Dueling With Andrew Jackson | President's Day | Kentucky Life | KET

Andrew Jackson
2 followers
A common misconception about dueling was that it was always to the death.
It was fairly uncommon in the duel to actually be trying to kill each other.
In a duel, you're settling a matter of honor.
So typically, if you just show up, you know, you put your, congratulations, you're not
a coward, you put your grievances aside, and everyone retires with their honor intact.
James Jasko is historian at the Hermitage in Nashville, Tennessee.
Jackson was a very polarizing figure, which would be true all the way through his presidency.
You either loved Andrew Jackson or you absolutely hated him.
But before he was the hero of the Battle of New Orleans, and before his presidency, Jackson
was practicing law in Tennessee.
He was also an avid horse breeder, and the origins of the grudge with Charles Dickinson
began at the track.
Dickinson went to a tavern afterwards and started kind of running his mouth a little
bit.
He talked about, talked a little bit about Jackson.
What he most likely talked about was Rachel Jackson, Andrew Jackson's wife, beloved wife.
Dickinson was referring to the fact that Rachel had married Jackson, not knowing her first
husband had failed to finalize their divorce.
Jackson found out about it.
Given that he is a gentleman on the frontier, he felt as though he had no choice but to
challenge Dickinson to a duel.
Dueling was illegal in Tennessee, but not in the border state of Kentucky.
The two chose to face off in Logan County, with many rooting for Dickinson, who is known
as the best shot in the state of Tennessee.
You can tell how both sides thought the duel was going to go by the way that they traveled
to Kentucky.
Dickinson loaded up a couple of wagons, they got his buddies together.
They stopped at taverns along the way.
Dickinson held shooting demonstrations.
From 20 paces, he would shoot through the middle of a spider web.
Or someone would hold up a piece of string and he would shoot it, shoot a bullet and
cut it in half.
So he had a reputation as probably not exactly a guy you want to go pick in a gunfight with.
Jackson took his best friend in a surgeon.
So if one of your close advisors or one of your seconds to a duel is a doctor, you kind
of have an idea that not quite as optimistic as the other guy is.
I believe both were pretty set on carrying this duel out.
I do believe that both sides went to Kentucky with the intention that only one was going
to be coming back.
On May 30, 1806, Jackson and Dickinson met at Harrison's Mill on the Red River.
By design, Jackson let Dickinson fire first.
So Dickinson shoots first by design.
The smoke from the gun and the looseness of Jackson's overcoat made it such that Dickinson
had to watch Jackson's reaction to see if he'd actually hit him.
Jackson took a half a step back and regained his position.
This is where Dickinson cries out, Great God, have I missed him?
He's not used to missing too terribly often.
So now it's Jackson's turn where he can raise his pistol and fire.
His gun doesn't go off, and Jackson is so mad at Dickinson that he makes him stand there
while he fixes his gun, takes aim for a second time, and this time his gun does indeed go
off.
Supporters of Dickinson claimed Jackson's shooting twice was a breach of etiquette.
The result of the misfire is up for debate.
At best, to be the most forgiving of Jackson, it was a questionable move.
When Jackson fired, it was pretty clear that Dickinson was mortally wounded.
The bullet went clean through, you know, in one side, out the other, and there just wasn't
a whole lot that could be done for Dickinson.
His seconds carry him to a nearby cabin where they just try to make Dickinson comfortable.
One story is that Dickinson bled through two mattresses before he ended up dying 14 and
a half hours after Jackson had shot him.
But it's what happened as Jackson headed back to Nashville that people would talk about
for years to come.
Jackson's surgeon noticed blood coming from his boot.
He says, General, have you been hit?
And Jackson, in what might be the understatement of Jackson's quotable career, says, oh, I
think he pinked me a little, and then he fell off his horse.
Dickinson had indeed been successful in wounding Jackson.
Dickinson hit him exactly where he wanted to, but because he pulled his jacket over
just a little bit, the bullet ended up missing his heart by about an inch and a half towards
the middle of his chest.
So the bullet shattered on Jackson's sternum.
Basically, it collapsed the lung, broke a couple of his ribs.
Ultimately, the surgeon decided and said, it's more dangerous to try to go in and get
all those bullet fragments than it is just to leave it alone.
So they sewed him up, sent him back to Nashville.
Jackson lived with the bullet fragments in his chest for the rest of his life.
Jackson was not prosecuted for murder because dueling was legal in Kentucky, and the duel
had very little effect on his successful campaign for the presidency in 1829.
What fascinates me about Andrew Jackson is that Jackson represents the best and worst
of America in the 19th century, given that he was a slave owner, a plantation owner,
is largely credited with signing the Indian Removal Act of 1830 into law, but he was also
a self-made man.
He kind of brought himself up through the ranks and was able to establish himself as
one of the nation's primary citizens.
He went from fairly well-known Tennessean to national hero, to an American rock star
with the Battle of New Orleans, that Jackson represents the self-made man of America and
kind of the anything is possible in this new world, but also lived out the prejudices of
the day.
However, in the end, Dickinson may have played a part in Jackson's death.
When Jackson died in 1845, he complained of symptoms that look an awful lot like lead
poison.
Given that they never took those bullet fragments out of his chest, it's logical to assume that
lead poisoning did contribute somewhat to his death, in addition to old age and hard
living.
But it's been said that Charles Dickinson did shoot and kill Andrew Jackson.
It just happened to be 39 years after Andrew Jackson shot and killed Charles Dickinson.
