Does Consciousness Defeat Materialism?

Human & Consciousness
3 followers
Oct 10, 2025
Does anything exist beyond the physical world? If yes, could consciousness undermine materialism? If no, could consciousness confirm materialism? It’s the big test. Featuring interviews with Ned Block, Rodney Brooks, Marilyn Schlitz, William A. Dembski, and Eric Schwitzgebel.
Materialism is the belief that only physical things exist.
Other than the physical world, there is nothing else.
I hope materialism is false. I want more to reality. I want more than physical things
in the physical world, meaning beyond the mundane, a richer reality,
possible purpose in life, something beyond death.
That's why I focus on consciousness. Is anything beyond the physical? If yes,
consciousness is a key to undermine materialism. If no, consciousness is a key to confirm materialism.
Because for the philosophy of materialism to hold, physical facts must explain everything.
Consciousness is inner awareness, felt experience, what it feels like inside to sense and to think.
The big question is whether materialism can explain our inner awareness and felt experience,
or does consciousness defeat materialism?
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn, and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out.
Sure, explaining consciousness is a central scientific question, but it's far more.
It's the heavyweight championship of competing worldviews. In one corner stands materialism,
in the other, consciousness. And the battle has only two possible outcomes.
Either physical facts about the brain totally account for all aspects of the mind,
and thus materialism subsumes consciousness, conquers it, or materialism cannot explain
consciousness, and materialism is dealt a mortal blow. It's a game of great stakes,
truly the meaning of life, the essence of existence, and winner take all.
I want consciousness to defeat materialism.
That's why I must be exceptionally careful. I cannot allow my hope to warp my reason.
So, how might consciousness defeat materialism? How to frame the question rationally, neutrally?
I begin with a leading philosopher of mind, Ned Block.
Ned, some philosophers would use consciousness as the primary evidence to defeat the philosophy
of materialism. Do you agree with that? I think that if materialism is going to be defeated,
it's going to come from consciousness. Consciousness is the one phenomenon in our lives
that may not be understandable within a materialistic framework. First define materialism.
Okay, well, one version of it is the mind-body identity theory. It's that consciousness just
is a state of the brain, the way water is H2O, the way lightning is electric discharges,
the way heat is molecular kinetic energy. Now, that could be defeated in two ways. One is,
if it turns out that consciousness is a state of the immaterial soul, that would be really a big
defeat for materialism. But another way would be if consciousness turns out to be something
functional, whose essence isn't any particular kind of matter, but whose essence is something
computational, the way adding is a computational thing. Now, nobody feels that the fact that adding
does not have a material essence shows that materialism is wrong. But in the case of
consciousness, I think it would require a different way of thinking. It turned out that
a computer program could really capture all there is to consciousness.
Okay, but that would not invalidate materialism because the computer,
whatever substrate that this is working on, is still well in the material world.
In the material world, but not essentially so.
How do you distinguish between them?
The idea is that water is essentially in the material world because it's just H2O.
But adding isn't essentially in the material world because there might be an immaterial
computer that could add. All it takes is to function a certain way. If an immaterial state
could function that way, then it would be adding.
How would you rigorously define materialism or physicalism? Do these differ from each other?
How do philosophers deal with that today?
The natural way to define physical is to define it in terms of what physicists talk about. But
that leaves one hostage to the physicists of the future. We know that the physicists now
are certainly wrong. Future physics will correct what physicists say now. So, there is that problem
in how to define physical. One way that people have of getting around that is to just do it in
terms of non-mental. So, the idea is that what's physical is what does not require mentalistic
concepts to talk about.
Concepts. And defining it that way carefully, you can still ask the question about,
is consciousness that kind of material? You haven't destroyed your definition by
defining it that way.
Is what consciousness fully is something that can be picked out without using mentalistic terms?
Yes. And many people would answer no.
Yes.
You can't do that.
Right. Many people would.
How would you conclude? I mean, you skew very heavily to you think yes.
Yes.
But are you like a 51-49 or 99-1?
I'm 90-10.
90-10. Okay. But how has your feelings progressed over this, over your career?
I used to be 50-50 and now I'm 90-10. Because the neuroscience of mind has just been fantastic.
We seem to be finding out more and more. It's looking more and more like consciousness is a
biological phenomenon. Of course, things could go the other way and that could defeat materialism
if we hit a wall. But I don't think it's going to work that way. I'm a materialist.
Ned is a materialist motivated by accumulating achievements of neuroscience.
