The Hero: A Medieval Icon Interpreted Through the Sword

Medieval Legends
5 followers
In this film, master bladesmith Ilya Alekseyev forges The Hero — a Saint George and the Dragon themed sword created in the spirit of medieval Christian iconography. Use our code THATWORKS and this link https://reurl.cc/9bM2Nd For GentleBands Rings. This is more than a sword build; it is an exploration of sacred art, theology, and the old-world discipline of hammer and chisel engraving.
#SwordMaking #Bladesmith #DamascusSteel #MosaicDamascus #HandForged #CustomSword #SwordArt #HistoricalWeapons
You can't really understand sword design as well as medieval art without understanding the religious
work that went into designing the images that even now inspire us and make us hold our breath.
The story of Christian and medieval art really begins at the Seventh Ecumenical Council
convened by Empress Irene in 787 to resolve the iconoclastic controversy. You see, for over a
There was a controversy in that some versions of Christianity loved depicting the saints
and what is shown in the holy texts. Others really thought that depicting the saints,
especially God, was wrong. It is an idolatry and more akin to the pagans rather than the
true righteous path. So the controversy led to a point where we even had wars
All the depictions of the saints and a lot of the Greek, Roman, and Christian art was defaced.
And you can see those defacements right now in museums, especially if you took an art history
class. Now, in 787, the church decided that depiction of holy images was okay because it
is a veneration, proskynesis, as opposed to worshiping, Latria. The reason for that is
a theological one and it's kind of cool. So a depiction of a holy person is not an image of
that person the way we would think of as a photograph. No, it was considered to be a window
to the divine. Creation of an icon was a religious practice that is similar to God made flesh. So the
in admitting holy images was if word becomes flesh, so the creation of the holy image is the
window to the divine. The icon is holy not because it's holy in itself, but only in so far that it
leads to the divine. The door to your house is not your house, but it is a necessary step for you to
arrive at home. Conventionally, the process of creating an icon is in itself a worship-like
procedure. It is a devotional practice. The creation of the icon follows roughly the steps
of Genesis. The preparation of the blank ground with subsequent beginning with dark colors moving
all the way to light, then gold, and then the highlights shows the book of Genesis. And the
earth was without form and void and darkness was upon the face of the deep and the spirit of God
was moving on the waters. The last thing that is painted on the icon is the eyes of the saint,
as well as the highlights, symbolizing breath of life and the fulfillment of prophetic vision.
That is light and word of God is coming into being. And there's no real any other way of
painting a traditional icon. And it has been like that all the way up until the Renaissance.
There are other cool things about an icon that an appreciator of medieval art has to keep in mind.
One of them is perspective. Perspective on a traditional icon is always weird. And if you
don't know what to look at, you will think that the artist was bad at art. But in fact, he was
really, really good and very, very, very well read. The perspective does not converge on the horizon
inside the image. It is, in fact, reverses and converges on the viewer, you. That's why buildings
are so weird in the background of almost every icon. Now, in preparing for this presentation,
I've read a bunch of counter arguments. One of them says that it's simple convenience or
compositional necessity that required the icon painter to paint buildings weird. That does not
hold water if we know the texts on which iconography is based on. And here we can go
back to ancient Greece. If you see early theologians, for example, Saint Augustine,
as well as later ones like Thomas Aquinas, were really, really well versed in Greek philosophy.
You can argue that the crowning achievement of Greek philosophy is Christianity itself.
That's why on the Cathedral of Chartres or Eastern Orthodox icons, you have the venerable pagans
represented. Aristotle, you can see Plato, you can see Archimedes, and last but not least,
Pythagoras. And Pythagoras is key. In ancient Greece, you have the cult of Pythagoras,
who thought the world to be rational and mathematical. In fact, all the way to the
17th century, people thought that the orbits of the planets corresponded to the sphere that
could be built around a platonic solid. And starting with the cube, then tetrahedron,
then dodecahedron, all the other planets organized like that. And it's only in the
late 17th century that we found out it's not the case. So for a thousand years,
Christians thought that the Pythagorean way of looking at reality is a way of knowing God.
And if you look at what happens when you paint in a holy image, reverse perspective,
it starts looking very similar to a representation of a four-dimensional cube.
Now, it is all intentional. Why? Because if you're representing divine, you're representing
it. You're not showing it how it is, but you're giving a window to it. A little bit of fun house
window, nonetheless. So it is intentional. The stylization of the human figure is also intentional.
You're not painting the true Saint Matthew. You're painting an idealized form of the saint
as he is in the divine realm, because you're supposed to arrive there through the icon.
