The Legend of Michelangelo’s First (and Last) Signature

Sculpted Rome
10 followers
Michelangelo carved his St Peter's Pietà when he was still in his early twenties. It was the young artist's first major commission in Rome, and the first and only time he ever signed a work of sculpture (or painting). Supposedly he added the signature in secret, in the middle of the night, as a way to claim credit for the work after it was wrongfully attributed to another artist. At least, that's the story that gets repeated. The truth is a bit more complicated...
#art #arthistory #michelangelo #pieta #renaissance
Was the most famous signature in all of European art just an afterthought, carved in secret?
Picture this. The year is about 1500, and a young Michelangelo, barely in his mid-twenties,
is walking around St. Peter's Basilica in Rome. He has just finished his first major commission,
the St. Peter's Pietà, a sculptural group showing the Virgin Mary mourning her dead son,
Jesus Christ, and it has recently been installed in this very basilica.
While Michelangelo is wandering in St. Peter's, he overhears a group of visitors from northern
Italy praise the statue greatly, but then he hears something unsettling. The visitors
incorrectly attribute this work to a different sculptor. Even worse, they give the credit to
a northern Italian. Michelangelo is proudly Florentine, not a northerner. Despite this erasure
of his name and identity, Michelangelo stays quiet, choosing not to correct what he hears.
But sometime later, he enters the basilica in the middle of the night, and carves his signature
into the sculpture on a strap that runs right across the torso of the Virgin Mary. He does
all this in relative secrecy, by candlelight, in the dark. It's the first and last time he ever
signs one of his sculptures, and he apparently does it as an afterthought to claim the credit
he'd been denied by those northern visitors. At least, this is what the 16th century art historian
Giorgio Vasari would have us believe. He wrote this story in his encyclopedic Lives of the
Artists. But Vasari is, at best, an unreliable source of information. Much like the famed
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, his Lives contains much that is apocryphal, or at least
wildly inaccurate. But it's not all nonsense. Vasari contains a ton of useful information for
art historians, some of which is even true. Does that mean this story is true? How would we even
figure something like that out? It's not like we can call up Michelangelo and ask him. Well,
it turns out we can say whether or not Vasari's story is fact or fiction. Sort of. At least,
we can say how likely it is, if we dig into things a bit. It'll mean finding out who Vasari
got his stories from, and considering what the sculpture itself can tell us. To start,
we need to take a closer look at Michelangelo's St. Peter's Pietà. It's a marble sculpture
depicting the Virgin Mary with her dead son arranged across her lap. The figures are just
over life-size. Mary is seated on rocky ground that is largely hidden by the voluminous folds
of her clothing. With her right hand, she gently cradles the torso of her son. With her left,
she appears to gesture to the viewer to invite contemplation of this sacrifice. More so than in
any of his other sculptures, Michelangelo here employed a variety of polishes and finishes on
the marble surface to convey all the textures of the scene. The stone ground looks coarse.
The fabrics drape and hang with convincing softness and volume. The skin of the two
figures suggests the bones, muscles, and veins beneath its translucent surface. All this carved
from a single block of Carrara marble. The commission for this work came in 1497 from a
French cardinal in Rome. Michelangelo, who was born near Arezzo in Tuscany in 1475,
had come to Rome in 1496 after working in Florence and Bologna. In 1499, shortly after the cardinal
who commissioned this work died, the sculpture was completed and subsequently installed in St.
Peter's. And, of course, at some point, it was also given a signature by Michelangelo. On a strap
that runs across Mary's torso, he carved the following, in Latin, Michelangelo Buonarroti
the Florentine was making. Yes, it says was making, not made, but we'll get to that later.
Was this added in secret after the sculpture was already installed as the legend goes?
Let's consider our source, the notoriously anecdote-prone
the Italian artist and art historian Giorgio Vasari released the first edition of The Lives
of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects in 1550. The title is often shortened
to The Lives of the Artists or even just The Lives, as the full title is a bit of a mouthful.
