Conservation of Velázquez's Portrait of Philip IV

Fine Art Conservation
153 followers
14 Video Views·Oct 3, 2025
The ""Portrait of Philip IV"" by Diego Rodríguez de Silva y Velázquez (1599-1660) returned recently from The Metropolitan Museum of Art, having been cleaned for the first time in more than sixty years. The gleaming silver brocade covering the king's crimson coat is executed in an extraordinarily free and spontaneous manner, which is almost unparalleled in the painter's production and can now be better appreciated. The treatment by Michael Gallagher, Sherman Fairchild Conservator in Charge of Paintings Conservation, revealed the dazzling original surface that had been veiled by a yellowing varnish. Additionally, the first technical studies of the painting were undertaken, involving microscopy, X-radiography, and infrared reflectography.
I'm Michael Gallagher. I'm Sherman Fairchild,
Conservator-in-Charge of the Paintings Conservation Department at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The Frick Collection has had a very long and fruitful association with the Painting
Conservation Department at the Museum, and when I took up my position in October 2005,
it was very much something I wanted to continue and looked forward to exploring.
Probably a few months into that post, I walked through the galleries of the Frick with Chief
Curator Colin Bailey, and we discussed the condition of the paintings, in part just enjoying
the sheer riches of the collection, and in part looking whether there were pictures that might
benefit from conservation treatment. And one of those pictures that we discussed at length
was Velázquez's magnificent portrait of King Philip IV of Spain, sometimes known as the Frog
The reason we were discussing the picture was because it was self-evident that the painting
was to a degree obscured by discoloured varnish. It's not always easy to tell how much of varnish
that has oxidised, has changed, has darkened, is distorting a picture, and I was very conscious
of not wanting to simply bring this painting in for treatment if it wasn't strictly necessary.
No conservator in their right mind would not be excited by having a picture as wonderful as this
in the studio for a time, but that isn't what this profession is about, and the whole reason
for doing a treatment is to regain the artist's intention. If we cut to quite a few years later,
the painting actually did come to the studio, and I thought I would examine it, I would see
how discoloured the varnish was. I knew that the last time it had been treated, and by treated I
mean that an old varnish had been removed and restoration had been completed on any damages,
was 1947 by William Saw. William Saw was a very distinguished conservator who worked on a number
of the pictures from the Frick Collection. He left very thorough records of the work he did,
including a lot of photo documentation. In his documentation he reports that he worked on the
painting in 1947, but then in 1970 there is a problem. He blames it on idiosyncrasies with
the air conditioning system, but the varnish on the painting clearly had bloomed or blanched,
it had become slightly opaque, and so he did a treatment with wax and more varnish.
That told me that there was quite a considerable layer of varnish on the picture,
and that was confirmed by initial cleaning tests. A discoloured varnish does two things really.
If you think of it as a discoloured milky layer, so on one side it distorts the colour palette of
the painting, and that happens differentially. It will have a big impact on pale colours,
colours in a blue or purplish range. It won't have such a big impact on say reds and yellows.
An oxidised varnish is sort of broken down, it's a crystalline structure,
and so you get a milky haze over the picture. So darks appear lighter. If you think of dust on the
top of a black surface when you draw your finger through it, you lose the tonal variation of the
picture. So those two things, a distortion of the colour and a distortion of the tone,
can really have an enormous impact on the effects created in a painting.
And of course here we're talking not about any painting, we're talking about one of the greatest
craftsmen in terms of the manipulation of paint that ever lived. And so those subtleties,
those subtleties of tone and colour, are absolutely essential to the work in question.
One of the areas you can see the distortion of the varnish for the recent treatment is in the
forehead of Philip, where the discoloured brownish varnish pools in the texture of the paint,
creating sort of spurious effects as it were, and a very patchy, unpleasant look.
I first started to remove the varnish from the right hand side of the painting. The image here
is part way through cleaning. The varnish has been removed from the sleeve. It's rather difficult to
see when you look at the whole picture, but if you look at the detail, there is a sort of clear
line through the middle of the image and on the left hand side the old varnish is still in place,
on the right hand side it has been removed. And I think what's interesting here on the sleeve
is to see the way that discoloured layer hides effects that Velázquez intended to read for the
viewer. If you look at the elbow, he uses a sort of rather translucent grey-brown to model the
satin of the sleeve to sort of create shadows. And where that varnish layer, which is a similar
colour, sits on top of it, you totally lose that effect. The same distortion can be seen in the
collar. The varnish has a brown grubby appearance over on the left hand side. Where it's been
removed, you really sense the brushwork. There has been some change, the paint as it ages becomes
slightly more transparent, so there's certain dark brush marks underneath the layer we see
that show through more now, but there is a clarity to the vigour with which Velázquez has applied
the paint. In looking at the painting after cleaning, what is interesting to me is what
extraordinary condition it is in. I wish every picture that I worked on was in this condition.
