Inflation Sticker Shock Across the US

FinFocus
3 followers
8 Video Views·Feb 2, 2025
The national rate of inflation has dropped significantly since its post-pandemic peak, but perception of inflation in different parts of the country is not created equal. Michael McKee talks to a small restaurant owner that is now passing along the higher cost of brisket to her customers and Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari about how people in his district are dealing with higher prices.
We're known for the best brisket in Chicago.
We work really hard to provide the area
with true craft barbecue.
Our customers are regulars here
because they love the atmosphere.
Brisket.
Dominique Leach is the owner and chef
at Lexington Betty Smokehouse on Chicago's south side.
She opened in 2019 and like other restaurateurs
in Chicago and across America has seen firsthand
how the surge in inflation over the past five years
has affected small businesses.
I'll bring it over to you when it's ready, okay?
Thank you.
Everyone's favorite are brisket that we're known for.
Two years ago, I was paying $3.80 per pound.
Today, I bought brisket for $4.60 per pound,
which means we have to sell it at a higher price.
Inflation is really affecting the restaurant
because we have to spend more money on product,
therefore increasing the prices for our customers.
It makes it really uncomfortable.
You typically have to give people an explanation.
Why is brisket by the pound more this week
than it was last week?
It disappoints people.
The challenges facing Leach play out across America,
even as inflation falls from the dramatic highs of 2022.
A recent survey found that 24% of small businesses
identified inflation as the top problem they face.
I think one of the things that we've learned
in the last two or three years
is people really, really hate high inflation.
But do people who aren't on Wall Street
even care that the Fed has a 2% target?
The impact of inflation is often felt more acutely
in rural areas where household wealth tends to be lower.
With far less disposable income, those earning the least
have to dedicate a greater proportion of their income
to everyday necessities.
That divide is compounded by the fact
that wealthier Americans, often found in urban areas,
have relied on a booming stock market
to increase their wealth
and offset some of the effects of inflation.
Is the experience of inflation different here in your district
in the Midwest and to the West
than it might be in New York on Wall Street?
I think so. I mean, I think,
especially when you go out to rural communities,
we have a lot of rural areas,
the challenges that families are facing are different.
I mean, they're all facing the higher prices
that virtually all Americans have faced.
But they also have acute challenges.
Hospitals are closing in many rural districts
because there's not enough population
to support those hospitals.
In some cases, colleges and universities are closing.
It's hard to get home construction built,
even though there's a lot of land available,
getting new construction and new development built.
So the challenges in rural communities are different,
but a lot of times they're driven by price as well.
So there's some important similarities,
but there's some specific differences in rural communities.
For the likes of Neil Kashkari and Austin Goolsbee,
a large part of their districts cover vast rural areas.
While a big focus in John Williams' jurisdiction
is naturally on Wall Street in New York City,
where analysts and traders
immediately dissect any inflation data,
not just looking at the headline number,
but peeling back the layers
to look at individual contributors,
which can vary widely.
You get the headline number, the core number.
Literally the next second, I look at services.
So services versus goods.
Then I look at where's the shelter.
And what has been high?
So what's keeping inflation high
is not a broad-based higher inflation across.
Then I would be a little nervous,
that are we getting stuck somewhere above too?
It's really a couple of components.
It's shelter, it's lagging.
Zillow rents are coming down.
It's just taking a while.
People who own their homes,
it takes a while for that to show up in the data.
So there's a lag there.
Auto insurance, medical insurance,
these are imputed numbers.
That's why I think it's actually good for them
to have that flexibility,
because why should they keep policy high?
Just because shelter inflation,
which is owner's equivalent rent,
is running above target,
just because it's adjusting slowly.
For those in the markets every day,
like JP Morgan's Priya Misra,
communication is a critical part of a Fed president's job.
And a clear target, 2%, makes that job a lot easier.
Well, you know, inflation is different
in different parts of the country,
and it can be different at different times.
I think where this became easier, unfortunately,
was when inflation was high,
and everybody said inflation was high everywhere.
Inflation was clearly damaging to the economy.
It was harmful to families and businesses.
Everybody wanted to see inflation lower.
I think the communication of the 2% goal
was incredibly powerful during this period,
because we weren't questioning
what we should get inflation to,
what does good look like?
We said, absolutely, we need to get to 2%.
We're consistent on that.
I think people understood that,
the importance of price stability,
the importance of getting inflation back down.