The Council of Nicaea also had an instructional purpose to iconography. That is, a lot of people
can't read, especially Latin or Greek, but they somehow have to internalize the meaning
of biblical texts. So in that respect, maybe a little bit degrading to the icon,
but it does have a comic book-like purpose, a picture book.
Now, even there, the high intellectual work of early theologians shows itself very well.
If you look at, for example, the icon of Christ walking in water, you also see a boat somewhere
on the water. And in that boat, you have the apostles or sometimes something else,
depending on the region and the time. You see, that boat is simultaneously a hint to the passage
that with me you will become the fisher of men. It is also Noah's Ark. So as Noah was walking in
water to save humanity in a boat, so is Christ walking on water to save humanity.
And this simultaneity of texts and meanings is very important to the creation of true
cathedral ecclesiastic art. St. Augustine has several ways you can reason about holy texts.
One is historical literal. So when, let's say, we read Moses is leaving Egypt, we read, well,
they actually left Egypt. Cool. There's a moral interpretation. Let's say,
the famous passage, it's easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich
man to get into heaven. There's a moral lesson to it, and it's pretty obvious. We can contemplate
what could be the implications, but we know it's a moral lesson. There's allegorical. You can see
Jonah to be representing something allegorically. But the new introduction that St. Augustine had
is anagogical reasoning. Anagogical sometimes is interpreted to be a type of allegorical reasoning.
Other scholars don't. And please, please, please, Catholic theologians, don't chop my head off
because I'm talking about this in a very condensed manner. Anagogical reasoning has
to do with secrets revealed about your soul or your soul's destination. See, early in Christianity,
a big problem was already discovered. And it's discovered because the story of the Bible has an
end, but we live outside of the events that biblical texts describe. So how do we extract
lessons of deep devotion from this to us? Because we're separated by hundreds of years.
St. Augustine says that some texts are outside of time. That is, time for God or in the divine realm
is happening all at once and eternal. That's the notion of infinity that medievals had.
So the great flood and Noah is happening at the same time as Christ walking in water and at the
same time as we're living now. So the ark is the same as the church that saves us. And only through
the church you can, at the end of days, find your salvation. The idea that everything is happening
technically at the same time allows for the narrative structure of the creation of icon
to create very specific meanings from texts that everyone has read before for a long, long time,
just by combining the references. If you're looking for something stylish or personal use
or a gift, I recommend gentle bands. They will fit a smart or formal environment as well as the
gritty operations in the workshop. Gentle bands are very affordable and don't sacrifice any
notional fashion. And if you check them out, I'm sure you'll find a ring that suits you or your
loved one. Gentle band rings are durable, so if you're working with machinery or laying bricks,
they will withstand the abuse. And did I mention they have tons of style? So whatever your
personality is, I'm pretty sure you will find something that suits you. And if you're married
and work, for example, as a welder, you might not want to bring your expensive gold ring
to work. Gentle bands is a great substitute where you signal that you're married, but the ring you
have will not be damaged too much by weld sparks or grinding dust. And if you like this kind of
content, gentle bands and other sponsors like it support us making these videos. So why don't you
hop over to gentlebands.com and find something that you like.
Anagogical reasoning also helps us with a very, very cool thing. And for a moment, my dear
listener, I might sound like Jordan Peterson, and sometimes Jordan Peterson does sound like
a middle schooler who just discovered this thing and made it his entire shtick. I assure you,
I'm not doing that. Anagogical reasoning allows us to create new art that is not strictly within
the canon, but place it inside the devotional canon. That's why you have saints that are
depicted outside of the Council of Nicaea. Now, our story is Saint George. And when I was asked
to make the hero, I was asked to make it on the theme of Saint George, but with a problem.
A. I'm a modern sword maker, but I'm asked to execute it in a gothic style. That means I had to
completely put all my knowledge of Western art into one box and cut the box at the exact time
approximately the Renaissance and not be influenced by anything after that, which is difficult to do.
And that's why I had to read and reread the context of creating devotional art.
The cool thing about the story of Saint George is that it's one of the early Christian myths,
stories, or parables, however you prefer, that directly mirrors ancient Greek mythology.
Here's an example. In ancient Greek mythology, you have Hercules, you have Perseus,
whatever. The demigod, usually the hero, which is the definition of a hero, a demigod,
is asked by a king or someone or as a form of atonement to eliminate one of the Chthonian
monsters. The Chthonian monsters come from the beginning, the creation of the earth,
where gods and titans gave birth to all kinds of ugly beings that are pestering the world. And
a good representation of Greek myths or rather rereading is Stephen Fry series of books. They're
just wonderful and I recommend them. And Stephen Fry, as a scholar, as a scholar of literature,
points out that the gods had a task of eliminating all this primordial evil to lay bare the path of
So the story of Saint George roughly follows the Greek myth. However, in the Christian context,
we can't really appeal to the hero being divine by virtue of birth. That is over, that is paganism.
