Why are most craters circular, no matter which angle the meteor falls? Is there a size limit for a telescope before diminishing returns take place? Can black holes have atmospheres? Answering all these questions and more in this Q&A show.
00:00 Start 00:24 How big can a telescope get? 05:12 Does an optical telescope on the Moon make any sense? 08:13 Can black holes have atmospheres? 11:05 Why are craters circular not elliptical? 12:41 Will Starship refuel in orbit in 2025? 12:52 Is there evidence for primordial black holes?
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
[Music]
why are craters of the Moon always round
are there limits to the maximum size of
a telescope and can black holes have
atmospheres all these questions and more
in the question show it's time for the
question show your questions my answers
as always wherever you are across my
channel if a question Pops in your brain
just write it down I'll gather them up
and I will answer them here all right
let's get into the questions restoration
Shaman how big can a telescope get
before diminishing returns four a
groundbased telescope uh you have a
bunch of issues that are going to start
causing you problems with the size of
your telescope it's going to give you
diminishing returns so the the first
thing is the atmosphere which is that
until a couple of decades ago there was
really a limit to the size that you
could use a telescope for because at a
certain point the atmosphere causes so
much Distortion to the images that
you're trying to capture that there's no
value in attempting to do a longer
exposure it's just going to all turn
into mush with the atmospheric
Distortion and then they developed this
technology called Adaptive Optics that
essentially reverses the atmospheric
Distortion and and it acts like a ground
you know it's as if a groundbased
telescope is in space and so a lot of
those problems have gone away and so now
telescopes can just get bigger and
bigger and bigger and we're seeing the
development of the upcoming um 39 M
extremely large telescope from the
European Southern Observatory and people
had proposals for building 100 meter
telescopes so there's you know there's
kind of no limit for optic size on the
ground but you do start to run into
gravity and so at a certain point the
just the pull of gravity on the super
structure of the telescope just becomes
such a pain you're having to build more
and more telescope to support the thing
and about 100 m is sort of the largest
feasible telescope that you can build on
the surface of the Earth for a
reasonable budget you know5 billion and
then beyond that the thing is going to
start just getting too difficult to to
Wrangle and also there are issues that
you can solve with a smaller telescope
like with Adaptive Optics but once you
hit a certain size then you know you've
got temperature changes you've got all
of these issues and and the you know the
the metal is changing based on the
amount of heat in the inside of the
building and so on and it's really hard
to compensate over large scale so I
would say you know beyond 100 m you
start to get diminishing returns for
sure once you go to space though uh a
lot of those issues disappear you no
longer have the atmosphere and so the
size of your telescope can just get as
big as it wants to be you do have
temperature changes so those are going
to start to become an issue but you can
adapt to them uh you can have telescopes
that are made of multiple segments and
so the multiple segments can move and
change and adapt depending on like like
there is a role for Adaptive Optics in
space
for this for dealing with temperature
changes as parts of it are being hit by
the Light of the sun even if it's behind
a sun shield and you're going to want to
be able to to adapt your telescope shape
to be able to handle that um but you
could just go big like you could go 100
meters 1,000 meters kilometers across
and you would still have value for your
telescope now you would
eventually start to have a problem where
the like you know people always talk
about this idea of interferometers if
you take two telescopes you separate
them a certain distance apart then the
telescopes act like the separation
between the two telescopes and as long
as you can align them down to the
nanometer but you you know down to the
wavelengths of the light and they're
collecting the same wavelengths then you
can use that Baseline that difference
between those those telescopes but I
think that most people don't realize is
that any telescope is actually an
interferometer that if you have a single
telescope mirror and you've got you know
one side of the telescope is collecting
photons and the other side is collecting
photons you get the size of your
telescope mirror because you're able to
have them be arriving at the telescope
at the at the same wavelength but once
your telescope gets too big then you may
get to a situation where photons are not
arriving at the same wavelength on both
sides of the telescope and now it is
kind of no longer in phase and so you're
going to have some issues as your
telescope gets too big but but I mean
practically we are talking huge now for
personal telescopes uh the rule is
