Why investors aren't taking Trump's tariffs seriously

FinFocus
3 followers
8 Video Views·Feb 4, 2025
President Donald Trump has imposed sweeping 25% tariffs on Canada and Mexico imports, alongside additional levies of 10% on all Chinese imports and 10% on Canadian energy that will take effect at midnight. Veda Partners' managing partner and director of economic policy, Henrietta Treyz, joins Catalysts to discuss this development and how investors are feeling.
President Trump outlining sweeping tariffs over the weekend, 25% across Canada and Mexico,
an additional 10% on China, currently on track to go into effect at midnight.
Let's get the view from Washington. We want to bring in what kind of impact
this is going to potentially have on the market, on the economy. For that,
we want to bring in Henrietta Threes, VEDA Partners Director of Economic Policy.
Henrietta, it's great to have you back here on the program. So I think the scale of some
of these tariffs, certainly taking investors, taking Wall Street, Main Street even,
by a bit of a surprise. What do you make of the market's relatively, I think you can call it
muted reaction here this morning, maybe what that signals about what Trump's strategy is going to
look like? Yeah, I think that's a great question for today. Spending all day and all night with
clients is effectively what I do. And my understanding and my impression from them
is to still have a lot of expectation that these are either going to get materially watered down
in the next 20 hours or so, or they're going to be pulled back altogether, especially where
Canada and Mexico are concerned. So I think a lot of the market reaction is absolutely
muted today versus what it will be should the tariffs go into effect at midnight.
There's a lot of expectation that this is not serious right now.
Is part of that expectation due to the fact that the market is anticipating carve-outs
for things like energy, for example? Yeah, I think these are much more
wide ranging than analysts expected. Certainly myself, I anticipated with only 20% odds that
we would see universal tariffs. And that's what we have right now with both Canada and Mexico.
We have a slightly lower 10% rate on energy, which is moderately helpful, but that is millions of
barrels a day of oil coming in from Canada. So that needs to be taken all the way off the board.
And I think a lot of expectation is that huge sectors like the auto industry,
which has such integrated supply chains between the United States and Mexico,
just to name one, those products cross the border eight or nine times before they're even
put into the final vehicle. So how many times is that piece tariffed? There's a lot of questions
and a lot of carve-outs that I think people are still expecting from here.
Henrietta, what do you think the conversations are like inside the White House here this morning,
just given the fact that we know Scott Besson has been very much has questioned, I think,
this type of strategy in the past. It was brought up during his confirmation hearing. He has
certainly published papers on this in the past. And given the fact that this seems to be the
strategy under President Trump, is that going to act as, and the market's reaction, even though
we aren't seeing maybe selling to the worst degree here this morning, is that going to be a check
then on Trump going forward? That's, I think, why the market is so muted today. There is an
expectation on the street that Scott Besson is the one running the show. And he's got this huge
Wall Street backing behind him that's serving as a major voice inside the Trump administration.
I disagree with that sentiment. The folks that are dealing with trade in the president's office
are much more voluminous than just Scott Besson, who, by the way, also supports tariffs and has,
as a general starting point, this expectation that tariffs will go into effect.
So I think that the focus of the street on Scott Besson is inconsistent with the focus on Capitol
Hill and in the White House, where folks like Peter Navarro, Kevin Hassett, Howard Lutnick,
Jameson Greer are much more at the forefront. And then let's not forget, President Trump himself
is a staunch advocate of tariffs, and he is unabashedly pro-tariff.
Help me understand the totality of policy from the Trump administration,
how business-friendly or unfriendly it might be, according to some notes this morning. The market
holding on to this idea of an 11th-hour deal. Is that such good news for the market if that
stops tax cuts, for example, because there's the idea that tariffs will pay for those tax cuts?
Yeah, the pay-for component is really critical here. One of the things we're watching closely
is the House Budget Committee, which was supposed to convene this week to begin work on that tax
bill, paving the road for that tax bill to get written. My expectation is that they're
delayed at least a week. And quite frankly, I have very low optimism that they can get their
one big bill through. I think a tax bill is not going to happen until December of 2025.
And I think what's different that the street needs to incorporate when we say that the first
round of tariffs weren't inflationary, first of all, that was on $350 billion worth of goods
from China. This one is $1.4 trillion worth of goods. And we do not have the added stimulus
of a 14 percentage point corporate rate cut that was just enacted a couple of months before those
2018 tariffs went into effect. So it's a very different scenario, very different environment
for these tariffs to be going into effect, which will start as early as 12 o'clock tonight.
And the tax extension is A, not stimulative, and B, not going to pass until December.
How much money do, if these tariffs, let's just play it that way, if these tariffs do go into
effect at midnight, how much revenue will be raised from this? There's, it depends on a lot
of the carve outs that again, we're expecting, but what they're factoring in is about a trillion
dollars in revenue. My expectation right now from a $74 billion run rate in terms of collections
is maybe they get that up to 100 and over 10 years, you can get to a trillion, but all those
tariffs would need to stay in effect and probably continue to escalate as supply chains move,
as retaliation hits GDP, things like that. So I think 700 billion is probably the max that they
should assume. And that is a tax on obviously everybody, US consumers. Given that explanation,
Henrietta, do these tariffs potentially change the course of action from here on out for the
Federal Reserve? That's the big question. If the tariffs are inflationary, are we going to be able
to see Fed cuts? Are there going to have to be Fed hikes? If we're also simultaneously planning
to lay off huge portions of the federal government via doge and furloughing federal
employees, that's going to raise unemployment. Those puts and takes are really critical. I am
highly skeptical that the Fed's going to be able to cut rates this year if we have inflationary
tariffs. I want to talk about congressional pushback before I let you go. On X, we saw
Senator Chuck Grassley asking for an exception for farmers. And we're going to throw up that
post that he made this morning here on our screen. He's pleading with President Trump
to exempt a fertilizer from the tariff because of the impact it could have on farmers that are
his constituents. How successful do you think members of Congress can be at getting these
exemptions? Again, I think those exemptions should be forthcoming. And the question really
then becomes, does Canada see that pain and decide to keep the pain alive? You know, really,
it's the retaliation that we have to be worried about. The short version is the senators do not
have the power to strip the president of his authority to impose these tariffs. They do
technically have the power. They don't have the votes, is the way I should say it. So they
simultaneously don't have the votes to support the tariffs and calculate that revenue in their tax
bill. But they also don't have enough votes to go against the president and strip this power away
from him the way that they could otherwise do if they wanted to. They could. So the expectation
that I have is that you're not going to see necessarily a potash carved out. I think we're,
you know, at this point, lucky to see energy carved out in those 10% tariff rates brought down
to zero, which would be huge for states like Maine. You know, 95% of their heating oil comes
from Canada. You're going to see winners and losers. And I think the way the Trump administration
has responded to the farmers' retaliation in the past is to provide bailouts to the farmers. We've
passed four so far, totaling almost $50 billion for the farmers. So I would expect more of that
in an upcoming government funding bill or in a debt ceiling negotiation, things along those lines.
There will be more federal spending along those lines to, again, keep pressure on the Fed.
All right, Henrietta, we've got to leave it there. Thank you so much for joining us. Appreciate it.
Thanks for having me.
