Physicist Avshalom Elitzur faces the existential problems posed by consciousness, and blesses a baby.
Consciousness is widely seen as an impossible problem for materialism. Furthermore, the phenomenon of consciousness disobeys the laws of physics. Join physicist and philosopher, Avshalom C. Elitzur as he makes a radical new proposal about the relationship between consciousness and material reality.
Avshalom C. Elitzur is a Professor in the Centre for Quantum Studies at Chapman University in the United States. He is best known for his work on the Elitzur–Vaidman bomb-testing problem in quantum mechanics.
00:00 Introduction 00:12 Physics leaves no room for consciousness 02:25 Romeo's love has no impact on his behaviour 03:52 When does fear become real? 05:19 Where, in evolution, does consciousness begin? 07:02 Philosophical explanations of consciousness reviewed 09:12 Avshalom blesses a baby 09:45 Non-interactionist dualism, epiphenomenalism, parallelism 12:42 Pan-psychism 13:34 The consciousness inessentialism postulate
We would do exactly the same thing had there been no consciousness in our mind.
My dear Oscar, how are you?
We, I know about myself, we believe we have conscious experience, each of us is sure that
they have conscious experience, and we assume that the other has also.
But science cannot give us any certainty about that, because if you are talking about a mechanism,
nothing can help you with that, and let me give you a few examples.
Here I'm a physicist, so here are billiard balls, and I'm analyzing their behavior.
So all I need to calculate it is the laws of mechanics.
There is no place for the experience of the balls, say,
feeling pain and then repelling from one another.
This is absolute nonsense.
But it is not only that I don't need it for the calculation.
If I take it into account, I'll get the wrong answer.
The physical world is completely full of energy, momentum, matter.
There are conservation laws.
There is no room for anything like that.
It's only the laws of mechanics.
I come home and I see that one of my pots, the plant, is almost dry, and I say,
oh my goodness, it needs to have water.
So I water it, and then I can see the turgor pressure within the leaves, and I say, it was 30.
No, it was not.
And this is all just physics.
Not different than the billiard balls, just much, much more complicated.
So there are laws, and people here who know some physiology know what happens.
There is water outside.
There is water with saline or sugar inside.
And there is osmosis and so on.
We don't have to go into the details.
Once again, I don't have the precise calculation of the billiard balls.
But if I have a computer, strong enough, which computes it,
then of course I can't put into it anything like the thirst of the plant,
because I will get a wrong result.
Less water, more water.
Our world is very tight.
And when I go to the doctor and he just examines my patella reflex, that's the same thing.
My consciousness is not needed for that.
Although I am conscious of being hit by the hammer.
And replying with a kick.
Now you know what goes at the end of this scale?
Here is Romeo singing love songs to Juliet.
And what science tells you is that if conservation laws are correct,
and if psychology is reducible to biology, which people believe it is,
and biology is reducible to chemistry and physics, then it's just the same.
The fact that Romeo has the conscious experience of loving Juliet
has nothing to do with what he and she are doing.
According to another great British giant, Charles Darwin, and the evolutionary theory,
actually what we do has been shaped by evolution, procreation, and so on.
We would do exactly the same thing had there been no consciousness in our mind.
Just brains.
I know it sounds really strange, but here it is.
Machines, computers, do what we do, and sometimes even better than us,
in some functions which are called mental, and they keep advancing.
We don't have to assume that there is anything conscious there,
that there is any subjective experience of red and blue.
There doesn't have to be anything like that.
Only the process.
So here is the problem.
The laws of mechanics completely explain the motions of billiard balls, plants, and even us.
Just to make my point clear from another perspective,
when I was in the bathroom, I washed my hands with some detergent, with soap.
So I say that the detergent molecule is hydrophobic in that it is repelled of water.
Now, come on, there is no real phobia there.
There is no fear.
It's just electric interactions.
Now, here, this unicellular creature is photophobic, right?
If I shed light on it, it swims away.
I don't need any fear.
