This Is a Stock Picker’s Market, Says Robinhood’s CIO

FinFocus
3 followers
Apr 16, 2026
Robinhood CIO Stephanie Guild says this is a stock picker’s market — and explains what retail investors are buying right now. In this Trader Talk conversation, she breaks down ETFs vs. individual stocks, AI investing tools, volatility, and how Robinhood users are navigating this market. Robinhood CIO Stephanie Guild joins Kenny Polcari, Amanda Polcari, and Julie Hyman to break down what retail investors are actually buying right now, why ETFs surge during uncertainty, and why she believes this is a stock picker’s market. They also discuss AI investing tools, active trading, Robinhood’s digital advisor, and how everyday investors are navigating volatility.
Welcome to Trader Talk. I'm Kenny Polcari.
And this week I am here again with my daughter, Amanda Polcari,
who was a former head of people ops at Ellevest. We've got Steph Gild,
who is the chief investment officer at Robin Hood Markets.
So that's going to be a great conversation.
And I have a dear old friend, Julie Hyman, who is senior anchor here. Yahoo.
But Julie and I, we go back probably at least a decade and a
half. We're not allowed to say how long we've known each other.
When I was broadcasting live from the floor of the New York Stock Exchange and
Julie was at Bloomberg. So that's where I first met Julie.
So it's a pleasure to have you back on.
And I'm really looking forward to this conversation because there's a lot going
on. There's a lot going on in the markets.
There's a lot going on kind of around the world.
So there's certainly plenty to talk about and plenty happening.
But I want to give Steph an opportunity just to jump in here and talk a little
bit about your role at Robin Hood.
What's going on there because I know Amanda's got a million and one questions
for you. So get ready.
Sure. Thanks for having me.
I am chief investment officer at Robin Hood.
That means I do a couple of different things.
And everybody at Robin Hood, if you ask them, they have more than one job, like
many jobs. And so I formulate opinions about the markets
and do economic research and share those opinions with
our customer base. I write a blog every week called Investors Guild.
And I also lead Robin Hood Strategies, which is our digital
advisor we launched about a year ago.
So we manage money for our clients as well across a plethora of.
Now, it's going to be interesting because it's going to be right where Amanda wants
to go. You manage money for them.
It's a digital advisor.
Digitally, like a digital advisor.
Digital advisor. Yes.
Yeah, yeah. So they, you.
We're going to talk technology.
Using technology.
Not human beings.
Not human. But, well, the thing that we have actually tried to
differentiate on is that traditional robo advisors had stripped it down.
Right.
To be cheap and easy and fast.
And that part is great.
But I actually do think, like, the fact that humans are the other side of that.
Bingo!
You, we, so we try to create a service that we, like, guide you along the way.
I leave messages for you in the app based on the portfolio that you have.
Provide context, like if, forget what's happening in your portfolio.
If the markets are, you know, moving crazy, like we want to leave a message to
you that says, like, we got it.
This is what we think of it.
Like this, you know.
And do the people who have, do they communicate with a person?
Or do they, do they like a person assigned to their account?
Okay.
No.
It's, it is all digital, fully digital platform, but we try to infuse, like.
But when you respond, you're responding across the platform.
So everybody gets the same message?
Or are you responding to me individually?
It depends on the portfolio you're in.
That's how we, we divide it up.
So if you're in an all bond portfolio, my message will talk about
what's happening with interest rates.
If you're in an all stock portfolio, my message will be talking about what's
happening in a lot of different places, right?
But your, but your platform is also more than just stocks.
Fill me.
Is it options?
Stocks, options, ETFs, uh, futures, event contracts, crypto, um, bonds.
No, no, no bonds, bonds or ETFs.
Okay.
Got it.
Are you doing a, like, like, uh, the prediction markets as well?
It's not in our portfolios for Robinhood strategies, but it is something that our
customer base has access to on our platform.
Oh, okay.
Interesting.
Yeah.
All right.
So I'd love to put it in a managed portfolio.
I actually do think there's some cool uses for it, but.
