Summers Says Tariffs Cause Higher Prices, Hurt Jobs

FinFocus
3 followers
9 Video Views·Feb 9, 2025
Former US Treasury Secretary and Wall Street Week contributor Lawrence H. Summers says most economists would agree that tariffs don't create jobs and cause higher prices on goods. Council on Foreign Relations Director of Studies Shannon O'Neil agrees that the auto industry is likely to be among the earliest affected sectors. They speak to David Westin on "Wall Street Week."
The proximate effect, of course,
is that you protect some jobs
in the industry that's tariffed.
But there are effects that go in the other direction.
When you put a tariff on steel,
it gets more expensive for auto producers,
and that makes them less competitive.
When you put tariffs on, the dollar goes up,
and that makes it more expensive
for anybody who's trying to export products
from the United States.
When people pay higher prices because of tariffs,
they have less money to spend on goods
other than the tariff jobs, and that hurts jobs.
So it's very hard to know which way the effect will go
or whether there'll be any positive effect.
It depends in part on what the Fed does,
but the idea that protection is some kind of solvent
that creates large numbers of jobs,
I don't think would be supported by most economists.
After all, if that were right,
Argentina would have had a great record
through the years at having low unemployment.
What's the best case for Donald Trump's argument for tariffs?
You sometimes agreed with him,
sometimes actually disagreed with him.
But what's the best case you could make
for President Trump's case on tariffs?
Look, I think the argument is that it's a negotiating tool
and that there are important things
that we want to achieve in negotiation.
Whether we will achieve those things,
I think very much remains to be seen.
Whether the aggressiveness
with which we pursued this strategy
will ultimately make cooperation
with other countries more difficult,
that remains to be seen.
But I think the best argument for this approach
is a set of considerations based on leverage.
And of course, there are also arguments
for specific tariffs in specific sectors
that are directed in ensuring
that our economy is adequately resilient.
I certainly feel much better about the situation
with the tariffs suspended and negotiations underway
than with the tariffs actually imposed.
And we're just gonna have to watch
and see how all this plays out.
I do think the United States has gained an enormous amount
from an international approach based on international rules.
And when we flaunt those rules,
we may make it more difficult for such a system to exist.
And that may ultimately undermine what our interests are.
So we're gonna have to watch very carefully.
Larry, with respect to jobs specifically,
the job market is fairly robust.
It has been a fairly strong job market,
low unemployment.
If in fact there are other reasons for imposing tariffs,
as you suggest, some geopolitical reasons,
some political reasons, is this a good time actually?
Can President Trump in a sense afford
to risk a little bit on the jobs front?
Well, it's a good time on jobs.
It's a nervous making time on inflation.
And we're all hoping that inflation's
durably gonna get back to the 2% target,
but it's not quite there.
That's why interest rates are being kept at a level
where mortgage rates for families are very high.
And so I think we have to be very careful
with respect to what we do
that is going to influence the price level.
So I think economists are gonna be watching
very carefully what all of this means.
Shannon O'Neill is an economist
at the Council on Foreign Relations specializing in trade.
She sees a direct connection
between President Trump's new trade policies and jobs,
and it's not necessarily good.
So tariffs actually could have the wrong effect on jobs.
We've seen strong job growth in the United States.
The United States is really a robust, booming economy,
one of the strongest right now in the whole world.
But tariffs may take some of that away.
And the reason they will do that
is because so much of U.S. production,
particularly in manufacturing and factories and the like,
depends on selling to our neighbors,
to Canada, to Mexico,
because of integrated North American supply chains.
So if you put on tariffs
and you break down the supply chains,
then you're not selling engines from New York
down to Mexico to put into cars.
You're not selling produce or cattle
or other things that go to Canada, go to Mexico.
You break down the supply chains and jobs get lost.
As of right now,
they've suspended the tariffs on Canada and Mexico.
If they went into effect,
as previously announced by the president,
which sectors would be hit the first?
So one of the sectors that would be hit the hardest
is the automotive sector.
This, we see in automotives,
very integrated supply chains across North America.
So first, you would see losses because of higher costs.
If it's 25% more expensive
to import things from Mexico and Canada,
then the parts and the components
that are made in the United States
don't get shipped down there
to be assembled into cars into Mexico or into Canada.
So that's one way you lose jobs.
The other way you lose jobs
is that those cars that are sold in the United States
just cost more.
As President Trump goes into this negotiation
with Canada and Mexico,
does he have by far the upper hand
given the degree to which those economies
depend on the United States,
as opposed to the United States depending on them?
So they look out at the many countries
that Trump has threatened tariffs,
or in some cases, putting tariffs on,
and Mexico and Canada are distinctively vulnerable.
Trade for these economies is so important overall.
70% of their GDP comes from trade,
and trade with the United States is paramount.
It's almost 75, 80% of trade for Canada,
for Mexico comes to the United States.
So they are uniquely vulnerable to these kinds of tariffs.
China, Europe, yes, trade with the United States
is important, but it's much smaller
as part of their overall economy,
and as part of their overall export market.
We're talking right now about President Trump
potentially changing the terms of trade
with Canada, Mexico.
He's also talked, obviously, about China.
He's imposed 10% on China.
What about actually tightening up
the existing terms of trade?
We also saw the United States Postal Service
saying they're going to suspend
the so-called de minimis rule.
Give us a sense of what the government could do
with China or with others,
actually tighten down on what things are going on right now.
So there are many tools you have to manage trade.
Tariffs are one, and that seems to be one
that we're starting with in the Trump administration,
but there are many other ways.
There are import controls, there are licenses,
and there are things like the de minimis rule,
which says that anything that's imported
that costs less than $800,
you don't have to go through the paperwork,
you don't have to pay tariffs and the like.
That, at least temporarily,
has changed for Hong Kong and China.
They're looking at all those packages that are coming in,
which are the tune of 300 million packages a year
that are coming in under this de minimis rule,
so lower than $800.
Some of that is fast fashion.
It's companies like Xi'an and Taimu,
which sell you $5 T-shirts and other trinkets and the like,
so some of it is that.
But there is a worry, and perhaps a justifiable worry,
that in those packages are also coming things
like fentanyl pills, which are very small,
can come in a small package, precursors,
or things that are more expensive
that are evading the tariffs
because they come in a small space.
We're talking about a lot of hypotheticals
because we're not sure what actually will happen or when.
But talk to us about the time
between we find out what happens.
What about that period of uncertainty
for U.S. businesses in making decisions
about employing people, investing?
What does that do to the economies?
Well, the time in between and even what it will look like
and how long it will last,
this all creates incredible uncertainty.
So if you're a CEO or the board of directors
of a company, you're trying to think about
where you'll, what suppliers you'll use
or what your final markets will be
and what the costs and the profit margins will be,
you really have much less visibility into that.
It could be 25% more expensive
or you could earn 25% less
if you're selling into particular markets
or it could all go away.
So what I think we will be seeing
is freezing of much foreign direct investment,
freezing even of investment here in the United States,
and freezing of growing jobs, of growing footprints.
It will be very difficult for businesses to operate.
