After the Fall: The Conservation of Tullio Lombardo's Adam

Fine Art Conservation
153 followers
6 Video Views·May 14, 2025
Conservators, scientists, and curators tell the story behind the unprecedented conservation of Tullio Lombardo's "Adam."
It was a Monday morning, and I got to work, and I got a phone call from Jack Sultanian,
and he said, can you come to the Blumenthal patio? There's been an incident.
He sounded very serious, so of course I went upstairs, and I saw the sculpture and pieces all over the floor.
He was on a plywood pedestal, and that
collapsed. It buckled underneath the weight of the sculpture.
For a piece, you know, that important to be damaged was something catastrophic.
Really high quality Renaissance sculpture outside of Italy is not common. This was an iconic piece
in being one of the earliest nudes, going back to inspiration from antiquity.
I think there's a purification of form going on here that makes it even exceptional in
Renaissance depictions of Adam overall. There's this forthright and yet dreamy quality about
the tulio that set it apart. The reaction is to document everything as it is, just like
you would on a crime scene. We immediately began plotting out a grid on the floor,
and then we went and took a picture of every single square. After that, we began to pick up
pieces. He's in about 28 major fragments, but there are hundreds of very small fragments,
and it was all saved. Then there was just a period of pausing and trying to come up with
a general plan of what to do. I proposed that we may be able to utilize three-dimensional imaging
if we scanned the object. We could create a virtual reconstruction and hopefully move on to
finite element analysis of the piece. You're taking a structure and you're basically turning
it into a 3D jigsaw puzzle, the difference being that all the pieces in that puzzle are glued
together. You're analyzing what's happening with each individual piece and then determining how
that pertains to the entire structure, because all the pieces are connected together. The color
distributions that you see are graphical representations of stress distribution or
displacement. If we were to be asked, look, you have to put this together next month, we would
have done what we've always done before. We would have drilled holes in every joint, used stainless
steel pins, rather large and long, to put this sculpture back together and use very strong
adhesives. But we wanted to say, can we step back from those materials? We have a class of acrylic
adhesives that we use commonly in conservation that are reversible. They've never really been
tested adequately for the kind of stress that the fragments of the atom would be under when they
were rejoined. So this is about an engineering and material science approach that includes mechanical
testing, computer science. What arose out of that work was the fact that these reversible adhesives
are strong enough to carry some of the big joints on this sculpture all by themselves.
Stones and all materials have a different strength, and they have a different stiffness.
And there are pinning materials that have similarly different stiffnesses. And as we assessed
different pinning materials, we came to a material which needed to be stressed very, very highly to
fail. But when it failed, the pin failed without damage to the stone. And that pin turned out to
be fiberglass. We sort of from the beginning felt that the ankles, because of the stress on them,
basically had the whole weight of the sculpture on a relatively small surface area,
that they were going to require some pinning. We ultimately wound up
showing it only in one other area, which was this fragment in one of the knees, which was an area
where the angle of stress really shifted very quickly, and where there was a small fragment
at the knee, which lessened the stability of that joint and had to be dealt with. The breaks on the
sculpture were so fresh, we wanted to minimize the amount of times we put the pieces together,
took them apart, moved things around. We sort of collectively came up with this idea, like wouldn't
it be great if we had another sculpture? And of course, we weren't just going to break any
sculpture, a work of art, so we thought that we could get some kind of reproduction. There was a
very ugly marble statue of David. We broke that David along the fracture lines of Adam.
And we used that to plan our armature. It was a full-scale, copy-made, CNC-milled piece of
each and every piece of Adam. We then applied those concepts to the milled version. Those
carbon fiber straps could be taken off the model and used directly on the sculpture.
We're starting at the ankles, and we glued the two ankles, and then we stacked everything up
just for the ankles, so we knew that everything was in line. And then we slowly worked our way
from the bottom up, joining the legs to the torso. We were aligning two places, all very rigid.
Michael was on one leg, I was on the other, and we became very familiar with our particular joint.
When you're just going stone to stone, things kind of lock together in a very nice, satisfying way.
When you put the adhesive in there, things kind of move around. It's like having ball
bearings in the joint, and you really need to let that adhesive kind of ooze out to create
a very consistent film. After years of seeing, you know, as fragments,
to have the head on and actually have it be a complete form, it was quite an amazing moment.
Congratulations, Michael. Luckily, the major fragments fit together very well,
but in other areas, particularly in the arms and hands, there was considerable damage.
In terms of the aesthetic presentation of the sculpture, it's going to be
those small fills that are going to be the most critical aspect.
Over the years, dirt had accumulated on the sculpture. It was cleaned before filling any
of the losses. You work on different areas of the sculpture simultaneously. The main philosophy is
to have an even surface. When it comes to putting on fills or retouching something,
we always use reversible materials. We tried to get everything we could out of this horrible
accident. I think in the end, he will be back to where he was. So is that the same or not?
That's for everybody else to decide, but I think that the spirit of the sculpture and
the true beauty of it is still there.
