Can somebody really enforce any space treaties and do they make any sense? What's a better future, colonies on Mars or on giant rotating spaceships? What's India's space program been up to lately? And in Q&A+, would I take a one-way ticket to Mars?
00:00 Start 00:28 [Iamsick] Mars vs O'Neil cylinders 02:08 [busybillyb33] How enforceable is the Outer Space Treaty? 06:04 [Tarun Pulikanti] Thoughts on India's space station ambitions 08:23 [Doogle] How difficult is it to see the Orion Nebula? 10:21 [Larry Tilghmon] Why did Oumuamua leave our solar system so easily while we cannot? 11:58 [GTP_ VEXD] What is a light year and why do we use them?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
Can a country really enforce a space
treaty? And so, do they make any sense?
What's a better future? Colonies on Mars
or on a giant rotating spaceship? What's
India's space program been up to lately?
And in Q&A plus, would I take a one-way
ticket to Mars? Answering all these
questions and more in this question
show. Time for the question show. Your
questions, my answers, as always,
wherever you are, across my channel. If
a question pops in your brain, just
write it down. I'll gather them up and I
will answer them here. All right, let's
get into the questions. I am sick. Would
you rather live on Mars or in a rotating
habitat? Personally, me, neither. I'd
like to live on Earth. But if I had to
choose, if you're going to destroy Earth
and then I had to choose whether I was
going to live in a rotating habitat or I
was going to live on Mars, I would
probably choose the rotating habitat.
And the reason for that is probably just
because we can guarantee that we can
produce artificial gravity with this
giant rotating habitat. And we just we
don't know what the effects of low
gravity are going to be on the human
body. So if you go and live on Mars and
you're living on 1/3 gravity for years
and years and years on end, we don't
know what the cumulative health effects
are for that experience. Could be that
it's fine and that living on Mars is
just like living on Earth. But it could
be that it is bad for your body and it
shortens your lifespan and gives you all
kinds of health issues a couple of years
into this process. And so then what are
the methods to mitigate that? You're
going to have to live on some kind of
gravity train on Mars that is driving in
this big circle and you're pretty much
on a rotating space station anyway. But
living on Mars, you do have regalith.
You have dirt, right, that you can dig
around in. You can walk around out on
the surface. You can explore a vast
landscape. If you're living in a Now I'm
changing my mind. If you're living on a
rotating space station, then then you're
kind of limited to just the space
station. Depends on how big it is,
right? If you make it really really big
and really really fun and really cool,
that'd be all right. Um, so I Yeah.
Neither. Earth, please. Busy Billy B33.
How enforceable is the outer space
treaty? If a nation goes out to mine
resources, what do the others do? I
mean, the outer space treaty is an
international treaty that is enforcable
as various other international treaties
are. Some of them are very heavily
enforced and others are very loosely
enforced and people violate them all the
time. Now, the outer space treaty really
mostly is about the prevention of
nuclear weapons being deployed in space.
And so it would be devastating if you
allowed people to just launch nuclear
weapons into space and have them
orbiting overhead all the time. That
right now, you know, if two nations want
to go to war with each other with
nuclear weapons, they need to fire their
ballistic missiles and those missiles
need to take 45 minutes to arrive at
their destination. And you've got 40
you've got minutes of warning where you
can launch a counter strike. And so
you're locked in this nuclear stalemate.
But if you were able to put nuclear
weapons into satellites and have them
fly overhead, then when your nuclear
satellites were flying over your enemy
nation, you just launch the rocket down
and it detonates a minute later, 2
minutes later. Like it doesn't take long
to go from low Earth orbit to detonating
above the city of your choice. And you
can imagine there would always be
nuclearpowered
platforms, nuclear weapon platforms just
floating overhead at all times and there
would be no stalemate. And so the really
the key of the outer space treaty, the
purpose was to limit the ability for
nations to put these nuclear weapons
into orbital platforms and have them
hanging over top of each other. And that
went through and so like how enforceable
is the outer space treaty? Nobody has
dared launch nuclear weapons platforms
into space and have them hanging over
their potential enemies. Uh if they if
anybody did, they would suffer immediate
and severe consequences. Would they
suffer a nuclear they would probably
suffer a conventional weapons hot war if
they tried to do it, right? If one
nation tried to launch a nuclear weapons
platform that went overhead their enemy
nation,
they would at the very least fall under
the entire sanctions of planet Earth.
That would be the best case scenario.
And the worst case scenario is they
would instantly be invaded by all of
their enemies. And anybody who was
sitting neutral on the fence would take
a dim view as well because people
shouldn't be allowed to start nuclear
wars with 2 minutes notice. we need to
have the 45minut notice that keeps us
all safe from the nuclear Armageddon. Uh
and so really, you know, then there's a
bunch of other stuff like you can't own
parts of space and here are the rules if
you you know on how you have to be able
to allow people to to hang out in your
colony on Mars and so on and so forth.
