses were there for impact warfare,
okay, and this is where I feel that the answer is coming,
you know, why does this really matter if you can't bring the shield on the other end, because if you're in a controlled
situation where you know how the horses are going to be used, you can control
which side of your horse is going to be facing the enemy for most of the time, because your enemy is going to be
in ranks, they're not going to be a scattering melee, you're not going to ride into the middle of them, because that's just suicide,
they would ride up to their enemy, and so even if they're riding forward like this,
they would ride up to the enemy with either a lance or a javelin, get to the close to their ranks,
launch the javelin, trying to hit someone over this side of the horse with their lance,
knock them on the side, all the while, look at this, like,
you can imagine if you're my enemy, and I'm on horseback, I'm approaching you, and I'm doing these big attacks and everything,
can you hit me in return, like, and the main reason is because
the shield offers so much protection, this extended bottom is protecting that bottom leg only on this side,
but only this side is being shown to my enemy in this style of combat, in this context.
So you run in, you hit, and when you run off, then you use that shoulder strap where the shield gets hung over your back,
and you ride off,
and,
and again, you ride off on a distance, so it's an angle,
so you're coming in on an angle, and then you're riding away on an angle, and on both situations,
this shield is protecting you completely. You see, I feel this is an important point that needs to be addressed,
because in this context, I do feel the kite shield is still the better choice over a round strap shield,
like, far better. So when you're looking at horses being used in impact warfare against ranks of enemies,
still the kite shield, in my opinion, unless I'm missing something, and I could be. So yes, please do remember that fact that
battles rarely ever
fell into a huge melee, and there are famous examples of when they did do this, because they were the exception, not the rule,
like the Battle of Agincourt, perfect example of the circumstances that need to be in place for a true
fight-to-the-death battle, where both armies commit 100% of their forces to the death, because when I say this ranks-and-ranks things,
like, even the rank-and-rank army
engagements and stuff
wasn't the whole way medieval warfare was done. A lot of it was done through sieges.
Taking over a castle meant you controlled that land area, and
that was kind of the linchpin, and you would take castle, castle, get any more land. And so, like, just
rank-by-rank armies, that's not the only way. So the circumstances that an army needs to be in, well,
like I said, Battle of Agincourt, perfect example. The English are
backed into a corner where they don't really have a retreat, and they're faced by a
huge army of the French, and the French, they outnumber the English massively,
so they think they have the upper hand, and so they're ready to go all in and attack them, and the English,
they can't retreat, so again,
they're kind of screwed, and they have to commit everything as well. The English, when they get in there,
they ride in with their horses, ready to try and wipe out all the English archers, and their horses get stuck in a bog,
well, it's not a full bog,
but the horses are being sunk really deep, and the English just pick them off, and then, and for the same, or
similar reasons for why the English can't retreat, the French can't really retreat either, because they get stuck in this bog and everything like that,
and so it's a complete annihilation for the French, and the English win completely, so
unique circumstances have to be in place for an all-out melee to happen, but if that does happen,
I do agree with Matt, that
the Kite Shield might not be your best pick as a shield on horseback, because it can't protect either side,
but when I say that, there are a couple of questions that come to mind again, that, well, hang on,
maybe the Kite Shield still would be useful,
even in an all-crazy melee, and my thought is just this, if you have the Kite Shield on this side,
you're fairly, you'd feel fairly confident, with exceptions, of course,
but generally, you'd be fairly confident that your left side is decently protected,
and so it means that you wouldn't really have to worry about your left side too much, of course,
you're gonna have, you know, see things in your periphery, and if anything happens, you'll take an account to protect for it,
but for the most part, like, look at me,
you'd be fairly confident that you're safe, alright, and so with this shield on this side,
the right side is not left defenseless, because what are you holding in this hand? You're holding a weapon,
and so this is capable of defending yourself just as much as attacking, and any person who tries to attack you on your right side
has to deal with your sword before they get you, and so
does this make the Kite Shield better than, say, a smaller round that's strapped to your arm?
You know, I don't think it makes it better, but I think there's an, I feel, just from my imperfect analysis of
what I'm looking at, I feel that the trade-off is fairly decent, you get
more protection on your left side than a round, but less protection on your right side,
but it doesn't mean you're completely defenseless, where with a round, you have the option of defending this side,
defending this side, but the problem with the round is that it's smaller,
it does not defend you nearly as much as the Kite Shield, and so to me, that feels like an even trade.
Okay, and last thought, why I feel the Kite Shield might still be
preferable on horseback than a round shield, and that is the fact that Kite Shields are
more narrow
than round shields. Now, it's funny, both my examples here, my kite and my round, are wider, bigger,
when I say that, you can easily classify these sizes as standard sizes of Kite Shields, okay,
of Kite Shield and round shield, because there was a bit of room to move, and I generally feel Kite Shields are represented a bit smaller
than they were. I feel Kite Shields have more height than what is shown,
but, you know, my Kite Shield might be a bit wider than the standard type, and so I'm happy to acknowledge that, and I know
I made my round shield slightly bigger, but when you say this is a big round shield, it's not
impossible to get them right. In fact, there was a lot this size,
so this isn't an impractical or an improbable size at all. The reason why I'm pointing this out is because I want to make a
comparison between a Kite Shield and a round shield in regards to having straps, because remember,
straps, very important. One of the big reasons why you want straps on one of these shields is for when you're on horseback. When
you're not on horseback, I feel center gripped all the way, including for the kites.
That's my personal opinion. It isn't really said with any level of definitive authority, but that's what I
prefer when handling a shield. On foot, I love the center grip so much,
but when you're on horse, as I've talked about in my other videos, very
not only impractical, impossible to try and
manipulate one of these shields with a center grip while trying to hold the reins of a horse. It doesn't work.
So you need straps to bring your grip close to the edge of the shield, because if it's centered,
there's too much shield in the way of the horse, and you can't get a hold of them. Now,
my point is, because the Kite Shield is more narrow than a round shield,
it means your fist is far closer to the edge of the shield than it would be on a round one, and
that's important, because as soon as you get too much shield,
past your fist,
you are gonna have such a problem trying to hold those reins close to the horse, and then guide and steer the horse where it
needs to go, if the shield is getting in the way. And so I feel like Kite Shield
has the advantage in that regard, being more narrow, easier to hold the reins,
easier to ride a horse on them. And the Kite Shield being more narrow, I feel, does not reduce
the level of protection it offers. In fact, I feel the Kite Shield offers far more protection than the round shield, and
you might think that, like,
the round shield looks bigger than the Kite Shield, is because the perspective of the camera, just pointing that out. See, now the Kite Shield
looks bigger than the round, so
the comparison might be hard to see when, if the shields aren't looking the right size in proportion to one another,
but I think you're gonna agree with me that the Kite Shield is predominantly,
undisputably, a more narrow shield than any round shield, and therefore better to hold straps,
better to have straps on, to, you know, hold the reins of a horse.
So these are the questions that I still have with the
excellent points that Matt has raised in regards to the Kite Shield being an impractical shield on horseback.
I think, well, what about, what about this and that? And
this video is the what about this and that, and so
if you have anything else to share, if you have thoughts, what you feel would be more practical,
more effective on horseback, a Kite Shield or a strapped round shield, let me know in the comments.
I'd love to hear what you have to say, and thank you for watching. I hope you enjoyed, and I hope to see you again.