So Saint George is shown to be a hero through faith. And we have a shifting paradigm that
follows the rough narrative. So the story goes, in Syria, in the later stages of the Roman Empire,
a kingdom is pestered by a dragon. The dragon breathes all kinds of poison, he lives by the
swamp, and he's starting to eat the peasants. The peasants eventually start bringing sheep
to the dragon to prevent him from destroying the fields. The dragon is greedy and asks for
women. So now virgins are being sent to the dragon. The dragon is satisfied for a little bit,
but then comes the turn of the princess. Now the king, of course, the princess has to put a stop to it
and recruits Saint George to slay the dragon. And Saint George, being a righteous warrior,
demonstrates to us, the reader, what can be achieved through faith. That's the rough compendium of what
the story of Saint George is about. But the story of Saint George, in anagogical reasoning,
is not only about Saint George. It's supposed to be about us, what kind of things we can accomplish
through faith. And please, dear viewer, if I sound like a proselytizing preacher,
I'm just giving respect to a beautiful tradition that has been passed to us from, let's say,
5th century AD all the way to modern day, and I'm treating it with absolute respect. And plus,
you can't really understand even modern literature like Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings without
knowing these things. J.R.R. Tolkien was writing to C.S. Lewis specifically about this kind of motif
in their writing. So, let's proceed with the sword. Now, usually, when you're creating an icon,
you have to refer to the New Testament and to Christ himself. If you look at the imagery that
I'm creating on the hero, you don't see a cross anywhere. Well, one of the reasons is, if you look
at churches, let's say, 8th century all the way to 14th, 15th century, the church itself is already
the shape of the cross. So, here, the sword is already, as a frame, depicting that without showing.
So, that theme is settled. On one side, I'm depicting the classical Saint George slaying
the dragon. I can never go wrong with classics, and it's a great, great, great way to exercise my
engraving skill, as well as my imagination of how that would look in deep relief on metal.
On the other side, I'm showing, and this is a little bit of my invention for this project,
is the princess as if she's already captured by the dragon. That is outside of standard iconography,
but I'm a modern person living in modern time, and I can allow myself, if I treat the stylistic
parameters and ecclesiastical parameters very well, to create a little bit of my own retelling
invention. It's a foreboding image. Now, there are difficulties in executing a project like that.
I've already explained, in part, the conceptual difficulty. That is, I have to follow a specific
canon, and I have to maintain a certain train of thought. It is not just slapping images here and
here and here, and now the sword is impressive. No, we don't do this if that works. Other channels
do it. We and our viewers are intelligent human beings who love art and love literature.
So, this sword is a piece of literature. Partially, my authorship, but at the same time, I'm working
with the parameters of an icon. An icon is kind of anti-art. The artist depicts something that
the artist feels is the case. The creation of a medieval icon, you eliminate the ego. It's
an almost Buddhist moment, in a sense. You are devoting your skill to the creation of this
window to divinity. So, that is the kind of intellectual work, before I even put a hammer
to steel, that I have to do in designing. In designing a project like this, I spend more time
at the sketchbook than I do actually forging the sword. The physical constraints of the object are,
for example, in order to create these panels that are the icons themselves on the blade,
I have to forge well medium carbon steel in the location, rather than using the mosaic Damascus
that's the rest of the blade. There's a scientific reason for that. See, when you forge out Damascus,
right? You stretch it, stretch it, stretch it. Your boundaries, and basically alloy boundaries
that you created between the 15 and 20 and 80 CRV, grow carbides along it. As you stretch it,
the carbides stretch with it. So, if your layers go this way, it's easy, relatively, to carve it.
But, if you carve against it, like on a tree stump, every hit hits a carbide layer. Now,
that is a natural process of mosaic Damascus, but I don't need to be carving on mosaic Damascus.
If I etch it, the etching of the Damascus itself will interfere with the design I have
for the pictorial depiction. So, I forge welded a piece of 1045 there, right? Now,
another problem with creating swords like that is the size. This is the longest mosaic Damascus
sword that I have done so far. It is very possible that I'll make a bigger one. I don't see necessity
for it. And, the third major, major constraint of the primer is the price. I am using rubies,
I'm using gemstones, I'm using silver and gold, and the price of those things fluctuate. If you
budget to work this week on a handle and you buy the silver, thinking that it's last week's prices,
you're out of pocket, you're poor all of a sudden. So, that's another constraint. Your
precious materials have to satisfy a budget, and not only that, your precious materials have to
satisfy the intended meaning. It's very easy to just randomly put gold everywhere on your project.