I think the prediction markets, actually, I think the prediction markets do a better
job, like when you talk about, like even talk about the midterm elections, I think
the prediction markets are much, are much better at it than even the polls.
Yes.
And also I think from an investor's perspective, like if you can have a
prediction market and like earnings are going to beat estimates or not, that it's
kind of like you do, you can do your work, they beat, but the stock goes down.
Right.
Like, and so if you can be a little more finite and you're thinking, or it's
another way to, in some ways a head to head, I was just going to say, yeah.
So go ahead.
No, no, no.
A lot of questions.
When Robinhood first started and please correct me, keep me honest here, but it
was obviously all about getting more of the average investor, really just making
it more accessible, right?
That was kind of part of the original mission.
Are you seeing now across your customer base, are you still seeing the majority
of people really looking to day trade and stock pick and do that?
Or are you, I mean, because you've now offered a diversified platform, are you
seeing people really back to kind of what my dad, his traditional advice, which is
diversification and ETFs and make sure you have exposure.
And what are you seeing, I guess, across the base?
Um, I, I think it is, it's, we definitely still have a very active trader, um, set
of customers and we continue to build for them and, and care about them.
Um, we built something like legend, which has like a ton of different trading
tools, but certainly as we've grown and our customer base has, our original
customers have grown up, you know, like they've, they've, some had kids, bought
homes, then obviously your priorities start to change.
And so we also see that as well, like a, a plethora of people who have built a nice
amount of wealth and want to need a little more advice.
So we have our concierge service that is not exactly like having an advisor, but
it's, it's a higher level customer service where you can get some.
So define that though, if it like the concierge service.
So you're telling me is that someone would have the ability to talk to a
person, not necessarily the same person.
You do have kind of an assigned, like loosely assigned person.
Um, they're not giving you advice, but they're there to help you to navigate
the platform, help with customers, you know, client service issues.
Um, and, and while you may get somebody else when you call, because let's say
the person is out of the office or something, um, we are starting to provide
some higher level, high touch service.
And I'm curious, are most of your clients at this point new to investing?
Are they my, are they people who are already in the markets who are migrating?
Are you getting market share from other platforms?
What does that kind of, yeah, it's, um, I'd say we're, we're not, I'd say early
on, it was a lot of new, right.
That's what it felt like.
And young and the average age on the platform, you know, I think when I
started four and a half years ago, it was like 30 now it's like 35.
Um, so it's slowly creeping higher.
Um, and as a result of that, we do actually have a lot of experienced
investors and I think our early investors are now the experienced investors.
Like, I don't think there's a better way to learn than to do it.
Right.
You know, you can read any book you want, but you gotta, you gotta, you
have to learn from some mistakes too.
Um, and so, yes, I, I'd say, uh, we are, we definitely see market share
and ACAP coming in from outside, uh, third parties, but you know, competition
is fierce out there too.
So I'm curious, where do you guys custody is self-custody you self-custody
did it a few years ago or more than a few years.
So, so if I came to your platform, I'm going to have a Robin hood account.
Yep.
It'll be.
Yep.
Robin and securities is our clearing.
And, uh, so would you, would you say that that would be like I had a
Schwab account or a Fidelity account?
Yeah.
It's like, it would move.
It's not like a Bernie Madoff account is the point I'm trying to make, right.
They're individual.
It's not like you're taking control of my money and her money.
No, no, no, no.
We're holding it for you.
We obviously, you know, adhere to all the regulations in an individual
account.
So my money's my money, her money's her money.
You can't say Bernie Madoff in a conversation about that.
Thank you.
Yeah.
You can't just say, oh, it's not, of course it's not like Bernie Madoff
could have custody.
He was still taking the money.
Yeah.
He probably didn't use a custodian.
He just was also taken.
He was a custodian.
Well, well, right.
Went to this Hampton's house.
Um, right.
And the friend's house and his house and the apartment in New York City.
Yeah.
I mean, it's very, no, I mean, I don't even want to use that.
No, no, no.
You can't.
You really shouldn't.
Let's just edit that out.
No, you really shouldn't.
