How don't comets lose all their mass really quickly? Where are all the photos of the Milky Way from the ISS? Can you reach out from orbit and poke a black hole with a stick? Answering all these questions and more in this Q&A show.
00:00 Start 00:24 Comets and their tails 04:06 Where are the pictures of the Milky Way from the ISS? 08:36 Will the Sun's expansion bring the Moon closer to Earth? 11:27 Can you poke a black hole with a stick? 13:35 When did 'our' part of the Universe form?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
why don't comets lose their Tales round
two where are all the Milky Way pictures
from space and what if you jab to black
hole with a stick all this and more in
this week's question show it's time for
the question show your questions my
answers as always R you are across my
channel if a question Pops in your brain
just write it down I will gather them up
and I will answer them here all right
let's get into the questions Thomas
Shields I don't think you answered
Scott's question about the comet he
wasn't asking why did the tales and
trails last for tens of thousands of
years he was asking why the Comets
themselves don't lose enough matter
during their regular approaches to the
Sun or disappear sooner so after a
question show that we did I guess last
week but you I'm not sure exactly how
many shows ago it was but why don't
comets run out of tail fuel I think was
the was the thumbnail that we had and a
lot of people in the comments said you
answered the wrong question you asked
about you answered why do the taals last
a long
time in the solar system but not like
how can the Comets be continuously
producing tales for long periods of time
and I apologize that I I answered the
question I I wanted to answer as opposed
to the one necessarily that was being
asked and so I here's the other version
of that answer so yeah so comets right
they come from Icy regions of the solar
system and they are balls of ax mixture
of rock and water ice as well as other
volatile elements and when comets get
relatively close to the Sun within the
orbit of Saturn Jupiter they start to
produce this tale that the solar wind
that is striking the comet starts to
cause the volatiles on their surface to
boil off and create this tail that is
following behind them in space now the
Comet Tail points away from the Sun and
so that's why when a comet is moving
towards the the sun it looks you know
it's got this tail going behind it and
makes sense but then when the comet is
moving away from the Sun the tail is
still moving away from the Sun it looks
like the the comet is following its own
tail but absolutely this material is
being degraded by the solar wind and
there's a limited amount of material
that's on the surface of the Comet and
it lasts somewh on the order of
thousands of years and it really just
depends on the orbit of the Comet and so
in some cases let's say you've got a
comet like Haley's Comet that gets in
relatively close to the Sun but then
goes pretty far out into the solar
system astronomers have been tracking
Haley's Comet because it's a very bright
Comet it's very recognizable for about
2,000 years and it still produces a tail
every time that it comes by the Sun but
there are other examples of comets that
maintain within the orbit of say Jupiter
they don't get that far away from the
sun and it appears within just a few
dozen orbits they've lost their tails
they no longer have these volatile
elements on the surface of the Comet now
something that's really interesting is
that over the last couple of decades
astronomers have found objects which are
asteroids and yet they seem to produce a
comet likee tail or a fairly diminished
tail but still and so what's probably
happening is that you're getting this
loss of material on the surface of the
Comet the stuff that the solar wind can
easily reach but then once that's all
gone you still got lots and lots of
material that is underneath the surface
but now it's all just covered in this
shell of rock and so if something
happens like the comet gets hit by an
asteroid or breaks apart in some way
then all of this material is then
freshly revealed to the solar wind and
then it can generate a tail again
so comets definitely don't last forever
they last a few thousand years depending
on their orbit how close they get to the
Sun and how far away they are from the
Sun at the farthest point of their
orbit if there's like a third version of
this question I'm ready JD
mm4 how come there are so few pictures
from the Milky Way taken from the space
station I think they'd have a much
better view than we do on Earth the
astronauts on board the International
Space Station absolutely have a better
view of the Milky Way than what we have
down here on the surface of the Earth
they are above the atmosphere and so
they get this clear view they're
effectively their eyeballs have become
space telescopes and they're able to
look out into the cosmos and I've had a
chance to interview with astronauts
directly about this question especially
the ones who are amateur astronomers I
talked to Ron Garen uh and Don Pettit
