The ‘Infantry Revolution’ of the late Middle Ages is kind of a hot topic among armchair historians and academics alike. This is how the argument goes: In the late Middle Ages, infantry grew in importance to the detriment of heavy cavalry; by then battles were increasingly won with pikes, longbows and arquebuses instead of mounted knights with lances., the argument continues, and as a result of that, the socio-political make-up and development of European polities changed lastingly. So, this infantry Revolution supposedly had an incredible impact on European state building processes AND, the argument finally concludes, it laid the foundation to Europe’s conquest and colonization of many parts of the world. However, in public spaces such as YouTube this whole debate is more discussed in regards to tactics and fighting techniques than economics and politics. Consequently, much of the public discussion is about how and if the importance of knights changed after the high medieval ages. Likewise, Topics such as the efficacy of the English Longbow or the impact of pikes in the late Middle Ages are frequently the subject of discussions. All of that is controversial to say the least but it gets worse: these changes must be viewed in the broader military changes such as the rise of gunpowder artillery between 1420 and 1530 is called an artillery revolution, the decline of sieges between the 1420s and the 1530s which, among many things, led to the resurgence of heavy cavalry in the later late middle ages. Lastly, all of these revolutions belong to a notion called ‘military revolution’. This video is not intended to argue one side or the other of the ‘infantry revolution’ but to provide a broad overview over both the debate and the military changes during the 14th and 15th centuries. It explains how contemporary historiography quarrels over the infantry revolution.
The infantry revolution of the late middle ages is kind of a hot topic among
armchair historians and academics alike. This is how the argument goes.
In the late middle ages infantry grew in importance to the detriment of heavy cavalry.
By then battles were increasingly won with pikes, longbows and arquebuses instead of
mounted knights with lances. This radically changed the way armies were structured,
the argument continues, and as a result of that the socio-political makeup and development of
European policies changed lastingly. So, this infantry revolution supposedly had an incredible
impact on European state-building processes and, the argument finally concludes, it laid
the foundation of Europe's conquest and colonization of many parts of the world.
However, in public spaces such as YouTube, this whole debate seems to be more discussed
in regards to tactics and fighting techniques than economics and politics. Consequently,
much of the public discussion is about how and if the importance of knights changed after the
high medieval ages. Likewise, topics such as the efficacy of the English longbow or the impact
of pikes in the late middle ages are frequently the subject of discussions. All of that is
controversial to say the least, but it gets worse. These changes must be viewed in the broader
military changes such as the rise of gunpowder artillery between the 1420s and the 1530s,
which is called artillery revolution. The decline of sieges between the 1420s and the 1530s,
which among many things led to the resurgence of heavy cavalry in the later, late middle ages.
Lastly, all of these revolutions belong to a notion called military revolution.
This video is not intended to argue one side or the other of the infantry revolution,
but to provide a broad overview over both the debates and the military changes during the 14th
and the 15th centuries. It explains how contemporary historiography quarrels over
the infantry revolution. The Belgian historian Jan Frans Verbroeken characterizes what the
traditional academic view was, quote, Medieval warfare in Europe was characterized by the
dominant role of heavy cavalry, end quote. Today, this statement is controversial among medievalists.
Many historians have pointed to battles such as Dinsche Pre in 1106, Bouvines in 1214,
Dunbar in 1214 or Falkirk in 1298, where infantry supposedly played an important role.
Other historians, such as Clifford J. Rochers, point to the same battles, saying that they were
actually decided by a cavalry charge. So, the whole debate seems to be quite contradictory.
Today, scholars like Rochers restrict the infantry revolution usually to the 14th and
15th century in Central and Western Europe. So, pointing to the Thirty Years' War or the
winged Hussars, as we've seen quite often, would be misleading. With that said, we will guide you
through the main arguments. Let's start at the beginning.
Like so many historiographical disputes, the infantry revolution goes back to the 19th century.
In our case, it's the famous military historian Hans Delbrück, who in a nutshell asserted that
medieval knights usually charged each other and then dueled in pairs, while the infantry
was basically useless. In all fairness, the medieval sources overemphasized the role of knights
and Delbrück was one of the first to make such a large-scale study on military history.
Basically, Delbrück simply followed the medieval sources and then came to the conclusion that
battles had no tactical thought to them. Delbrück's blind trust in the medieval
sources may look naive nowadays, but it is important to remember that historians at the
time saw the Middle Ages as a backward period between classical antiquity and the modern world.
This view was influenced by arguably the most important intellectual movement of modernity,
the Enlightenment. We nowadays have, of course, a much more refined and balanced view of the Middle
Ages. Here historians like Jan Franz Verbrucken come in. He pointed out that warfare in the
Middle Ages was not chaotic. Heavy cavalry, for example, operated in small, coordinated contingents
and regularly bested larger forces. These kinds of engagement required close-order formation if
they wanted to break through enemy infantry lines. Such cavalry formations were coordinated by horn
signals and at least from the 12th century onwards by flags and banners.
According to Verbrucken, such combat maneuvers were relatively basic. They mostly consisted of
charges, regrouping or fake retreats. However, none of this is as easy as it sounds and needs
to be planned, exercised and finally executed with precision. The German historian Volker
Schmidhin explains that all these things were actually drilled in knightly tournaments.