But really it's about no nukes in space.
So, how enforceable? Um, you know, if a
niche tries to go out and mine
resources, that's not really covered by
the outer space treaty. When you think
about it, the Japanese Hayabusa 2
mission and NASA's Osiris Rex mission
have mined resources from asteroids and
brought them back to Earth. Now, it's
measured in the grams, but it happened.
And nobody is considering that to be a
violation of the Outer Space Treaty. And
if they brought back tens of kilograms,
hundreds of kilograms, thousands of
kilograms, like at a certain point,
someone's going to go, "Wait a minute.
What are you doing here?" Um, but I I
don't think it's going to be a big it
won't be a big issue to have nations
agree to certain reasonable spacebased
insitu resource utilization uh into the
future. Terrun Pilanti, India's building
its capabilities to construct a space
station. What are your thoughts? I think
that's great. I think the more nations
that are capable of building uh
structures in space is better. The ISRO
is a fascinating group and they're very
effective in producing spacecraft. Like
the engineering capability of the people
at ISRO is world class. With their mom
mission to Mars, they sent a spacecraft
to Mars for a fraction of the price that
it cost other nations, just a few
hundred million. And even sort of when
you consider wages in India compared to
wages in other countries, it's still
done on a cheaper budget than than other
countries are capable of. There's a lot
of really great engineering. India built
the Shundryan probe. This was the
spacecraft that discovered the presence
of water at the moon's poles. And so,
uh, they're going to be attempting
another landing on the surface of the
moon. They're planning now on building
their own human space exploration
technology capability in the same way
that the Chinese did. And so, so first
you build an orbital capsule, a rocket
capable of carrying an orbital capsule
into low Earth orbit. You have
astronauts go on board. Then you build a
space station where the capsules will
dock with it. And it is planning on
sending people to the moon um probably
within the next decade as well. So there
are many more nations now that are
capable of doing long duration space
flight. I mean it's not just NASA,
Russia, the Chinese now um as well as uh
India is going to be coming up quickly
as well you know and then other nations
participate. I mean the the Japanese,
the Canadians um various European
nations contribute astronauts and funds
to the work done by other nations. So,
uh, more and more we're seeing as the
costs come down for space flight, more
and more nations are capable of sort of
stepping up and being able to start
deploying into space. It's time to shout
out our new patrons at the $5 level and
above. Ryan C91, Benjamin Valamort,
Lucash Waggle, Sandy, Steven Brown,
Steven Thomas, Tom Dixon, Steve Nichols,
Stefan Bertold, and Daniel. Join a
community at patreon.com/universetoday.
Google, how difficult is it to see the
Orion Nebula? Not hard at all. Uh, the
Orion Nebula is very bright. So, where I
live in Canada, I have Bortal 2 sky. So,
not the absolute darkest skies, but
they're one step away from the darkest
skies. And I can walk outside, I can
look in the direction of Orion when
there's no moon in the sky, and I can
see the Orion Nebula with my eyes. Now,
it's it's this little fuzzy hazy patch
uh in Orion's scabbard, but it's
definitely there. And then when you look
at it in a small pair of binoculars, you
can see the area where the Orion Nebula
is. And when you look at a small
telescope, it looks even better. And
then obviously when you take a longer
exposure photograph, then it looks
phenomenal. So, uh yeah. Yeah, it's easy
to see the Orion Nebula. when I'm doing
the virtual star parties with the
telescope and Orion is up, then it just
is an overwhelmingly beautiful nebula
compared to anything else you can take a
picture of. It's so big and so bright um
with so much material, so much going on
in the Orion Nebula compared to, you
know, everything else is like little
fuzzy bits or you have to do really long
exposures to get some of the fainter
nebulosity. But Orion is big, bright,
very short exposures do incredible
justice to that to that nebula and it
just shows you can see it. I mean
there's there's a bunch of stuff that I
think people are surprised that you can
see with your eyes. You walk outside,
you can see the Pletes star cluster very
easily. In fact, they used to in theory
I've heard this that they use as an eye
test. So how many stars can you see in
Pletes will tell you how good your
eyesight is. You can see Andromeda, the
Andromeda galaxy. It's, you know, once
you know where to look, it's this little
fuzzy spot in the sky. You can see M33,
which is the other galaxy that's part of
the local group. You can see the large
and small Magelina clouds. Uh, so
there's a lot of objects you can
actually see with the unaded eye just
when you walk outside. A lot of star
clusters I can see with my eyes. Larry
Tilgamon, why can't we leave our solar
system the way OmuA Mua came in? Umuam
Mua is on a hyperbolic trajectory that's
going to carry it through the solar
system back into interstellar space. It
has not been captured by the solar
system. And in fact, we have sent
spacecraft on escape trajectories from
the solar system. So, the Pioneer
spacecraft, the Voyagers, and the New
Horizon's mission are all on velocities
that are so high they're going to leave
the orbit of the sun and they're going
to go into orbit around the Milky Way.
