Sport Psychology: Does Mental Practice Really Work? (1/3)

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
2 Video Views·Jan 29, 2025
http://www.learningpsychology.net
Thanks to brain research we know that it is enough to think of a movement (e.g. the service in tennis) to activate almost the same areas of the brain that are involved in the actual movement.
In addition, we also know that the repeated use of "information highways" in the brain (associated neurons) is a central feature of many learning processes.
So one could conclude: Mental practice must be working.
But is it really that easy?
After all, an extremely important component is missing: Feedback from the environment. Was the imagined movement really successful?
So how effective is mental practice in comparison to physical practice?
Let's take a look at the research...
Author: Eskil Burck
Hello and welcome back to the world of psychology.
Sports psychology. Does mental practice really work?
In sports psychology mental training or mental practice means to systematically
and repeatedly imagine a movement without actually performing it.
And without any question mental practice really works.
Everybody who has ever learned coordinative demanding movements like for example demanding
dance steps knows that it's not possible to just do it. You first need a mental representation of
this movement in your head. You first have to play it through and give it a try in your mind.
Strong evidence also stems from brain research in which could be shown that just by mentally
practicing a movement almost the same areas in your brain are activated just like when you are
actually performing the movement. So in fact the question is not really does it really work.
The question is how well does it work. Especially in comparison to actual practice.
I mean you have to keep in mind that some things are missing. Your muscles are not really activated
at least not that strong. And what's much more important you don't get any feedback. You don't
know whether your mental putts in golf or your free throw in basketball or your service in tennis
which you play through just in your mind really works. So obviously there are some limitations.
But let's take a look at the actual evidence and first of all I want to present to you a
very interesting field study which has some methodological flaws but that are the boundaries
of field studies. For example it's just very difficult to have a randomization or a control
group. Nevertheless I really love the movie-like story behind this field study which was published
by Philip Post and colleagues in 2010 in the Journal of Imagery Research in Sport and Physical
Activity. And the title of the study was a field test of the influence of pre-game imagery on
basketball free throw shooting. And as I said this could really be the story of a movie
because the participants in this study were 16 players of a female high school basketball team.
The average age was about 17 years and the average experience in basketball was about 10 years.
And these girls really had trouble with their free throw percentage. At least from the coach's
point of view it was way too bad. They scored only about every second free throw. Their coach
who happened to have a degree in psychology decided that this was unacceptable. He really had
to do something. And as he was quite familiar with the literature and science about mental practice
he decided to conduct an intervention which was pre-game imagery. Mental practice
of free throws right before the game. But unfortunately or luckily from a scientific
point of view he didn't always have the time to conduct this intervention. So all in all there
were 18 games preceded by the pre-game imagery and on the other hand there were 18 games without
the visualization. Of course from a methodological point this procedure is not really perfect
because usually you should plan it out before when to conduct the intervention. But as I said
it's a field study and it's not always easy to adhere to the methodological guidelines.
Before we take a look at the results let's take a look at what he did. What was this pre-game imagery
about? Well in fact it was not magic. It was a 15-minute lasting session in which he told the
girls to take a deep breath and to relax and to imagine themselves in the game situation.
And this is an important component. Simulate various distractions like the voices from the crowd
and tell yourself to let these distractions go. Then they should imagine being fouled,
going to the foul line and adjust their feet until they feel comfortable.
Well afterwards the whole movement is described. Again I quote from the study. Flip the wrist
forward and let the ball roll off your fingertips and see the ball swishing through the net.
And of course this is a very important part as well to visualize the positive outcome.
This kind of imagery was repeated for several times and of course the question was whether the
girls scored better in games preceded by the imagery. Well it turned out it really had a huge
effect. In games which were not preceded by the visualization the girls missed 153 free throws
and they only made 174 which means a free throw shooting percentage of about 53 percent. Not
really good. But on the other hand you might say well that's still as good as Shaquille O'Neal.
