Does coordination training enhance mental processing speed? Some of the first scientific analyses of an adaptive coordination training (Life-Kinetic) yielded promising results. For instance, in a study by Matthias Grünke (2011), children with learning difficulties participated in 15 Life-Kinetic sessions (lasting 25min.). In comparison to an active control group the coordination-training group significantly improved their performance in an attention task and a task of fluid intelligence.
And who would have thought that learning new dance steps might be an appropriate means to stimulate the grey cells (Kattenstroth et al. 2012.) - even in old age. At the end of the episode, we will take a look at studies on the effects of aerobic exercise (jogging, walking, Nordic walking, etc.). Are training programs effective in reducing Alzheimer's and cognitive decline?
keywords: intelligence training - brain - cognitive training - adaptive coordination training - Life Kinetik - Horst Lutz - Felix Neureuther - Dortmund - Matthias Grünke - n-back training - motor training - mental flexibility - improve balance - attention control - executive functions - children with learning problems - Life Kinetik vs.. typical sports games - d2-attention test - number connection test - fluid intelligence - processing speed - dancing - Kattenstroth - running - walking - Nordic Walking - aerobic exercise training - meta-analysis by Smith et al. (2010) - Erickson et al. (2011): Hippocampal growth due to aerobic endurance training - dance - ADHD - learning disabilities - psychology - sports psychology - learning - motivation - sport
Editor: Eskil Burck
hello and welcome to the world of sports
psychology can Sports make you more
intelligent effects of adaptive
coordination training for example life
ktic or
dancing and effects of aerobic training
for example
walking in the past few years I think it
All Began in 2008 when Yi and colleagues
published their study on the effects of
a NB working memory training in the past
few years there's been a Renaissance a
rebirth of the field of cognitive
training until 2008 many scientists were
convinced that improving fluid
intelligence wouldn't be possible at all
fluid intelligence at core is your
reasoning ability is your ability to
process big amounts of information very
fast and to solve problems and finally
to make good decisions so obviously it's
a very important ability which is
important not only at school um but also
in everyday life so many scientists were
convinced it's not possible to improve
fluid intelligence it's been viewed as a
trait a personality factor which cannot
be improved by training or maybe a
little bit improved but not seriously
but with the development of
computerized working memory training
programs like for example the the N
training or training programs to improve
executive functions which is about um
your ability to control your attention
and one program which produced really
interesting results was the task
switching training developed and
evaluated by by kabak and Kay by the way
if you're interested in all these
studies um I'll put the links on the
literature section of the website with
the development of all these programs
more and more scientists became hopeful
that maybe fluid intelligence is
trainable to a significant and
meaningful
degree nevertheless all these programs
have one big obstacle working memory
trainings or trainings to improve
executive functions are not making
fun they are really boring they are
monotonous and at the same time they are
very difficult because the difficulty
level rises the better you become so the
training programs are adaptive the
better you get the more difficult the
tasks become and this combination of
monotonous tasks and very difficult
tasks makes it really hard to motivate
participants so wouldn't it be great if
we were able to embed a cognitive
training in a motoric training because
especially young children have a natural
desire to move to learn new movements so
what about an Adaptive coordination
training you have to learn a lot of New
Movement which stresses and thereby
hopefully improves your executive
functions your ability to control your
attention and that correlates with fluid
intelligence that this might indeed work
could be shown by Matias gruna who
conducted a randomized training study
with children aged 9 to 12 having
learning
disabilities so it's been a group which
is known to be worse in intelligence
tests than the
average and therefore they thought well
this might be the right sample for a
intervention to rise fluid in Legend
one group of children the control group
played typical games which are usually
played in sport lessons like dodgeball
steeple chase
Etc the 19 kids of the experimental
group were trained with life kinetic
which is nothing else but an Adaptive
coordination program which has become
more and more popular in Germany because
very prominent German sport stars have
included it into their training program
for example the players of Borussia
Dortmund or the German skiing star Felix
Nora so what did they have to do um one
task for example was to take two balls
one ball per hand and you have to throw
the two balls right up but you don't
catch them with the same hand you've
been throwing them no you have to cross
your arms and then you have to catch the
balls well this is not too hard but the
idea of this um life kinetic is as soon
as you master this task as soon as it
becomes routine you have
to switch to the next more difficult
level so maybe you've crossed your arms
with the right hand up so next time you
have to cross your arms with the left
hand up and then you have to switch
between the two one time right hand up
next time left hand up so it gets more
and more difficult and you continuously
have to be concentrated there is no
automization it it's always learning new
movements and so it's always stressful
for your attention control system for
your executive functions the children of
both groups attended 15 sessions which
were 25 minutes long and usually they
trained two times per week so two 25
minute sessions per week which is really
no long
intervention nevertheless there have
been really interesting effects of this
training um because
moderate effect sizes could be observed
for a attention test which was the D2
test uh which is often used to diagnose
ADHD and of course for an ADHD diagnos
many more tests have to be conducted and
they observed effects on a a test on
fluid intelligence which was the number
linking test from oswal which in fact is
quite simple um you are presented a
crowd of numbers and you have to link um
the numbers beginning with one and then
