The 1835 Assassination Attempt on Andrew Jackson

Andrew Jackson
2 followers
It is January 30th, and 188 years ago today, the nation was shocked by the first known
attempt to assassinate a sitting President of the United States.
The attempt by Richard Lawrence on the life of Andrew Jackson was itself high drama, and
the trial won of great interest, but it turns out that even an attempted assassination was
not nearly as interesting as, nor as sordid as, the politics of Washington, D.C.
The attempt on the life of President Andrew Jackson is history that deserves to be remembered.
Richard Lawrence can rightly be called an enigma.
On February 4th, 1835, he told Nathaniel Cosson and Thomas Sewell, both medical doctors, that
his health for several years past had been uniformly good.
Lawrence told his visitors that he had been born in England, had come to the United States
when 12 or 13 years of age, and that his father died in this district about 6 or 8 years since.
Of his age, the doctors reported that question alone he sportively declined to answer, but
he seems to have been born around 1800.
Lawrence told the doctors that he was a painter by trade, and had followed that occupation
to the present time.
That claim was reaffirmed by one Thomas Swan, who reported to the Washington Globe,
I employed him three or four years ago to paint some rooms in my house, and he performed
this work entirely to my satisfaction.
Mr. Swan offered an opinion of Lawrence.
I considered him an excellent workman, and his conduct while he was with me was correct
and orderly.
I thought him a well-disposed and an obliging young man.
But doctors Cosson and Sewell felt the need to ask some more pointed questions, and Lawrence
told them that he had never labored under any mental derangement, nor did he admit the
existence of any of those symptoms of physical derangement which usually attend mental alienation.
In fact, the doctors described his demeanor at the time as being perfectly tranquil and
unconcerned.
These answers were perplexing, but particularly relevant.
The reason for the doctor's visit was that the Marshal of the District of Columbia had
asked them to assess whether Mr. Lawrence was sane, because Mr. Lawrence was in jail
for having five days previously, on January 30th, attempted to kill the President of the
United States, Andrew Jackson.
The shocking events occurred following the funeral service for South Carolina Congressman
Warren R. Davis, who had passed away in Washington on January 29th, before the opening of the
24th Congress.
The 67-year-old Jackson had attended the funeral, despite being in ill health, as one witness
observed, there sat the gray-haired President, looking scarcely able to go through this ceremonial.
Colonel John Lane, son of Indiana Congressman Amos Lane, who witnessed the act, gave an
account of the dramatic events to The Globe.
I saw the individual enter the hall of the House during the delivery of the funeral sermon.
Before its close, however, he had taken his stand on the eastern portico, near one of
the columns.
The President, with the Secretary of the Treasury on his left arm, on retiring from the rotunda
to reach his carriage at the steps of the portico, advanced towards the spot where Lawrence
stood, who had his pistol concealed under his coat.
When he approached within two yards and a half of him, the assassin extended his arm
and leveled the pistol at his breast.
The percussion cap exploded with a noise so great that several witnesses supposed the
pistol had fired.
On that instant, the assassin dropped the pistol from his right hand, and taking another
ready cock from his left, presented it and snapped it at the President, but that moment
had raised the stick and was rushing upon him.
Mr. Woodbury and Lieutenant Godney, at the same instant, laid hold of the man, who gave
way through the crowd and was, at last, knocked down.
Lawrence had confirmed many of the details to Dr. Kazin, a physician at the jail, and
Dr. Sewell, professor of anatomy and physiology at the Columbian College, as reported in the
National Intelligencer.
He observed that he did not enter the hall, but looked through a window from the lobby
and saw the President seated with members of Congress, and then he returned to the
rotunda and waited until the President again entered it, and then passed through and took
his position in the East Portico, about two yards from the door, drew his pistols from
his inside coat pocket, cocked them, and held one in each hand, concealed by his coat, lest
he should alarm the spectators, and states that as soon as the one in his right hand
missed fire, he immediately dropped or exchanged it and attempted to fire the second before
he was seized.
He further stated that he aimed each pistol at the President's heart and intended, if
the first pistol had gone off and the President had fallen, to have defended himself with
the second, if defense had been necessary.
These events were shocking.
Never before in history had someone tried to assassinate a sitting President, but perhaps
even more surprising was that the assassin had ample time to shoot at the President at
point-blank range, not once, but twice, and both pistols mysteriously misfired.
And the aging and ailing President, instead of seeking cover, decided instead to charge
the assassin and beat him with his cane.
The most immediate question was motive.
The reason for the pointed questions of Drs.
Cossin and Sewell was whether Mr. Lawrence was insane.
On the one hand, he seemed to be in control of his faculties, was able to discuss the
event with clear detail, and even admitted having pre-planned it, telling them that he
had loaded the pistol three or four days previous, with ordinary care, for the purpose intended.
When asked why he went to the Capitol that day, the doctors reported he replied that
he expected that the President would be there.
He also stated that he was in the rotunda when the President arrived, and on being asked
why he did not attempt to shoot him, he replied that he didn't wish to interfere with the
funeral ceremony.
But alongside what appeared to be such rational planning, the doctors found reason to question
Lawrence's sanity.
