Can the clothes we wear influence our thinking and behaviour? For example, do we become more intelligent when we wear a doctor's coat? Or do we become more helpful when we wear a nurse's coat? Some recent studies on so-called "enclothed cognition" suggest that there might really be some truth to this phenomenon...But how robust are the effects really? Could the effects be replicated? __________________
Studies and books (only a small selection):
Adam, H., & Galinsky, A. D. (2012). Enclothed cognition. Journal of experimental social psychology, 48(4), 918-925.
Burck, E. (2019). Das manipulierte Gehirn: Psychologie der unbewussten Beeinflussung. BoD–Books on Demand.
Burns, D. M., Fox, E. L., Greenstein, M., Olbright, G., & Montgomery, D. (2019). An old task in new clothes: A preregistered direct replication attempt of enclothed cognition effects on Stroop performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 83, 150-156.
Jones, M. G., Lee, T., Chesnutt, K., Carrier, S., Ennes, M., Cayton, E., ... & Huff, P. (2019). Enclothed cognition: putting lab coats to the test. International Journal of Science Education, 41(14), 1962-1976.
Kraus, M. W., & Mendes, W. B. (2014). Sartorial symbols of social class elicit class-consistent behavioral and physiological responses: A dyadic approach. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 143(6), 2330.
López-Pérez, B., Ambrona, T., Wilson, E. L., & Khalil, M. (2016). The effect of enclothed cognition on empathic responses and helping behavior. Social Psychology.
Mendoza, S. A., & Parks-Stamm, E. J. (2020). Embodying the police: the effects of enclothed cognition on shooting decisions. Psychological reports, 123(6), 2353-2371.
Zimbardo, P. G. (1969). The human choice: Individuation, reason, and order versus deindividuation, impulse, and chaos. In Nebraska symposium on motivation. University of Nebraska press.
About the Author: Eskil Burck, a psychology graduate, is a psychological consultant and textbook author. He teaches psychology for Kalaidos University of Applied Sciences (Zurich). His psychology podcast "psychologie-lernen.de" consistently ranked #1 on iTunes in the "Education" category. His books "Angst - was hilft wirklich ...?", "Das manipulierte Gehirn" and "Neue Psychologie der Beeinflussung" became Amazon bestsellers. Even in his spare time, he enjoys reading studies...😅🙈 For more information, visit: www.psychologie-lernen.de
Can you improve your intelligence
by putting on the right clothes?
In 2012, a fascinating piece of research
was published by Adam and Galinsky,
in which they showed that when participants
wore a doctor's coat,
their cognitive abilities seemed to improve.
But what most people don't know,
and I mean, this piece of research
really got a lot of media attention,
what most people don't know is that one of their experiments
actually could not be replicated.
But first, let's take a short look
at what they actually did in their experiments.
In the first experiment, they had 58 participants,
I wish they would have had more,
who were divided into two groups,
and the cover story to make them wear these lab coats
was to say, well, we are conducting this experiment
for a while now, and when we began the experiment,
the laboratory was under construction.
So the participants in the first run had to wear coats.
So it is essential that you wear these lab coats as well
to have similar conditions.
And while wearing these lab coats,
the participants had to take part
in the classical Stroop test.
Some of you probably already know this test.
It's a test in which you are presented with color words,
like for example, the word blue,
but the letters of the word have a different color.
So for example, the color yellow.
And your task is not to read the name of the word,
so you don't say blue, but you have to resist to say blue
and instead to say yellow,
because you only have to name the color of the letters.
So this is a classical inhibition task
in which you have to suppress your first impulse
and to concentrate your attention onto something else.
And the results of this study really seemed fascinating
because in this classical cognitive test,
those participants who wore the lab coat
actually conducted less errors.
And the idea of enclosed cognition
that what you're wearing is influencing your cognition
seems to be supported in experiment two and three.
In those experiments,
in which they luckily had some more participants,
in experiment two, they had 74,
and in experiment three, they had 99 participants.