and Don Pettit actually is on the
International Space Station right now
although you know we were having a beer
at a conference and not uh you know
talking to him on the station and
what the impression I get from them as
amateur astronomers like they own
telescopes they go out they do
photography of the night sky that the
experience of being on the International
Space Station is that is like you are
being in the darkest Skies you've ever
been in on Earth and then some and that
in fact it's actually a little
disorientating because the just the
regular stars are all so bright that
it's really hard to orient yourself to
recognize the constellations because
just more and more stars are out there
and and you know if you've ever been in
really dark skies you've experienced a
version of this where there's so many
stars and they're all so bright you just
you actually can't find the obvious
constellations that you're very familiar
with but the Milky Way apparently does
look amazing and so like why are we not
seeing a lot of images of the Milky Way
taken from the space station so there a
couple of reasons one is that the space
station orbits around the Earth every 90
minutes and so it's in the Sun sunlight
and then it's in the shade of the earth
and it's in the sunlight it's in the
shade and so if you have cameras sitting
outside that are attempting to do
astrophotography they're going to for
time be in complete sunlight and they
don't like that and so you're going to
need to switch the cameras on switch the
cameras off and so on also a lot of the
cameras like the automated cameras that
are on board the International Space
Station are pointing down they're
looking at the Earth uh you know in some
cases they do actually get like a nice
view off to the horizon and you can see
the curvature of the earth and then you
can see the sunrise Over the Horizon and
things like that now there were a bunch
of automated cameras installed on the
space station and and there are still
some which take pictures in different
angles on a regular rate and a lot of
people made really cool timelapse videos
of the earth passing under the space
station you could see Aurora forming and
then it was in day and then it would go
into night and you could actually see
the Milky Way Rising above the limb of
the earth and then the other thing is
that when you do have an an astronomy
minded astronaut on board the station
they've got a bunch of cameras at their
disposal and Don ped is up there right
now and you know has talked quite a bit
about how he takes pictures from the
coua which is this cool observing room
on the space station and he has taken
just amazing pictures of the Milky Way
seen from the the space station when
it's in one of these shaded periods and
so hopefully you know Chad's been
putting up a whole bunch of really cool
images of the Milky Way seen from the
space station so it's just like most of
the time it's looking down at the Earth
during the day or there's images of the
astronauts inside the space station it
just has to be like an astronaut has to
decide that they're going to go look
through the couple of Point their camera
take images of the milkyway or the moon
or other things that are going on but
there are tons of those pictures and
even time-lapse videos of it if you want
to support the work we do at Universe
today consider joining our patreon club
your support lets us have a minimum of
ads and no sponsorship messages patrons
get no ads on university.com for Life
want the extra parts of the live stream
that aren't in this edited version you
can sign up for a special Patron only
podcast feed and get the overtime
segments as well as other special behind
the-scenes episodes including our
monthly Patron only question show thanks
to everyone who has already subscribed
and Welcome to our recent newcomers
Antoine David L berer Miguel Andrew
blakers Maxim abran and Blake join the
club at patreon.com Universe today I Arc
Sim in 5 billion years the sun will go
through a giant phase and expand around
the earth and the moon won't the Earth
and the moon get dragged so close to the
Sun by friction with the sun's gases
that they won't meaningful exist in 50
billion years so that 50 billion years
number was from a previous show where I
said what the time it would take for the
earth and the moon to tidy lock to each
other to become a true doubl locked
planet and so a good example of this is
Pluto and Sharon so in the case of Pluto
and Sharon Pluto is locked to Sharon and
Sharon is locked to Pluto they're both
gazing at each other as they orbit
around a common center of gravity
between the two of them and with the
Earth and the Moon the Moon has locked
to the Earth but the Earth has not
locked to the moon and so because of the
way the tital forces work and the
conservation of orbital momentum the
Earth's rotation speed is slowing down
and the Moon is moving farther away and
eventually the Earth will lock to the
moon but it'll take about 50 billion
years and I think I even said in the
question that you know it doesn't matter