This is an encyclopedic compendium of artist biographies that covers roughly three centuries
of art history, from the 1200s up until Vasari's own day, though with a clear bias toward Florentine
and Tuscan artists. Curiously, in that first edition of The Lives, there is no mention of
Michelangelo carving his signature in the middle of the night. Vasari heaps praise on the work,
calling it a miracle that stone was brought to such a level of perfection, and then offers a
different explanation for the signature. He writes that because of all the love and effort put into
the work, Michelangelo did something which he would not do in any other work. He left his name
written across a strap that encircles the bosom of Our Lady, as something with which he himself
was satisfied and pleased. Nearly two decades later, the story changed, or at least expanded.
Michelangelo died in 1564 at almost 89 years old. At the time of his death, he was probably the most
famous artist in all of Western Europe. Four years later, in 1568, Vasari released a revised,
expanded edition of his Lives of the Artist. This featured a reworked biography of Michelangelo,
and it's here that we get the new story about the Pietà signature. This is how Vasari tells it.
It happened that one day, Michelangelo, entering the space where the sculpture was located,
found a number of visitors from Lombardy greatly praising the work. One of them asked who had made
this, to which another responded, our sculptor Gobbo from Milan. Michelangelo stayed quiet,
thinking it strange that his labors were being attributed to someone else. One night, he entered
the space with a little candle and his carving tools, and carved his name into the work. By this
point, the rationale has completely changed. Vasari does still include a bit about the great love and
labor as part of the motivation, but then comes this new story about the Lombard visitors, those
are the northern Italians, and the clandestine nighttime carving. We also get the misattribution
to Gobbo, the nickname of a northern Italian artist named Cristoforo Solari. Not to throw
Vasari under the bus here, but we really cannot uncritically believe much of what he writes.
Vasari is a valuable source of information, and he did lay much of the groundwork for the modern
study of art history. But he never let something like factual accuracy get in the way of a good
anecdote. This is not to say he was routinely making things up. It's more that he wasn't always,
or ever, vetting and fact-checking his sources in the way we might hope. Unfortunately, we can't
always track down Vasari's sources of information. Who knows where he heard this story? Actually,
in this case, we can follow in Vasari's footsteps. It turns out we've got the receipts, so to speak.
In the 1930s, a German art historian digging around the archives found a letter containing
the anecdote about the signature that ended up in Vasari's 1568 edition of The Lives. The original
letter probably dates to about March of 1564, shortly after Michelangelo died. Unfortunately,
the version of the letter that survives doesn't include either the sender or the recipient,
although it's almost certain that this was sent to Vasari by someone who had been close to
Michelangelo. The letter's account of Michelangelo signing the Pietà is almost word for word what
Vasari later includes in his updated edition of The Lives. The young Michelangelo overhears the
incorrect attribution to Gobbo of Milan and he goes into the church later to carve the signature
by candlelight. But in the letter, the story doesn't end with the signature. Despite his
apparent love for anecdotes, Vasari very purposefully left out the truly strange conclusion
to this episode. Here is what the letter goes on to say, picking up right as Michelangelo is doing
his nighttime carving. A nun opposite the Pietà thought someone wanted to hurt the statue.
And so she wanted to cry out. But recognizing the truth of what was happening, she instead
thanked Michelangelo for having made so beautiful a figure of Christ. And she begged him to give
her a small bit from the wound in Christ's side. And he was so moved by this devotion that he
removed some flakes and a little marble dust and gave them to her. In thanks for this, the nun
then made him an omelette, which he ate right then and there that night. And this is why the
letters look the way they do, having been made at night and nearly in the dark because they aren't
finished. So a nun hears the carving, thinks someone is damaging the statue, and comes out
to find that it's actually the artist. And she asked for some bits of marble dust from it, like
a relic, and then makes him an omelette. I love this story. It's got the makings of a Renaissance
rom-com. A nighttime meet-cute that springs from a misunderstanding, an exchange of homemade gifts
in the form of the marble dust and the omelette, and a candlelight dinner. But apparently Vasari
didn't feel it was worthy of inclusion. And it's not all that clear that the letter writer believed
this story either. Whoever wrote this, they begin their letter by stating the following.
I'm writing you these few memories, as you requested, although I ask that you find the
and in your judgment determine what is the truth and what deserves mentioning.
It seems that Vasari decided this last bit was more thorn than rose, which is really a shame
since it adds so much color to what is already a somewhat juicy bit of Renaissance gossip.