And if you wanted to send a spacecraft
from Earth and you wanted to be able to
achieve that that velocity, you just
need about 12 1/2 kilometers/s
in escape velocity once you've already
once you're already in space. So, it
takes you about 7 1/2 km/s of delta V to
get off of the surface of planet Earth.
And once you're in orbit around planet
Earth, it takes about another 12 1/2
kilometers/s of delta V of velocity to
be able to leave the solar system. And
the best way to do that is to use
gravitational assists that you can add a
few kilometers/s to the speed of your
spacecraft by doing gravitational
assists of Jupiter and Saturn, Neptune,
Uranus. Um, and that's why Voyager 2 is
going so fast and Voyager 1 is going
even faster. Um, but because they were
able to do these really good
gravitational assists. Same thing with
New Horizons. So, uh, yeah, we've
already sent five spacecraft on a
trajectory that's going to leave the
solar system. GTP vexed, for those of us
who don't understand, can you please
explain what a lightyear is and why we
calculate distances using them? Sure. A
lightyear is just the distance that
light travels in one year. So light
travels at 299,000
900 like just shy of 300,000
kilometers/s.
And if you stretch that out to an entire
year, it is a vast amount of time. So
like why do astronomers use that? Just
because light is the fastest possible
moving thing and light moves very far
and the distances in space are enormous.
And so it's only thinking about in terms
of light years, thousands of light
years, millions of light years, billions
of light years that you can start to
really wrap your head around the vast
scale of the universe. But actually
astronomers don't use the term
lightyear. That is a thing that we
regular people use in the common
parliament. But astronomers use a more
obscure term um called a parseek. And a
parseek
like trying to explain a parseac a
parseek is about three layers.
So that's the simple answer. But
essentially it's based on trigonometry.
The earth's position on two sides of the
sun and the triangle that it makes and
the amount of degrees and arcs seconds
that move across the sky. They use that
to measure. It's called a parseek. And
then they measure thousands of parsects,
millions of parsects. And but roughly
when you hear that something is one
parseek, in your mind, you should just
go that's about three lighty years.
That's what I do. Did you know that you
can watch the same video with no ads and
get a bonus question over on Patreon
completely for free? We call it Q&A
Plus. And this week's bonus question is
all about going on a one-way trip to
Mars. Would I do it? I'll put a link in
the show notes. All right, those are all
the questions that we had this week.
Thank you everybody for hanging out and
asking your questions in the YouTube
comments as well as everybody who
answered questions in the live shows
that we did over the course of the year.
I'm going to talk about a book series
that I'm reading. But first, I'd like to
thank our patrons. Thanks to Abe Kson,
Andrew Gross, Brayley Griffin, Brian
Bod, Carwin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander
Bay, Sin Nelson, David Gilton, David
Matz, Dustin Gable, Evan Pro, Greg Phy,
Hudson Moore, James Clark, Jeremy
Matter, Jim Burke, Jordan Young,
Marcelitz, Michael Barcel, Modzo, Paul
Rob, Rank, Kaidu, Rob, Sean, Sergeant,
Steven Fam, Munley, Vlad Shibelin, and
Wolf Gang Clots who support us at the
master of the universe level and all our
patrons. All your support means the
universe to us.
So, I just wanted to give you an update
on uh books that I'm reading right now
during the summer hiatus. So, I'm
reading a book series called Dungeon
Crawler Carl. And this was a
recommendation from my son. And they're
great. They're very much in the sort of
same vein as Weird Legion, Iron Bob, uh
The Martian, Andy Weir books, you know,
very lighthearted but very, very
creative. And the gist of the story is
it's about a guy who uh and his cat who
are uh the world ends and they are
sucked into a uh sort of alien blood
sport video game and have to descend
down through this dungeon level after
level. And it is a like it's totally a
trope in uh especially like Chinese uh
web fiction but also Japanese stuff when
you think about say and Korean Squid
Game or uh uh Alice in Borderlands.
But the book is very well written. uh
the it's sort of the first book is like
the weakest in my opinion and they get
stronger and stronger over time as the
ideas get more fleshed out and what
feels very formulaic very quickly kind
of goes off the rails in a very good way
and sort of showing you a much larger
picture of what's going on. But um you
know if you're looking for something
that's very light, very digestible, and
also wildly entertaining, I highly
recommend uh Dungeon Crawler Carl. So
check that out. All right, we'll see you
next