I don't need to invoke any fear.
Just you have this flagella.
When light hits them, they move, and then you get the net motion away from light.
What about this guy?
Now, he or she, it, I don't know, shows some fear from me.
I can say that there is no real fear there.
This is only just the mechanism.
But you understand, I think it was Bertrand Russell who said,
a person who was not a communist in his youth has no heart.
A person who has not ceased to be a communist has no brain.
So here, I either have no heart or have no brain,
because I don't know where to go to the extremities.
If I say that this lobster, which is going to pinch me,
is not afraid of me, and it is only the sum of its reflexes,
what about this case?
Here is a human.
Between it, there is my cat.
There is the chicken in my garden.
Where along evolution do I talk about consciousness rather than physical events?
This may happen to you if you don't have too many cockroaches at your home.
If you have too many, then it won't happen to you.
If you don't have, it won't happen either.
But if you have a few cockroaches every few weeks,
you may understand what happened to me one day.
I saw a cockroach in my saloon.
I didn't like the idea, so I went to this cockroach
to do what humans usually do to cockroaches
with whom they don't want to share their home.
That cockroach didn't really like my plans about his or her future,
and it climbed on a chair.
Of course, I was not going to give up,
so I picked up the chair, looked.
It was not there.
I turned it around.
It was not there.
Come on, it was there a minute ago,
so perhaps it went to the other side.
I flipped, I turned it around.
I didn't see it, and then I turned it around carefully and slowly,
and then I saw the cockroach carefully and slowly moving to the other side.
Now you can imagine how silly I felt at that time,
and a person standing there with that creature on the chair,
and I'm thinking,
does he, does she have real fear,
or is it only reflexes?
If I say that it has fear,
I can go to the detergent molecule or to that unicellular organism.
If I say that there is no fear,
what would I say about a human?
I didn't solve the problem that evening.
I just walked out, placed the chair,
and said, do me a favor, go away.
But the mystery is still there.
So philosophers have invoked all kinds of isms in order to explain it.
I'll review them very briefly.
So we all know physicalism.
There were some eminent British philosophers who argued this way.
There is no consciousness.
It's some illusion.
You think that there is something unique to it because it's very complex,
but actually what you have in the universe is only physical laws,
matter, energy, and that's it,
with relativity, quantum mechanics,
but there is nothing other than the material world.
This is what our forefathers believed in, our ancestors.
There is dualism.
There is matter.
There is mind.
Something comes from God.
We have a soul which goes into the matter,
and this is the source of the mystery.
Now, the worst case here is interactionist dualism,
which all philosophers and especially physicists like me abhor,
which say that there is actually something non-physical
which interferes in what we do.
This is what religion believes.
This is what, I mean, even the person in the street believes.
There is something which is distinct from the body which interferes with it.
From the physical viewpoint, it is an anathema
because that means that conservation laws are somehow wrong.
Think again, and you can pause for a minute to think about it.
Think again about the billiard balls.
The billiard balls, if anything interferes with their motions,
you will get a different result in the lab, and we never get it.
What's the difference between billiard balls and brains?
As far as we know, it's just a matter of complexity,
but it's the same laws.
They can be, even when quantum mechanics comes into the picture,
they can turn into something statistical,
but conservation laws are always obeyed.
So this is what most physicists fear most, interactionist dualism.
The majority of philosophers, and the most genius among them,
tried all kinds of non-interactionist dualism.
They didn't want to be as silly.
How is Oscar?
Can I say him for a minute?
My dear Oscar, how are you?
Here you see the pristine consciousness of somebody with the greatest mystery.
And as we say in Hebrew,
have a happy new year.
Bye-bye.
There is a mystery there, okay?
And it's great.
So non-interactionist dualism.
This is what people like Bertrand Russell and others believe.
There is another aspect of matter which is distant from the matter,
but it's just the same.
You can ignore it because there is nothing which is immaterial
which goes and interferes with what we are doing.
So let me give you a few examples.