Personally, I bear witness. I did my doctorate in brain research and I follow the remarkable
discoveries. But I have doubts. Is neuroscience progressing in explaining the phenomenal
experience of consciousness or only in providing mechanistic components of mental content?
But are my doubts caused by my hoax or worse by my superstitions?
I should examine the other side, reverse my thinking for a while.
What would it take to show that consciousness cannot defeat materialism?
One way for me would be if consciousness could be created artificially in non-biological materials.
I ask a robotics pioneer and entrepreneur, a former director of MIT's computer science and
artificial intelligence laboratory, Rodney Brooks.
I don't think that consciousness can defeat materialism. I think that consciousness and
the things that we are emerge from the biological activity of the biomolecules. But that emergence
may be quite complex. So, I think modern physics says that chemistry emerges from physics. There
are fundamental particles, they interact in certain ways, and out of that comes chemistry.
But you wouldn't try to have a chemistry department which was just made up of physicists
who didn't have the specialized chemical knowledge. We need a different set of tools
to describe the chemistry. And I think that same is true in the biological systems and with
consciousness. I think that it comes from what is below, but we aren't able to bridge that gap
in any way right now. So, it is worth asking the questions at that higher level.
The question is, when you get to consciousness, in principle, can you make that same statement?
Can you say that for consciousness, if we knew everything at the lower level,
we could, in principle, predict and explain consciousness?
I think that's an, in principle, valid thing to say. It's so far in the future, it's hard to...
And that's fine. The other argument would say that, in principle, it will be impossible,
ever, to be able to make that leap. But that's not saying there's some spirit or soul or anything
like that. It just says that to go to consciousness requires something so different in the structure
of the physical world that it's, in principle, impossible to predict.
I reject that. And I like to think about that level of complexity change with an analogy.
If you look at what a computer is doing down at the lower level with bits going in and out,
we can't infer the structure of the programming language. But we know what it's doing.
It was written in C++. When we just probe and look at those things, even though we built the thing,
it's really hard to reverse engineer it. So, that, in principle, argument about consciousness
coming out of the physical layer, it may be something we never do because it would take
longer than the universe exists to work through all the computations.
But the question is, in principle, is it possible? Because many people now say that
it's not possible, that there are kinds of laws operating at the level of consciousness
which are sufficiently different. Now, they may be the equivalent of,
I mean, to take an extreme case, a fifth law of force of nature.
I can't rule that out. That may be the case. We've come across new forces before in history.
But since consciousness is so abundant around us, if it relies on this other law,
I think we would have started to see other manifestations of it.
Do we have any help from the rapid development of artificial intelligence?
Well, I think the sheer bulk of computation doing some task makes us understand things differently.
And I think we saw that with the Watson program from IBM that played Jeopardy.
Some of those answers that it came up with were completely amazing.
How did it know to make that analogy, that word play?
Well, it didn't really know it was applying statistical techniques and doing a big search.
But to us, it was really astonishing how it got some of those answers.
So, at a certain level of deep quantitative improvement,
you suddenly have a sense of qualitative difference.
To me, that says we see another version of that emergence
in these artificial intelligence systems.
And it feels to us the same as seeing it in a human.
And we know it's different.
So, that says to me, we don't need more stuff than mechanism to explain it.
So, to external observers, it appears as if artificial intelligence is doing human-level
things, even though we know that internally, it is not.
Well, isn't consciousness even more special?
Consciousness is an internal experience that feels like something that's radically special.
It's not what consciousness does that's the problem.
It's what consciousness is.
I should explore the opposite side,
where consciousness is assumed to transcend the physical.
It's not hard to remain skeptical.
I meet an expert in consciousness studies,
President Emeritus of the Institute of Noetic Sciences, Marilyn Schlitz.
Marilyn, some would say that consciousness defeats materialism.
Others would say that consciousness is the perfect expression of materialism.
So, consciousness becomes the battlefield
for the fight over the worldview of the primacy and the dominance of materialism.
Well, I'd start by resisting the metaphor of a military battle.
Oh, I love it. I love battle.
Well, this is going to be a gender issue between us then.
But I would prefer to think that they're complementary
and that certainly there is a biological material substrate that is consciousness
and is very real.
And it is equally true that people have these experiences that transcend
this sense of our embodiment.
I am increasingly fascinated by the discoveries we're making about the brain
and the physical aspects of our consciousness.
Things like intention that, you know, had kind of been woolly and ill-defined.
We now know about these sort of configuration of neurons called the mirror neuron.