But there are some people that may think that that's the way it works.
Right.
I think I actually, the, the example I always like to use is, um, when Lehman
brothers went under, right.
Where was your money?
Where was your mind?
Of like spread everywhere.
Right.
That's one of the, at the time I was at JP Morgan and you know, that was one of
the winning things of JP Morgan is that we, we self custody, we know exactly
where your money is and Robin Hood.
We know exactly where you're right.
And that's great.
And that, and that has actually helped.
I'm sure to build the platform and, and build credibility amongst people.
I think the thing that always frustrated me personally is that it felt like.
Um, Robin Hood was gamifying investing.
Right.
And for me, that's a negative because I don't view it as a game.
I view it as serious business.
Right.
And I always felt that, you know, they, they, whether it was Robin Hood or
some of these other platforms, they encourage young people to come in and
trade, trade, trade, trade, trade to try to create all this activity.
And I always found that to be anti investing.
I think we try, like the goal has always been, I think to make it easy to get
like, and you can call that what you want, but it's extremely easy to use.
It's a very intuitive platform.
Right.
Accessible.
You're working, it's accessible for everybody.
And we do have things like education.
Um, you know, I mentioned my blog.
We did it last week, actually.
We did a, um, 11 a.m.
Like, uh, YouTube, you know, kind of live thing.
I think for sure it's changed, but I'm saying my first impression of it.
Right.
Was not like, I was very cautious about it.
Kenny, I think you're getting like maybe to a bigger sort of
cultural shift in investing too.
Exactly.
Where, which is not exclusive to Robin hood.
I mean, it's the users who come to Robin hood, but you know, when we probably
started in the business, you didn't invest in stocks to sort of get rich quick or
invest in anything really to get rich quick.
Right.
You weren't, um, you know, you were doing it in order to build wealth over time.
And I think that that perception of what markets are for has changed.
Rightly or wrongly, it's changed.
People want a hundred baggers.
Like, did you even hear the phrase a hundred baggers before 10 years ago?
No, right.
We've had a good market for a long time and it makes people, it can make people
feel like they're really good at it.
Right.
And it's when markets go down is when you learn the most, right.
Yeah.
Um, but I do, but, but that being said, there are definitely clients that we
have met that are, are, you know, really want to learn and know, and that
is almost their full-time job.
Right.
I know that across other platforms because everyone's offering education
and webinars and understanding and the ability to ask questions, which I think
is great, right?
Because I think people need to understand and learn, especially they need to
understand what the markets are, how they help you generate long-term,
almost generational wealth.
And what are you making up?
I mean, I'm just, you know, every day seeing people using chat,
UBT using cloud, using plug in the blank saying, Hey, I have a hundred
thousand dollars, $50,000, $2,500, right.
Fill in the blank.
What trade should I make?
I mean, that's, that's, are you hearing that from those types of questions
from customers or are you seeing that?
I mean, we have, we have, um, uh, we have some AI usage that you can have
on our platform and, and a customer service agent and one of the biggest
questions is, should I buy this?
And we were like, I can't give you advice.
Um, but I, yeah, I mean, that's, it's, and so they're probably doing it
off platform to get their advice.
And I think it's both in a great thing because information has never been more
attainable, like even, you know, even more so than when the 90s brought on
the age of the internet, this is like an even another level of it.
Um, but it doesn't mean that you're going to like, make
necessarily better decisions.
You still need to like judge what it says.
And I love cloud.
I use it all the time, but it's always tells me I have a good idea.
But I will say chat GVT and the other ones will say, you know, I
can't give you specific advice.
It will say that if you ask it that question.
Actually, mine gives me advice and then says it's not advice.
It'll say it's not, you know, and that's what I, but I, I think it's
just a matter of like giving it's someone to me to someone to talk to.
And one thing I always think about is, uh, I learned the most when I was
sitting on a trading desk, like watching, hearing people on the phone,
talking, having an, Oh, this just hit on CNBC.
What do we, you know?
And that's like, that's what I think like Twitter's or sorry, X has become.