Lawrence's first explanation of motive was that of late he could not find any steady
employment, which had caused him much pecuniary embarrassment, and that he had been told the
President caused his loss of occupation and the consequent want of money, and he believed
that to put him out of the way was the only remedy for this evil.
The story then gets even odder.
When asked who had told him that, he said that his brother-in-law, Mr. Redford, had
told him he would have no more business because he opposed the President, and had believed
that Redford was in league with the President against him.
And if a supposed plot between the President of the United States and his brother-in-law
to deny him business painting houses was not odd enough, he then told the doctors that
he had long been in correspondence with the powers of Europe, and that his family had
been wrongfully deprived of the crown of England, and he should yet live to regain it, that
he considered the President of the United States as nothing more than his clerk.
Apparently unconvinced that Lawrence was the rightful king of England, the good doctors
concluded, we do not hesitate to state as our own opinion that this unfortunate man
is laboring under extensive mental hallucination upon some subjects.
That conclusion was further reinforced by another examination on February 26th by a
Dr. Benjamin Borer.
Borer not only observed physical symptoms of mental illness, writing that the pupil
of the eye was dilated, pulse was slightly tense to febrile, his tongue furred into a
practiced eye, a morbid physiogamy, a peculiar cast of countenance was manifest.
But like Drs. Cossin and Sewell, he found Lawrence's state of motive to be that the
President knew his claim to the crown of Great Britain to be just, that it was only necessary
for him to reach England to secure it, and that he wants money to get there, where he
has a large body of friends to support him.
That General Jackson, having control over the bank of the United States, ought to furnish
him with that money, and not having done so, was the cause of his attack upon him.
Asserting that the cause of the delusion may be related to his trade has been that of a
painter which exposed him to the action of lead and also the rays of the sun, Borer concluded
that having solely truth and justice to govern him, begs leave to state that in his opinion,
the case of Lawrence is one of true insanity, and belonging to that species termed monomania,
leaving further that if he had not taken up the present maniacal hallucinations, he might
have fastened upon one equally dangerous.
The diagnosis of insanity was confirmed by two further physicians before Lawrence's trial
in April.
But despite these examinations, not everyone was convinced.
Professor Richard Roars of Oklahoma State University noted in a 1981 edition of the
Journal of the Early Republic, a European traveler in Washington at the time noticed
the pervasiveness of partisanship.
She noted that within two hours of the attack, reports connected nearly every eminent politician
in Washington with Lawrence.
Roars continues that although Lawrence denied ever having discussed his intent with anyone,
charges and counter charges pervaded Washington for several months as political machinations
and petty vendettas obscured the grave significance of the attack.
The two most commonly expressed theories suggested that either Jackson's enemies had instigated
the assassination attempt, or that the Jacksonians had arranged it to promote public sympathy
for the president.
For example, in February, it was reported that one David Stewart had made an oath on
the Holy Evangely of Almighty God before a magistrate that the last of December or
January 1st last, he saw Richard Lawrence go into Tennessee Senator George Poindexter's
dwelling house on 4 1⁄2 Street.
And the Tuesday before the attempt to assassinate the president of the United States, the dependent
did see Senator Poindexter and Lawrence in Senator Poindexter's passage in conversation.
The newspaper Rhode Island Republican reported, a captain of high standing in the Navy had
previously stated in this city that Poindexter on his voyage from New Orleans had threatened
to demand satisfaction for the remark made upon him by the president in an anonymous
letter to the Baltimore Patriot, saying that if the president refused, he would shoot him
wherever he saw him.
Roars writes that letters from the time show that Jackson immediately blamed Poindexter.
On the day of the assault, the president rejected the suggestion by a group of well-wishers
that Lawrence was insane.
Instead, Jackson expressed the belief that Poindexter had hired the assailant because
In a speech before the Senate, Poindexter denied the charges and blamed them on Jackson,
saying that the investigation that I have thus far given to the conspiracy against my
character has been able to trace the authority on which the statement in the letter referred
to was founded to a member of the House of Representatives from Rhode Island.
And the depositions therein spoken of have been taken on the insistence of the president
himself.
At Poindexter's suggestion, the Senate formed a special committee to investigate the matter.
The committee found that the two people who claimed to have seen Poindexter and Lawrence
together were not credible, but they absolved Jackson of having any influence over their
testimony.
The entire argument seems to be ridiculous.
Poindexter had not achieved re-election in 1834.
He had only a few weeks left in his term.
Other charges were less direct.
Instead of directly asserting a hand in the assassination, they blamed the inflammatory
and partisan speeches of the day.
The Washington Globe opined on February 4th that Lawrence was in full possess of his natural
faculties, but blamed disappointed and ambitious orators in the Senate who depicted the president
as a Caesar for motivating Lawrence's despicable act.
The New York Evening Post wrote that there are men who will grieve that the ball of the
assassin did not perform its office.
There are men who would have rejoiced if the life of the president had been sacrificed,
who would have looked on the assassin not as a wretch deserving to be slain by lingering
tortures, but as a brutus who struck a brave blow for liberty.