I think that was, regardless of all the debates
of exactly how did you come to 2%,
it was a very clear, strong message.
It's a message that Chair Powell repeated over and over
that we're not compromising on achieving that.
That's not the kind of analysis
Americans elsewhere are making.
They see inflation in the supermarket,
at the pump, and in their rent.
They're still coming to terms with so-called sticker shock,
something Goolsbee and Kashkari say
requires a different kind of communication.
We do a lot of conversations with labor unions.
And one of the sources for me of information
about people's expectations,
in economics, we talk about expectations matter,
inflation expectations matter.
We talk to labor groups about what wage rates
they're negotiating in their multi-year contracts
to look at what is the inflation embedded
in their own thinking, looking ahead two to three years.
Now, as they're having their negotiations,
they may not be thinking,
well, my inflation expectations are X
and I need this kind of wage growth.
But it's clear that inflation is woven into the fabric
of their thinking about the economy and the future.
So it does register.
They may not be as technical as a Wall Street analyst
in how they talk about it,
but it's present in their thinking.
Inflation is eating away at the funds available.
Go back to the inflation of the 1970s, 80s.
Paul Volcker's time in office
and people would do things like bring two by fours
and throw them in front of the Fed
because they were mad at the level of interest rates.
You're in a kind of ironic situation.
People hate inflation,
but they get mad at the people whose job it is to fix it.
Look, that's true.
Nobody's ever like, ah, my greatest central banker.
They're just mad if you don't do the job
to keep inflation low.
I was close personal friend of Paul Volcker.
He's a personal hero of mine and mentor.
His widow, Anka, gave me that original two by four
that they sent to him.
Somebody scribbled on the top of it,
please reduce these insane interest rates.
And I keep that in my office on the shelf
right next to my desk here at Chicago Fed
as a reminder of two things.
One, the decisions that the central bank makes
affect regular people, regular businesses,
regular consumers quite directly.
And two, sometimes if it starts going wrong,
you got to make tough decisions.
What we want to once we're in this experience
is have wages growing faster than prices.
And the good news is lately, that's what's been happening.
And as productivity grows, we can do that even more so.
But if you talk to regular people,
I kind of think the world of inflation targets
is not in their space.
They're like, why is it so expensive?
The dynamics you just described about wages and prices,
I imagine that most of the people you talk to
when you go around in the district and speak,
they don't understand that.
They don't think of it that way.
I think it's true that most people
do not think of it that way.
And if you look in the surveys,
they're extremely upset about inflation.
And then if you say, but look at your wages,
they tend to say, I earned the wage increase I got
out of my hard work.
The inflation, I had nothing to do with.
And so that's the part that makes me upset.
They are in reality tied together,
wage growth and price growth.
On the surface, wages are growing faster than inflation.
The latest reading had wage growth at 4.2%
compared to an inflation print of 2.9%.
Wages are going up, but are they going up enough
to offset the significant period of time
where high inflation comfortably outpaced
any growth in wages?
It turns out that since the end of 2018,
inflation still outpaces wage growth overall.
And who's benefiting from that wage growth anyway?
While all income groups have seen wage growth
in the last year, historically America's wealthy
have seen their average earnings grow 46.2% since 1979
compared to just 17% for its lowest earners.
The overwhelming message that we've received
and I have received is, hey, high inflation is really bad.
It was very painful for my family.
It was very painful for my business.
Get it all the way back down.
They might debate whether 2% should be the right target
or 1% or zero, but get it all the way back down
to what we were used to before the pandemic.
And they probably couldn't necessarily put an exact figure
on what they were used to before the pandemic.
So I wonder, is the 2% target necessary?
It is necessary.
It's necessary because those Wall Street analysts
that you talk about, they are very active
in financial markets.
We know that most financial products
ultimately get priced off of, for example,
the 10-year treasury market.
So it is important that the people who are professionals
in investing and in forecasting understand
what we're trying to do and have confidence
that we're going to achieve it.
So I do think having a specific numeric target
is very helpful.
It becomes self-reinforcing the more we demonstrate
our ability to hit it.
But it needs to be a low enough number
that people on Main Street don't need
to spend their time thinking about it.
They have better things to do with their time
than thinking about inflation.
That's our job to get it back there.
From Wall Street to Main Street, inflation is felt by all.
And target or no, ultimately the real goal
is former Chair Alan Greenspan's definition
of price stability, when people don't think
about inflation at all.
