The Real Homer's Odyssey

Politeness Forgotten
9 followers
Aug 10, 2026
For millennia scholars have sought the historical and archaeological reality of the Odyssey and its hero Odysseus. With Christopher Nolan's upcoming film arriving imminently let's investigate the main candidates for the home of a real Odysseus.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the enduring archaeological mystery of locating Ithaca, the legendary homeland of Odysseus. While scholars like Heinrich Schliemann proved that other Homeric sites were real, Ithaca remains elusive. The narrative examines various candidate locations, including Cephalonia, the Paliki peninsula, and the modern island of Ithaca, weighing literary evidence against archaeological findings.
When Heinrich Schliemann first presented his firmly held convictions to the world
in the 1870s, that the heroes of the Trojan War were not in fact pure myth,
but real people of flesh and blood, who'd inhabited genuine places that could still be found,
The vast majority of scholars and readers alike looked on with scepticism and disdain.
And yet, sure enough, as the years went by, ever stranger similarities with the myths
in archaeology, and even in the written archive of the Hittite palatial system,
continued to lend weight to his hypotheses, if not his often destructive methods of excavation.
First Mycenae, then Troy, Pylos, Sparta and Thebes were pinpointed as likely locations
for the mythic tales. Today the list grows ever longer. One though, since the very first known
attempts to track it down all the way back in the 3rd century BC, has thus far eluded everyone.
The homeland of perhaps the most famous Homeric hero of all. The one to give Homer's sequel to
Trojan War its name, Odysseus. Though more outlandish commenters have sought to place
Odysseus' realm of Ithaca and even Troy well outside of the Aegean, in Italy or even Britain,
based on the literary evidence of Homer and the known archaeology of Bronze Age Greece,
Odysseus' power base is most widely assumed to have been located on an island off the northwest
coast of the Greek mainland. And yet, despite more than 2,000 years of trying, it is still
by no means definitively located. In the 3rd century BC, Eratosthenes,
the famous philosopher and chief librarian at the Great Library of Alexandria,
was known to have speculated on the location of Ithaca. His conclusions not being too dissimilar
to those most recently put forward just in the 21st century. Likewise, after a number of other
speculations by ancient writers, Roman historian Strabo gave it his best attempt. By the 19th
century, some 1,800 years later, the likes of William Gell, William Leake, and Schliemann's
colleague and successor Wilhelm Derpfeld would all do the same. As far as these scholars of the
Gilded Age were concerned, the latter actually carrying out several archaeological investigations
at various locations too. Ithaca lay in plain sight, located or on nearby Ithacae Island,
which still bears a variation of the name Ithaca today. More recently, other writers have hypothesized
the nearby islands of Cephalonia and Vathi as equally valid hypotheses, as Derpfeld clearly
demonstrated, lands of very real Bronze Age archaeology, with many sites showing an abundance
of Mycenaean remains. The largest of the islands, Cephalonia, has a remarkable archaeology,
with a story going back more than 40,000 years, deep into the Paleolithic past. With a population
today of over 35,000, it is the most densely populated of the islands, with an abundance
of Roman remains stressing its importance in antiquity too. The population was much higher
in the past, having steadily declined since the 1800s. A disastrous earthquake in 1953
was the final end for a good deal of its people, some doing what their ancestors may have also done
in hard times. Moving on. Like many islanders, ever focused on their own past,
perhaps the most prosperous era of all was the Mycenaean Age. The mighty Tholos Tomb excavated
by Lazarus Colonas in 1991 at Poros on the southeast of the island, being the largest
ever discovered in northwest Greece. A tomb very much fit for a king. Built in around 1300 BC,
more or less the time of the Trojan War, though a corresponding town has so far eluded archaeologists.
Most recently, the northwestern region of Paliki, now a peninsula, has been suggested as Ithaca
by authors such as Robert Bittlestone. Based on the writings of Strabo and on geological research,
in the late Bronze Age, this location is thought to have been an island.
Unfortunately, the three-year dig that followed in 2007 came up with inconclusive results.
Discovering the remains of a settlement at Paliki thus remains but a possibility for future
archaeologists. Finally, we have the island of Ithaca itself. With a tiny population of less
than 3,000, it is the second smallest of the seven main Ionian Islands. Inhabited since at least the
4th millennium BC, based largely on the name of the island, remaining apparently unchanged since
ancient times, Ithaca has long been the favoured candidate for the location of Odysseus' capital.
And of course, largely invisible perhaps to ancient scholars, today we have a good deal
of archaeology to back up the written arguments. Oral traditions, most obviously resulting in
Homer's Odyssey, claim Ithaca as one of the foremost Greek powers in the Age of Heroes.
Its access to the sea being the facet that gave it its influence and reputation as a home to able
seafarers, navigators and explorers. Since the first excavations in the early 20th century though,
a great palatial complex has thus far eluded scholars.
The island is nonetheless unique, possessing remains from all periods of prehistoric archaeology
since the Neolithic. Notably, traces of walls, roads and buildings being found from as early
as the early Helladic in the 3rd millennium BC. By the Mycenaean era, all these developments
would coalesce into a flourishing society. Most obviously seen at the remains of Loisos Cave in
Polis, and at Aeitos, where a good deal of Mycenaean evidence is followed by that of the
Geometric Age. If Odysseus' palace ever really did exist, it has thus far defied discovery.
Like the location of Agade and the decipherment of the Indus Valley script,
remaining one of the great mysteries of prehistoric archaeology, and a wellspring for
books and documentaries, it is a secret that may well be unlocked by future generations.
If you enjoyed this brief exploration into the Mycenaean world,
here's another six and a half hours I made earlier, covering the entire rise and fall
of that most ancient of Greek civilizations. Just click the link here and it'll take you
to my main channel, HistoryTime. Thanks, and see you next time.