And we can see that the brain lights up in a certain way
when we attribute intention to another person.
Whether that's the complete final story is, to me,
something that ultimately we're all going to have to die to understand.
But if you accept the lineage lines of these various traditions,
whether they're religious or spiritual or even, you know, pagan,
which one's going to win could become a political issue.
One truth claim overriding another because they control the budgets
of the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation.
And therefore, they then become the official authorities on what is true.
We would all want to reject that, for sure.
Even if that dominates, it can't last.
Because whatever is true is true.
And if that is true, it will last.
But that assumes truth is an absolute reified construct.
And what I would argue from the history of science
is that our model of what is true has changed periodically over time.
And it's going to continue to change.
And my hope is that rather than seeing these kind of militaristic metaphors
as the dominant paradigm, is to begin to cultivate a position of pluralism.
Here's the reason I use the militaristic language,
because that's what materialism has set up.
Materialism doesn't say,
we explain some of the things and we can have other things.
Because if there is anything that materialism can't explain,
then materialism by itself definition is destroyed.
Well, my hope is that as we move into 21st century life
with all of the ways in which complexity and multiplicity of viewpoints come together,
that we can begin to build a more humble approach to this question about what is true.
And I think this notion that one system trumps the other one
becomes a power issue, not an ontological issue.
The most important aspect of this convergence
is that science is being informed by wisdom.
And wisdom is being informed by knowledge.
And out of that, I think, come a new set of possibilities
for how we can understand reality and, in fact, how we live into it.
Marilyn argues for diversity of worldviews and for harmony among them.
But that won't do.
If materialism allows other worldviews to coexist as real,
it's self-contradictory.
Suicidal materialism dies.
Can religion help?
Religion and materialism are mortal enemies.
But if consciousness requires some kind of soul,
as most religions assume and most people believe,
then materialism is defeated instantly.
I ask the intellectual leader of the intelligent design movement,
William Dembski, I'm cautious.
Bill, you have pioneered the development of intelligent design
as a mathematical, philosophical view
to, in essence, defeat the materialistic, naturalistic view of the world.
Do you see consciousness as another arrow in your quiver?
I'd like to, but it seems to me that right now
we don't have any in-principle proofs that matter cannot generate mind.
We'll talk about reductive materialism, non-reductive materialism.
And intelligent design, actually, would not be at odds
with a non-reductive materialism.
So, I don't see consciousness as being an avenue for defeating materialism.
I think it's a challenge to materialistic theories.
I mean, that, you know, why isn't there a theory?
You know, is it just that it's a very difficult problem on materialist terms,
or is it that materialism simply cannot support consciousness?
What I find interesting is that you would look to other things
in the physical world, as we find it, as evidence of design.
Some micromotors in certain types of single-cellular animals,
would you see that as being stronger evidence for design
than the human consciousness, the self-awareness
that we think is the most certain thing that we have?
I think we don't really even fully grasp what consciousness is.
I mean, these motors, we can objectify them, we can deal with them, we can quantify.
But consciousness, I mean, you read various people, it's an illusion.
We don't even really have consciousness.
And so, what is it?
As an argument to defeat materialism,
it's not clear that you have a lot, really, to work with there.
And then you've got materialism itself.
What is the nature of matter?
The sort of reductive materialism, I think, we're getting closer there
because this notion that we can get consciousness just by sheer complexity,
where basically it's just electrical impulses
and just their interaction that gives it to us.
But if we're talking a materialism that's non-reductive,
you have some sort of emergent property that has these new causal powers.
To me, that's mystery-mongering there,
because you're putting all this emphasis then on emergence.
I'm skeptical of all these arguments that other theists think have a lot of weight.
What I'm fascinated by is why the intelligent design of micromotors does move you,
whereas consciousness does not.
Well, I think there's a vast difference between things being consistent, you know,
and there's sort of this beautiful interplay of things
where everything is kind of fitting together hand in glove.
You know, I mean, consciousness, non-materialism, belief in God, all of that.
But it's one thing for things to fit nicely.
Paranoids have delusions that fit nicely, you know.
But it's another thing for there to be positive reasons,
confirmation, disconfirmation.
These sorts of design inferences in biological systems do give me reason,
actually, I mean, not just to believe in the design of these systems,
but to question the reigning materialistic creation account for biological complexity.
But you do not feel the same way about the nature of consciousness?
No.
I think what we have to say is we just don't have a materialistic account at this point.
Bill surprised me.