because the sun will be dead by then and
so yeah around 5 to seven billion years
from now the sun will bloat up as a red
giant as it uses up all of the hydrogen
fuel in its core it'll become this red
giant it will consume Mercury it'll
consume Venus but astronomers aren't
entirely sure that it's going to
actually consume Earth and the moon and
this just goes back and forth uh you
know one week will report on Universe
today that someone's produced a paper
that says that the sun is going to
consume the Earth and then someone will
produce a different paper that says that
the Sun Won't consume the Earth and we
don't really know and the question comes
from the mass loss so as a star like the
sun a main sequence star gets into that
red giant phase
it starts to you know it bloats up and
then it Puffs out these outer layers and
then shrinks back down and loses some of
its mass and then it does it again and
then keeps going back and forth and each
time it sort of throws this shell of
material out into space and eventually
it ends up losing whatever mass that it
does and so the mass loss will cause the
Earth and the moon to change in their
orbital position and it might very well
be that you know that the Earth will
orbit a little more closely to the sun
the sun will bloat out and it will
actually get captured by that red giant
face or maybe it won't and so you know
this is one of those continuing
unfolding Mysteries and maybe we're just
going to have to wait 7 billion years to
find out what happens but whatever the
case the solar system will be
unrecognizable in 50 billion years from
that final day when the Earth has
finally tily locked to the moon or both
were long gone gobbled up by the sun
Kyle steward
had a random thought if you could orbit
right on the edge of an event horizon
and then have a long pole and put the
pole through the Event Horizon what
would happen so the question you're
asking is that if you were orbiting
around a black hole and you right at the
edge of the Event Horizon this place
where the escape velocity of the black
hole exceeds the speed of light and then
you took a pole and you put the pole
down into the Event Horizon what would
happen so
like obviously the first thing is like
what is the tensile strength of the pole
that you are using because it needs to
overcome just immense tidal
gravitational forces that are going to
tear it apart at an atomic level and no
matter what the pole is made of uh it is
going to be just just pulled apart and
you know you're not going to have a
you're not going to be able to bring
anything back up but I'm assuming that
you have created this out of some sort
of unobtainium something that cannot
that is so strong that it can never be
maybe it's made of black hole maybe it's
made of neutron star even tougher than
that it cannot be shredded by a black
hole's tital forces and so you kind of
then have to go back to the first rule
of of the Event Horizon that nothing not
even light can escape its grasp and so
there is no amount of force that you
could put onto that pole to try and pull
it back up that would allow it to escape
the pull of the black hole once you're
inside the Event Horizon all paths lead
to the singularity including the pull
now you know obviously it's going to
pull you in with it so um but there's
you can't break the rule which is you
can't get out of it even if you you know
and because the the pole strong enough
to handle the title forces or is
impossible uh that alone will make the
problem uh not work so even if you could
you can't get it out like it just it
won't it will it will be held fast
Graham goens when did the universe
become our universe in a greater
Universe well I mean we don't really
know what caused the universe but
essentially by the best measurements
that astronomers have been able to make
the observable universe that we find
ourselves in today has been around for
13.8 billion years and so right now we
look to the left of US 46 billion lter
away we look to the right of US 46
billion lter away and yet in the past
those regions were 20 billion years
apart light years apart and then at one
point they were you know just a few
hundred thousand kilometers apart and
then there was a time when it when the
entire observable universe everything we
could see was the size of a volleyball
and maybe smaller um maybe the size of a
p we don't know or maybe like a
singularity infinitely small but that
was just one component of the larger
universe and so you know if you had this
volleyball sized version of the universe
then right beside of it there was
another one and another one and so on
and so that like the question that
you're getting at is like what came
before right like what was the what was
the environment of the universe that
then we got our local version of space
starting to become less Den over time
and become the universe that we see
today and you know obviously you can
think well okay there was another
version of our our universe right beside
us you know and they're going through
the same thing that we are and then
there's the people that kind of split