And it's what I think like you can have another person through your agent or
whatever to talk to you about what's going on and they can point out things
that you maybe not have thought about, right.
Help you make, like, I was like, what does sulfur matter in copper production?
Like I, you know, now you have to be a commodities expert.
So those are great questions to ask.
I will say, I think whether it's Chad or Claude or perplexity, you know, name
any one of them, if you ask it the right question, I think it's great.
You have to be careful though.
Cause some of them hallucinate.
Also, I just think there's to be careful about asking the right
question about asking the right question.
How do you ask it?
Right.
If you ask it the wrong way, you're going to get a wrong answer.
I think the one thing is like, I think for a long time, you know, and this
is, this is slowly broken, but like the retail investor was, they weren't
smart enough to deal with it.
Give it to give it to an expert, just be to buy an index fund.
Don't worry about anything else.
Like, I just, I think it's like not giving people enough credit that like,
and that's why I like about, you know, I think our customers understand
that they can't fully like, right.
Oh, it told me to do it.
So I did it.
And why didn't it work out for me?
Right.
I think they have to understand to your point.
They do understand that.
Yeah.
Well, they're sort of self-selecting too, right.
The people who are coming to Robinhood probably want to be active
investors.
They don't want just somebody telling them what to do.
They want to make those decisions and gain agency over their finances.
Yes.
Which is why Robinhood strategies, when we built it, we really had to
think about like a different way.
It's like somebody who's like, still wants to have a stay over their wealth,
but they don't have the time.
Right.
They're not as big, can't be as hands-on.
Do you have like a list of strategies?
Like this one's conservative.
This one's volatile.
This one's
So then if you go in there, it's already pre-populated like a model.
It's already pre-populated with ETFs or individual names?
Both.
That's interesting.
Except for the most conservative is all bond allocation and that is all ETFs.
But yeah, we, and that's actually one of the things in our philosophy is that I
actually, for a number of reasons, mostly because interest rates fell for 40 plus
years and they're not anymore.
We are borrowing at a pace that we, you know, our deficit is minus 6% of GDP.
We are, you have the baby, something called peak 65, which the baby boomer
generation, like now by 2027, I think they'll all be 65 and you know, by, you
have to start taking your RMD, like there's a reason to see money coming out
of the index funds and 401ks.
I just, there's a multitude of reasons why I actually think like it's never
been a better time to be a stock picker.
If you're ready to pull in them.
I agree with you.
And that's why I was like, why should I stick you in just ETFs when
we can like do the work?
Isn't that what stock pickers always say?
Yes, but it's never a better time.
But if you had come to me in 2010, I would have said just buy an index fund.
But because you had peak quantitative easing, you know, like I just think all
the factors I'm talking about were like, it was the peak of these four tailwinds
that are, so, so do you think that like, I mean, we joke around here
at Yahoo finance sometimes and just say stocks go up, right?
Because over time stocks go up, but it's not, not every stock goes up.
No, but the indices go up over time.
Yes.
Do you think that's not true anymore?
No, not that I'm saying, I just think you leave opportunity on the table.
Got it.
I agree.
Not picking, not having both.
Some explosion.
That's why I have foundation of ETFs that give you the risk return profile
that you should have based on what you said you wanted, uh, and your tolerances
and then overlay from stock picking.
Right.
But when you overlay it's you overlaying it's or my, do I have the ability
then to pick my own stocks to overlay?
We're overlaying it for you, but you can restrict some names that you don't want.
Right.
I can buy, I have clients that do that too.
Yeah.
That's I just don't want to, for some reason, a lot of people
don't want to own Disney.
It's very interesting.
I, Tesla's a polarizing one too.
I mean, our platform generally, they, they invest in Tesla, but then
there's some people who just, yeah.
Why don't people want to own Disney?
I don't know.
I mean, it hasn't done very well, but it's, it's almost like the, you know,
look, I just, I'm at the end of that baby boomer.
I just turned 65 two weeks ago.
Right.
So I'm at the end of that.
Oh, thank you.
I'm at the end of what you just defined as this baby.
Right.