In those experiments,
the approach actually was even a little bit more clever
because they made participants wear the same coats,
but one time they told them, well, it's a doctor's coat.
But in another condition, they told them,
well, it's the coat of a painter.
So now you have two different primings.
The first one is the doctor priming,
which is associated with being intelligent,
having high attention.
And on the other hand, you have the painter,
which is more associated with being creative
and maybe a little bit chaotic.
And indeed, again, in this experiment,
they could show this time with different cognitive tests.
I guess you know this kind of cognitive test as well.
You were shown two pictures, for example,
of a nice building,
and the two pictures seem to be identical,
but there are some small differences
and you have to spot the differences.
So a really classic.
And when they analyzed the data,
again, in these two experiments,
those who were wearing the doctor's coat outperformed
those who had thought they are wearing a painter's coat.
So at first sight, really fantastic results.
But as I said, the problem is that one of those experiments,
the first one actually in a new study published
seven years later, published in 2019,
could not replicate the results.
Even though they did almost everything exactly the same way,
and even though they had more participants,
so more statistical power,
all in all, they had 400 participants,
whereas in the original study,
they only had, as I said, 58 participants.
They were not able to show that wearing a doctor's coat
actually improved the performance in the Stroop test.
So what is going on?
Well, there are some explanations.
First of all, it might have been that the original authors,
Adam and Galinsky,
they might have conducted several small experiments.
And if you do so,
if you conduct a lot of small experiments,
chances are quite high
that you get one false positive result.
And if you only publish this one positive result
and ignore all the non-significant results,
then of course, this is highly problematic.
Another explanation might be that
they actually conducted not only the Stroop test,
but maybe they conducted a lot of other cognitive tests.
And I mean, if I had conducted this experiment,
I probably would have conducted
tests of general intelligence as well,
like for example, the Raven mattresses.
And maybe, and I know this is pure speculation,
but maybe this is exactly what they did.
They conducted several cognitive tests
and they only published the one which was positive
and which actually then might have been a false positive.
But aside from some kind of scientific misconduct,
there might also be another plausible explanation
because it could also be that maybe the participants
who took part in this replication study
actually did not have such a strong association
between scientists and doctors
and being intelligent or having strong attention.
Because as I said, the study was published in 2019
in the United States at a time Donald Trump was president
and in which the belief in science and medicine
was actually not that strong.
So maybe this could have affected the results as well,
but surely there will have to be more research
to answer those questions.
So what's the conclusion?
Is enclosed cognition a hoax?
Does it not work at all?
Does what you are wearing
not influence your thinking or your behavior?
Fortunately, there are some more studies
to answer this question.
So for example, take a look at a study
by Lopez and colleagues in which they could show
that when participants were told that a tunic
that they had to wear for the experiment
either was the tunic of a nurse or the tunic of a cleaner.
And when they thought that they are wearing
the tunic of a nurse,
the participants showed more empathy
and they were more willing to help somebody
in need of help.
In another study, it could be shown that participants
who were wearing a business suit
in comparison to participants who had to wear sweatpants
negotiated much more assertive
and they also had higher levels of testosterone.
So they really behaved like business alpha males.
And maybe the most scary results
come from classical de-individuation experiments
in which nurses had to wear Ku Klux Klan-like coats
and gave electric shocks to an alleged victim
that were two times longer than in the control condition.
So from a psychological point of view,
there is absolutely no doubt
that what we are wearing can affect our behavior.
And I mean, unfortunately, we see that in every war
when people are wearing uniforms,
they also lose their scruples.
There is no doubt that what we are wearing
can affect our behavior.
But at this point in time,
I would not bet that you can also improve your intelligence
just by wearing something else.
Maybe you can have a little bit more sustained attention,
but when it comes to higher cognitive processes,
probably the effects are too weak.
That's it for today.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
If you want to take a look at the books
or take a look at the website,
or if you found this episode helpful,
feel free to give a thumbs up.
And maybe we will see you next time.