There is a couple of minor scratches, a tiny little loss in the hat and just above it, and
then on the sides, on each side, there is a line of loss. That's to do with where at some point in the
picture's history, part of it was turned round a stretcher and then it was nailed, believe it or
not, and at a later date that was turned back to be part of the picture. So that's where the most
loss has taken place, but otherwise it's really an incredible condition. After cleaning, the next
stage is to apply a first varnish. The varnish has two roles. One is, and in a sense its most
important role, is an optical one. It starts to saturate the paint surface so that you get the
full range of colour and tone that the artist intended. It also acts as an isolating layer
between the original painting and any retouching that has to be done on damages. When we see the
picture after cleaning with the surface properly saturated, you really read the sort of richness
of the colours, the forms. The costume works far more in space. Previously there was a sense that
Philip was stood in about 10 inches of space behind him in a wall. Now the picture opens up in a way
where that space behind feels more infinite, which is very typical of the effects the artist used in
portraits. One of the important things to remember about the work we do is that everything is recorded
both in written and photographic form before treatment, after cleaning, after restoration.
All the materials we use are recorded and the governing principle really of any restoration
is that it has to be as stable as possible and most importantly completely reversible so that
if someone were to come along tomorrow or in 200 years they could remove any retouching
or any varnish I've applied very very easily without endangering the paint film. One of the
privileges of working closely with a great work of art is that a degree of detective work can take
place and we can see into the creative process how the artist started to think about the composition,
changes that were made. In Velázquez's King Philip IV of Spain there are a number of key,
what we call pentimenti, changes of mind. One of the most important ones is in the hat that Philip
holds in his proper left hand. Initially this was painted to be I think more across the body,
certainly the shape was rather different and even now in natural light you can see a sort of ghost
image of the previous position of the hat but this is particularly evident using means like
x-radiography or infrared reflectography that we have access to at the museum. Velázquez moved the
hat from where it was slightly obliquely across the body to a much more sort of frontal position
as you look at the picture. To my mind it's a less natural position, it feels slightly artificial
but it works beautifully compositionally and it gives a certain iconic quality to the image of
the king. There's nothing natural or relaxed about that pose, it is intended to communicate
kingly power. The change in the position of the hat necessitated a number of other revisions.
The hand had to be raised and moved slightly to the left and it now overlaps onto an area where
the buckskin undercoat, that slightly yellowish garment the king is wearing under the splendid
rose-coloured robe, the hand overlaps onto that slightly so you do get a somewhat incongruous
jump between the sort of two-thirds of the hand which have a slightly greyish colour where
Velázquez started to paint the hand on a darker underlayer and then when he made the change,
raised the hand, moved it over, the left-hand side overlaps onto this buckskin jerkin
and so appears lighter. That's a change that is natural to the ageing of the painting and it is
not one which we would try to change, it's just a part of the picture's history. He also changed
the contour of the coat, he slightly altered the sword and again some of these can be perceived
just with the naked eye. There is a chance that some of these changes were made because the king
shifted position. We know an extraordinary amount about the circumstances of the painting and for
example that it was completed in three sittings which is really quite extraordinary but I think
generally the feeling is that these revisions were far more to do with creating an effective
composition and in communicating the political aims of the portrait. One aspect that was revealed
during examination was that at some point in the picture's history it was extended at least
on the left and right, possibly also top and bottom. Canvas additions were probably sewn
onto the edges and then a reddish ground, that's the preparatory paint layer that is put on
the canvas, was spread into, actually parts of it was spread into the original painting.
Those additions were taken off at a later date, then probably at that point the original perimeter
sides of the canvas were used as a tacking edge. Again at a later date they were turned back out
so there was this interesting changes in dimension, not so unusual in general and
particularly with the artist. He was known to alter his own paintings but in this case it
was probably much more alterations to do with taste and even possibly convenience in terms of
a particular hang or working with another painting or working within another frame.
