Saving Michelangelo’s Epifania Cartoon

Fine Art Conservation
153 followers
28 Video Views·Aug 31, 2025
Works of art can take years to produce - even when you're Michelangelo. However, weird as it sounds, conserving those works of art can take even longer, especially when it's a Michelangelo.
Join Emma Turner, Senior Conservator for Western Art on Paper, as she takes you on a journey through through the painstaking and extensive conservation work on one of only two known Michelangelo cartoons: the Epifania. Starting with scientific analysis in 2006, we follow the incredible work of the conservation team up until the Epifania's final installation at the British Museum in 2025.
This is called the Epiphania. It is one of only two surviving cartoons made by Michelangelo.
In 2006 it was removed for scientific research which revealed that the old glue and lining,
which is almost as old as the drawing, was breaking down into acidic compounds which
were slowly degrading this precious object. It wasn't until new facilities were built at the
museum in 2014 that the museum could finally get around to solving these problems. This was no easy
task. This is a piece so delicate that it takes eight people and half a day's planning just to
turn it over. This is the story of how to save a Michelangelo. Hello, I'm Emma Turner, Senior
Conservator for Western Art on Paper at the British Museum. One of the most exciting projects
to have ever come to our studio is a cartoon by Michelangelo known as the Epiphania. A cartoon is
a one-to-one scale preparatory drawing for an artwork in another media. This cartoon was drawn
by Michelangelo and was used by his friend and biographer Ascanio Condivi for the production of
a panel painting. Epiphania is incredibly rare and important, being one of only two surviving
cartoons by Michelangelo. The cartoon is made of 26 overlapping paper sheets with the image being
drawn in black chalk and charcoal. It became part of the British Museum's collection in 1895
and unlike many old master drawings it had not been conserved since that time,
remaining mounted on the pinewood panel it was presented to the museum on.
Having been analysed in 2006, we knew that the 19th century pine panel was causing damage to
the cartoon paper, contributing to it being brittle, weak and extensively discoloured.
Because of this, we identified that Epiphania required a conservation treatment.
Epiphania is so large that we had to wait until the new studios in the World Conservation and
Exhibition Centre opened in 2014 to have enough space to treat it. In 2019 we collaborated with
Factor Marte to scan and make a digital record of Epiphania's three-dimensional topography.
This was part of a comprehensive documentation of the cartoon which also included photography
in various lighting conditions and the creation of a digital condition map.
Combining these methods of documentation enabled us to better understand the condition of the
For example, recording historic repairs, tears and losses and also to reveal features of the
cartoon paper such as the paper's watermarks. As with many things, planning for the Epiphania
conservation project was disrupted by the Covid pandemic so it wasn't until late 2022 that we
were able to commit to it full-time. By then, preparations were well underway for the British
Museum's temporary exhibition Michelangelo the Last Decades which Epiphania and Condivy's
corresponding panel painting were due to be displayed side by side. This was especially
exciting as it is believed that this would be the first time the pair had been united
since the 16th century. Given the pinewood panel was found to be causing damage we knew that our
treatment would have to provide at least a new mounting solution and a frame but that further
treatment to preserve the Epiphania may be necessary. The first step was to lift the
cartoon from its panel. To separate and lift the Epiphania away layers of paper and canvas
which had been attached onto the front of the cartoon had to be cut and carefully removed
layer by layer with scalpels. To make a decision about the level of conservation treatment required
we needed to turn the cartoon over to assess the back which is known as the verso. Prior to turning
the cartoon over we repeatedly checked that the black chalk and charcoal media was stable on the
paper surface as we couldn't risk altering the image through any action. The media was stable
but the paper surface was seen to be fragile. We used a very dilute spray of gelatine which we had
tested on model papers and found gave a good result. We used an airbrush and worked sequentially
across the surface taking great care to ensure an even coverage. Another advantage of using
gelatine is that it is a traditional sizing ingredient which would have been used in the
original formation of the cartoon paper. As such we believe that we could achieve a secondary effect
of reintroducing some strength to the cartoon paper through the action of gelatine being
absorbed into the paper structure. Having completed the consolidation Epiphania was
turned over to the verso. Given the size and fragility of the cartoon this was no small
undertaking. The safest way to turn the cartoon over was to sandwich it within soft and inert
layers between two rigid boards. For each turning hours of material preparation and rehearsal were
required along with eight people from the conservation team. Once the cartoon was turned
to the verso we could see that the entire back of the cartoon was covered with a 19th century
brown backing paper and that this backing wasn't offering sufficient support. The brown paper was
weak, fractured easily, leached brown discoloration and there were air pockets where the brown paper
was no longer adhered to the back of the cartoon. Because of this we decided that we needed to
Our next job was to remove the brown backing paper. Moisture was needed to soften both the
backing paper and the adhesive for removal. However it was clear that any uncontrolled
introduction of water could cause significant physical and aesthetic changes to the Epiphania.