always just uh you know spend as much
money as you can afford right that that
you will reach no practical limit when
you try to buy a telescope you want to
get as much aperture as you can afford
if you can afford a 10-in telescope buy
a 10-in telescope you can afford a 12-in
telescope buy 12-in telescope that
aperture is the most important thing now
that's not entirely true because you
know portability is an issue if you get
a 20in telescope then you're not going
to have anywhere to put it inside your
house you're going to have a hard time
moving it outside the house you may have
to keep it in a barn but you're going to
love the Optics from a telescope that
big LL are there any benefits to
building an optical telescope on the
moon there are some benefits to building
a telescope on the moon um there are a
lot of downsides like you're trying to
put your telescope on the moon and the
Moon is very far and it is very
expensive to put things onto the moon
well you know it might cost you $3,000 a
kilogram to launch a mission into low
earth orbit you're looking at millions
of dollars to put a kilogram down onto
the surface of the Moon but hopefully
over time with more missions it'll the
cost will come down in price the Moon is
really good as a place for a radio
telescope because you have no atmosphere
you can be on The Far Side of the Moon
and so the moon itself is blocking all
of the radio waves that are coming from
the Earth all of our Earthly
Transmissions are being blocked and so
the moon will be radio quiet and then
you can say put a giant Observatory a
radio telescope into a crater and follow
the the curvature of the crater to be
able to now have this enormous telescope
that's accessing the the universe and so
a radio telescope is one idea that is
considered but there are some really
great ideas for putting an optical
telescope on the moon and these ideas
have been around for a long time um when
James web was first designed back in the
'90s uh the ideas went back and forth
was you know are we going to build a big
Space Telescope or maybe we're going to
build a telescope and put it on the moon
and then eventually they settled on the
current format for James web that we see
today and so one of the things that's
really interesting about the Moon is
that you can put an interferometer on
the moon that's where you have multiple
telescopes that are uh separated by
distance and then they can work like a
telescope that is the size of the
distance between those telescopes and on
Earth you have to deal with the
atmospheric Haze it's really hard to
line things up to build this
interferometer space based
interferometers are in the works and
people will eventually build these
things and you you need a way to be able
to maintain the distance of your your
separate telescopes as they're free
floating in space but on the moon it's
sort of the best of all worlds which is
that you don't have an atmosphere and so
you can can set up your telescope you
don't need to build a complicated
Adaptive Optics system and then you can
move your other telescope some distance
away from the first one and then you can
line them up with a laser to get them
perfectly in tune and you can build an
interferometer on this stable base of
operations the Moon is mostly
geologically stable you're not going to
get a lot of issues they're going to
change flexing Tides things like that
and so you can separate these optical
telescopes on the moon both them into a
foundation and that is sort of
considered to be one of the easier
cheapest ways that you can get an
optical interferometer functioning um
but you've got you got to get to the
moon first and that's going to be the
challenge okay Charles chap Pockets
could a black hole have an
atmosphere sort of um like when you
think about an atmosphere around the
earth the atmosphere is this layer of
gas that surrounds planet Earth and it
is held down by the gravity but the
pressure of this gas and the temperature
of it stops it from turning into a
liquid or a solid it wants to remain a
gas and so you get this shape of the
atmosphere this density and thickness of
the atmosphere because of the Earth's
gravity but also the chemical
characteristics of the gas the sun is
another good example the sun has an
atmosphere you have particles that are
whizzing around the Sun and even though
the sun has an enormous amount of
gravity that is pulling material into it
uh also those particles have a lot of
energy velocity and so they are held out
away from the Sun and they can form this
atmosphere around the Sun and in fact
the the corona like when you see an
eclipse and when the moon passes
perfectly in front of the sun you can
see these cool kind of petals that are
around the sun and that is the sun's
atmosphere and so a black hole will have
a Corona it will have material that is
surrounding the black hole
um and a lot of times you know when a
black hole is is actively feeding it
can't eat an entire planet star whatever
it actually breaks it up and tears it
into this accretion disc that surrounds
the black hole and whirls around it and
then these magnetic field lines s
spinning around the black hole that are
then sort of channeling material into
