Lockdown Longbow - Do shields stop arrows?

Shield of Antiquity
8 followers
9 Video Views·Nov 16, 2025
The lockdown longbow trials continue with SHIELDS!
Ever wondered if a shield will protect you from arrows from an English Longbow? Well you are in the right place. I accurately made a reproduction 15thC shield, fitted the back with maille and a pork joint and shoot a variety of arrows at it and look at what happens.
Shield was constructed from 15mm thick poplar planks, butt glued, faced with bonded linen canvas front and rear and scraped all over with gesso and the painted. Arm pad was two layers of linen canvas and four layers of a heavy wool cloth.
Comments are disabled for this video.
That got it.
Hi it's Tod of Tod's Workshop and Tod Cutler here and today is shield day. So we're going
to take these lovely pointy arrows by Will Sherman and shoot them at this properly constructed shield
and find out that question we all want to know, will hiding behind your shield save you from
arrows from an English archer? And we're going to do that using my lockdown longbow which is here.
Yes I know it's not a longbow and if you're new to these films go and have a look at the first
one or two and you'll find out what the hell I'm using this for, but basically that crossbow will
shoot these arrows at the same speed that an English warbow archer will shoot them. So basically
it allows me to do my backyard tests against things like this shield and find out what the
hell happens. Here we are down at the range and ready to start shooting, but before we do that
I'm going to take you down there so you can see what I've done with the shield, how I've hung it,
that sort of thing. So here's our shield on a slightly flexible system, basically a little bit
of bungee cord just hanging off the top, just allowing some movement. Of course it doesn't
replicate the human body exactly, but it allows some movement and that is better than me nailing
it straight onto the boss there. And the next step with arrows, there you are, good look at them,
you'll see they've got wax on them. For these tests I'm going to wax all of them and the reason
for that is really that I think they did, I'm almost certain of it. Have a look at my previous
films to understand my thinking behind that, but straight up a bit of beeswax on all of these types.
So let's go and have a look at the back of this thing now. So we have the bungee as discussed,
we have a leg of pork in here, I've just left it in the cling film, I don't suppose that matter much,
sheet of mail, because probably anybody who owns a shield is going to have some kind of armor on
their arms. I'm not going to redo this with plate steel, but we'll do it with mail and we'll get
some flavor for it. And then the stick is really just to hold that all in place, it's not replicating
bone running, it's just holding everything in place. The shield itself, 15 millimeters of poplar
lined inside and out with a hemp canvas, then covered in gesso, which is like a chalk and glue
mix that sort of seals it, gives you a decent painting surface and then paint. Time to shoot.
First up, type 7 needle bodkin. I'm going to try and get it through the pork. Well it's certainly in,
blimey, I think that's a bit high, but anyway let's find out. Next up type 9 short bodkin,
definitely too high. I'm going to go for another bodkin, short bodkin on that.
That's a pork hit. M2 Tudor or Tauton bodkin. It's going to be a fast little fella this one,
goodness me, I mean they are peppering the shield. My lousy shooting has let me down.
I know I've got scope, but maybe crossbows and longbow shafts weren't a natural match pair. I
don't know, who would have guessed huh? Last one of course is now the type 16. Goodness me, right
let's go and have a look what we got. Well that is pretty convincing, I think we can tell by the
length of that one for sure arrows go through shields. I'm just going to untie it and we're
going to have a look at what's going on in the front and the back because this is like pretty
nasty, I wouldn't want to be holding that. So this one here is the needle bodkin type 7 that has
gone through the shield, through the mail and it's just sort of clipped the pork, but I mean let's
face it you can see that that's going to hurt you if it happens. The M2, well I missed that, we'll
shoot again. Short bodkin, that one was I believe here. Now looking at the length of that I would
say without a doubt that one has gone in and it has, so that one is straight through the mail,
straight into the leg. Type 16 is this one here and actually it didn't quite, oh there we go,
oh no there we are, type 16, that's it, there you go. So the type 16 is just here where I'm tapping
and in fact type 16 did go through the mail, can you see it, but maybe a centimetre,
three-eighths of an inch, so it's not going to be a particularly disabling injury. Nonetheless you
know who wants a basically an arrow tip stuck in their their arm half an inch, but it's not going
to kill you, it's not going to stop you fighting. The needle bodkin quite clearly is going straight
through the shield, straight through the mail, straight through the leg and let us just see if
we can excavate under here. Well okay you can see hopefully that one, that's a short bodkin,
straight through the shield, the padding, the mail and into the arm by the looks of
inch, inch and a half, maybe 30 to 40 millimetres. That one is one that could hit the bone, hit an
artery, that one is an injury that's going to stop you. So I would say from this if you are wearing
armour under a shield, needle bodkin and short bodkin are definitely a problem. So after my not
prize-winning shooting, I've got two more M2s and I'm going to go for the pork joint again.