To control the amount of water being introduced we decided to use gels in our treatment.
One type of gel used was a chemical hydrogel. These hold a large volume of water within their
structure which slowly transmits through tiny pores. This is the same technology which is found
in a contact lens. We cut the hydrogel into small squares and placed them onto the brown backing
paper allowing time for it to humidify the paper and slightly swell the adhesive. Once the backing
paper and adhesive were appropriately humidified we then used tweezers, spatulas and blunted scalpel
blades to remove the paper. It was clear from the outset that the verso of the cartoon was directly
beneath the brown paper so it was necessary to progress extremely carefully. It was painstaking
work and required absolute concentration. As the brown paper was removed we uncovered numerous
historic tears that needed addressing in order to safely continue the treatment. Tears were
temporarily supported using small splints of white Japanese paper. This secured the tears in position
but allowed us to return and repair the tears with perfect alignment at a later date.
Using a team of up to six people a day it took us seven months to remove the backing paper.
A lot of research had been undertaken in support of our conservation treatment.
When the backing paper was finally removed we were the first people to see the verso of the
cartoon in 170 years. Even though we had to disappoint our curators with the news that
there were no further Michelangelo drawings underneath the brown backing paper, seeing the
verso of the cartoon was very exciting as it provided further clues about the history of
epiphania. We observed the impression of two separate canvas linings which had been removed
prior to 1850. These linings would have been applied to give strength to epiphania as it
travelled through Europe as well as to facilitate various historic mounting and framing campaigns.
However, combined with the brown backing paper it also meant that there were at least three layers
of glue on the verso of the cartoon. Analysis of the adhesive layers confirmed the presence
of starch and protein which tallies with the traditional use of flour paste and boiled animal
bone adhesives. In time these glue layers become brown and brittle so it's not surprising that
epiphania showed strong discolouration, was torn and the black chalk and charcoal image appeared
slightly indistinct. It was also apparent that the cartoon paper had become inherently degraded.
Because of this we decided that it was safest to thin the adhesive layers down rather than remove
them completely. At the same time we thinned historic repair patches which were applied
extensively across the verso as this would help flatten the cartoon paper.
As we worked we repaired the cartoon's widespread tears and losses.
Repairs were made using thin Japanese mino paper which is made from kozo fibres. Kozo fibres are
long and provide a lot of strength even when the paper is very lightweight so it's an ideal choice.
Some of the mino paper was dyed brown so that it wouldn't be visible behind hairline tears.
We used the mino paper in conjunction with gluten-free wheat starch paste
which is a reversible conservation grade adhesive.
We infilled areas of loss with paper of a similar thickness to the cartoon which was pre-dyed to a
colour slightly lighter than the cartoon paper. Dyeing to a lighter colour was necessary because
across the cartoon the colour of the paper varied significantly and it is extremely difficult to
colour correct a paper which is too dark. When making repairs and infills to works of art on
paper it is necessary to use weights to press both the paper and the repair to prevent local
undulation. Given the number of repairs and infills that Epiphania required we quickly realised that
we would need to make lots of extra weights to use in the treatment so we were fast depriving
the rest of the studio. To solve this problem some of the Epiphania team developed newfound
sewing skills to make cotton and silk coverings which contained sealed bags of lead shot.
Having completed the repair stage of the treatment we were in position to face our biggest challenge
which was to reline the verso of the cartoon with conservation grade paper.