The Post laid the blame for the act on exactly those people, writing that no doubt Lawrence
was insane, nor do we doubt that he inhaled the latent seed and poisonous atmosphere of
the United States Senate chamber.
Aye, we say it fearlessly and with full confidence in its truth that if the man is mad, he is
a political maniac and has been wrought up to the frenzy by the hysterical harangues
of Senators Clay, Webster, and Calhoun and their besotted followers.
Morris notes that the pro-Calhoun United States Telegraph responded in kind by suggesting
that Vice President Martin Van Buren would benefit more from the president's death than
those senators critical of Jackson's administration.
And Telegraph editor Duff Green concluded that the accusation against Calhoun was additional
proof that the president was a feeble man surrounded by vile sycophants and knaves who
fill his ears with loathsome jealousies.
Calhoun argued on the floor of the Senate that such accusations were being used by Jackson
to suppress Senate criticism of corruption and abuses of power.
The debate was further inflamed by the strange misfire of both pistols.
Drs. Cosne and Sewell wrote that in their interview with Lawrence, when asked about
the pistols which he used, he stated that his father had left him a pair, but not being
alike, about four years since he exchanged one for another which exactly matched the
best of the pair.
These were both flintlocks, which he recently had altered to percussion locks.
That he had been frequently in the habit of loading and firing those pistols at marks
and that he had never known them to fail going off on any other occasion, and that at the
distance of ten yards, the ball always passed through an inch plank.
His confidence in the pistols was supported by a test by Francis Scott Key, District Attorney
for the District of Columbia, who wrote in response to requests from Congress.
On Saturday, I proposed to General Hunter, the marshal of the district, that we should
examine the pistols produced on the commitment of Lawrence to ascertain whether there was
any defect in them or in the charges, or any other way of accounting for the failure
to discharge them.
I proposed that we should try the pistols still loaded by putting on another cap, and
should then try each of them several times by reloading them with powder.
In taking the loaded pistol from the marshal's desk, we examined the tube and found the powder
visible at its summit.
General Hunter, by inclining the pistol, threw out a few grains of the powder in his hand.
We took from a box of caps found in the prisoner's shop, without selecting it, one which was
placed upon the tube.
When we walked to a small enclosure near the office and fired it, the ball passed to an
inch plank at a distance of about 5 or 6 yards, and lodged nearly behind, in the opposite
side of the enclosure, 7 yards distance.
When we loaded with the small quantity of the powder found in the prisoner's possession
to the pistols several times, without taking any other means of forcing the powder into
the tubes than the ramming home small paper wads of the charges, the discharge took effect
on every trial.
The failure of the pistols was truly remarkable.
The website of the History Channel notes that a century later, Smithsonian Institute researchers
conducted a study of Lawrence's Derringers, during which both guns discharged properly
on the first try.
It was later determined that the odds of both guns misfiring during the assassination attempt
was 1 in 125,000.
While Jackson supporters took this as divine intervention, the Evening Post writing,
Who is there so blind to the services of Andrew Jackson that he does not feel sensations of
the liveliest gratitude for the almost miraculous preservation of the valuable life of the
greatest man of modern times, the truest benefactor of the human race, the most efficient guardian
of the great principles of human liberty?
Roars writes that Green and the intelligentsia scoffed at the idea, arguing that the day
for miracles had gone by, implying that the likely explanation for the failure of the
pistols was that the assassination attempt had been staged, with the editors of the anti-Jackson
United States Telegraph opining that,
Oddly, at the time, attempted murder was only a misdemeanor in the District of Columbia.
Lawrence seemed unhinged throughout the trial.
The Richmond examiner said there was something around the eyes that was certainly indicative
of mania, but maintaining throughout the trial that he was the rightful king of England,
and at one point standing up and shouting at the jury,
It is for me, gentlemen, to pass judgment on you, not you upon me, was plenty enough
to convince the jury.
After just five minutes of deliberation, they brought back a verdict of not guilty, by reason
of insanity.
District Attorney Key didn't seem to offer a very vigorous opposition to the insanity
defense, and maybe that's because a finding of insanity gave a better chance that Lawrence
would be confined for a longer period of time than being convicted of a mere misdemeanor.
In fact, Lawrence was committed to an asylum in Washington, D.C., and remained committed
in asylums until his death in 1861.
As to the pistols, it was a particularly rainy, wet, foggy day, and those kinds of derringers
were particularly subject to moisture in the powder, and that seems to be the most likely
explanation for why both misfired.
In the end, perhaps the most interesting thing about the entire affair, and the part that
is most relevant today, was not in the assassination attempt, but in the way that a random act
of a lunatic was exploited in a period of harsh partisan politics.
Dr. Roer explains, Lawrence's acquittal brought an end to the immediate aftermath of the assassination
attempt.
It had been a sordid affair, yet few in Washington seemed surprised by the political intrigues.
I hope you enjoyed this episode of the History Guy.
Check out our community on thehistoryguyguild.locals.com, our webpage at thehistoryguy.com, and our
merchandise at teespring.com, or book a special message from the History Guy on Cameo.
And if you'd like more episodes of Forgotten History, all you have to do is subscribe.