I'd have thought he'd eagerly recruit consciousness
to defeat materialism and defend his religious worldview.
But if consciousness is entirely physical, Bill says,
that would not upset his religious convictions.
I feel I'm on shifting sands.
Scientists, philosophers, even religious believers
all seem split over whether consciousness defeats materialism.
Why such uncertainty, such confusion?
What's going on?
I need a philosopher who grasps the uncertainties and confusion troubling consciousness
and who values the nature of belief.
I meet Eric Schwitzgevall.
Eric, does consciousness defeat materialism?
I don't think it defeats materialism.
I'm about 50-50 on materialism myself.
I started as a materialist, but I also think there are alternative views out there
that might also work and that we can't decisively refute.
What caused that transition?
I think it was caused by reflecting on our poor epistemic situation
with respect to settling questions of metaphysics.
So, I think there are basically three ways that you can approach
the metaphysics of consciousness.
You can do it with science.
You can do it with common sense.
You can do it with things like theoretical elegance.
But none of those things seem to me like they decisively settle
among the various options.
For me, maybe the last straw was reading Nick Bostrom's simulation argument.
The idea that we might be computer programs
in an artificial simulated environment.
If that's the case, then when I look out at the world,
what I'm seeing is something that has been kind of constructed for me
by the computer in which we're being instantiated.
But that's a wholly materialistic...
No.
Why?
I disagree with that.
Does computation have to be material?
I don't see why.
If something is not spatial, it's not material.
Computation doesn't have to be spatial.
Space might be a feature of our programming environment
that doesn't reflect the fundamental nature of reality.
Maybe the fundamental nature of reality is God's mind is a computer
transitioning through a Turing table, right?
Different kinds of conditional computational possibilities.
There's nothing about Turing tables, I think,
that has to be spatial.
Okay.
I understand your transition away from a hardcore materialist
to 50-50 sitting on that fence, along with me, by the way.
What's in that other 50 percent?
What are the components of it that make up
a non-materialist possible worldview?
There are four broad categories of metaphysical position.
So, one, it would be materialism.
But another would be substance dualism, right?
The idea that there's an immaterial soul and a material world,
and they're equally real and equally fundamental,
and one's not reducible to the other.
That's a view that deserves some credence, I think.
Certainly, it's been a religious view in many different religions.
I find various forms of idealism also attractive.
On an idealist view, what's really fundamental are minds, right?
So, you could have a view like Barclay's,
where they're just our minds,
maybe in interaction with each other and with God, right?
Or you could have an atheistic version of that,
where they're just our minds in interaction with each other.
Another possibility that I find attractive
is something like Kantian transcendental idealism.
What is that?
So, in transcendental idealism,
space is something that's constructed by
or created by our minds, right?
And not fundamental to reality, kind of independent of us.
Or maybe it is, but we don't know that it is.
On transcendental idealism,
we don't really know what reality fundamentally is like.
But there's no particularly good reason to think that it's spatial.
It might be something quite alien to us,
something that we wouldn't understand.
Or maybe something mental or something divine.
One of the things that, as a skeptic, I want to do
is try to put back on the map
other possibilities besides materialism
that I think philosophers in the 20th century,
there's this very quick shift
in the philosophical community to materialism.
Scared by science.
Maybe.
So, I think that swift transition
left behind a variety of other views
that are worth at least still taking seriously, I think.
For materialism to triumph, it must explain consciousness.
Here are five ways.
One, consciousness is an illusion.
There's no problem to solve.
Two, neuroscience is making great progress.
Eventually, brain will explain mind.
Three, consciousness is a weak emergent property of the brain,
like the wetness of water from hydrogen and oxygen.
Four, consciousness is a strong emergent property of the brain.
Even if consciousness would be impossible to predict,
it would still be physical.
Five, consciousness requires a new kind of physical law
or force or dimension.
I myself reject one, two, and three.
Consciousness is not an illusion.
Neuroscience can never account for consciousness.
Mental states cannot be explained
solely in terms of brain states.
Four, strong emergence is a candidate,
but how would it work?
It must be material, and it can't be magic.
If I were a materialist, I'd go for five.
Something beyond known physics.
There could be at least two non-material explanations of consciousness.
One, a kind of non-physical component
that somehow combines with the physical brain.
Two, consciousness is the true reality,
and the entire material world is either derivative or an illusion.
That makes at least seven possible explanations of consciousness.
Five material, two non-material.
Which do you think is closer to truth?
For complete interviews and for further information,
please visit closertotruth.com