In the early days these were the so-called Buchurts, in which knights would fight each
other in two battle lines. The jousting tournament with a small wall between the combatants only
became popular in the 15th century. So, if we think about an infantry revolution,
we've got to ask first just how important was cavalry to begin with and to what extent did
infantry actually gain significance? Cavalry was certainly important in high
medieval battles. Traditionally, the argument goes as follows. In contrast to classical Roman and
early medieval armies, the high medieval battlefields were dominated by knights with
couched lances, which means that lances were fixed under their armpit. The rise of these heavily
armored lancers is usually connected to the introduction of the stirrup and the adoption
of longer saddles. Both of these innovations essentially allowed the rider to deal with
the strong forces of impact better when attacking with a lance. The impact of a lance was way
stronger than the one of a thrust, because the knight could use the full force and weight of his
horse on his enemy. One expert on medieval warfare, Kalli de Vries, affirms that the lance became the
weapon for knights all over Western Europe. He points to chronicles but also to an increasing
number of medieval illustrations. In addition, horsemen became increasingly more armored.
In the 10th century, an Ottonian knight could have looked like this. From the 11th century onwards,
cavalrymen developed into an increasingly heavier force who could have looked like this.
Since only nobles could afford such expensive equipment, being a knight became associated with
a strong social code of honor and political power. Subsequently, the sociopolitical makeup
of the medieval world changed. This is usually referred to as feudalism. Today, this term is
controversial among medievalists, but many military historians still tend to use it anyways,
so we'll stick to it for this video. As a result, armies were increasingly organized
along these feudal structures. Let's pause for a moment. At this point in the video,
it is obvious that we can never cover all the details of a certain topic.
For additional information, we recommend you have a look at the various documentaries of today's
sponsor CuriosityStream. CuriosityStream is home to thousands of streamable documentaries and
non-fiction TV shows on topics like history, nature, science and more. One of our favorite
series is the story of Europe, which spans across several centuries. The documentary does a great
job of giving you the bigger picture of what happened in Europe and how it is connected.
It is hosted by Dr. Christopher Clarke, who is actually one of our favorite historians.
CuriosityStream offers a great deal. If you sign up using code SANDROMAN, you get unlimited access
for just 14.99 for the whole year. So, go check that out. Now, let's jump back to the
infantry revolution thesis. As always, historians do not agree on topics, so naturally, some
historians think that the importance of cavalry is overemphasized. Let's flip this around and look
at the debate from their perspective. These historians often point to the crusades.
They argue that such big enterprises as the crusades needed many flexible men to do all
sorts of jobs. Knights simply didn't cut it by themselves. At the battle of Jaffa in 1192,
for example, the crusaders under Richard Lionheart resisted the attacks of Saladin's men by forming
a shield wall of infantry which was protected by stakes. From behind the shields, they shot
their enemies with their crossbows. Some historians argue that at the end, a cavalry charge of the
knights drove Saladin's men off the field. Regardless, this battle shows that infantry
was important in the high middle ages. We should keep in mind, though, that they were in a fortified
position and fought a comparatively light cavalry force which was not intended to break an infantry
formation with a shock assault. Many of them were armed with bows. Because the enemy forces
were so different, it's hard to use the crusade as an example. In general, advocates of the
infantry revolution thesis usually restrict the discussion to Central and Western Europe,
particularly around the French cavalry and its immediate enemies, the English, Flemish, Swiss,
and later on the Spanish. Moreover, it is important to note two things here. Firstly,
most advocates of the infantry revolution don't deny that infantry was important in high medieval
battles. They are of the opinion, however, that cavalry was the decisive factor in these battles.
Secondly, historians usually form such wide-ranging hypotheses on the basis of ideal types.
Rarely do they discuss every battle in all its complexity. That means they generalize. So,
generally speaking, battles in Europe that involved knights on both sides were indeed often
decided by a cavalry engagement. In addition, Volker Schmidchen stresses the fact that footmen
actually had good reasons to flee when their side fell behind. Not only because they hardly stood a
chance against cavalry in the open, but more so because if they were captured, they were much less
likely to be ransomed back to their families than knights. They were instead either killed,
forced to work for the winners or sold into slavery. It looks like knights could take higher
risks than footmen on the battlefield. But let's not jump to conclusions here.
Let's next investigate a few battles that are frequently mentioned in this debate.
The battles of Kortrijk in modern Flanders, Pannockburn in Scotland and Moorgarten in
Switzerland. All of these count as early successes of all infantry forces. It is true that in all of
some form of a peasant infantry force defeated well-equipped mounted knights.
However, as Clifford J. Rogers, an advocate of the infantry revolution,
mentions himself, the importance of these early victories should not be overemphasized.
At Kortrijk, the Flemings chose a battlefield which made it hard for the French cavalry to
form up prior to their charge. They charged anyways and were severely hampered by swampy
ground and ditches. The battle ended in a disaster for the French. At Pannockburn,
the Scots put the English in a very similar situation. The end of that battle was similar
to Kortrijk. At Moorgarten, lastly, the Swiss ambushed the Austrians in a narrow mountain pass
and never gave them a chance to form up. In all three cases, the infantry force fought with their
back to the wall or was fighting for their independence. This means they had less of an
incentive to flee due to either a physical or psychological deterrent. Still, on other occasions,
as the battle of Mont-en-Bével in France or Kassel in Germany, knights bested infantry in the open
field. All of this is evidence that no major shift in favor of infantry was taking place
in the early 14th century. What happened subsequently?