And, to some people who like that kind of stuff, that is appealing. It is not appealing to me
because it's creating differences without necessity. And, since the project has to be
executed in a very specific style, imitating a very specific time, I can't allow myself to
replace good design and thought with godliness. So, I use silver without gold plating because
silver is a pure material and that's the part of the handle that will come into contact with
your hand. And, honestly, gold in ecclesiastical iconography depicts divine light. So, I save the
gold for the halo of Saint George because that's its meaning. And, putting gold on the
handle in this context would have been quite inappropriate given the themes depicted on the
handle. Another complexity of a project like this is the time constraint. I've mentioned
way early in the video that this sword took me several years. Well, I completed the first version
when the handle was made out of mammoth ivory. It was great. However, the client did not like it.
He wanted the hero to be more like the heretic, which, saying it now, sounds like a little bit
of an inside joke on the part of the client. Okay, well, a handle like this takes time and
I have to redo everything and, like, redesign things, go back to the sketchbook. So, the
creation of a work of art in modern times, well, actually, since the time of the Renaissance,
probably, is a collaborative effort between the client, the customer who has ideas, and the
craftsman who has other ideas and actually has to make it. In creating unique works in a specific
style, especially a style that is no longer alive in any meaningful sense, the people who developed
it are long dead and the ways of viewing the universe no longer exist. We no longer look at
the world through the Copernican system or a system of sacredness hidden in everyday objects.
We no longer use alchemy. We know about atoms. We know about light refraction and the people in the
medieval era never knew all of that. The glimpse of modern knowledge was so far away from them
that the way they saw the world is more alien to us than the depiction of aliens in pop culture
movies that we ourselves create. So, in order to do them justice, you have to submerge yourself
fully into their way of thinking, into their way of reading literature, into their way of listening
to music and living. I am a trained art historian. I'm a trained philosopher. Those were my degrees.
I read medieval texts in translation but nonetheless and I try on this channel to
bring that knowledge and that training to you, the viewer, for free on YouTube.
In my craft, I'm also a trained artist. I try to bring together various disciplines and present
to you, once again, something that is of value. If you don't like listening to
interpretations of literature, into cool topics of theology, you can, in theory, put this entire
video on mute, turn on your favorite Spotify soundtrack and just watch it. But I'd like this
channel to be somewhat different than other sword maker channels. We have experts on this channel
that can talk about specific topics. For example, today's episode was a lot about Christian art and
its foundation. Now, I will present the same amount of respect when we're dealing with Buddhist art
like a Tibetan sword or a piece of Japanese armor. In that case, we'll talk a lot about Shinto,
we'll talk about Buddhism, esoteric Buddhism and developing of the architecture. Because those
are necessary to understand holistically. The sword, the European sword, exists within a specific
worldview, in a specific context. It embeds itself in specific cultural expressions like
architecture, like literature, music and even day-to-day etiquette. So the hero is more than
just a sword. It is a testament to my scholarship. It is a fingerprint of my art. It is a fingerprint
of my vision and how I understand artistic expression itself. It is also a piece of
literature that is embedded in the material. It is a piece of literature about what I've read.
It is a piece of literature about what you see in my work. It is a piece of literature that
reinterprets with a modern eye, but respect to people who came before me, the legend of Saint George.
The legend of Saint George is iconic in the Christian warrior tradition.
And it combines two worldviews already at the time of its creation. It combines the Roman
and Greco-Roman pagan worldview about what it means to be a heroic warrior. But it also attaches
a new way of thinking at the time. The Christian notion of righteousness and where does truth come
from? And in creating a sword that combines these ideas and that seriously takes them
and ponders them, I think you will enjoy the outcome. And any moment of me as an artist,
like the aspect of the sword that you like, it came from that place. It came from a place of
reading 5,000 pages of Saint Augustine. It came from listening to lectures on Greek philosophy
because I have to refresh them too. It was a long time since I got my degree. It is a moment
of a creation of art, of something new. And in research, I was finding a lot of new things
about very old things. And I think that's cool. And that's how I want this channel to be. Present
new original work in a way that relates to the stuff you study in school, to the stuff you
ignored reading and now would love to read and find out. YouTube is a wonderful place where you
can find lectures by Harvard professors talking about very specific, very cool and obscure topics.
And I'd like this video to be part of that library that when you come home tired,
you still would like to learn more about the world where you live in.
So with these words, I present to you the hero. Thank you for watching. This is the third and
last sword in the triptych idea, the Inquisitor, the Heretic, and the Hero. If you like these
long-form big project videos, be sure to check out the previous video, The Heretic, right here.
And don't forget to subscribe. Thank you!