And maybe Vasari was too quick to dismiss this part of the story. It turns out there is a detail
that might lend it some credibility, or at least a kernel of truth. And that detail is the nun
herself. We don't know anything about who she was, but in the original Italian she is referred
to as a Murata, that is a member of a religious community of women in isolation from society.
These women lived lives of intense religious devotion, asceticism, and piety. This detail
is important if we consider where the Pietà was located when it was first installed. The
sculpture's present location, in the first chapel on the right or north side of the nave of St.
Peter's, is not its original location. In fact, the current St. Peter's didn't even exist back
when the Pietà was commissioned and installed. At that time, there was an older church at this
location that was the original St. Peter's, which we now refer to as Old St. Peter's.
In this previous iteration of the church, the Pietà was located in Santa Petronilla,
a chapel by the transept, or the transverse part that crossed the nave to form the cross-like
shape of the plan, right by the chapel where the Pietà was installed, along with the tomb of the
cardinal who commissioned it, was the location of the cells of the nuns who were the very nuns
mentioned in the letter. But this arrangement didn't last long. Construction on new St. Peter's,
the building that stands in the spot today, began just a few years after Michelangelo's
Pietà was installed, though it would take over a century to complete. In 1514, workers began
demolishing the chapel of Santa Petronilla, and sometime before 1519, the sculpture was moved to
a different location, where it remained for several decades. So, Vasari never saw the work
in its original setting. And yet, the letter seems to refer to just that. By mentioning the nun from
this specific community nearby, it would suggest they knew something of the original placement.
Presumably, this might help us evaluate whether there's any truth to the account.
Except, as luck would have it, it turns out that the cloistered nuns were also moved during
construction, and in their new location, they once again were right by the Pietà. This wouldn't change
until it was moved again in 1568, four years after the letter was written. So, the presence of this
nun in the story, and her proximity to the sculpture, does not, unfortunately, help us out.
Is there anything we can turn to, then, to figure out whether Vasari's account, and the letter it's
based on, are rooted in reality? Well, what about... Let's start with where the signature is located.
Michelangelo carved the letters into a strap that runs diagonally across the verge of the torso.
The strap then disappears under Mary's veil, by her left shoulder. It's not immediately clear what
the purpose of this strap is, aside from serving as a place for the signature. It doesn't seem to
be an integral part of the Virgin's clothing, for instance. One suggestion is that the strap refers
to similar ones used by mothers to support their infant children, both when being carried in
This interpretation would link the death of Christ, portrayed in the statue, with his birth
and infancy. Making this sort of connection was not uncommon for artists at the time.
So, the strap alone doesn't automatically prove or disprove Vasari's story, as it's possible it
has some significance apart from serving as a place for the inscription. But what about the
This is not a signature in the way we often use the word to refer to a handwritten autograph.
But it was done by Michelangelo's hand, and it is visually distinctive. And the visual and
formal qualities of the text are crucial to its meaning. The signature, in Latin, reads
In English, we translate this as Michelangelo Bonarotti the Florentine was making.
That final word, the verb faciebat, is very clearly meant as was making, and not made.
In the original Latin, that verb form is the imperfect, which combines both the past tense
and the imperfective aspect. That imperfective aspect signifies continuing or ongoing action.
So, why is Michelangelo signing an extremely polished and finished work of art in a manner
that suggests the work is not completed? It's more than just being cheeky or ironic,
though we shouldn't discount that completely. Michelangelo is referencing a signature
tradition from classical antiquity that was described by the ancient Roman author Pliny
the Elder. In the preface to his Natural History, a compendium on everything from botany to astronomy
to zoology to art, Pliny wrote the following
Pliny was writing this in the first century CE, about 1400 years before Michelangelo carved his
name into the Pietà. In those intervening centuries, signing in this way, with the imperfect
form, basically disappeared. All through the Middle Ages in Italy, artists who signed their
works opted for the more straightforward made, if they included a verb of creation at all.