The x-ray image does provide us with information but it is not as clear as many x-rays you might
see and that's because at this point in his career Velázquez was using a ground and that
is the paint layer the artist first puts over the entire canvas to prepare it for the painting that's
to come. The ground he was using at this point in the 1640s had a high lead white content, it was
in fact a sort of mid-grey colour but the lead white content blocks the x-ray and the ground
was applied usually with a sort of painting knife and you get these slightly arching movements where
it's been spread onto and into the canvas weave so it makes for a quite a uniform image that is
difficult to read. You do see the current stretcher which appears lighter as I sort of you see the
sidebars and the cross vertical and horizontal in the middle and there's also traces of the original
strainer. You can see a dark line running particularly along the top and at the sides
and then two dark parallel lines just below centre which were the position of the original
rather narrow strainer that the canvas would have been stretched on. Velázquez has a dazzling
painting technique he's I think a great favourite of most painting conservators because it's just
a pure pleasure to look at this amazing facility and it's an amazing facility combined with insight
with sensitivity and a cool objectivity but not a heartless one. His paintings for the King are
very particular they're court portraiture. The most finished area of the painting is the face
here the brushwork is relatively blended to create this very smooth and polished transitions
between the various tones and forms. Elsewhere the picture has a really quite startling abbreviation
he built up his paint layers over a grey ground the grey ground is the first preparatory layer
put over the canvas this would have given him a mid-tone and he exploits that to some degree
but interestingly he doesn't use it in the coat the grey tones we see in the coat are actually
an additional paint layer. It's very difficult to see from the floor in the gallery but there are
areas where you can see the junction between paint layers you can see the original ground
layer showing through for example between the white collar and the King's neck or in just above
the eyelid in the King's proper left eye. The paint's fluidly applied and in many ways what
is always striking with Velázquez and this may sound misleading but it's a simple technique
it's not a complex system of layering he admired the Venetian artists greatly but it's not a
painting that relies on elaborate glazing techniques it's just that using simple means
he achieves dazzling effects and he has a manipulation that is really sophisticated
so it's a limited range of pigments a lot of the painting is done wet and wet but there is
this extraordinary eye-hand relationship that produces these amazing painterly effects
particularly in the rich rose coloured overgarment you see these fireworks painterly fireworks
when the painting was in the studio Professor Jonathan Brown the expert American hispanist
who specialized in the work of Velázquez came to see the picture and he commented seeing it
wonderful light in our studio how even for Velázquez this was audacious this level of
abbreviation it's very interesting in the context of the interpretation that Pablo Pérez-Dóz has
put forward that this picture had to be completed within a short period of time because it had a
very significant political role it had to be back in Madrid it had to be displayed on the Catalan
National Day to communicate all of the complex spin that was associated with it we know that it
was painted in three days and when you get up close to the surface it's very easy to believe
the paint is pushed pulled dragged across the surface in this very exciting way in detail
it's very easy to think of New York school painters of the 1950s so lively and courageous
is the application of paint of course Velázquez's gift is that though you get this wonderfully
rich complex surface there is a real feeling for paint itself and its application but it's it is
in the service of form and so with this unbelievable economy of means we completely believe this rich
silver embroidery that decorated the rose-coloured garment and I think it's
interesting that Philip himself embraced this type of painting when you think not many years earlier
you'd have probably been able to count every single thread and part of the depiction would
have been to emphasize the sheer luxury of the garment this is far more to do with a painterly
feeling than simply the display of privilege one of the great pleasures I get as a painting
conservator oddly enough is when the pictures leave the studio when they are in the studio
one frets about the problems getting the right surface doing the right thing by the picture
and then when they leave they regain their independence and I don't think any more about
those condition issues and I hope looking at the painting no one else would this picture actually
is in remarkable condition it's fascinating to know something of the history the changes
the painting technique but in the end I think the important thing is to stand in front of a great
work of art like this and just let it speak to you there is a theatre in that interaction that is
the great pleasure of visiting a collection of top quality paintings a collection like the Frick's
you've been listening to Michael Gallagher head of paintings conservation at the Metropolitan
Museum of Art the exhibition focusing on Velázquez King Philip IV of Spain will be
running from October 26th through to January 23rd 2011 I hope this has provided some insights
into why the painting was treated and Velázquez's
extraordinary technique for more information on this exhibition please visit frick.org