Relining was essential as to mount and frame Epiphania for display it had to be strong
enough to hold its own weight. To help us in this stage of the treatment we called upon the
expertise of our specialist conservators for eastern art and paper and silk who are based
within the museum's Hirayama studio. The Hirayama team routinely reline large format artworks so
their experience was especially useful. Between our two teams we agreed that three layers of
Minopaper would be fully adhered across the cartoon. The first layer was applied using
relatively small rectangles of Minopaper which meant we could more easily accommodate inherent
features of Epiphania such as the overlapping joins of the cartoon papers. It was essential
to account for features such as these as each has an impact on the cartoon's response to our
treatment which contributes to the overall success of the conservation. Using the example of the
overlapping joins these areas are twice as thick and consequently respond more slowly to moisture
from the lining adhesive. If we didn't acknowledge this by lining the overlap separately and with a
lighter paper significant distortions would occur. Before the first lining layer was completed we
added a margin of paper around all four edges of the cartoon. This had two functions it stabilized
the edges which were the areas with most loss and it provided a border which enabled us to show the
cartoon edges within a new frame. To make the margin the edges of the cartoon were traced onto
a polyester sheet. These tracings were then transferred to a dyed Japanese paper allowing
for an overlap onto the cartoon. We thinned the designated overlap of the Japanese paper down with
a knife which we refer to as paring down. Doing this meant that we didn't create additional thickness
at the edges. Once prepared the margins and edges of the cartoon were checked for precise alignment
and the margin was adhered in position. We then extended the first lining layer across the margin.
The second lining layer made use of a slightly heavier weight Nino paper so that the strength
of the cartoon gradually increased with each lining. The size of the lining paper was also
enlarged and we rotated the grain direction of the paper so that we did not give an intrinsic curl to
the cartoon. Throughout the first two linings we kept the cartoon under weight as much as possible
to prevent the degraded paper of epiphania from contracting. The final layer of the lining was
made of eight rows of our heaviest weight Nino paper with each row prepared in advance to span
the full width of the cartoon. Years of experience enabled our two conservators for Japanese paintings
to precisely paste, lift and adhere these long strips in position. Given the size of epiphania
the wider conservation team were required to support the operation for example in ensuring
that humidity was evenly distributed through the cartoon. Good adhesion of the lining was ensured
by repeatedly brushing the Nino paper and using raking light so that we could check that no air
pockets formed. After the final lining had been applied we needed to turn the cartoon face up
and place it on a wooden drying board to ensure that it dried as evenly as possible.
We knew that this would be the most complicated turning operation as epiphania was even more
vulnerable when wet. It wouldn't be possible to turn the cartoon in the way that we had previously
as it posed a risk of crushing temporary undulations which are associated with humid paper
into creases. We devised a method which inserted a rigid board under the cartoon
and used the newly applied Japanese paper margin to attach epiphania to the board with bulldog clips.
We then covered the cartoon surface with thick non-woven fabric which was also secured with
bulldog clips. Having tested the system in advance we knew that this method would be safe but it was
still a test of our nerves and our teamwork. Seven members of the team turned it over so that
epiphania would be face up. Four people then held the rigid board above the drying board
whilst the rest of the team released the non-woven fabric and gently lowered epiphania down.
Epiphania was attached to a drying board so it could dry evenly under tension as well as achieve
greater overall flatness. We kept it on the drying board for as long as possible which
meant that it remained attached whilst we carried out many of the final treatments to the recto.
These final treatments included adhering any areas of paper that were lifting
and finalising the colour matching of infills which we had started using the dyed Japanese paper.
Colour matching from the front was achieved using watercolours and was done in such a way as to draw
attention away from losses rather than recreate missing details of the image. Where there were
small surface losses of the recto we made infills that were adhered from the front and also toned
with watercolour. Once the cartoon was fully dry and we had completed as much of the treatment as
we could whilst it remained horizontal we were ready to release epiphania from the drying board.
We had needed to replace the pine panel with something which offered appropriate structural
support and which was inert and remained rigidly flat. Our expert conservation mounters undertook
extensive research and testing identifying the mounting materials that would be most suitable
to support a large paper artwork. In producing the new panel we decided to collaborate with the
technical staff at London's National Gallery as their team have the facilities and experience in
reframing monumental scale artworks. We presented them with our chosen mounting material a smooth
sided aluminium which has an internal aluminium honeycomb structure. The National Gallery team
then structurally joined two sheets of this aluminium honeycomb together to make a single
panel of the right size. Our conservation mounters then covered the aluminium panel
in a hundred percent cotton rag museum board which would act as a buffer against any changes in
relative humidity and pollutants. To release epiphania from the drying board thin and flexible
bamboo spatulas were inserted underneath access tabs which we had positioned around the margin.