By the late 1400s, Italian artists, like Michelangelo, were starting to revive the
use of Faciebut and the imperfect in their signatures. He wasn't the first artist to do so,
but he did become the most famous. To really appreciate Michelangelo's use of the imperfect,
we also need to look at how the word is represented. If you look closely at the
Faciebut as it's written on the strap, you'll note that the final T is covered by the Virgin's
veil. So, technically, Michelangelo has carved Facieba rather than Faciebut, which is to say,
the word itself is unfinished. It's a clever visual pun that plays with the significance
of the inscription's meaning. The importance of the signature's formal elements doesn't stop there.
The letters used are sometimes considered Roman capitals, meaning they draw from the appearance
of letters seen in ancient inscriptions. But except for the B-O-N-A-R at the center of the
inscription, the signature's letters don't really follow ancient models all that well.
They have irregular widths, they lack the pronounced emphasis on thick and thin strokes,
and in several instances, a letter is nested within another letter. By the time Michelangelo
was carving his Pietà, there were plenty of examples of Roman capitals for him to copy,
both from antiquity and from his own day. Clearly, he made the choice to go with a
different lettering style. The art historian Eileen Wong proposed that the artist meant to
portray written rather than carved letters. Remember that the strap on which they appear
is meant to be cloth or leather, so written letters may make more sense in the context
of the illusion. I think it's also likely that these letters are intended as a conscious
throwback to older styles of lettering. Specifically, the letters made by the
artistic giants of the generation prior, Donatello and Lorenzo Ghiberti.
The way Michelangelo abbreviates the N in his name with a superscript line with a hump,
for example, is a feature seen in inscriptions by people like Donatello. Using this old-fashioned
lettering style was a way for Michelangelo to visually align himself with those artistic titans.
Michelangelo very proudly declares himself to be Florentine in the signature itself,
and the style of the letters reinforces that statement.
Michelangelo may have also been influenced by another signature, that of the sculptor
Niccolo dell'Arca on his Lamentation Group, completed around 1463 in Bologna,
a city where Michelangelo had worked for just over a year before coming to Rome.
In that instance, the artist's name appears on a scroll that touches the dead Christ's shoulder.
This puts the artist in perpetual contact with Christ, in much the same way that the
strap across the Virgin's torso does for Michelangelo. Niccolo's signature also
makes use of nested letters, as Michelangelo would later do.
One other point to note is how Michelangelo has presented his name.
There is great prominence given to his family name, Bonarotus. Those letters are generously
sized and centrally placed. Clearly, the artist was proud of this lineage.
He's also chosen to split his given name into two parts,
Michael and Angelus. He even put a little interpunct, a small triangular dot, in between
the two, emphasizing their separation. Doing this highlights the name's association with
Michael the Archangel, and appears to align the young artist with that
divinely appointed angelic messenger. Which brings us to...
So to recap, Michelangelo carved his name on a strap that appears tailor-made for it.
He included a reference to an ancient mode of signing with the imperfect that features a visual
pun. He consciously used an old Florentine lettering style to underscore his civic and
artistic identity. And he made deliberate choices in how he arranged his family and
his given name. None of that sounds like something done in haste, by candlelight,
in the middle of the night as an afterthought. Although the actual carving may have only taken
a few hours for someone with Michelangelo's skill, the formal and textual complexity
strongly suggest that this was something planned in advance.
So it turns out that Vasari's story about Michelangelo signing his Pietà is almost
certainly just that, a story. It was probably invented long after the sculpture's execution,
and therefore long after the signature was carved. Sadly, that also means our charming
story about the nun and the omelette is also unlikely to be true.
As for the Pietà itself, its modern location leaves a lot to be desired as far as viewing
conditions go. It's too far away, too high up, and is behind a wall of bulletproof glass,
a consequence of it being attacked by a hammer-wielding geologist in 1972.
That's a story for another day. Sadly, this means it's all but impossible to really appreciate
the fascinating signature placed on this work by the young artist. This is a shame,
as it's a part of the sculpture that is so loaded with meaning, both in terms of how
Michelangelo saw himself and how he wanted to be seen. The inscription is a powerful
reminder that words in stone are things unto themselves, carrying meaning far beyond the
simple transcription of their letters. Thanks for watching. If you enjoyed this
video and might want to see more, give it a like and consider subscribing. If you really
enjoyed it, share it with a friend, as that really helps the channel grow.