So all of the others managed to land into the mail and pork area, the M2 missed completely,
so I'm going to go. Might have got it, but I'm going to try again. That got it. Let's go have
a look what we got. Back at the range these two are M2s and one of those is an M2 which is
definitely into the pork mail, so I'm just going to have a look now. So interestingly,
hopefully you can see that there we have got the type 9 from the last round which is
maybe 30 millimetres into the chap's arm and next to it, hopefully you can just make out inside of
it between the mail and the type 9, is the M2 just poking its nose out. I'm guessing that that is
going to be much like the type 16 in this instance, that it did the guy injury. Certainly
he's going to be getting bruising and impact damage from it, possibly depending where it lands,
maybe a broken arm or something similar, probably not. I think he would get a shallow but not very
significant stab wound and one hell of a bruise. That's what I expect to happen. Would I want that
to be me? No way. But anyway, let's go and sum up that little bundle of nastiness. Back at base to
have a look what we got. So if we ask that question again, will you be safe behind your
shield from an English longbowman? No you won't. I mean that, that there, short bodkin type 9 is
what 22 centimetres, nine inches sticking out the back, something like that. A couple of M2s here,
you can see what they're doing, but more importantly you can see that the needle bodkin
type 7 and the type 9 both go through the shield, the arm pad, the mail and significantly deeply
into the port joint. Summing up, looking at exactly the different arrowheads, needle bodkin
type 7 that did pretty much what I expected, penetrated shield and mail. I think that's
probably what it's built for. Type 9, the short bodkin, that did really well. The M2 didn't do
as well as I was expecting actually. I mean quite clearly it's poking out the back here and that's
you know potentially going to ruin your day, but the mail stopped it. Type 16 again, I was not really
expecting it to go through mail, I don't think that's what it's for, but again yes the mail
stopped it, but to be fair it had just gone through 15 mil of poplar before that and what
five mil of padding on the arm pad, a few layers of canvas in there, so you know it didn't fare badly,
but there you go. Ask the question, are you safe behind your shield? No you are not. I've taken
the mail and the pork off the back of this shield now and just have a look at that. If for whatever
reason you're not wearing armour, your day has been thoroughly upset by all of this, but the other
thing to notice is that the shield itself is in really very good condition. It's had seven
arrow strikes on it, half inch, 12 mil arrows, you know these are big tree trunk arrows
and the shield is still in one piece, so the planked construction really has held
and the canvas and the gesso on the front that holds everything together as well. It's really
important, just the planks on their own it'd be a much weaker shield, but it's held up well, but
don't forget, don't look at this and go oh the shield should be stronger, well you have to be
able to carry this, so you can't have a you know one and one and a half inches of oak, it's just
going to be dead weight, you've got to be able to use it and don't forget it's not Hollywood here,
you're not taking dead blows like this from a sword or an axe, something like that, you're
cleverer than that, you're stepping aside, you're deflecting, you don't need this to be able to stop
everything because then you wouldn't be able to hold it and you wouldn't be able to use it.
Preview of the next episode, gambesons straight like this one, hardened in wine and salt like
you told me I should do. Let's try both with and without mail, let's see what happens and
if you like the t-shirts check out the merch shelf below the videos and don't forget to
subscribe. There's going to be a lot running in these ones, we've still got a long way to go.
Thanks guys.