So, um, but it's interesting, but a lot of them are people that are in my age
group that just not interested in Disney.
They want to replace it with something else or just cut it out completely.
Which is interesting.
I find, I don't own Disney.
I it's funny.
I never liked Disney.
I never owned it.
I just wasn't, wasn't a name for me.
I don't know where to go.
Yeah.
Just wasn't a name for me, but one way or the other, let me ask you a question
about what you're seeing in terms of, um, what was the activity right now?
Just given everything happening in the world, are you seeing money
going into aerospace and defense?
Are you seeing it go into nuclear, you know, what theme, what themes?
Our customer base is like, they're pretty, um, they're pretty willing to
take risks like in, in some of the longer term, longer pool things.
Um, average customers, 35.
Yeah.
Uh, I mean, I'm on this side.
Look, Tesla and NVIDIA have been the most traded, the most traded, but
sometimes they're on the buy and sometimes they're in the cell.
Our customers tend to own like a core set of positions that they trade around.
So use the volatility in your favor, buy on a dip sell on a win.
Um, you saw, so the other one thing I tend to look at is like.
What percentage of the activities and ETFs versus single names.
And when there is like kind of a big amount of uncertainty markets kind
of peak in terms of volatility, you see a lot more just broad-based ETF buying.
And then as soon as things come down, they start to go back to single stocks.
So we just saw like not last week, but the week before that, like a little
bit of a peak in ETF buying, and then it, uh, it's more recently come back
like in the last week or so come back to single names, are you seeing
nervousness because of the geopolitical stuff that's going on?
Can you see nervousness amongst.
Amongst a little bit, like going in, like, as it started, you saw some more
like T bell ETF buying, um, and kind of like, you know, the sort of sitting
on the sidelines and waiting.
Um, we saw, you definitely had a lot of like gold and silver ETF buying as well.
Um, silver especially was something that, um, was a focus, uh, and then
oil where people getting people, like, because I felt like all of a sudden
everybody is so interested in the oil story and getting into oil and
treating commodities in a way that they wouldn't have before.
I mean, you did see some, uh, energy stocks, but it wasn't like a big focus.
Um, you saw it, like we have something called the Robinhood investor index
that is like the 100 most traded and then the most traded on the Robinhood
platform on the platform.
And then we wait and then we wait it by, um, how our customers
weight it in their own portfolio.
So that's like what determines what the weight is in the index, um, across it.
And so, um, Tesla and Nvidia are always at the top.
And then, um, you, you did see some energy stocks in there, but not
like it was smaller weighted.
You have like quantum stocks, um, are big, like allocations are just kind of
like willing to wait for it, I think.
Yeah.
Um, are you seeing just more money?
I mean, are people, are you seeing just an uptick in overall like cash coming
in people looking to put, put more to work?
Or has it remained kind of city as the war has evolved?
Like that's the one thing I would say, like buying curtailed like a little
bit when got quite dicey, um, that week of like March 30th around there.
But, and it, but otherwise our customers have remained net buyers, which I think
is like, it's, you know, just shows, I mean, they listened, right?
Because when, when this conflict first started, the first thing I saying is on
average, if you go back over history, it impacts the markets for eight days.
Like, you know, it doesn't have a long-term impact.
Can you really focus on oil if that's where you want it?
Like, yeah, stay the course.
Politics and geopolitical events don't ever price stocks in a long term,
create short-term chaos, which actually then creates the opportunity, right?
In, in whether it's aerospace and defense or oil, whatever it is, that's
what creates the opportunity.
I was asking him too, what are the, what are the names, you know, as for the
average investor, someone who's not living and breathing this all day, like
you all are, um, what are the names not in the headlines that you think.
There's opportunity with right now.
Oh, um, I mean, it's hard for me to know whether in their headlines or
not, because I feel like I'm like, it's in my headline, but like,
are they in your headline?
You know, um, all those like optical names that are kind of the picks and
shovels of AI have been like, you know, uh, coherent is a name in our
portfolio that represents that.
Uh, Marvell technology is another one like credo, which is like
copper oriented, like all of that.
