Roman Fire Arrows! - How To

Defending with Past Crossbows
3 followers
10 Video Views·May 28, 2026
Roman Fire Arrows! - How To
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTod Cutler explores the mechanics of ancient fire arrows, attempting to recreate a functional version without using modern oxidizers like saltpetre. Through a series of experiments with various fuels and binders, he discovers that while liquid fuels fail due to airflow, a combination of smoldering embers and sulfur can eventually ignite a target.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Oh well that was good, that was really good. Hi it's Tod from Tod's Workshop, I'm Tod Cutler here
and today I have decided I'm going to find out how ancient fire arrows worked. You see them in
Hollywood films all the time. Now I've done some films about later ones from about 1400 onwards
but look at how effective these fire arrows really were. It's the introduction of the oxidizer that
allowed them to even burn underwater, incredibly difficult to extinguish. How cool is that? But
they could do this because they used what was then a modern oxidizer, saltpetre, potassium nitrate.
But what were people up to before that? So I've thought about what they would have had in the
ancient world that would have been relatively accessible to them and this is what we end up
with. I'm going to start with the easy one, the obvious one. I'm going to wrap some cloth around
this and I'm going to try turpentine because that was the one that really wanted to stay alight.
We're going to dip it, shoot it, see what it does. So I'm just going to wire that into place,
dip it in the turps and time to shoot it. So we've got turpentine on a cloth,
well that certainly lights easy. So putting an enflambled liquid on a pad, a cloth, a wick is the
obvious thing to do but it's not burning the fabric, it's heating up and it's burning the
vapour of the fuel. So it's not actually burning the fabric itself, it's burning sort of gas cloud
around the fabric so it puts the ember out. And what happens when you shoot it is you've got a
big burn, brilliant, but as soon as it starts rushing through the air that flame front, the
bit that's burning on the surface is pushed further and further back by the airflow until
it reaches here and there's no more fuel to light. Let's try some ethanol. Lighting up,
yeah, nearly invisible flame. Well it bounced out and again it went out. I can conclude that
liquid fuels on their own certainly don't work. So now I've got some pitch so let's get that
burning as best we can. Okay I don't think there's any point in shooting that. Oh tiny,
tiny, oh look, look, look, tiny. Well let's shoot the thing anyway, it's going to make a nice big
splat at the other end, see what it does. Right, as predicted, nothing at all. Yeah, and wait for
that to cool before I take that. So what I'm thinking there is that if we combine wet materials
and dry materials, a bit of charcoal and a bit of spirits as well, try and get some heat in the
charcoal. Hopefully that will then lift the spirits up when it lands at the other end.
Oh well, that was good, that was really good. Well I was not expecting that actually. That
is so exciting. In the history of fire arrows, me and no oxidizers, that is the first time ever.
Here we go, reliability issues. Let's try one more and out again. My initial excitement,
of which I was very excited, has gone. Let's try our next set. Charcoal and iron filings,
out again. So I'm going to change direction slightly and I'm going to look at sulphur. If
I try and light the plain end of this bit of wood, there's not enough heat energy,
it's not doing anything. But the other end, it's got a little bit of sulphur in it,
and I have the tiniest little flame and you can transfer it to something bigger.
It lights very easy and we can use that I think. So I'm going for a dry mix again and I've got
some charcoal here which I have dusted in honey and sulphur. The honey is there just as a binder,
so you can immediately see the sulphur go, it's got a very particular look and smell. It's not
doing anything obvious but don't forget the sulphur burns with almost an invisible flame,
nothing. Well that was another failure, rather obviously. I think what's going on is that the
So when it smacks the board, they just get rammed into the board and that's no good for keeping a
burn, you want it like a body of ember. It's got a big wadge of cotton fibre here. Now I'd like a
little bit of airflow through this to try and maintain that smoulder. We have a fairly sustained
and hot ember. Right, let's see what that does. Ah, I can see it's still smoking. Yes! So what
we've got now, it's pretty easy to see, is an ember and if that ember is there, there's going
to be enough to light sulphur. I've got the health and safety gear on now because sulphur is pretty
noxious stuff. So what we've got now is a bit of bandage with some sulphur on it. So here's our
theory, should look something like that. Ooh, there's a little tiny bit of smouldering. So
looking back at the slow-mo, something really interesting happened. I shot it, this of course
has mass not particularly well attached to the shaft, it slid back, it did that, it landed on
an impact, it rammed forward and it just stuffed the whole thing against the board. Let's stop it,
slamming into the board. Now I see smoke. There's no real evidence of the sulphur starting to light
yet. That's been smouldering now for, I don't know, six or seven minutes and it's not gone out but it's
not gone up and so we're going to change the format, the layout slightly and we're going to try
again. I have done this. The idea of this little crossbar is it's going to stop our charge either
sliding forward or sliding back. Got some hot coals in my brazier here, I'm going to stuff one deep
inside. Let's see what it does. Oh, I can't see any smoke. Let's go have a look. Okay, there's a little
wisp. What I do know, you can see from this here, the whole thing slid forward. I've got to stop that.
Ah, still got smoke. Let's go and have a look. Okay, well the good news, the charge has not rammed
forward and slammed against the wood. Eight minutes in, still smouldering, not burning. Oh goodness,
of course then it goes. I am close. Slightly less waxy cotton. Flame, flame, flame, flame, flame,
flame. Okay, you can see the sulphur burning, it's sort of bubbling. The burn is now coming to the
back where the waxy cotton is. I've done it once so I'm not going to be happy until I've done it
reasonably consistently so I'm going to go for another couple of goes. It should start to burn
the wax on the string and then hopefully it will go back and keep burning until it hits the chunk
of wax and fibre at the back. Two out of two. Light the fella up. The smouldering's good but
now as we know, we have to wait. And we have flame. We have flame. That took about 10 minutes
from shooting to actually being in fire. From the dramatic Hollywood point of view,
total rubbish. But interestingly, from a strategic point of view, that's probably really good. If you
see fire arrows coming in and they land, if they're burning like the modern ones, the post 1400 ones,
you can see exactly where they are. Clouds of smoke, big fire and all that. These ones, they go,
you rush into the building, where are they gone? Nothing in here. 10 minutes later, that happens.
That is really interesting. I think it's time to conclude because I'm going to call that a success.
Fire arrows are the ancients. I am not saying that this is how they did it but I am saying
that they could have done. Does it work? Yes. Absolutely it works. Straightforward? Yes.
Got to be patient? Yes. Have I solved the mystery? No, I can't promise you that.
But I can promise you that they could have done it like this. Anyway, I hope you've enjoyed this
film and if you have, then don't forget we've got the Todd Cutler channel as well which is sort of
more niche content films, also history related. And then we've got our websites. Two of them,
absolutely chock full of stuff that if you like this, you are going to be really interested in
that. And then the last thing to say of course is the Patreon page. If you want to support us that
way, it's really helpful too. See you.