And you can't help admiring the genius of these people.
I'm coming back to Leibniz.
Epiphenomenalism.
In German, it's called Stettentheorie, the theory of the shadow.
And it goes something like this.
I'm walking and my shadow is walking next to me.
Whatever I do, my shadow is doing.
Who is affecting whom?
Or in order to use Leibniz's example,
there are two clocks, one big, one large,
and they show exactly the same hour.
So I may think that it's one clock which affects the other
or the other which affects the first.
And we understand that it's wrong.
One watchmaker just made the two clocks
and from now on they are in parallel.
So suppose Oscar is thirsty and he cries
and daddy gives him something to drink.
So there are two clocks going on here.
The physiological one, which is the process of being thirsty,
kidneys, throat, and so on, and brain, and so on.
And the mental one, being thirsty,
having the experience of drinking something,
being happy, and so on.
Leibniz said we have two parallel worlds.
We just have the illusion that they affect one another.
And of course, he was a deist.
He believed in God.
So for him, it was not a problem.
I think that it's genius, but it doesn't help us much.
No, actually, sorry, I was confusing.
Sorry, this is parallelism.
Matter and mind run parallel to one another.
So this is Leibniz.
Others proposed epiphenomenalism that said
only one thing affects the other.
Somehow my brain gives rise to my consciousness,
but my consciousness never interferes with my brain, okay?
So sorry for the confusion.
Parallelism says that there are two worlds
which do not interact with one another.
Epiphenomenalism says there are two worlds.
One of them affects the other
without somehow violating the conservation laws,
but the other is not affecting the first.
And this is how we have this mystery.
There is something mysterious,
but we don't have to fear for conservation laws,
and we don't have to worry about physics.
And then there is identity theory,
which actually is so dumb that I have no time.
They say that there are the same,
sorry for saying that,
but they say that there are the same,
but we think they are different.
It should be, come back to physicalism,
but they admit that there are two sides of it.
And yeah, and there is one which I like.
I don't have much time to it,
and it says something very radical.
It says, here's your problem.
You have studied physics, chemistry, biology,
and neurophysiology.
You went up at the scale of complexity,
and then you came to the brain,
and you say, ah, there is something mysterious there.
There is consciousness,
and I can't understand how the working of the brain,
with the more and more details
that I work and understand the brain,
I still can't understand
why there are conscious experiences.
Perhaps you neglected something
from the very beginning.
Perhaps there is something in matter itself.
Any grain of sand, in any rock,
in any drop of water, in any molecule,
in any particle,
that there is something mysterious
that you don't understand,
and then when they become very complex,
they give rise to consciousness.
Here is your mystery.
I admit that I like this one.
But here is now my question,
and here I come to what I believe
to be my original contribution to the debate.
I didn't solve the problem.
I believe I made it much worse.
So here it is.
All of them are non-interactionist dualism.
Common to all of them
is the consciousness in essentialism postulate, okay?
For every action which looks like a consequence of a quail,
yeah, I forgot to say what a quail is.
Red, the subjective experience of red is a quail.
So science is talking about quanta
in consciousness has to do with qualia,
the quality of red versus blue versus yellow,
or the quality of sweet versus salty and so on,
which are distinct from the structure,
from the process of seeing red or tasting it.
So the problem is with qualia,
and here goes the postulate.
For every action which looks like
the consequence of some quail,
there is a neurophysiological explanation
which ignores qualia altogether.
So I still say that Romeo kisses Juliet
because he loves her.
Actually, it is a shorter way to say
that Romeo kisses Juliet due to very ancient instincts
and having to do with his education and so on,
which is a consequence of earlier physical causes.
So this is what is common to all these theories,
which I think are ingenious,
but it kills actually what is the most essential part
in our lives, and this is the qualia,
the quail, the subjective experience.
To continue watching this video,
click the link in the top left
or in the description below,
or visit iai.tv for more debates and talks
from the world's leading thinkers
on today's biggest ideas.