the difference right the people who are
in between us and the universe beside us
and they've got their own sphere and
they're seeing a little bit of our
universe and a little bit of the next
universe and so it's thought that if the
universe is infinite today than it was
infinite before uh this dsif foration
started to to happen but like what set
this off in the first place and you know
we don't really know in fact we don't
know at all and anyone who tells you
doesn't know uh they're guessing or you
know someone told them or you know
they've got a theory but they don't have
any observational evidence to back it up
but probably the strongest Theory that's
going right now is this idea of
inflation that that there are problems
with the big bang in the flatness of the
universe the lack of magnetic monopoles
the way that parts of the universe
shouldn't have been able to um sort of
average out their temperature and yet
they you know they did and so this idea
of inflation that before we got just the
regular densification of the universe
there was this period that was sort of
incredibly short like fraction of a
second where the universe went through
this doubling in size and sort of one of
the interesting things about you know
the underlying requirements for this
idea of inflation is that it was going
across a larger volume of space and that
different parts of this universe were
inflating at different times and
different speeds it could very well be
that there's parts of the universe that
are still inflating today billions of
years later and other places where
inflation stopped before we did and that
in each one of these local areas of the
universe they potentially have their own
underlying laws of physics and you can
imagine you know each one is gone off
and inflating its own place and pushing
the other Universe Parts away from them
and we could never reach one of these
alternative universes so one possibility
is that just the entire universe is just
getting less ense over time one
possibility is that there's sort of this
larger landscape of universes within the
universe and they're sort of
experiencing different versions of
themselves and they're not going to
overlap so uh you know we don't know we
don't know is the is the answer and and
that's got to be fine like like you've
got to be okay with the possibility that
we may never know the answer to this
question a million years into the future
our descendants will go where did the
universe come from and the astronomers
will go I don't know we've looked for a
million years for any shred of evidence
that connects this universe to what came
before and we haven't been able to find
anything and so everything is still on
the table we still don't know and
hopefully in a billion years the
astronomers then will have a better
answer thanks everybody who asked your
questions in the YouTube comments and
everybody who joined me for the live
chat this was the first episode that we
did in European Time and so it was an
entirely new group of people that were
in the chat for the live show but still
we had almost the same number of people
for the regular Monday show that I do at
the normal time and so it was a huge
success we're definitely going to do
this again next up comes the Australian
Asian time zone now I'm going to talk a
little bit about my current video game
Obsession but first I'd like to thank
our patrons thanks to Abe Kingston Adam
schaer Andre gross barake Roofing David
Gilton and David mats Dennis alberty
Dustin cable James Clark Jeremy mam Jim
Burke Jordan young Josh ultz Paul Roach
spiders swap. and Steven fer monley who
support us at the master of the universe
level and all our patrons all your
support means the universe to
us so like many people out there I've
been playing Path of Exile too and you
might not know that I'm a Path of Exile
player but I sure am I've been playing
for about five or six years I'm at the
point now where I mostly play solo self
found I like to make my own builds I
like to try to get as far as I can into
the content on the last League I was
able to on my own build able to get all
my void stones for those of you who have
no idea what path of XL is that's fine
but for those of you who know uh that's
good um but I'm playing path of XL 2 and
uh so far my initial feeling has been
it's fantastic I love it it's exactly
what I wanted now I know a lot of people
think it's too hard a lot of people
think there's not enough loot I think
it's great I enjoy the suffering and the
sacrifice and learning and experiencing
a brand new game that I've just have
never tried before and sort of making my
own way as I go and it's exactly the
kind of experience that I really enjoy
so and I'm playing it all on the steam
deck I'm not playing it on a computer uh
just entirely on the steam deck which is
great because then I can hang it with my
wife parallel play uh while she's
watching TV so uh if you are on the
fence and you're wondering if it's a
good game it's got my seal of approval
and they're not paying me to tell you
that all right hopefully I will have
some spare time
to see you next week