Yeah that's right. But in games which were preceded by the imagery intervention the girls
were much better than Shaquille O'Neal. They missed only 109 free throws and made 254. This
means their free throw average was 70 percent. So really an impressive improvement and in the field
of mental practice studies this is let's say a positive outlier. So the effects in this study
are really strong. And maybe it's also because of a methodological weakness which was that the
intervention was conducted by their coach who of course was convinced that it works. And maybe or
let's say for sure in games preceded by the visualization he probably had a more positive
energy about him a more positive mood. Maybe today the free throws will be great. And of course this
positive energy could have influenced his players. And furthermore without having any control groups
unspecific placebo or nocebo effects cannot be ruled out. So for example right before the games
preceded by the visualization the girls just felt well today is our day. We just made the
very important mental practice. Now we will make it. Whereas on the other days without the mental
practice they might have felt well today we didn't do it. Maybe therefore it probably won't work. I
do not really feel confident. So placebo effects or nocebo effects could have played a role.
Nevertheless I think the overall effect was too strong to say well it's probably just because of
placebo effects. Unfortunately in the basketball free throw study by Post and colleagues they had
no control groups. So it would have been really interesting if some players of the team had
actually practiced free throws right before the game instead of the mental practice. And another
group of course would have been interesting. A no contact control group. That would have been
really interesting to see the effects of mental practice in comparison to other interventions
or no interventions. Of course in this basketball free throw study this was impossible because
they just had 60 participants. So to compare mental practice to for example real physical
practice you need another experimental design. And this design was for example given in the study by
Coelho and colleagues published in 2012 in the journal of experimental psychology
learning memory and cognition. The title of the study imagined actions aren't just weak actions.
Task variability promotes skill learning in physical practice but not in mental practice.
This time the study was all about golf. To be more exact it was about golf putting.
They had 81 participants who on average had almost no experience in golf. So no professional
players. And first of all they conducted a pre-test to see what is the baseline ability of these
players. Therefore all players had to complete a 10 put pre-test. The distance to the target
varied from 1.35m to 1.71m. After their pre-test the participants were randomly assigned to three
groups. The first group was a practical training group which was allowed to take 50 trials.
The second group was the mental practice group. They were given the putter as well but they were
not allowed to actually hit the ball. They just made 50 dry runs. Just like the movements you see
from professional golf players right before they really putt the ball. The third group is a really
funny one. In this group the participants were also asked to mentally practice but this time
they were not allowed to mentally putt the golf ball to the target but instead they were told
imagine to kick the ball to the target. And of course the researchers hypothesized that this
group will be the worst group because they did not really practice putting. The results were quite
representative for the research field of mental practice and this is why I chose this study.
The control group who mentally kicked the ball to the target improved on average in the 10 putt
post-test for about 2.5cm. The group that mentally practiced the actual golf putt
showed an improvement of about more than 7cm but much better and therefore the winner
was physical practice. This group on average showed an improvement of almost 14cm.
And as I said this is a result that is often found in the literature.
Mental practice is often better than control conditions and especially better than no contact
control conditions but actual physical practice is usually the best. Because as I said in the
beginning you get the feedback you hit the golf ball and you feel whether it was too much or too
less. Whereas when you just play it through in your head well you can only make an educated guess.
Now you might ask well if mental practice is obviously not as good as the actual physical
practice why should we waste any time? That's a good point but there are some good reasons.
First of all mental practice seems to be especially effective when the movements you have
to learn are really complex, are really demanding movements. And on the other hand you also have to
keep in mind that you cannot always be in your practice environment. You cannot always be on
the court. Maybe you have to drive half an hour to the court. So in this case mental practice is
very time effective and very cost effective. And this is something that is of course very
interesting for medical disciplines like for example surgery or dentistry in which you have
to learn very complicated movements as well. And you don't always have a test object a participant
to test your new movements as a surgeon for example. You're new from a textbook
learned movements that you need to do when you operate a gallbladder for example. And that's in
fact a new approach in mental practice to transfer ideas from mental practice in sports psychology
to for example surgery. And this is something we will also talk about in a minute.