Measurements were taken from the new aluminium panel and were used to square off and cut the
surrounding Japanese paper margin to the correct size. A 3D rayon mesh laminated between layers of
Japanese paper was prepared to use as the mounting material which would attach epiphania to its new
panel. This combination gave us the strength and flexibility we needed whilst also enabling us to
use a starch paste adhesive. Strips of the laminated 3D rayon paper were cut to size.
These strips were first adhered into position on the margin and left to dry under weight.
At this point the cartoon was finally ready for mounting.
Registration points were marked along the height and width of both epiphania and the panel
ensuring that the cartoon would be accurately centred on the panel and within its frame.
The cartoon was carefully moved across to the panel where it was lightly humidified
and weighted down in the correct position. We then wrapped the laminated 3D rayon strips
around the panel pasting the strips to the sides and verso of the panel.
All of us had to work precisely and quickly to ensure that a secure bond formed between
the mounting attachments and the panel and that the mounting held the cartoon under light tension
so that epiphania remained flat. The following day a secondary layer of Japanese paper was
applied at the back of the panel further securing the attachment. Once mounted it was possible to
move epiphania into an upright position for the first time since 2018. This was an incredibly
exciting moment for us. Being able to access the cartoon in an upright position allowed us to view
the cartoon essentially as visitors to the museum would. The change in orientation allowed us to
check and adjust the toning of our infos which was really important as the lighting type and angle
impacts the way colours are perceived. We were so pleased to see that our treatments had subtly but
positively affected the overall presentation of epiphania. At around six foot I was the tallest
conservator working on epiphania and whilst it was on the table even I found reaching the centre a
bit of a stretch. Framing epiphania was a really momentous day of the project as it acknowledged
that we had reached the point where we were satisfied we had completed the conservation
treatment. It was also hugely exciting for us to see epiphania fitted within a new frame which
had been specially designed to display the newly conserved cartoon. In addition to defining the
space around the cartoon the new frame was constructed to provide stable environmental
control which means that it functions as a core part of our long-term preservation strategy for
epiphania. The new epiphania frame is effectively formed of two parts a slim portable glazed
aluminium display case and a separate wooden veneer frame which attaches to the front of the
display case to provide a traditional framed presentation. Epiphania will first be displayed
set within a temporary wall in the museum's Michelangelo the last decades exhibition.
It will then return to permanent display. On permanent display the presentation of the
cartoon will be completed with the addition of a newly carved veneer frame.
This wooden frame has also been made in collaboration with experts at the National
Gallery. The frame design incorporates architectural elements and 16th century
details both of which are befitting of Michelangelo. So today we are installing the epiphania cartoon
into its permanent display location which is in gallery 90a.
Getting it into the gallery was a real challenge it's incredibly heavy it's about 250 kilograms.
Since the exhibition the piece has been in our storerooms so we brought it through the galleries
had some contractors come in to build the scaffolding where we used a pedestrian stacker
to then lift the object on a frame so we can move it across the stairs. A huge amount of sort of
thought and planning has gone into it you know everybody is professional they know they know
their jobs inside out but it's still very nerve-wracking to see a huge cartoon which is so
valuable sort of being hoisted into the air and put onto a platform. Today we've now had to
manipulate the drawing get it into the right orientation and we're currently about to install
the drawing onto its hanging wall. So we had a steel framework made that we've attached to the wall
with a split batten so when we lower the piece onto it it engages and holds it tight to the wall.
I've not seen the frame yet in person and so it'll be amazing to see sort of it fitted on
to the front and really kind of complement the 16th century nature of the drawing.
It gives you an enormous sense of achievement when you see the thing actually on the wall
and you see that final moment where it's the display. Yeah it's a relief to have it up on the
storage so everyone can enjoy it again. Today is a very kind of poignant day for me. It has been an
incredible incredible journey especially with Michelangelo because there's nothing surpassing really.
Working on the epiphany has been the greatest technical challenge our team has ever faced.
However we have been daily rewarded with close proximity to a renaissance masterpiece,
increased experience in treating cartoons, a deeper knowledge of Michelangelo's materials
and working methods, a greater understanding of epiphany's history and a closer professional
network. What's been particularly pleasing is that our efforts have improved the visibility of the
drawing and evened out the tone of the paper whilst most importantly we have removed so much
of the material that was causing degradation. For any conservator of art on paper working on the
largest drawing by Michelangelo has to be the highlight of their career.
For myself and I'm sure I speak for all of the team it's been an unbelievable privilege.