you have to search for two and where's
the three and so on so it's all about
fast thinking which as well is a core
ability in respect to fluid intelligence
and in both tests in the attention
control test and in the fluid
intelligence test the life kinetic group
so the Adaptive coordination training
group clearly outperformed the control
group and in respect to the very short
duration of the training program these
effects are really very interesting
especially because the transfer from
motoric tasks and learning new motoric
movements to fluid intelligence and
attention control is really
far however we have to be very careful
with the results um it's been a nice
little study and from a methodological
point of view also quite well done but
of course it's just one study up to now
and it will be very interesting to see
if those results can be replicated
la
if learning new movements might improve
your fluid
intelligence what about dancing and
especially learning to dance in fact
this is an Adaptive coordination
training as well so maybe we could
observe effects of learning difficult
especially difficult dance moves on
fluid intelligence or executive function
S as well up to now there are not really
many well done studies on this topic but
as people get older there's more and
more interest in alternative ways to
keep our brains in good shape and one
way to do so might be to learn to dance
one very interesting study was conducted
by Ken Kimura and noro HSI and was was
published in
2012 in psychology of sport and
exercise and in this study 65 to 78y Old
participants were randomly assigned to
two groups one group was a so-called
freestyle dancing group um in this group
they had to learn single dance moves and
in the second group the so-called
combination group
the seniors had to learn the same
movements but those movements were
combined in a Coro choreography this of
course is much
more demanding for your cognitive
flexibility you not only have to think
of how to do this one single movement
but you have to keep in mind which
movement has to be done in which moment
so this is much more stress for your
working memory for your executive
functions and directly after the
40-minute dance session um all
participants had to solve a task
switching task which is a classical task
to measure executive functions and it
demands cognitive flexibility because
you have to switch very fast between two
different tasks and the group which
performed the more difficult dancing
lesson the group which had to learn the
combination of the single movements um
this group outperformed clearly
outperformed the group in which the
cognitive demands weren't that
high so this is a interesting hint on
the acute effects of a dancing
intervention for seniors but the
question is what about the longtime
effects are there any effects on
cognition for seniors who train dancing
for a much longer time and as I said
there is a lack of really well done
studies but one study that can give us a
hint is the study from Yan Kristoff cut
stro and colleagues um in which healthy
elderly participants aged 60 to 94 years
learned dancing for 6 months 1 hour per
week in comparison to the passive
control group this of course can be
criticized because some methodological
artifacts can
occur like Rosen tal effect or placebo
effect or maybe one group outperforms
the other group because they were
getting more attention and so they are
more motivated in the post test so let's
regard the results as a preliminary
result and as a hint for for future
studies but in many tests the dancing
seniors were really much better than a
control group in hand arm fine Motor
Performance or in
posture um which is also very important
because many elderly people
are in high risk to have dangerous fall
downs but also in some measures of
cognition in this case there's been no
significant effect for fluid
intelligence but effects on reaction
times or on other as aspects of
cognition could be observed so maybe
dancing is a interesting intervention
for elderly people but
looking back to the results of the
Adaptive coordination training probably
the effects are high if you have to
learn new movements so if you're just
doing steps and movements you all you
already know which are
routine um the effects of cognition are
probably not that big
last but not least
some words on aerobic training for
seniors in comparison to Adaptive
coordination training demands on our
cognitive system when we are jogging or
walking or swimming aren't that
high nevertheless the results of many
studies seem to promote the idea that
there is at least a little effect of
aerobic training on aspects of cognition
like processing speed executive function
or
memory um this is for example the result
of a meta analytic review published in
2010 by Smith and colleagues in which 29
randomized controlled studies were
analyzed together and all in all there
were
2,49 participants that took part in
these 29
studies and taking together the results
of all these studies was that there are
indeed modest effects on some parts of
cognition like for example attention and
processing speed executive function and
memory and less or no effects as it
seems on working
memory but why are there effects at all
all well it seems like aerobic training
promotes the production of a yeah well
you could say a brain fertilizer which
is called bdnf the brain derived
neurotrophic factor and this seems to
lead to brain growth at least in some
parts like for example the hippocampus
which is very important for our
memory and that this is the case could
be shown in the study very famous study
from Ericson and colleagues exercise
training increases size of hippocampus
and improves memory it's been published
in February
2011 and in this study it could be shown
that after a aerobic training
intervention for one year three days per
week beginning with 10 minutes and and
increased by 5 minutes per week so at
the time of week seven the duration of
the training was 40 minutes and the 60
participants of this aerobic training
exercise um again this were seniors um
on average they were about 68 years um
and in this group a growth of the
hippocampus could be observed in
comparison to a group which were just
stretching and doing some yoga movements
so this group had no aerobic exercise
the growth of the hippocampus was 2% in
the aerobic group in the stretching
group the hippocampus decreased about 1
and a half% which is quite normal at
this age so this study was the first
study to show that even at an older age
an important part of the brain the
hippocampus can grow as a result of
aerobic
exercise so that's it for today hear you
next time