these jets that go out of the North and
South Pole of the black hole but you
also get all of this hot gas that is
surrounding ing the area that's glowing
in the x-rays and this is how
astronomers find black holes in some
cases is they can see this this
essentially atmosphere this cloud of
plasma that is surrounding the black
hole in its environment caused by the
intense magnetic field the energetic
particles around it that are blazing in
x-ray radiation and so you know it
wouldn't be a breathable atmosphere but
there's definitely a cloud of Highly
charged plasma around a black hole
if you want to support the work we do at
Universe today consider joining our
patreon club your support lets us have a
minimum of ads and no sponsorship
messages patrons get no ads on
university.com for life you want the
extra parts of the live stream that
aren't in this edited version you can
sign up for a special Patron only
podcast feed and get the overtime
segments as well as other special behind
the- scenes episodes including our
monthly Patron only question show thanks
to everyone who's already subscribed and
Welcome to our recent newcomers sarv
Marg B Scott Peter Paul Mackin and
Sheldon heightman join the club at
patreon.com
universetoday Mr Man are all crators
circular why don't meteors striking at
an angle make elliptical craters yeah if
you look at the craters on the moon they
are all circles and you would expect
that the uh the objects are coming in at
a variety of different angles so why are
they all these nice perfect circles and
that is because what happens is that
when an object comes in and hits the
moon at any angle
as soon as it hits the moon the kinetic
energy of the object the impactor is
turned into energy it essentially it
vaporizes it's like a bomb that goes off
on the surface of the Moon and then it
creates this almost like a mushroom
cloud in that spot that you know the
energy goes straight down gouges out
this big chunk of the Moon and you get
this splashback of material you get this
ejectable blanket that comes out of the
crater and it doesn't really matter the
angle the that you know as the object is
coming in at any angle as soon as it
touches and it it explodes and that's
what creates the crater not the impact
but there are some examples of of things
that hit at such a low angle that they
actually do create a bit of a smear of a
crater and so there's a couple of
examples where they must have come in at
like I don't know 89° 89.5 de like a
really low angle very shallow angle and
you actually do get a bit of a smear of
a crater you also get examples where
things have broken up and you can see
like a shotgun like a line of craters
that have all sort of lined up TJ will
Starship successfully refuel in orbit in
2025 podcast listeners I made it I don't
know face Casey ree is there a consensus
on How likely it is that these
primordial black holes actually exist
there is no consensus so we're at the
place where uh scientists have proposed
that conditions in the early Universe
were dense enough and that you had these
regions of overdensity and underdensity
that were so different that you could
have black holes just forming in situ
just right there in the early universe
and then those could be any size you
don't need the process of a collapsing
star to form a black hole you just get
any size of black hole from something
that is the mass of of a like I said a
house an asteroid a star a billion times
the mass of the Sun you could have all
of this stuff forming right there in the
beginning of the universe and then one
of the proposed ideas that this could be
an explanation for dark matter but the
problem is that there should be some
evidence for these primordial black
holes because as they pass in front of
stars they would be warping The
Starlight and you would detect this micr
lensing event and You' you would be able
to see you know if they're 10 times the
mass of the Milky Way is made up of
black holes then there's a certain Mass
regime where so many of these are going
to be out there that they would be
easily detectable by watching as stars
are flickering as black holes are
passing in front of them and astronomers
don't see that astronomers have done
surveys to look for these black holes
that are out there in vast numbers and
so they've been able to rule out various
Mass ranges for primordial black holes
now you're left with some Mass ranges
that are that are either like a thousand
times the mass of the Sun or more
because they would be very rare like you
would event you know occasionally see
one of these pass in front of a star but
there wouldn't be a lot of them if you
added up these thousand times the mass
of the Sun versions then you could come
up with dark matter or they could be
much lighter they could be more like the
mass of an asteroid and then you
wouldn't detect their microlensing
events as they were passing but there'd
be a lot more of them out there and so
astronomers are continuing to come up
with ways that you could check to see if
these primordial black holes are out
there and there's been other ideas like
you know there could be a black hole
that is orbiting around the solar system
and there is no planet nine there's