I'm like, it's in my headlines, but I don't know if other,
and all that stuff's already been flying though.
Lumentum, right?
Like all of the optical stuff, the memory chip names, Sandisk, I think
it's still at the top of the S and P.
Right.
But I still think we're very much in the early stages.
I think there's plenty of room for this to run.
I think so too.
It's like, I mean, I I'm the first I'm.
It's funny on our team.
Like someone who I partner very closely with, who works for me is very
gross, like willing to take risks kind of person.
And I'm like, well, I don't know.
It's up a lot already.
Like, you know, I, I at the bottom and, and right.
So we're always like having these debates about it.
And I actually, on the optical stuff, when I first started looking at it,
it flew so fast.
I was like, Oh, did we miss it?
But I actually kind of agree with you.
I think.
Yeah.
But let me ask you a question.
Is that person younger than you?
Um, by like 10 years, but not like, and I'm old,
but 10 years, when you think about investing 10 years could be a long time.
Yeah.
And it would change your perspective.
So maybe, I mean, I like to think.
I think of myself as young, but I think I do too, but it's not happening.
I know.
But I think there's, um, the one thing we always talk about is like, she's
actually really willing to like stick out in a downturn.
And the one thing about this market is like, once the market decides it doesn't
like something, it's like not just a few percent down, it's like demolished.
So when we have a really, when we have a good winner, I'm like, we got to
take some chips off the table.
Like I'm really adamant about that.
Yeah.
But would you take you, you, again, you would keep a core
position, trade around it.
Exactly.
You take some chips off the table, but leave a core position if you still like
the name.
Exactly.
And if it sells off, I'm like, I don't feel so bad.
Like I got, you know, cause you took some money off the table, but I always
say to people, and I've been saying it more recently because of all the, all
the, all the, um, volatility that's happened is you can have good names that
get mispriced because people get anxious, but the thesis hasn't changed.
So that creates the opportunity because the story's the same.
If you bought it at 300 and it's out trading at 250 and the story has not
changed, this is a huge opportunity.
Absolutely.
And that's like, it's a, it's a red flag to say, go check.
Did something change about the thesis or not?
And there's a name last week, Cloudflare.
Yeah, I'm sure.
I was like, what did we miss?
Like I started like diving with Mr.
Claude, Ms.
Gemini.
And every,
Oh, I like how you gendered them.
I'm the same.
I don't know, I don't know.
Gemini definitely is a woman.
She's a lady.
Oh, Gemini is a woman.
You think?
That's what I think.
Claude's like, I haven't used Gemini, I have Claude.
Claude's like a friendly French man or something.
I don't know.
Um, but I think back to the point, Gemini could be, now I'm going to read
all of Claude's answers in French accent.
Um, but, but that's like, so I went to my, like, you know, our, our size,
our chief, you know, security officer.
And I was like, what, like, do you still think this is relevant?
There was mythos, like literally killed every, you know, and he was
like, no more relevant than ever.
I feel that way about Microsoft.
I'm sorry to take down 36% off the high.
The story has not changed.
I am with you on that.
Okay.
But listen, we, this went by so fast.
We ran out of so much time.
I want you to come back because I want to do this again, because I
thought this was very engaging.
Uh, and I really, really appreciate your perspective and I'm sure.
And he's going to open his Robin hood account later today.
I'll keep him.
I'll keep him to it.
You're late to the party, man.
I am so late to the party.
I've tried.
You're not late to manage the story of my life.
Strategies, portfolios, that's the one thing we changed.
So our fee is 25 basis points, but as for gold customers, every
dollar over a hundred thousand is 0%.
Because our thing was like, why should you pay more to invest more with the
way, like things are priced out there?
So we're changing.
We were looking at.
Good for you.
It's very exciting.
It was very, it was great to have you on, on trader talk this week.
And I look forward to seeing you the next time.
Yeah.
All right.
Thank you.
Ladies and gentlemen, once again, for joining us for trader talk,
we'll see you next week.
This content was not intended to be financial advice and should not be used
as a substitute for professional financial services.