actually a black hole which you know I
don't think very many people think is is
a legitimate uh possibility um or you
could have black coals that are trapped
inside of planets and they're causing
excess heat in the planet that could be
detectable so you know I think that if
you ask most astrophysicists and people
who research dark matter and you say Do
you think that dark matter is made of
black holes they'll say no no probably
it is probably not the most likely
explanation for dark matter and then if
you say well can you rule it out they'll
say no
they can't right which is fine you know
like that's that's how science works is
that there's going to be ideas that are
uh not the one that is supported by the
vast majority of the evidence but is
still there and it's not been ruled out
yet and that's awesome that's totally
fine you just wait you just wait for the
evidence before you make up your mind
and I think like a lot of people okay
this is about to turn into a rant so
buckle up but um
I think that you know a a lot of
people want some kind of certainty about
things that we see in the universe what
is dark matter what is AR energy why are
we alone in the universe and they and
and they want that certainty so bad the
most extreme version of that is where
people think that UFOs are aliens right
they're like I saw light in the sky I
don't know what it is therefore aliens
Case Closed Italians and if you don't
believe that Italians you're a bad
person and you're part of the cover up
right like you have to be okay to be in
this space where you are uncertain about
the answer and about the outcome and
that you were just enjoying the process
of watching the evidence build watching
as new ideas new research proposals New
Missions are launched which are going to
attempt another crack at this problem
and I think like the example the classic
example the one that that I find most
frustrating but also kind of hilarious
is when people roll their eyes and go
dark matter LOL that's ridiculous
scientists just came up with this thing
so they could make their equations work
and like anybody who says that like tell
me you don't understand the search for
dark matter without telling me you don't
understand the search for dark matter
right which is like that that it is this
series of observations these careful
observations that have made over time
that have built this
growing understanding that the universe
is not as we perceive it um and that
nobody ordered this nobody asked for
this and yet this is the uncomfortable
truth and that and that whenever you
have find these things that are
surprising and shocking and not expected
and so on then the resolution is not
going to come quickly it's going to take
its time and so with dark matter with
primordial black holes
with why there's more matter than
antimatter in the universe uh what is
dark energy uh how did galaxies form so
quickly uh what was here before the
universe these are Big questions and uh
we may not find out the answer in our
lifetimes but we will enjoy the journey
and if you're not entertained by the
journey then science might not be for
you all right those are all the
questions that we had in this episode
thank everybody who asked your questions
both in the YouTube comments as well as
everybody who showed up for the live
show and the live show is two hours long
and is many many more questions so uh
there will be a notification for when
the next live show is but usually it's
on Mondays at 5:00 p.m. somewhere in the
world all right I'm going to talk about
a new feature that we've added but first
I'd like to thank our patrons a special
thanks to Abe Kingston Adam Schaefer
andream gross be Lake Roofing David
Gilton and David mats Dennis leie Dustin
cable James Clark Jeremy Madden Jim
Burke Jordan young Josh Schultz PA
robach Sean Sergeant spiders swap.
Steven fer menley Thomas El scadron and
Vlad sh who support us at the master of
the universe level and all our patrons
all your support means the universe to
us as you probably know we record the
Live question show it's two hours long
and what we then do is go through and
edit out and find a bunch of the
questions that are going to serve for
the two question shows that we publish
here on the channel and that adds up to
about 40 minutes so two episodes that
are 20 minutes long and then you're left
with all of the other material and we
call that overtime previously we had
just been editing together that overtime
segment and making that available to the
patrons as a podcast and I'm not sure
why Anton did this but now he's got a
little more time on his hands or
something and he decided to make it a
video and then even put b-roll and do
some nice edits and Transitions and so
when you go on to our patreon Channel
and you want to be able to watch the
overtime segments it is another video
now that you can subscribe to but you do
have to be a patron to be able to get
access to that but whatever is the
minimum amount you want you can get
access to the additional it's about 40
minutes long Patron overtime segment
from the question show all right we're
continuing to add more features to all
of our offerings so I'll keep you posted
we'll see you next time